Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The papers coming out by the mainstream are slowly coming around to the idea, comets are NOT dirtysnowballs.

Because that thinking went out 30 years ago, as you have been told umpteen times. So they can't be slowly coming round to anything, when they've known it for a long time, eh? Your trouble is that you lap up the crap spouted by idiots like Thornhill, who wouldn't recognise a comet if it hit him on the head.
 
In fact there a raft of new papers out on Ceres.

Nature, formation, and distribution of carbonates on Ceres
Filippo Giacomo Carrozzo,1* Maria Cristina De Sanctis,1 Andrea Raponi,1

Thedifferent chemical forms of the sodium carbonate, their fresh appearance, morphological settings, and the uneven distribution on Ceres indicate that the formation, exposure, dehydration, and destruction processes of carbonates are recurrent and continuous in recent geological time, implying a still-evolving body and modern processes involving fluid water.

And

Variations in the amount of water ice on Ceres’ surface suggest a seasonal water cycle Andrea Raponi,1* Maria Cristina De Sanctis,1 Alessandro Frigeri,1 Eleonora Ammannito,2 Mauro Ciarniello,1 Michelangelo Formisano,1 Jean-Philippe Combe,3 Gianfranco Magni,1 Federico Tosi,1 Filippo Giacomo Carrozzo,1 Sergio Fonte,1 Marco Giardino,1 Steven P. Joy,4 Carol A. Polanskey,5 Marc D. Rayman,5 Fabrizio Capaccioni,1 Maria Teresa Capria,1 Andrea Longobardo,1 Ernesto Palomba,1

Is Ceres a comet? Maybe captured old dormant comet?

The dwarf planet Ceres is known to host a considerable amount of water in its interior, and areas of water ice were detected by the Dawn spacecraft on its surface. Moreover, sporadic water and hydroxyl emissions have been observed from space telescopes. We report the detection of water ice in a mid-latitude crater and its unexpected variation with time. The Dawn spectrometer data show a change of water ice signatures over a period of 6 months, which is well modeled as ~2-km2 increase of water ice. The observed increase, coupled with Ceres’ orbital parameters, points to an ongoing process that seems correlated with solar flux. The reported variation on Ceres’ surface indicates that this body is chemically and physically active at the present time.

Seems there a common denominator with a comets “water’ cycle.




Now if “rc drivel here”, indeed did come from Mars...

Reflectance spectra diversity of silica-rich materials: Sensitivity to environment and implications for detections on Mars

Spectrophotometric properties of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from the OSIRIS instrument onboard the ROSETTA spacecraft.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

Asteroids are classically understood to be essentially inert objects composed primarily of non-volatile material. They are mostly found in the inner solar system (inside the orbit of Jupiter) where they are believed to have formed. Meanwhile, comets are classically thought of as ice-rich bodies originally from the outer solar system
 
Last edited:
NO, the ELECTRIC SUN claims the exact statement above as being contradicted by the observed temperature of the corona compared with the photosphere!

The only other place on the sun we’ve measured the temperature :rolleyes:

You are wrong. The photosphere is in thermal contact with deep space because the corona is transparent. What is beneath the photosphere is not in thermal contact with deep space, because the photosphere is opaque. So it cannot be, as you claimed, cooler than the photosphere.
 
In fact there a raft of new papers out on Ceres.

Nature, formation, and distribution of carbonates on Ceres
Filippo Giacomo Carrozzo,1* Maria Cristina De Sanctis,1 Andrea Raponi,1



And

Variations in the amount of water ice on Ceres’ surface suggest a seasonal water cycle Andrea Raponi,1* Maria Cristina De Sanctis,1 Alessandro Frigeri,1 Eleonora Ammannito,2 Mauro Ciarniello,1 Michelangelo Formisano,1 Jean-Philippe Combe,3 Gianfranco Magni,1 Federico Tosi,1 Filippo Giacomo Carrozzo,1 Sergio Fonte,1 Marco Giardino,1 Steven P. Joy,4 Carol A. Polanskey,5 Marc D. Rayman,5 Fabrizio Capaccioni,1 Maria Teresa Capria,1 Andrea Longobardo,1 Ernesto Palomba,1

Is Ceres a comet? Maybe captured old dormant comet?



Seems there a common denominator with a comets “water’ cycle.




Now if “rc drivel here”, indeed did come from Mars...

Reflectance spectra diversity of silica-rich materials: Sensitivity to environment and implications for detections on Mars

Spectrophotometric properties of the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko from the OSIRIS instrument onboard the ROSETTA spacecraft.

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system

That might make sense to you, but I cannot see the relevance. Spell it out.
 
Who cares about DLs? None were seen. None are needed to explain anything. There was also no EDM (lol), and no rock. So the EC is dead. Why don't you leave the experts to get on with the plasma physics? To the best of my knowledge, EU doesn't possess any.

:eusa_eh:


Whoo boy...

They been detected alright, notably at the more strongly discharging comet 1P

7. The cometopause is observed inbound at 160,000km with a thickness of 10,000km. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively charged inner surface with a potential drop of 50-100 kV. A current layer, with a thickness of 22,000 km and the electric current flowing from dawn to dusk is located on Vega 1 outside the cometopause at a distance of 8,000 km. The current layer contains the solar wind plasma flow that is not properly able to penetrate the cometopause but is diverted to move along the cometopause.

9. A current layer of thickness-7, 000 km is crossed at 0709 UT (54,000k in) by Vega 1. This layer is provided by the magnetic Field formerly stored inside this transition. In the current layer the cold electron density increases significantly which results in the rapid saturation of the measurements. The dc electric field exhibits a large gradient(the total potential drop over the layer is -135 kV), and a plasma wave burst is observed simultaneously.
ELECTRIC FIELDS AND COLD ELECTRONS AT COMET HALLEY LAKKSO

Those champ are current carrying double layers that care not for your Debye length!

Vega 1 probed the double layers on it's whizz past 1P and the data from that flyby is very similar to the SAFIRE loons dicking around with "plasma balls" in vacuum chambers, probing, recording and hypothesising. or as tusenfem says, getting or philosophical!

SAFIRE-Project-Report.pdf


A major discovery is that of an electro chemical catalytic process between hydrogen and other trace elements. It has been found to be the primary reason for the formation of the stable spherical plasma double layer shells. The formation of these shells causes the plasma to behave as a transforming capacitor. These extremely powerful electromagnetic shells are responsible for the trapping of high energy electrons, ions and photons.

The trapping prevents the ions from flying out and smashing up against the cathodes and the steel walls of the chamber. It keeps the high energies contained within the plasma, energies that would otherwise destroy the apparatus. The spherical plasma double layer shells show no sign of being affected by gravity – they are spherical and would require little or no inertial damping. This is enormously significant

Another surprise: both solid and hollow anodes are cooler than the plasma – defying the laws of thermodynamics. Although there was H being diffused through the hollow anode the temperatures of both the solid and hollow anodes were similar. These responses may be due to the extremely thin but powerful plasma double layer forming just off the surface of the anode. This limits electrons from impinging on the anode surface that would otherwise heat the anode to higher temperatures.

and

The last one is for you especially ziggurat!

Of course no peer reviewed papers yet but it's looking promising and i think they are heading in the right direction!

After all, who is going to be the next Einstein or Hawking for the mainstream gravity bangers?
 
Last edited:
You are wrong. The photosphere is in thermal contact with deep space because the corona is transparent. What is beneath the photosphere is not in thermal contact with deep space, because the photosphere is opaque. So it cannot be, as you claimed, cooler than the photosphere.

Sorry, my error.

I got my information from places such as wiki.

These high stages of ionisation indicate a plasma temperature in excess of 1,000,000 kelvins,[1] much hotter than the surface of the Sun

but

The Sun's photosphere has a temperature between 4,500 and 6,000 K (4,230 and 5,730 °C)[3] (with an effective temperature of 5,777 K (5,504 °C))[4]

They must have it wrong. Would you be prepared to edit this entry and correct the mistake?
 
:eusa_eh:


Whoo boy...

They been detected alright, notably at the more strongly discharging comet 1P

ELECTRIC FIELDS AND COLD ELECTRONS AT COMET HALLEY LAKKSO

Those champ are current carrying double layers that care not for your Debye length!

Vega 1 probed the double layers on it's whizz past 1P and the data from that flyby is very similar to the SAFIRE loons dicking around with "plasma balls" in vacuum chambers, probing, recording and hypothesising. or as tusenfem says, getting or philosophical!

SAFIRE-Project-Report.pdf

Nope. Read that paper. Never mentions DLs. I recall Tusenfem commenting on it, and he wasn't seeing them, either. Even Laakso wasn't convinced by some of his readings. However, none of that has any relevance to the death of the EC woo. Whatever was seen, it was creating no EDM (lol), no rock, no discharges to/ from the nucleus, etc. And that is what your woo predicted. And got horribly wrong.
 
They must have it wrong. Would you be prepared to edit this entry and correct the mistake?

Nothing I said contradicts your source, and nothing in your source contradicts what I said. You still haven't grasped the significance of the transparency of the corona. It's quite fundamental to making such a temperature profile thermodynamically possible, regardless of the heating mechanism of the corona. Seriously, if the corona were not transparent, then even under an electric universe model, the photosphere could not be cooler. It would be a thermodynamic impossibility.

Again, to make myself as plain as possible, no matter what heats the photosphere, and no matter what heats the corona, the photosphere can only be colder than the corona because the corona is transparent. And no matter what heats what, nothing inside the photosphere can be colder than the photosphere, because the photosphere is NOT transparent. This is INDEPENDENT of any POSSIBLE model you want to make for the sun. It's dictated by the simple laws of thermodynamics.
 
You are wrong. The photosphere is in thermal contact with deep space because the corona is transparent. What is beneath the photosphere is not in thermal contact with deep space, because the photosphere is opaque. So it cannot be, as you claimed, cooler than the photosphere.

Solar Corona
Temperature in excess of 1,000,000 kelvins,[1] much hotter than the surface of the Sun.

Photosphere
The Sun's photosphere has a temperature between 4,500 and 6,000 K (4,230 and 5,730 °C)[3] (with an effective temperature of 5,777 K (5,504 °C))[4]

Sunspots
Although they are at temperatures of roughly 3,000–4,500 K (2,700–4,200 °C), the contrast with the surrounding material at about 5,780 K (5,500 °C) leaves sunspots clearly visible as dark spots

Roughly the order we observe yeah!
 
Solar Corona

Photosphere

Sunspots

Roughly the order we observe yeah!

You still aren't paying any attention. You think that this disproves me, but in point of fact I'm explaining the thermodynamic requirements for exactly these observations. And those requirements are independent of what solar model you want to use.

Oh, and in case it isn't obvious, sun spots are not beneath the photosphere.
 
You still aren't paying any attention. You think that this disproves me, but in point of fact I'm explaining the thermodynamic requirements for exactly these observations. And those requirements are independent of what solar model you want to use.

Oh, and in case it isn't obvious, sun spots are not beneath the photosphere.

Ok stop waltzing around, is the solar corona hotter or cooler than the photosphere, ziggurat?
 
Nothing I said contradicts your source, and nothing in your source contradicts what I said. You still haven't grasped the significance of the transparency of the corona. It's quite fundamental to making such a temperature profile thermodynamically possible, regardless of the heating mechanism of the corona. Seriously, if the corona were not transparent, then even under an electric universe model, the photosphere could not be cooler. It would be a thermodynamic impossibility.

Again, to make myself as plain as possible, no matter what heats the photosphere, and no matter what heats the corona, the photosphere can only be colder than the corona because the corona is transparent. And no matter what heats what, nothing inside the photosphere can be colder than the photosphere, because the photosphere is NOT transparent. This is INDEPENDENT of any POSSIBLE model you want to make for the sun. It's dictated by the simple laws of thermodynamics.

The voltage drop of 270 volts very close to the chamber anode, if converted entirely into temperature, would equate to 3,000,000 K, which, remarkably, is the same temperature increase seen when moving from the Sun's chromosphere to its lower corona.

Solar Corona
Quote:
Temperature in excess of 1,000,000 kelvins,[1] much hotter than the surface of the Sun.
Photosphere
Quote:
The Sun's photosphere has a temperature between 4,500 and 6,000 K (4,230 and 5,730 °C)[3] (with an effective temperature of 5,777 K (5,504 °C))[4]

Regardless if it's transparent or not. It's what we observe! :D

Would you like to stoke the ELECTRIC SUN thread back up?

Photosphere (temperature between 4,500 and 6,000 K) > temp increase(shed loads, what percentage increase is that????)>>>>>>>>>>Corona (1,000,000 kelvins,)
 
Last edited:
Regardless if it's transparent or not. It's what we observe! :D

You don't actually know what thermodynamics is, do you? You don't actually know why heat flows from hot things to cold things, and not the reverse.
 
Ok stop waltzing around, is the solar corona hotter or cooler than the photosphere, ziggurat?

It's hotter. But it's only able to be hotter because it's transparent. If it were not transparent, then anything inside it would heat up to at least its own temperature.

And that is independent of its energy source.
 
Would you like to stoke the ELECTRIC SUN thread back up?

No. Why don't you start a new thread? Call it, "Look what happens when you put a squillion volts through a metal ball." I'm sure it'll be very popular.
 
No. Why don't you start a new thread? Call it, "Look what happens when you put a squillion volts through a metal ball." I'm sure it'll be very popular.

So you are much more comfortable with theoretical models and not empirical science the SAFIRE mob a doing?

Because your model would be “look what happens when you divide by zero!”, infinite density!!

Math, pffftt...
 
Last edited:
It's hotter. But it's only able to be hotter because it's transparent. If it were not transparent, then anything inside it would heat up to at least its own temperature.

And that is independent of its energy source.

Then what’s that white stuff around the Sun in an eclipse? Like your avatar.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom