Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Okay, I read through Harri Laakso's paper, and my goodness, now I know again why I have not looked at that paper for the last 7 years or so. Lot's is decribed but he could have taken the effort to put some lines in his plots to guide the reader. But anywhooo ...

I was actually right, he is mainly discussing AC fields or as he calls is fluctuations of the DC electric field Ey (there is only one component of the electric field that is measured with the APV-V instrument). However, there are some statements (3 actually) about "real" DC electric fields and potential drops, on which I will concentrate. For everything else I invite you to try and read the paper yourself.

But first he discusses the APV-L measurements with the two Langmuir probes, and there he immediately states in subsection "dc Electric Fields" of Section 3:



So, one can only use the Langmuir probes to study densities and waves. And why is the vxBz important? That is namely the convective electric field of the solar wind, which appears in the spacecraft frame of reference.

Then the APV-V antenna data is discussed, and we skip to Section 5 Cometopause, where Laakso observes (in Plate 4) that (and pay attention to the last sentence):



Measuring DC electric fields in a plasma is notoriously difficult on space missions. Here the two probes were 1.5 meter long booms at the end of the solar panel.

Where does the DC field come from? This is probably needed to slow down the solar wind:



Indeed, a bit further this is said:



Than later in the paper we get the information that from Vega 2 tells us that:



However, no evidence in the data is shown that this is actually the case. One should at least then show the electron and ion densities along the crossing of this region.

Which leads us the the conclusion section, where things are suddenly stated with a bit more determination than in the paper proper:



I did not mention the 135 kV potential drop on page 7751, but also there it is stated in the text that It is not evident whether such a large potential drop is possible, since spurious signals may be intensified at the current layer.

So, in all I think we can trust the oscillations of the electric field, as there you just subtract the background DC field, but the enormous potential drops of kVs are in my opinion (and in the text also Laakso's) dubious.

Ok, with the above in mind and not having your tail excursion paper, this would be a fair, if basic, visualisation of what's going on around comets in general?

2vw6x5i.jpg


very much sounds like you've got something like this going on around the dirtysnowball!

Experimental and theoretical investigations of plasma multiple double layers and their evolution to chaos D G Dimitriu1, M Aflori2, L M Ivan1, V Radu1, E Poll1 and M Agop3,4

At high values of the applied potential, the plasma system passes into a chaotic state, characterized by uncorrelated and intermittent oscillations (see figures 5(s)–(u), respectively)

The stability of a double layer is ensured by the balance between the production of electrons and positive ions through electron–neutral impact ionizations and excitations and the particle losses by recombination and diffusion

The final plasma system state is a chaotic one, consisting of uncorrelated and intermittent oscillations with a broad spectrum and many peaks being present, which corresponds to the unstable periodic dynamics of the multiple double-layer structure.

Thus, we state the possible correspondence between the multiplicity order of the double layer and that of the conduction bistability (see the experimental hysteresis cycles from figure 2 for double layers of multiplicity two).

if the above is a goer then why the need for "Special Circumstances"

E. Behar,1,2‹ H. Nilsson,1,2‹ M. Alho,3 C. Goetz4 and B. Tsurutani5 The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet – Rosetta
observations


K.L. Heritier,1? P. Henri,2 X. Vallieres,2 M. Galand,1 E. Odelstad,3 A.I. Eriksson,3 F.L. Johansson,3 K. Altwegg,4 E. Behar,5 A. Beth,1 T.W. Broiles,6 J.L. Burch,6 C.M. Carr,1 E. Cupido,1 H. Nilsson,5 M. Rubin,4 E. Vigren3 Near-surface expanding ionosphere of comet 67P

K. E. Mandt,1,2‹ A. Eriksson,3 N. J. T. Edberg,3 C. Koenders,4 T. Broiles,1‹
S. A. Fuselier,1,2‹ P. Henri,5 Z. Nemeth,6 M. Alho,7 N. Biver,8 A. Beth,9
J. Burch,1 C. Carr,9 K. Chae,1 A. J. Coates,10 E. Cupido,9 M. Galand,9
K.-H. Glassmeier,4 C. Goetz,4 R. Goldstein,1 K. C. Hansen,11 J. Haiducek,11
E. Kallio,7 J.-P. Lebreton,5 A. Luspay-Kuti,1 P. Mokashi,1 H. Nilsson,12 A. Opitz,6I. Richter,4 M. Samara,13 K. Szego,6 C.-Y. Tzou,14 M. Volwerk,15
C. Simon Wedlund16 and G. Stenberg Wieser12
RPC observation of the development and evolution of plasma interaction boundaries at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko



What's happening down the tail Tusenfem?

I could also see why you'd be scratching your head on why no continuous reconnection events going on! Seems the double layers are going to play havoc with your ion gyro radii on all!

But in affect the multiple "two layers" with a potential drop between them are acting the isolate the rocky nucleus from the more positive, with respect to the nucleus "ground".

No would you be willing to draw a stick in the sand sorta diagram with the Cometary Circuit? Where do they close?
 
Last edited:
Thanks tusenfem!

I'd have to go away a sit in my cave for awhile and ponder your answer.

But I may call them whatever I feel like it at the time?

Outer positively charged outer surface with an inner negativity charged surface with an disputed amount of potential drop across the + to -, maybe called a bow shock, cometopause, collisionopause, cavity boundary?

Merry xmas 'ol mate! :)

no you cannot call them what you want, each has a clear definition
nd i have seen no evidence for this chardged inner and outer sides
 
Ok, with the above in mind and not having your tail excursion paper, this would be a fair, if basic, visualisation of what's going on around comets in general?

[qimg]http://i65.tinypic.com/2vw6x5i.jpg[/qimg]

very much sounds like you've got something like this going on around the dirtysnowball!

Experimental and theoretical investigations of plasma multiple double layers and their evolution to chaos D G Dimitriu1, M Aflori2, L M Ivan1, V Radu1, E Poll1 and M Agop3,4









if the above is a goer then why the need for "Special Circumstances"

E. Behar,1,2‹ H. Nilsson,1,2‹ M. Alho,3 C. Goetz4 and B. Tsurutani5 The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet – Rosetta
observations


K.L. Heritier,1? P. Henri,2 X. Vallieres,2 M. Galand,1 E. Odelstad,3 A.I. Eriksson,3 F.L. Johansson,3 K. Altwegg,4 E. Behar,5 A. Beth,1 T.W. Broiles,6 J.L. Burch,6 C.M. Carr,1 E. Cupido,1 H. Nilsson,5 M. Rubin,4 E. Vigren3 Near-surface expanding ionosphere of comet 67P

K. E. Mandt,1,2‹ A. Eriksson,3 N. J. T. Edberg,3 C. Koenders,4 T. Broiles,1‹
S. A. Fuselier,1,2‹ P. Henri,5 Z. Nemeth,6 M. Alho,7 N. Biver,8 A. Beth,9
J. Burch,1 C. Carr,9 K. Chae,1 A. J. Coates,10 E. Cupido,9 M. Galand,9
K.-H. Glassmeier,4 C. Goetz,4 R. Goldstein,1 K. C. Hansen,11 J. Haiducek,11
E. Kallio,7 J.-P. Lebreton,5 A. Luspay-Kuti,1 P. Mokashi,1 H. Nilsson,12 A. Opitz,6I. Richter,4 M. Samara,13 K. Szego,6 C.-Y. Tzou,14 M. Volwerk,15
C. Simon Wedlund16 and G. Stenberg Wieser12
RPC observation of the development and evolution of plasma interaction boundaries at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko



What's happening down the tail Tusenfem?

I could also see why you'd be scratching your head on why no continuous reconnection events going on! Seems the double layers are going to play havoc with your ion gyro radii on all!

But in affect the multiple "two layers" with a potential drop between them are acting the isolate the rocky nucleus from the more positive, with respect to the nucleus "ground".

No would you be willing to draw a stick in the sand sorta diagram with the Cometary Circuit? Where do they close?

no
(and rhat is to all ideas and questions)
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Lies about nonexistent, unnamed "structures" - Harri Laakso has no 'structures

Have they got a name? Just so I don’t keep calling them “double layers”.
27 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about nonexistent, unnamed "structures" - Harri Laakso has no "structures" and names what they are looking at - current layers.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

For others:
We have a comet tail formed by gasses from by sublimating ices. The sublimated gas starts as relatively thick near the comet and thins out over scales of thousands of kilometers. The sublimated gas will be ionized by the interaction with the solar wind and sunlight. The amount of ionization will be dominated by the composition and density of the gas atoms. We have "thick" plasma near the comet formed by and thinner plasma along the tail further from the comet with a change in the degree of ionization. We thus expect currents in the tail.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A stupid question to derail from his comet delusions

definition of bulk porosity density?
27 December 2017 Sol88: A stupid question to derail from his comet delusions.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

In the case off 67P. ...
27 December 2017 Sol88: Idiotic CONCERT/MUPAS lie about 67P.
CONSERT told us that the porosity inside of the nucleus ruled out rock with up to ~70% empty space.
The lie is that any knowledgeable person thinks that the surface porosity (or the bulk density) is "representative of the interior". Sublimation of surface material means that this is obviously untrue.

What makes the lie idiotic is the delusion that a comet is rock. A dumb person with that delusion will mention the MUPUS results which showed that the surface has the tensile strength of sintered ice, i.e. not the "fluffy" interior, and thus debunking their delusion :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Repeats the stupidity of rock when he cited evidence that it is not

EC says rock all the way thru!
27 December 2017 Sol88: Repeats the stupidity of rock all the way when he cites evidence that it is not!
MUPUS = high tensile strength layer of sintered ices at the surface of 67P.
CONCERT = bulk porosity gives a "fluffy" mixture of ices and dust inside 67P.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

27 December 2017 Sol88: A blatant "Mainstream have “nothing’" lie when high porosity is what the mainstream predicts.

27 December 2017 Sol88: The utter stupidity of 87% porosity = nothing.
 
Sol88[/B]: Lies by not citing "On the density of Halley's comet" from 1989

On the Density of Halley's Comet S. J. PEALE
I missed this stupid lie:
27 December 2017 Sol88: Lies by not citing "On the density of Halley's comet" published in November 1989

On the density of Halley's comet by S.J. Peale (November 1989) is the author finding that using the perturbation of orbit by jets method of measuring the density of Halley had big error bars in 1989.

The lie and stupidity is comparing this uncertain method of measuring density from 1989 of Comet Halley to the in situ measurement of the porosity in 2017 of Comet 67P. There is also exactly what S.J. Peale recommended - an in situ measurement of Comet 67P's density which is 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3 (A homogeneous nucleus for comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko from its gravity field)
 
Last edited:
Well clearly, something is wrong with one of your equations, assumptions or readings!

Things rock as will be born out in the up coming papers.
 
Comet 76P/ Churyumov-Gerasimenko brought us to an unknown plasma environment §?

In the weakly outgassing phase usual conceptions , like traditional draping , do not occur §?

But „ nested draping “ is observed , i.e. regions of alternating B- field direction §?
Deflection of the solar wind makes the field „ vertical “ in the near tail region §?

In the „ far “ tail §?

the field is always pointing sunward §?
A helical wave travels down the tail
http://planetaryspaceweather-europlanet.irap.omp.eu/pdf/sip-2017-10/9_Volwerk.pdf


A helical wave travels down the tail. Interesting!

Even more interesting and perhaps you could fill us in but...

In the case of weakly outgassing comets §?

Intermediate mass loading §?
Leading to deflection of solar wind by momentum conservation §?
Draping goes „ up “

A weakly outgassing comet deflects the solar wind more effectively than the assumed radial 1r q28 that "Mass Loads" the solar wind?
 
Idealized model vs Realistic model §?

Changing IMF direction §?
“Nested draping” A layered structure of the draped magnetic field §?
Oppositely directed magnetic field regions §?
Clearly observed @ 1P/Halley with Giotto spacecraft

You coy bugger you!

So how is the dirtysnowball doing this Tusenfem??????
 
Well clearly, something is wrong with one of your equations, assumptions or readings!

Things rock as will be born out in the up coming papers.

Wrong. There is nothing in any published paper, nor will there be in any upcoming paper, that provides any evidence for comets being rock. As pointed out previously on countless occasions.
Every single instrument/ experiment that has been capable of detecting/ inferring rock, has failed to do so. Au contraire, they all show that it most definitely isn't rock. I refer to;
Impact at Tempel 1 (both ejected material and crater size).
Various density measurements (in particular those at 67P over 2 yrs).
CONSERT experiment.
MIRO surface and near subsurface thermal inertia measurements.
MUPUS hammer sound wave speed measurements.
Analysis of collapsed material from cliffs (i.e. it is icy).

In short, there is no rock. There is no EDM (lol) woo. There are no DLs. All the evidence (and I mean ALL of it) shows that the electric comet woo is dead (it already was; see Halley, Tempel 1 and Hartley 2), and that comets are just what we always knew they were - a mixture of ice, fluffy dust and denser dust, with a highly porous make up. Hence the density of 67P of 533 kg/m3.
So, if you want to infer that they've messed up all the above measurements, then I suggest you show these multiple errors. Or admit that you are lying. If you think there is a forthcoming paper that will provide evidence to gainsay those multiple measurements, then reference it. Or admit that you are lying.
 
Related to the above post - I had previously referenced the MUPUS hammering results from a conference abstract;

Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmmeyer, M. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K

That abstract is now an article in press at Science Direct;

Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmmeyer, M. et al
https://ac.els-cdn.com/S00191035173...t=1515144032_966b2798ca4f2bc613059fa771f6f253 (direct link to PDF)

Same conclusions as the conference abstract - it ain't rock. Not even close :)
 
http://planetaryspaceweather-europlanet.irap.omp.eu/pdf/sip-2017-10/9_Volwerk.pdf


A helical wave travels down the tail. Interesting!

Even more interesting and perhaps you could fill us in but...

Paper will be out soon, but I do not know yet what creates the helical wave.

A weakly outgassing comet deflects the solar wind more effectively than the assumed radial 1r q28 that "Mass Loads" the solar wind?

No idea what the bold is supposed to mean.
intermediately/weakly outgassing comets have a "stronger"effect closer to the comet where conservatios of momentum will let the solar wind ions and magnetic field move in the opposite direction of the newly picked up ion, which are accelerated by the convectional electric field of the solar wind.
Probably happens also at strongly outgassing comets, but ... we have not observed that at Halley, because there the magnetosphere was already over 100.000 km in diameter, so we don't know how it developed there, we do at 67P as we were right on time at the right spot.
 
You coy bugger you!

So how is the dirtysnowball doing this Tusenfem??????

Bugger yourself, Sol.

ionization of gas coming from the comet
mass loading the solar wind
solar wind having sectors of differently directed magnetic field
etc. etc.
all very basic stuff
 
ionization of gas coming from the comet
mass loading the solar wind
solar wind having sectors of differently directed magnetic field
etc. etc.
all very basic stuff

Indeed. Even as a non-plasma physicist, with more of an interest in planetary science, I could have answered that, having read enough of the RPC papers from this mission, as well as other papers from Halley, in particular. Not to mention Tusenfem's frequent explanations on here. People really should pay attention in class!

On another note, related to my previous post, another method of estimating the strength of the cometary material is outlined in this paper:

Tensile Strength of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Nucleus Material from Overhangs
Attree, N. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1712.07508.pdf

Given the very low gravity at 67P, why would solid rock collapse, as observed? Not to mention the fact that the debris is icy. As they say in the conclusions:

Low bulk strengths support the conclusions of Davidsson et al. (2016) that 67P represents a primordial rubble pile, directly accreted from the proto-solar nebular by hierarchical aggregation or streaming instabilities, or is a collisional fragment from a small (tens of km) body. A fragment, or rubble pile of fragments, from the disruption of a larger (∼ 1000 km) body would inherit some of that body’s properties, such as higher density and strength material from impact compaction and/or thermal processing and differentiation.

My bold. Perhaps the EU geniuses could perform the same calculations that the authors of this paper have done, and substitute in the values for igneous or sedimentary rock, and see how it comes out.
Of course, we all know that won't happen. There is nobody associated with that cult capable of doing such a thing. Nor are they interested, as they have the highly scientific observation of "it looks like rock" to hang their hat on! And why would they be interested in science, when their belief system is based purely on mythology? Anybody that believes that nonsense is not going to understand the science anyway. Nope, best to ignore all the evidence, and keep on selling the books and DVDs to their scientifically challenged acolytes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom