Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, without ploughing through the literature again, my take on it would be that there is a mixture of ice and dust below the surface. As the ice that was seen at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 was pure, based on its survival time against sublimation, then one has to assume that the two are mixed areally, rather than intimately. In other words, the ice and dust are separate, rather than the dust being within the ice. This scenario may change near-surface, as sublimating ice refreezes (sinters), as it may well freeze within the voids of fluffy particles.
It should be noted that there was good evidence that the dust/ ice ratio at Tempel 1 was probably greater than 1 (from Rosetta's OSIRIS, no less):

A large dust/ice ratio in the nucleus of comet 9P/Tempel 1
Küppers, M. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature04236 (paywalled)

So the ice and dust are separate and based on its (ice) survival time against sublimation should reach rosetta.

The morphology of the grains collected byCOSIMA supports the presence of solely refractory material. A grain composed of an ice–mineral mixture would not shatter at low-velocity collection; instead, the icy part of such a grain would evaporate very shortly after collection, leaving one or more voids in the particle that remains on the target plate. Grains composed
of (nearly) pure water-ice would evaporate at or shortly after collection
and create a dark signature on the target plate. At the scale of the
COSIMA image resolution (pixel size is 14 mm), there is no hint of
volatiles having left the grains after collection. In other words, there is
no indication of an ice–mineral mixture, or of pure icy grains hitting
the target. This is in contrast to cometary grains remotely observed, or
collected before the Rosetta mission.
Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko sheds dust coat accumulated over the past four years Rita Schulz1,

So no "ice"? just dust.
 
Actually, I screwed up that calculation! It should read;
...and ~0.5 km3 is ice. That is ~ 5 x 108 tonnes of ice (5 x 1011 kg = 500 million tonnes).
I thought it looked too low when the total mass is ~ 1 x 1013 kg. So, that leaves us with ~ 9.5 x 1012 kg of dust. Divided by 3.2 km3 (3.2 x 109 m3) = ~ 3000 kg/m3 for the dust. Seems a bit high, but in the ballpark, given that I was using the highest dust/ ice volume ratios.

I'd assume dust to water mass ratio is more or less the same as dust/gas ratio?
Well, the reported dust/ ice ratios of 2-6 were for volume, not mass. Not sure I've seen dust/ gas ratios, except as reported here, which could only be done meaningfully by mass anyway. So, if there is 6 x more dust than ice by volume, and 1m3 of dust has a mass 3 x that of ice, then dust would account for 18 x more mass than ice overall.

what is the km3 of empty space?
Vacuum. Hence the very low permittivity (vacuum = 1, ice = 3, rock is higher)
 
So the ice and dust are separate and based on its (ice) survival time against sublimation should reach rosetta.

No. It'll reach Rosetta as vapour, because it has sublimated. The only reason for the solid grains at Tempel 1 was due to the impact blasting them out. At Hartley 2 it was due to the ice being entrained by the vigorous CO2 jetting. There may well be some ice in the coma, but it could be 'dirty'. OSIRIS evidently saw some, due to the rocket action of the sublimation making the grains defy gravity and shoot all over the place. Alice detected ice grains in the outburst reported by Agarwal. I'm sure I saw a report of ROSINA, which isn't a dust instrument, catching a dust grain that had ice in it. I'll have to look.
 
Last edited:
No. It'll reach Rosetta as vapour, because it has sublimated. The only reason for the solid grains at Tempel 1 was due to the impact blasting them out. At Hartley 2 it was due to the ice being entrained by the vigorous CO2 jetting. There may well be some ice in the coma, but it could be 'dirty'. OSIRIS evidently saw some, due to the rocket action of the sublimation making the grains defy gravity and shoot all over the place. Alice detected ice grains in the outburst reported by Agarwal. I'm sure I saw a report of ROSINA, which isn't a dust instrument, catching a dust grain that had ice in it. I'll have to look.

Is that the dust grain Philae detected? Dust Impact Monitor (SESAME-DIM) on board Rosetta/Philae: Millimetric particle flux at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Attila Hirn1,2

1 single impact?
 
I said:


Indeed it did. More than one, actually;

Chemical composition of the semi-volatile grains of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Wurz, P. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2017EGUGA..19.5587W (conference abstract).

Yup a full 9!

The major groups of chemical species are hydrocarbons, oxygenated hydrocarbons, nitrogen-bearing molecules, sulphur-bearing molecules, halogenated molecules and others (including water and CO2). About 70% of these grains are depleted in water compared to the comet coma, thus, can be considered as semi-volatile dust grains, and the other about 30% are water grains.

What’s a water grain, jd116! Ice?

COSIMA and GIADA detected nix and ROSINA did?

Wurz, P. et al. Ever publish a peer reviewed paper to show how they arrived at this conclusion?

Looking looking but not finding, just some paper on sputtering.
 
Last edited:
Yup a full 9!



What’s a water grain, jd116! Ice?

COSIMA and GIADA detected nix and ROSINA did?

Wurz, P. et al. Ever publish a peer reviewed paper to show how they arrived at this conclusion?

Looking looking but not finding, just some paper on sputtering.

As I said, why are you getting so hung up with solid grains? There was no impact at 67P, nor were there the vigorous jets of Hartley 2. So we wouldn't expect to see many. At Tempel 1 and Hartley 2 there would have been enough of them per unit volume for them to be picked up spectroscopically in IR, not to mention visible to the naked eye at Hartley 2. That is very unlikely at 67P. As well as one of their IR channels failing not helping matters. So, it is left to serendipitous findings such as those by ROSINA, Alice and OSIRIS.

I'm not aware of any paper by Wurz et al on the volatile and semi-volatile grains. The conference was only last year.

Reading the abstract I assume that the water grains refer to the inclusion of ice in or on dust.
 
Sol88: Usual insanely ignorant lies about the science of comets.

Clueless parrot comes to mind. Hey rc?
True: Your clueless and mindless parroting of the Thunderbolts cult dogma has been in mind to all readers of this thread for years. That is the situation.

7 February 2018: Usual insanely ignorant lies about the science of comets.
The porosity of Comet 67P has been measured to be high.

The density of all comets have been measured to be below that of water and several times below that of rock. We know what comets are made of (ices and dust). Thus a low density = a high porosity.

7 February 2018: Usual idiotic questions to derail from his comet delusions.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Sol88: Gibberish, ignorance and lies to derail from his comet delusions

So fluffy ducks all the way down!...
7 February 2018: Gibberish, ignorance and lies to derail from his comet delusions.

The idiotic crank demand for "proof" when science has evidence and the overwhelming evidence is that comets have densities too low to be rock or even water :eye-poppi.

He lies about a "suspected impact crater". A crater at the point of an impact is an impact crater :eye-poppi.
He lies that the size of that crater in a "fuzzy photo" is not proof of anything. The measured size of the crater is evidence that the comet is not his delusion of rock.
He lies because the mainstream does model comets as various ratios of ices and dust from ice dominating to dust dominating.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Sol88: Stardust idiocy to derail from his comet delusions

The Dust is from the comet, yes?...
7 February 2018: Stardust idiocy to derail from his comet delusions

The Stardust mission told us nothing new about the porosity of comet nuclei. It returned dust grains from the comet coma. That was yet another confirmation that comets contain dust.

We have the mass of many comets measured over centuries before Stardust.
We have the volume of many comets measured over many decades before Stardust.
The mass and volume give us the low density of comets. The porosity then has to be high because ices and dust in a matrix need empty space to produce that low density.

What makes this whining about Stardust truly idiotic is that the grains make his comet delusions massively wrong. The grains collected by Stardust are not from Earth or any other planet. Some of them may be interstellar dust grains.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Sol88: Sstupid "refractory free ice" + "silca minerals" and "beddust" lies

...or like Tempel 1 pure refractory free ice, some x meters below the surface which is composed of silca minerals at around 2500kg m3?
7 February 2018: Stupid "refractory free ice" + "silca minerals" and "beddust" lies

He lies that the papers state that the surface is "silca minerals" with a subsurface of "pure refractory free ice"
He lies that anything in the papers says that any comet is made of rock (his "beddust").

He insanely cites the detection of water ice grains in the ejecta when he wants a comet made of rock and knows about the low amount of water ices detected on the surface of Tempel 1:eye-poppi! But I am sure he can make up yet another delusion to explain this.

The also insane citation of a paper pointing out the ejecta water ices + lack of surface water ices obviously means that the source of the water ices was below the surface.

The insanity that renaming scientific terms will support any of his comet delusions. Plus lying about what his comets delusions start with - that comets are made of rock.

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND (PDF) is a conference paper that makes his prophet Wal Thornhill into a deluded liar. It has an impact flash and no flash before impact. It looks at the composition of part of the ejecta - an arc of incandescent material preceding the bulk of the ejecta.

Detection of water ice grains after the DEEP IMPACT onto Comet P/Tempel

The distribution of water ice in the interior of Comet Tempel 1
 
Last edited:
Sol88: A stupid suggestion to run a calculation for an imaginary universe

What if you ran the same calculation as above with a upper ratio of 100:1?
7 February 2018: A stupid suggestion to run a calculation for an imaginary universe.
The "high end of the estimates" of the ratio of dust to ices was 6:1. The calculation can only be done for lower values.

7 February 201: Irrelevant "empty space" questions to derail from his comet delusions
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I screwed up that calculation! It should read;
...and ~0.5 km3 is ice. That is ~ 5 x 108 tonnes of ice (5 x 1011 kg = 500 million tonnes).
I thought it looked too low when the total mass is ~ 1 x 1013 kg. So, that leaves us with ~ 9.5 x 1012 kg of dust. Divided by 3.2 km3 (3.2 x 109 m3) = ~ 3000 kg/m3 for the dust. Seems a bit high, but in the ballpark, given that I was using the highest dust/ ice volume ratios.


Well, the reported dust/ ice ratios of 2-6 were for volume, not mass. Not sure I've seen dust/ gas ratios, except as reported here, which could only be done meaningfully by mass anyway. So, if there is 6 x more dust than ice by volume, and 1m3 of dust has a mass 3 x that of ice, then dust would account for 18 x more mass than ice overall.


Vacuum. Hence the very low permittivity (vacuum = 1, ice = 3, rock is higher)



So Comets Are Like Deep Fried Ice Cream is a fairly accurate description? :D

Water molecules are haphazardly mixed with other molecules, such as the organics, and remain frozen in that state. Amorphous ice is like cotton candy, explains Gudipati: light and fluffy and filled with pockets of space.

But with a hard shell of refractory material on the outside!

So maybe candy covered deep fried ice cream would be more apt?
 
Last edited:
Sol88: An idiotic "Deep Fried Ice Cream" question to derail from his comet delusions

7 February 2018: An idiotic "Deep Fried Ice Cream" question to derail from his comet delusions.
Idiotic because
  • That is a description of an ices and dust comet which according to him does not exist :eye-poppi and
  • jonesdave116's post is about dust/ ice volume ratios of comets, not composition.

7 February 2018: A "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie to be added to his comet delusions.
The evidence is that comets tend to have a soft layer of dust and ices on their outside, e.g. the dust layer found on 67P. This is expected by anyone who is not blind. A ball of ices and dust is heated by the Sun. The ices sublimate leaving a surface layer with less ices and more dust. Thus a dusty layer forms. The layer is soft because it is the ices that hold the dust particles together.

We have evidence that at one location on 1 comet (the Philae landing site on 67P) there is a subsurface layer of sintered ices.
Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Abstract
Thermal and mechanical material properties determine comet evolution and even solar system formation because comets are considered remnant volatile-rich planetesimals. Using data from the Multipurpose Sensors for Surface and Sub-Surface Science (MUPUS) instrument package gathered at the Philae landing site Abydos on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko, we found the diurnal temperature to vary between 90 and 130 K. The surface emissivity was 0.97, and the local thermal inertia was 85 ± 35 J m−2 K−1s-1/2. The MUPUS thermal probe did not fully penetrate the near-surface layers, suggesting a local resistance of the ground to penetration of >4 megapascals, equivalent to >2 megapascal uniaxial compressive strength. A sintered near-surface microporous dust-ice layer with a porosity of 30 to 65% is consistent with the data.
Emphasis added.

Comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: Hardening of the sub-surface layer
Abstract
From the operation of the MUPUS thermal probe Spohn et al. (2015) concluded that the material of the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko is likely to have a high strength, at least locally at the Philae landing site. In this work we consider the derived strength of the material in order to constrain its granulation. For this purpose we performed numerical simulations of the long-term sintering of ice–dust granular mixtures of different granulation, covered by a dust mantle. The dust mantle has a thickness of 0–16 cm, and a (pore size and temperature-dependent) thermal conductivity. According to our simulations a hardened layer at least a meter thick forms beneath the dust only when the grains are tens of microns in radius, or smaller.


His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, etc. etc.
+ a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie.
 
Last edited:
So Comets Are Like Deep Fried Ice Cream is a fairly accurate description? :D



But with a hard shell of refractory material on the outside!

So maybe candy covered deep fried ice cream would be more apt?

Give it up, you prawn. There is zero evidence of your lunacy, yes? There is a multitude of evidence in favour of the obvious outcome. As it stands, the electric comet woo is evidence free. Yes? You are possibly the only idiot on the planet who still believes this crap. Please give it up. It is becoming like shooting fish in a barrel. A piece of p***. I doubt that even the loons Thornhill & Talbott believed this crap. Bizarrely, you do. Weird that, eh? Please, do tell us about your scientific education, that led you to believe in this woo. I'd be really interested. I'm always interested in countries that have crap education standards.
 
So Comets Are Like Deep Fried Ice Cream is a fairly accurate description? :D



But with a hard shell of refractory material on the outside!

So maybe candy covered deep fried ice cream would be more apt?


Right - my apologies for almost losing it last night, but you must forgive me. I get a leeeeettle bit sick of explaining the same things over and over and over again, to somebody who is wilfully ignorant, and fails to take the slightest notice of actual evidence, in favour of carrying on with a belief in unscientific impossibilities.
The following is an example of what I mean:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11183619&postcount=2471

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11585429&postcount=2674

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11589697&postcount=2715

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11649808&postcount=2925

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11652045&postcount=2936

So, firstly, who said this layer was composed of 'refractory' materials? Answer: nobody. Why would it need to be? Answer: it doesn't.


TBH, if it was up to me, or if this was the Cosmoquest ATM thread, then I would CLOSE THIS THREAD. It is accomplishing nothing other than allowing one person to gleefully show of their wilful ignorance, whilst grandstanding for equally deluded lurkers. Nothing new is being added, and we are constantly having to explain things that have been explained umpteen times before.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom