Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well if M.Volwerk, M.Taylor, Jean-Pierre Bibring and others call it rock, ok if I do from now on?

Ok by you Tusenfem?

A rock in the wind is just a funny title taking some literary freedom.
If you want to call it a rock, call it a rock, what do I care?
Just be reminded that in the original "dirty snowball" the "rock" is made of meteoritic material.
 
I follow the RPC tweets and I've a fair idea on the "joke" :thumbsup:

What was the talk at Umeå on?

About "a rock in the wind"

The Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko has given us a treasure trove of data on the plasma environment around this weakly outgassing comet. In this presentation I will discuss some of the surprising findings by the Rosetta Plasma Consortium, such as “non-classical” magnetic field draping around the nucleus, the singing comet, the diamagnetic cavity and the near-tail region. First an introduction into modern cometary plasma physics will be given, starting at Alfvén and Biermann and the first cometary missions to comet 1P/Halley, before I dive into the more complicated Rosetta data set.
 
About "a rock in the wind"

The Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko has given us a treasure trove of data on the plasma environment around this weakly outgassing comet. In this presentation I will discuss some of the surprising findings by the Rosetta Plasma Consortium, such as “non-classical” magnetic field draping around the nucleus, the singing comet, the diamagnetic cavity and the near-tail region. First an introduction into modern cometary plasma physics will be given, starting at Alfvén and Biermann and the first cometary missions to comet 1P/Halley, before I dive into the more complicated Rosetta data set.


Well received I take it?
 
A rock in the wind is just a funny title taking some literary freedom.
If you want to call it a rock, call it a rock, what do I care?
Just be reminded that in the original "dirty snowball" the "rock" is made of meteoritic material.


Great :thumbsup: Any else mind? RC? Jd116? Even me ‘ol mate fred burfle?

As rc said, for the want of a better word, ROCK will do. :)

Now I wonder if ANY of those SURPRISING results from the RPC mob might introduce an error in the RSI mobs signal data?

Little bit like a strong solar flare mess’n up GPS timing signals.
 
Last edited:
And you know big slice of problem pie goes in the bin when the bulk density goes toward 2-3g/cm3?

And

If the dust to water ratio implies WET DUST and a percentage is highly hydrated, be interesting to see jd116 napkin calculations, recalculated.

Sunshine’s much beloved “ice” becomes less necessary. I’m sure Whipple won’t mind too much. :) that’s science.
 
Last edited:
About "a rock in the wind"

The Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko has given us a treasure trove of data on the plasma environment around this weakly outgassing comet. In this presentation I will discuss some of the surprising findings by the Rosetta Plasma Consortium, such as “non-classical” magnetic field draping around the nucleus, the singing comet, the diamagnetic cavity and the near-tail region. First an introduction into modern cometary plasma physics will be given, starting at Alfvén and Biermann and the first cometary missions to comet 1P/Halley, before I dive into the more complicated Rosetta data set.

I’ll ask you one polite question, if I may?

Out of all the surprises, what surprised a space plasma physicist the most, from the Rosetta/Philea mission? :)

Plasma wise of course.
 
Last edited:
What did J Sunshine say on hydrated minerals on the surface of a comet?

Investigation of the states of water and OH groups on the surface of silica
Liu Peng∗, Wang Qisui, Li Xi, Zhang Chaocan


NEAR INFRARED CHARACTERIZATION OF WATER AND HYDROXYL GROUPS ON SILICA SURFACES J. H. ANDERSON, JR. and K. A. WICKERSHEIM*

WATER ABSORPTION SPECTRUM

Sunshine’s paper is too simplistic but I guess that was done on purpose for its target audience.

A complete irrelevance. How many times do you need to be told? Including an email from J. Sunshine. They detected ice in the ejecta. End of story. There was ice around Hartley 2. Alice detected ice in an outburst at 67P. Ice has been detected around other comets, and I've given you links to the papers. It is ice. There is no doubt. Now quit this nonsense, and get over it. It is hardly recent news.
And what the hell would you know about "simplistic"? You believe an idiot who thinks Velikovsky's rubbish is viable! And that solar wind H+ is going to magically combine with non-existent O- to create water! Give us a break. You simply don't understand enough about the science to question it. Neither does the idiot Thornhill.
 
Last edited:
And you know big slice of problem pie goes in the bin when the bulk density goes toward 2-3g/cm3?

And

If the dust to water ratio implies WET DUST and a percentage is highly hydrated, be interesting to see jd116 napkin calculations, recalculated.

Sunshine’s much beloved “ice” becomes less necessary. I’m sure Whipple won’t mind too much. :) that’s science.

More idiocy. The bulk density is nowhere near 2-3g cm-3. So a bit of a pointless claim, isn't it? No rock, and a density of ~535 kg m-3. As measured. And nothing can change that. I don't need to calculate anything. The density is measured. QED. It doesn't matter if the comet is composed of dairy milk chocolate; the density has been measured. It is a fact. Get over it.
Want me to email Jessica Sunshine again? Tell her that some unqualified woo merchant is questioning what she detected? Like she said, there is no point explaining this to various idiots, who are just going to believe their idiocy regardless. Particularly when they have books, DVDs and conference tickets to sell to their scientifically illiterate followers. Believe what you like - there is zero evidence for it.
 
Now I wonder if ANY of those SURPRISING results from the RPC mob might introduce an error in the RSI mobs signal data?

Little bit like a strong solar flare mess’n up GPS timing signals.

Dear God. The idiocy. How long did this solar flare go on for? Over 2 years was it? See what I mean about scientific illiteracy? Why don't you download the RPC data, and have a look at the solar wind measurements from when the measurements were made? And for every day after that where Rosetta managed not to crash into the comet? Pure, unadulterated idiocy.
 
Sunshine’s much beloved “ice” becomes less necessary

Which part of the following is beyond your ability to understand?:

IT DOESN'T MATTER ABOUT "NECESSARY"! IT IS DETECTED. END OF STORY. GET OVER IT.
 
Aaaaannnnddddd......more lunacy!

Assumed to be ice 'cause that's what comets are, dirtysnowballs!

most defiantly not ROCK!!

I've already explained to you what the OSIRIS cameras are. They are not IR cameras. They are looking at dust in the coma. The ice is detected in IR. There is no chance of mistaking it for hydrated anything. Get an education on such matters, before making a fool of yourself. Again.
 
And the ignorance continues........

So what are we going to call this non rocky, rocky looking stuff that is a comet?

.....he asks, having just quoted the following........

Overhang compressive strength ranged from 3-15 Pa (upper limit 150 Pa), a 4-30 Pa

Seriously, what is the point? If you can't figure out what you're quoting, then why quote it?
 
A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.

And again................... Jesus H. Christ. Would you like me to quote the email from Skorov again? How many times? What is it going to take? Ignorance I can forgive, but wilful ignorance not.
 
Great :thumbsup: Any else mind? RC? Jd116? Even me ‘ol mate fred burfle?

As rc said, for the want of a better word, ROCK will do. :)

Now I wonder if ANY of those SURPRISING results from the RPC mob might introduce an error in the RSI mobs signal data?

Little bit like a strong solar flare mess’n up GPS timing signals.

Soooooo, can I call it rock, jd116? :duck:
 
A complete irrelevance. How many times do you need to be told? Including an email from J. Sunshine. They detected ice in the ejecta. End of story. There was ice around Hartley 2. Alice detected ice in an outburst at 67P. Ice has been detected around other comets, and I've given you links to the papers. It is ice. There is no doubt. Now quit this nonsense, and get over it. It is hardly recent news.
And what the hell would you know about "simplistic"? You believe an idiot who thinks Velikovsky's rubbish is viable! And that solar wind H+ is going to magically combine with non-existent O- to create water! Give us a break. You simply don't understand enough about the science to question it. Neither does the idiot Thornhill.

Not saying it was not detected, sport. You hit the nail on the head though, detected in quantities too small to account for much at all and it’s still pretty much “Dark Ice” hidden somewhere under the bedrock.

Too much dust not enough ice is the gist here champ :boggled:

Except in the ELECTRIC COMET it’s not!! :D
 
Aaaaannnnddddd......more lunacy!



I've already explained to you what the OSIRIS cameras are. They are not IR cameras. They are looking at dust in the coma. The ice is detected in IR. There is no chance of mistaking it for hydrated anything. Get an education on such matters, before making a fool of yourself. Again.

:dig:


Ummmm....did you even read the paper or my post before ya chucked a wobbly?

67. Cremonese, G. et al., 2016, Photometry of dust grains of comet 67P and connection with nucleus regions, A&A, 588, A59 doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201527307

Have a read on the interpretation of blue and comet “dust”, which by the way was also used to invoke “probable ice” on the surface as stated by H Sierks and the OSIRIS mob in a few papers and then regurgitated by others.

Photometry of coma dust grains show agreement with surface values, although some differences in composition from the surface could potentially indicate the presence of hydrated minerals [67].

So highly likely and far more probable hydrated minerals and not “ice”.

Though in cold traps why not a dusting of jack frost!

But the rock ‘aint made of ice :rub:
 
And you know big slice of problem pie goes in the bin when the bulk density goes toward 2-3g/cm3?.

We know the volume of 67P/CG: ~25 km3We know the weight of 67P/cg: ~1013 kg
We know the density of 67P/CG: ~4.1E11 kg/km3 or ~0.4 g/cm3
Why ever would the bulk density go towards 2 - 3? Is there some accretion of some electrical magical powder going on that you are hiding from us?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom