Sol88
Philosopher
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2009
- Messages
- 8,437
My god! you have no idea what MHD is!
Just saying "MHD does not apply" does not mean that you actually know what MDH is.
Here is the original Alfvén paper in which he introduced the concept of MHD waves.
Okay, I am going to hate myself for doing this, but I cannot stand the idiocy of sol making claims without actually showing he understands what the concept of MHD is.
So, what every first-year student learns in "introduction to plasma physics" course is the MDH approximation of the plasma physics equations. This means that you do not look at the motion of individual particles, but like the name says, you assume that the plasma is a fluid. This means that the regular equations are averaged over the motion of the particles.
This means that MHD is only applicable if you look at spatial scales that are larger than the largest ion gyro radius and if you look at time scales that are longer than the longest ion gyro period.
So, basically, you have a multi fluid situation, with an electron fluid and a (multi-)ion fluid.
Now, Alfvén made an extra assumption in his paper, namely that the plasma conductivity σ = ∞ (infinitely conducting). If you do that, then you find that this results into E + v x B = 0, which leads to the interesting situation that the plasma and the magnetic field are frozen in.
Of course, space plasmas are very highly conducting, but not infinitely, so this leads to so-called "resistive MHD" in contrast to "ideal MHD" that Aflven wrote up in his 1942 paper. That certainly changes a few things, adding resistivity into the system. For example, then there are restrictions on the frozen in condition. One can only speak of the field being frozen in the plasma as long as you look at time scales which are below the magnetic diffusion time scale. This is basically the inverse of the conductivity.
In ideal MHD, there cannot be parallel electric fields, because of the infinite conductivity. However, does that exclude parallel electric currents? Currents, we know from Maxwell's equations, are either generated by a time varying electric field or by a changing magnetic field:
curl(B) = mu ( J + epsilon dE/dt )
so if something happens to the magnetic field, for example the foot points of a loop can shear, and thereby generate currents.
For the rest I would just point to the excellent chapter by Eric Priest in the Saas-Fee Advanced Course Lecture Notes (which can be found on the internet as pdf)
So actually it is very very simple what MDH means, and how it should be applied, and which limitations there are (and indeed very few of my colleagues seem to forget now and then these limitations, unfortunately)
Excellent post, this should clear up all the misconception people have on MHD. I appreciate the time you have taken out of your busy schedule to compile a concise succinct post.
So basically, if you "step back" far enough and do not take into account a few complicating factors plasma's can be considered ideal and MHD applies, greatly simplifying the maths?
Much the same way is if we "step back" far enough plasma (Space Plasma) can be considered Quasi-neutral?
More or less.
Would this be the correct understanding of the above 2 interpretations, tusenfem?
If my understanding is correct, we can then move forward without having to be accused of not understanding "basic" plasma physics.
Last edited:


