Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
THE FRIABLE SPONGE MODEL OF A COMETARY NUCLEUS M. Horanyi,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 T. E. Cravens,2 A. Korosmezey,1 K. Kecskemety,1 A. F. Nagy,2 AND K. SZEGO1



Interesting in the above post about the MUPUS findings, don’t ya think jd116?

Totally irrelevant to MUPUS. That was written in 1983. We hadn't even visited a comet, let alone landed on one.
 
So again the above paper is humstrung based on the assumptions of a light fluffy nucleus!

Am I the only one getting sick of this wilful stupidity? Hey ho. READ WHAT YOU QUOTED!!!
They are NOT using the assumption of a fluffy nucleus. That is precisely what they are not bloody saying. What do you think 515 ≤ ρ ≤1635 kg m-3 means? It means they are using a lower bound for the nucleus bulk density, and a higher bound for the densest grains found. That is, between 515 - 1635 kg/m3. What is fluffy about that? The fluffy grains were ~ < 1 kg/m3!
 
Last edited:
And I’m still calling ROCK!

Who gives a toss? You wouldn't know a rock if it happened to mercifully hit you on the head.
Do please tell us; what happened when a projectile hit that rock at ~ 10 km/s? What came out? Just dust and ice and vapour, yes? Strange rock. What is the density of that rock? Very low, isn't it? What is its shear modulus? What is its Young's modulus? What sort of strange rock is this, that sits above a bunch of ice? How did that happen? A bit like an upside down Antarctica. Lol. Rock!
 
Last edited:
No, it isn't. As far as I can see there are only one or two people on the planet who still believe in this idiotic woo. It is no more a debate than astrology, which has far more adherents.
And the paper you stupidly quoted (Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase) is the same one whose abstract I have linked umpteen times to show the what CASSE/ SESAME observed was consistent with the low strength of a porous ice surface, and nowhere near that of rock!!! How stupid can you be? Why don't you read these damned things when they are first linked, instead of embarrassing yourself like this? To wit:

The abstract I've linked a squillion times:

Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmeyer, M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K



I've almost learned that passage by heart, I've had to paste it that often. Now, let's have a butcher's at what Knapmeyer says in the full paper you mentioned;

The SESAME/CASSE instrument listening to the MUPUS PEN insertion phase on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Knapmeyer, M. et al
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0094576516301643



And is also consistent with what was seen at Tempel 1, and the cliffs at 67P after collapses. So no rock anywhere to be seen, no debate to be had. This was all settled in 2005 at Tempel 1. Rock is a non-starter.

Ok then

we find a shear modulus between 3.6 MPa and 346 MPa, a Young’s modulus between 7.2 MPa and 980 MPa, and a bulk porosity below 0.74.
Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase M. Knapmeyer a , ∗, H.-H. Fischer b , J. Knollenberg a , K.J. Seidensticker a , K. Thiel c , W. Arnold d , e , C. Faber a , D. Möhlmann a , 1 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2017.12.002

What say ye on shear modulus between 3.6 MPa and 346 MPa, a Young’s modulus between 7.2 MPa and 980 MPa?

ROCK is back in the mix sport, wake up!
 
Last edited:
Ok then

Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase M. Knapmeyer a , ∗, H.-H. Fischer b , J. Knollenberg a , K.J. Seidensticker a , K. Thiel c , W. Arnold d , e , C. Faber a , D. Möhlmann a , 1 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2017.12.002

What say ye on shear modulus between 3.6 MPa and 346 MPa, a Young’s modulus between 7.2 MPa and 980 MPa?

ROCK is back in the mix sport, wake up!

No it isn't. I'll repeat, for the hard of reading:
Do please tell us; what happened when a projectile hit that rock at ~ 10 km/s? What came out? Just dust and ice and vapour, yes? Strange rock. What is the density of that rock? Very low, isn't it? What is its shear modulus? What is its Young's modulus? What sort of strange rock is this, that sits above a bunch of ice? How did that happen? A bit like an upside down Antarctica. Lol. Rock!
I will add that we can see the innards of these 'rocks' when they fall off cliffs. White inside, with the signature of H2O ice. What sort of rock would that be?

Whoops, nearly forgot; what sort of 'rock' develops thermal crack polygons? Feel free to look for analogues on Earth and Mars.
 
Last edited:
Why the hell would you want to wheel out the prediction by W.Thornhill of two flashes? As observed?

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab (University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).

Assuming an albedo of 0.1, appropriate for mafic silicate liquids, the total mass of the droplets was about 4000 kg. Because this is 10 times the mass of the impactor, we assume that the glowing material originated mainly from the comet and is thus probably silicate in composition.

Also, why did the point of impact “move”

Fig. 5. Movement of the impact flash at early times, illustrated by the location of the center of brightness for a given MRI exposure. The letters correspond to the exposure frames from Fig. 2: (A) represents the center of brightness of the rst light, (C) represents the beginning of the delayed brightening (100–200 m downrange of the rst light), and (D) represents the center of brightness of the rst saturated exposure (located another 100–200 m downrange).

Evolution of the Deep Impact ash: Implications for the nucleus surface based on laboratory experiments✩ Carolyn M. Ernst∗, Peter H. Schultz



Are you doing a captain swoop?

Already explained it's a standard tactic.
Beat you down until you give up then declare victory.
 
Last edited:
Am I the only one getting sick of this wilful stupidity? Hey ho. READ WHAT YOU QUOTED!!!
They are NOT using the assumption of a fluffy nucleus. That is precisely what they are not bloody saying. What do you think 515 ≤ ρ ≤1635 kg m-3 means? It means they are using a lower bound for the nucleus bulk density, and a higher bound for the densest grains found. That is, between 515 - 1635 kg/m3. What is fluffy about that? The fluffy grains were ~ < 1 kg/m3!


What is the density of the compact particles?
 
Ok then

Structure and elastic parameters of the near surface of Abydos site on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko, as obtained by SESAME/CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase M. Knapmeyer a , ∗, H.-H. Fischer b , J. Knollenberg a , K.J. Seidensticker a , K. Thiel c , W. Arnold d , e , C. Faber a , D. Möhlmann a , 1 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.icarus.2017.12.002

What say ye on shear modulus between 3.6 MPa and 346 MPa, a Young’s modulus between 7.2 MPa and 980 MPa?

ROCK is back in the mix sport, wake up!


For shear modulus, higher (more rigid) than rubber (0.3 MPa)
less rigid than plywood (620 MPa)
and within the range with polyethylene (120 MPa)


https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/modulus-rigidity-d_946.html


For Young's modulus it works out the same (see page 16)

http://www-mdp.eng.cam.ac.uk/web/library/enginfo/cueddatabooks/materials.pdf


Wood just at the high end of the given range, elastomers at the low end and polymer foams in the middle of the given range.

Concrete, brick and stone are an order of magnitude above the top of the given range.
 
Last edited:
Why the hell would you want to wheel out the prediction by W.Thornhill of two flashes? As observed?

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND. H. J. Melosh and the Deep Impact Team, Lunar and Planetary Lab (University of Arizona, Tucson AZ 85721, [email protected]).

Because Thornhill wasn't the first to predict that. It had been seen in lab experiments by Schultz. What Thornhill predicted was a pre-impact flash, and that didn't happen. Simple.

In this scenario (and in Scenario 1b), a three-component plume should be observed in the MRI and may allow the identification of this surface property.
i.T = 0.06 s (first frame): very weak flash.
ii.T = 1s (~17 frames): high-angle jet-like plasma plume due to cavitation and redirection back out the penetration funnel.
iii.T=1 to 20s: opaque spherical cloud forming a shadow above the
comet surface.
iv.T = 20 s to 100 s: high-angle ejecta plume extending >
10 km above the surface surrounded by a high-angle (~60?) ejecta curtain.
v.T > 200 s: advancing annulus of disturbed cometary surface near the
crater as low-velocity components return. High-angle central plume
may detach from the crater due to collapse and shut off of deep ejecta

EXPECTATIONS FOR CRATER SIZE AND PHOTOMETRIC EVOLUTION FROM THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Schultz, P. H. et al
https://pds-smallbodies.astro.umd.e...ience_reviews/crater_size_evolutn_schultz.pdf

But you already knew that, because I've posted it before. See what Captain Swoop means?
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10900541&postcount=1625



Also, why did the point of impact “move”

Evolution of the Deep Impact ash: Implications for the nucleus surface based on laboratory experiments✩ Carolyn M. Ernst∗, Peter H. Schultz

The point of impact didn't move. That would be ridiculous. I cannot believe that in over a decade you have never read the DI papers properly. Why is that? Because the results killed this idiocy stone dead right then.

EDIT:
By the way, the scenarios outlined by Schultz are based on real science. Based on lab experiment. As opposed to the wishy-washy tabloid psychic crap trotted out by the likes of the conman Thornhill.
 
Last edited:
Why the hell would you want to wheel out the prediction by W.Thornhill of two flashes? As observed?

Right, let's actually have a look at what Wal predicted shall we?

Copious X-rays will accompany discharges to the projectile, exceeding any reasonable model for X-ray production through the mechanics of impact. The intensity curve will be that of a lightning bolt (sudden onset, exponential decline) and may well include more than one peak.

https://www.thunderbolts.info/tpod/2005/arch05/050704predictions.htm

Fail. So, what was actually seen?

The comet was relatively faint on July 4th, and the total increase in X-ray flux due to the Deep Impact event was small, ∼20% of the immediate pre-impact value, consistent with estimates that the total coma neutral gas release due to the impact was 5 × 106 kg ( ∼10 h of normal emission). No obvious prompt X-ray flash due to the impact was seen.

Chandra observations of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact campaign
Lisse, C. M. et al.
http://ftp.astro.umd.edu/pub/lisse/xrays/final_proof_YICAR8214_cml_comments_18jul2007.pdf

The X-ray light curve indicates that the comet exhibited a prolonged soft X-ray outburst just after impact of the NASA Deep Impact (DI) spacecraft and enhanced X-ray activity lasted for 12 days
.

SWIFT X-RAY TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF THE DEEP IMPACT COLLISION
Willingale, R. et al.
https://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/results/publist/Willingale_ApJ_649_541_2006.pdf

So, we may ask ourselves, why has dunderdolts had this on their site as a 'successful' prediction for years? It was quite obviously not a prediction, as it was already outlined by Pete Schultz in a work pre-dating Thornhill's tabloid psychic impression. Secondly, his first flash was supposed to be pre-impact, and produce shed loads of X-rays. Well, that is quite obviously a failed prediction, isn't it?

CONCLUSION:
Both Thornhill and dunderdolts are lying in an attempt to pull the wool over the eyes of their scientifically challenged acolytes. Shame on them.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A lie that forbidden lines are caused buy electric fields.

5 February 2018 Sol88: A lie that forbidden lines are caused by "intense" electric fields as reading what he cited would reveal.

forbidden oxygen lines has no mention of any electric fields. He has already been told the source of forbidden lines - the low density of the gas or plasma allowing rare long loved states to decay.

5 February 2018 Sol88: Usual delusions about comet papers, e.g. the photochemistry of forbidden O lines at Comet 67P.

Photochemistry of forbidden oxygen lines in the inner coma of 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko

Interesting to note we do not use photo dissociation here on earth.
5 February 2018 Sol88: Stupid and irrelevant "we do no use photo dissociation here on earth" lie when a few seconds on Google gives photodissociation being used here on Earth :eye-poppi!

5 February 2018 Sol88: Utter stupidity of a electron beam ion trap Wikipedia article as if it were every experiment on Earth!
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Insanity of argument by insult to derail from his comet delusions

Not really the sharpest tool in the shed, jd116! ...
5 February 2018 Sol88: Insanity of argument by insult to derail from his comet delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: Idiocy that his assertions about the working comet model supports his comet delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: A lie that there is evidence for his deluded electric fields.
 
Sol88: Meaningless science word salad and lies to derail from his comet delusions

Ions jamming on anchors is achieved thru “double layers” depending which side the + side is and if you did not already know WILL accelerate them on the otherside!!!!...
5 February 2018 Sol88: Meaningless science word salad to derail from his comet delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: An ignorant delusion about double layers at comets

5 February 2018 Sol88: Repeated idiocy that his delusions about comet papers supports his comet delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: Repeated ices in quotes lie when he knows about the detection of ices on comets

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Sol88: Usual idiocy and ices in quote lie to derail from his comets delusions

...Interesting!...
5 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy and ices in quote lie to derail from his comets delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: Total stupidity of threatening to derail from his comet delusions into the insanely deluded "electric sun".

For others:
This is him mindlessly following every bit of the Thunderbolt cult's dogma. The electric sun denial of fusion at the core of stars such as the Sun is denial of the basic physics taught in first year astronomy courses! The balance of gravity and pressure needed for a stable star means that temperature and pressure inside a star has to increase with depth. A textbook first year astronomy exercise is to do the calculations for that balance. This is simple for anyone to understand. The weight of layers above a depth increases so the pressure has to increase to hold the layer up. That means that temperature has to increase. The result is that every star has to have an energy source at its core to provide that temperature gradient.

The calculations give the temperature, pressure and density at the core of stars (computer models are needed for the more accurate values). Apply nuclear physics and there must be fusion happening at the core of stars. We detect the predicted neutrino flux from that fusion. We get the formation of elements that we detect in older stars and nova.

The Thunderbolts cultists basically want the Sun to be a light bulb powered by imaginary electric currents. No fusion at all according to some idiots. Fusion magically happening somewhere, e.g. at the surface but not frying Earth with gamma rays.
 
Sol88: Usual idiocy of questions to derail from his comet delusions

What model was used for the “outgassing” from 19P/Holmes?....
5 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy of irrelevant questions to derail from his comet delusions (outgassing from sublimating ices this time :eye-poppi!).

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.

5 February 2018 Sol88: An insane "ad hoc complete rubbish with no basis in reality" lie.
That is an insane lie because he knows about the centuries of observations of real comets, the scientific model of comets as ices and dust form those observations in the 1950's, the more accurate modern observations confirming that model and the many visits to comets by probes in the real world that confirmed that comets are ices and dust. For example, the Rosetta mission to Comet 67P.
 
Last edited:
For shear modulus, higher (more rigid) than rubber (0.3 MPa)
less rigid than plywood (620 MPa)
and within the range with polyethylene (120 MPa)


https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/modulus-rigidity-d_946.html


For Young's modulus it works out the same (see page 16)

http://www-mdp.eng.cam.ac.uk/web/library/enginfo/cueddatabooks/materials.pdf


Wood just at the high end of the given range, elastomers at the low end and polymer foams in the middle of the given range.

Concrete, brick and stone are an order of magnitude above the top of the given range.

Wonder if they had used KNOWN densities from returned comet samples?

Stardust
 
5 February 2018 Sol88: Usual idiocy and ices in quote lie to derail from his comets delusions.

5 February 2018 Sol88: Total stupidity of threatening to derail from his comet delusions into the insanely deluded "electric sun".

For others:
This is him mindlessly following every bit of the Thunderbolt cult's dogma. The electric sun denial of fusion at the core of stars such as the Sun is denial of the basic physics taught in first year astronomy courses! The balance of gravity and pressure needed for a stable star means that temperature and pressure inside a star has to increase with depth. A textbook first year astronomy exercise is to do the calculations for that balance. This is simple for anyone to understand. The weight of layers above a depth increases so the pressure has to increase to hold the layer up. That means that temperature has to increase. The result is that every star has to have an energy source at its core to provide that temperature gradient.

The calculations give the temperature, pressure and density at the core of stars (computer models are needed for the more accurate values). Apply nuclear physics and there must be fusion happening at the core of stars. We detect the predicted neutrino flux from that fusion. We get the formation of elements that we detect in older stars and nova.

The Thunderbolts cultists basically want the Sun to be a light bulb powered by imaginary electric currents. No fusion at all according to some idiots. Fusion magically happening somewhere, e.g. at the surface but not frying Earth with gamma rays.

Not to go off topic but what’s going on in the corona then rc? :blush:

Do YOU know?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom