Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Then what’s that white stuff around the Sun in an eclipse? Like your avatar.

Mostly transparent. Which is why you can see the photosphere. It's so transparent that despite being far hotter, you can't see the corona unless you block the photosphere.

This is really basic stuff. Why are you failing it so badly?
 
Mostly transparent. Which is why you can see the photosphere. It's so transparent that despite being far hotter, you can't see the corona unless you block the photosphere.

This is really basic stuff. Why are you failing it so badly?

Yes yes, I should really stop but it’s just so funny reading your posts. :D
 
Yes yes, I should really stop but it’s just so funny reading your posts. :D

Not as funny as you thinking you can see through something opaque. You can't even understand English, let alone physics.
 
Not as funny as you thinking you can see through something opaque. You can't even understand English, let alone physics.


Ha ha about as funny as a fart in an elevator. :thumbsup:

It's hotter. But it's only able to be hotter because it's transparent.

It’s (Solar corona) is hotter than the photosphere because it’s transparent! :D

Classic mainstream. :blush:


SAFIRE on the other hand ascribe plasma double layer as an alternative to ziggurat’s “transparent” corona!

One result came about empirically the other....not sure where Ziggy made that up from? I never heard the corona is transparent as an excuse for the coronas much high temp!
 
Last edited:
So you are much more comfortable with theoretical models and not empirical science the SAFIRE mob a doing?

Because your model would be “look what happens when you divide by zero!”, infinite density!!

Math, pffftt...

SAFIRE has nothing to do with comets, so is OT here. Take it somewhere else. There is an EU thread specifically for this kind of thing, still on the front page. Secondly, it has nothing to do with stars. Stars are not metal balls plugged into the mains. So it tells us nothing. Zilch. Zip. Nada. It is irrelevant. Unless you are interested in what happens when you put a squillion volts through a metal ball. I can't imagine the top science journals will be. So, we'll never hear about this, unless we go to youtube.
 
It’s (Solar corona) is hotter than the photosphere because it’s transparent! :D

Wow. Your problems with English continue.

Transparency is a necessary, but NOT SUFFICIENT, condition for the corona to be hotter. I never said it was sufficient, I only said it was necessary. Do you understand the distinction?

No, probably not.

I never heard the corona is transparent as an excuse for the coronas much high temp!

Why would you? For anyone who understands thermodynamics even on a basic level (which will include anyone doing real physics about the sun), it's so obvious it doesn't need to be said. Just like you don't hear much from the medical community about how horse bites can hurt babies.
 
The corona/photosphere most definitely. :thumbsup:

Whole other thread that but it is fundamental to the EC model.

When u mob come up with a coherent model on the coronas temp, call me.

the problem is not that we cannot heat the corona, there are many processes that are at work, there does, imho, not seem to be one specific process.
there are nanoflares, ohmic heating, alfvén waves, shock waves ...
of course everyone wants their pet theory to be the main one
the sun generates more than enough energy to heat the corona, so the question should be why is the corona so cold!
 
Ummmm....I don’t know, let’s ask an EXPERT, ay jd116? Somewhere where we have actually got some data on.

In Tusenfems paper Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma

Or Decca’s paper Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

How does the Debye length and force free currents come into play in answer to jd116’s question.

We can then move back to my favourite plasma phenomena, current carrying “DOUBLE LAYERS” :jaw-dropp

my current sheets hwve nothing to do with electric fields nor double layers, but all with curl B
 
Meh....:whistling :

Stop being a :dqueen

Have a chill pill and Come over here for a big :grouphug5

The papers coming out by the mainstream are slowly coming around to the idea, comets are NOT dirtysnowballs.

:monkeyr:

I personally eagerly await M.Volwerks new paper on 67P tail excursions with Rosetta RPC suite of goodies.

Not long now ay, tusenfem?

alrwady posted the link to a&a pages ago, where it is in the upcoming papers and out of my hands
 
Insanity of a Thunderbolts propaganda video on delusions about the Sun

Well hasn’t the SAFIRE project....
19 March 2018: Insanity of a Thunderbolts propaganda video on delusions about the Sun.

His insanity includes that anyone here will watch a video from the deluded Thunderbolts liars that is an hour and a half long :eek:!
10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

The video points to the SAFIRE web site where there is a PDF illuminating the ignorant delusions of at least one of the project leaders: engineer Montgomery Childs.
  • The insanity of "researching photovoltaic energy production systems" revealing a unstated contradiction with the standard model of solar physics.
  • A delusion of a group of scientists investigating an electric sun when there is a mythologist, a deluded ex-physicist, a retired electrical engineer (the only ne with a few published papers.
  • The insanity that the behavior of stars ""throughout human history" is how they behave all of the time.
  • Abysmal ignorance that the "simple process "with physical evidence is that stars are powered by fusion at their core.
  • Stupidity of an Crookes experiment placing rubies in an "electrically charged rarifies gas" (they glow) behaving anything to do with stars (balls of plasma!)
  • A "Sun's atmosphere is a stable plasma existing in the vacuum of space" lie.
    The Sun's atmosphere is a turbulent plasma with a complex structure interacting with its magnetic field.
    This ignorance about the Sun sparks a fantasy that the solar atmosphere can be recreated in the lab. And we get that 4 years ago the experiments started and still have not produced a single electric sun paper :eye-poppi!
  • The rest of the PDF has lies about images in their experiment that look nothing like activity on the Sun, looking like the Sun.
    The Sun does not have uniformly spaced "tufts", etc.
    The Sun's atmosphere is not concentric layers even if they lie by labeling the layers with temperatures they have not measured.
The true electric sun insanity seems to be a star that is powered by electrical currents without any fusion at all or other heat source at its center.
We detect the neutrino flux from that fusion in the Sun.

A stable star requires that gravity be balanced by thermal pressure, so temperature has to increase with depth and thus there must be a central heat source. For example when the Sun runs out of fusion, it will collapse to a white dwarf because the interior temperature becomes uniform. An external heat source can only produce a uniform temperature and an electric Sun has to be a white dwarf today :jaw-dropp!

There is obvious hypocrisy here since the other Thunderbolts cult prophets (Thornhill and Scott) know about the neutrinos and their delusion is fusion in the solar photosphere and once again the Sun has to be a white dwarf!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
A lying because already answered question to derail from his many comet delusions

What’s generating the electric fields at a comet, jd116?
19 March 2018: A lying because already answered question to derail from his many comet delusions.

For others:
This has been answered many times before: Cometary coma is plasma. Plasma is partially ionized gas. Ions have electric fields because they are charged. Electrons have electric fields because they are charged.

There is also the mainstream possibility that during the period of time that the coma does not prevent the solar wind from reaching the nucleus, the nucleus may preferentially hold onto ions or electrons from the solar wind. I suspect that this hypothetical charge will vanish with the formation of the coma because the replenishment of charge by the solar wind will stop and charge equalize by grabbing ions/electrons from the coma.

In any case, these are not his ignorant delusion about a solar electric field.
 
Is that mathamajics translated into a form of English?
It is not just mathematics - it is the empirical laws of thermodynamics that was established with your holy grail of experiments in labs here on Earth.

Start with The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi! that is based on the empirical laws of gravity and gas plus empirical observations (neutrinos!).

The thermodynamics is simple enough even for you to understand: Heat flows from hot to cold (with conditions).
Heat the Sun at its surface and its interior will heat up. Do that for billions of years and the hottest the interior can become the temperature of the surface = ~5700 K. This is something any cook knows - if you slow roast something at say 100 C for hours or even days, you do not have to worry about the center heating to many hundreds or thousands of degrees :eye-poppi.
A rational person will have a heat source at the center of the Sun so that that flows outward from the hot center to the cooler surface.

A condition that can allow the interior of the Sun to be cooler than the surface is that an alien race installs gigantic refrigerators inside the Sun, externally powers them and removes the hot gas somehow. But then we are back to
The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!
 
Last edited:
Stupid repeating of electric sun lies about the corona

NO, the ELECTRIC SUN claims the exact statement above as being contradicted by the observed temperature of the corona compared with the photosphere!
19 March 2018: Stupid repeating of electric sun lies about the corona.
He must know that the body of the Sun is not the corona :jaw-dropp!

Not having a heat source at the center of the Sun gives: The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!

For others:
The corona is different from the body of the Sun. In the body of the Sun heat is transferred by radiation in the innermost 2/3 and by convection in the outermost 1/3. The density of plasma then drops by a lot at the photosphere and we have plasma that is basically transparent to light. The plasma is no longer heated by the light but gets hotter rather then the expected colder. That means that a condition of the second law of thermodynamics is being broken, i.e. that the system is isolated. The solar atmosphere is thin plasma in a changing magnetic field. Magnetic fields contain energy. Changing magnetic fields can release energy. That changing magnetic field is an obvious source of energy to heat the plasma. There are two leading physical mechanisms to do this each with some empirical evidence:
  • "waves carry energy from the solar interior to the solar chromosphere and corona".
  • "nanoflares" with magnetic reconnection releasing energy.
 
Lies about detected electric fields being the electric field in his comet delusions

Whoo boy...
19 March 2018: Lies about detected electric fields being the electric field in his many comet delusions.

The mainstream expected electric fields in comet coma are not his delusion of an electrical field around the Sun creating electrical discharges on comet nuclei (in reality jets of sublimated ices and dust).

19 March 2018: Lies about "ELECTRIC FIELDS AND COLD ELECTRONS AT COMET HALLEY" by LAKKSO
No sign of double layers.

19 March 2018: Lies abut double layers that do "care about Debye length" as he knows from several posts.
Double layer
The thickness of a double layer is of the order of ten Debye lengths, which is a few centimeters in the ionosphere, a few tens of meters in the interplanetary medium, and tens of kilometers in the intergalactic medium.[citation needed]


19 March 2018: Idiocy of citing the deluded SAFIRE PDF which has the insanity of making the Sun a white dwarf!
The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
Lying solar corona question to derail from his many comet (and now sun) delusions

Ok stop waltzing around, is the solar corona hotter or cooler than the photosphere, ziggurat?
19 March 2018: Lying solar corona question to derail from his many comet (and now sun) delusions.
Ziggurat has said that the corona is hotter than the photosphere and why it is hotter.

His delusions about the Sun (unless he wants to acknowledge that he is making honest mistakes because he does not know about physics):
  • He has the delusion that the temperature of the solar corona is not explained by mainstream solar physics.
    The only question is which mechanism (or mixture of mechanisms) heats the corona.
  • He lies that the ignorant and deluded electric sun idea can explain the temperature of the corona.
    Fantasies do not explain anything.
  • He is ignorant about the Sun, i.e. that all stable stars need a central heat source to be stable + the Sun without a central heat source = a white dwarf.
  • He has the delusion that the inane SAFIRE experiment will say anything about the Sun.
    This is basically a metal sphere with an external (mains!) power cable. That is not the Sun which is plasma with the physical evidence giving fusion at its core.
    After 4 years all we have are lies from the SAFIRE group, e.g. images looking like activity on the Sun or the corona and The true insanity of the electric sun delusion is that it makes the Sun into a white dwarf :eye-poppi!

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom