Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Fortunately, there isn't more to life than just living. You don't need more if you're doing it right. When you enjoy life, you don't ask for more: 'Is that all?!'
However, doing it right depends on your living conditions: A lot of people are forced to work so much that they don't have time to live, or they don't have the basic necessities for enjoying life.
That's what makes class struggle necessary.
Religion, the people's opium, enables them to carry on with their meaningless lives by giving them a delusory reason to accept unacceptable conditions.

:thumbsup:

"Living" is so vague a word, it's a meaningless concept outside of "not dead" or "was never alive", as well.
 
But how do you know that? I think I've mentioned elsewhere that IMO probably 90% of theists throughout history haven't really cared about God or their Holy Books. It's not that they CAN'T bring any critical analysis to bear on that, but they can't be bothered. What does it get them? They're busy with their lives, working and raising children.

That's the average theist. The non-average theist -- the other 10% -- probably have looked into their beliefs critically to some degree. I suggest you are coming from a position of "if they TRULY brought critical analysis to bear, they wouldn't be theists."

I'd also suggest that the percentages are the same for atheists as well.

Well as far as having a detailed knowledge of all that is inscribed in those Holy Books I would agree, but as far as knowledge of that uttered from the pulpit not so.

Given that atheists don't have any sort of holy manuscript to refer to it's understandable they don't.


I honestly haven't seen many on this "Religion and Philosophy" forum. Perhaps we disagree over what makes "many".

There again I would disagree. We have Gaetan, Paul Bethke, and The Big Dog just for starters. The Big Dog has told us the RCC is the "One True Church" as well as treating us to lines of scripture.


Sounds like Ms Teschmacher talking to Lex Luthor here (20 sec video):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O83e7nagEw

Good clip. I am with Ms Teschmacher. :)

"There's more to life than just living" is meaningless, IYO? Let me rephrase that as a True/False question: "If atheism is true, then there's no more to life than just living." True or false? Or meaningless?

I think dann and kellyb have it right ^.

Meaningless. But I have a problem with the "If atheism is true" part.

Having said that, I feel privileged in having experienced life, and being aware of the immense diversity and complexity of nature, in the immediate vicinity and beyond, whilst not being uncomfortable with the knowledge, of my immense lack of knowledge about so much. I think I am fortunate in this.
 
I think dann and kellyb have it right ^.

Meaningless. But I have a problem with the "If atheism is true" part.

Having said that, I feel privileged in having experienced life, and being aware of the immense diversity and complexity of nature, in the immediate vicinity and beyond, whilst not being uncomfortable with the knowledge, of my immense lack of knowledge about so much. I think I am fortunate in this.
Good comment. :thumbsup:
 
How do you argue with someone who doesn't believe that there is more to life than just living? I don't think you can, since it isn't an empirically true statement. You either believe it or you don't.

One of the tenets of empiricism is that you don't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. This is why you require, as you have said you had, a "leap of faith" for your beliefs. There is no leap of faith required not to believe that God exists. All that is required is an acceptance that it's logical not to accept as true things for which there is no evidence (which is a proven philosophy that in less than a hundred years has led from the first electromechanical computer to us all being able to type these messages to each other wherever in the world we happen to be, using devices we can carry around in our pockets - which can also do a myriad other things, including using satellites and Special and General relativity to pinpoint our location on the globe), and a lack of evidence for the existence of God.
 
One of the tenets of empiricism is that you don't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. This is why you require, as you have said you had, a "leap of faith" for your beliefs. There is no leap of faith required not to believe that God exists. All that is required is an acceptance that it's logical not to accept as true things for which there is no evidence (which is a proven philosophy that in less than a hundred years has led from the first electromechanical computer to us all being able to type these messages to each other wherever in the world we happen to be, using devices we can carry around in our pockets - which can also do a myriad other things, including using satellites and Special and General relativity to pinpoint our location on the globe), and a lack of evidence for the existence of God.

I've found that kind of agnosticism is rare. A person is going to naturally wonder where the universe came from, and it always comes back to the same thing: it's either eternal or caused itself to come into existence. Someone can think those attributes are more suited to a being than a physical universe, and someone can think the opposite, but there's no evidence that one view is better than the other. Personally, I think there's a huge problem positing a physical universe is eternal or contained within itself the cause of its own existence, which is one of the reasons I'm an idealist. But an atheist could reason the opposite way, and there's no evidence he can give that would change my mind or vice-versa.
 
I'd be interested in hearing the experiences of those who have been reasoned out of religion. If it is because of some tragedy in their lives, resulting in "no good God would allow that", then that is a philosophical/metaphysical argument. It's certainly not something that is empirically true, since it needs to make certain assumptions about God. It seems as valid as the reverse.

Perhaps some who were theists and became atheists can give their reasons?
Sure, I'm game. Allow me to ask a question of you first, to make sure we're on the same page.

Suppose I were to give you, GDon, a taped-shut cardboard box. I tell you that inside that box is something you will find to be incontrovertible proof that your personal religious beliefs are wrong. It doesn't disprove all beliefs, all gods, but it does find one of the rare places where your own beliefs intersect with reality in a falsifiable way, and duly falsifies them. I assure you that if you open the box, either your conception of reality or your conception of divinity will need to fundamentally change.

The box is, again, taped shut. You'll need to find a pair of scissors or some keys or something to deliberately open it, you can't just flip the lid and peek. You, GDon, will have to come face to face with your own enlightenment. Alternately you can reject the box, no consequences, but then you'll never know.

Do you open the box?

More importantly, what emotions did you experience while making up your mind?

[ETA] https://youtu.be/WPk8sA-UAT8?t=197

[ETAA] And just so you don't get the impression I'm leading you into a gotcha, where I'm going with this is my own box, and what I found inside.
 
Last edited:
I've found that kind of agnosticism is rare.
Rubbish! The complete and utter lack of any empirical/credible evidence for the existence of any god is the core reason for all considered atheism. Do you know of a single atheist that believes there's evidence for a god but still doesn't believe there's a god anyway? Perhaps you do. Perhaps you're one of those pathetic theists that believe atheists are denying a god that they secretly know really exists. Theists with such a brain-numbing god belief that they just can't imagine anyone else not having it.
 
Last edited:
One of the tenets of empiricism is that you don't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. This is why you require, as you have said you had, a "leap of faith" for your beliefs. There is no leap of faith required not to believe that God exists. All that is required is an acceptance that it's logical not to accept as true things for which there is no evidence (which is a proven philosophy that in less than a hundred years has led from the first electromechanical computer to us all being able to type these messages to each other wherever in the world we happen to be, using devices we can carry around in our pockets - which can also do a myriad other things, including using satellites and Special and General relativity to pinpoint our location on the globe), and a lack of evidence for the existence of God.
That's an empirically true statement regarding the lack of empirically true evidence for a god being the core reason for considered atheism (or something like that).
 
Last edited:
I've found that kind of agnosticism is rare.

I didn't 'say anything about agnosticism.

A person is going to naturally wonder where the universe came from, and it always comes back to the same thing: it's either eternal or caused itself to come into existence. Someone can think those attributes are more suited to a being than a physical universe, and someone can think the opposite, but there's no evidence that one view is better than the other. Personally, I think there's a huge problem positing a physical universe is eternal or contained within itself the cause of its own existence, which is one of the reasons I'm an idealist. But an atheist could reason the opposite way, and there's no evidence he can give that would change my mind or vice-versa.

That's where the question of parsimony comes in to it. Well, parsimony and, as I said above, the tenet that you shouldn't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. I don't claim to know how the universe came to exist - or even if that's a meaningful question. Believers in a creator-God do.
 
Last edited:
The box is, again, taped shut. You'll need to find a pair of scissors or some keys or something to deliberately open it, you can't just flip the lid and peek. You, GDon, will have to come face to face with your own enlightenment. Alternately you can reject the box, no consequences, but then you'll never know.

Do you open the box?

More importantly, what emotions did you experience while making up your mind?
I would certainly open the box. My emotions: trepidation, excitement. But I couldn't imagine NOT opening the box.

[ETA] https://youtu.be/WPk8sA-UAT8?t=197

[ETAA] And just so you don't get the impression I'm leading you into a gotcha, where I'm going with this is my own box, and what I found inside.
I saw the video (which was funny), and I'm hoping it wasn't a head! :)
 
One of the tenets of empiricism is that you don't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. This is why you require, as you have said you had, a "leap of faith" for your beliefs. There is no leap of faith required not to believe that God exists. All that is required is an acceptance that it's logical not to accept as true things for which there is no evidence (which is a proven philosophy that in less than a hundred years has led from the first electromechanical computer to us all being able to type these messages to each other wherever in the world we happen to be, using devices we can carry around in our pockets - which can also do a myriad other things, including using satellites and Special and General relativity to pinpoint our location on the globe), and a lack of evidence for the existence of God.
As I described earlier, my belief in God is what I call a 'place holder' for an informal working hypothesis, which provides an explanation for certain things that satisfies me. The 'leap of faith' is accepting the hypothesis is true, rather than 'might be true, requires more evidence'. By 'accepting' I mean 'living and acting as though it were true', rather than doing nothing while awaiting further evidence.
 
I didn't 'say anything about agnosticism.



That's where the question of parsimony comes in to it. Well, parsimony and, as I said above, the tenet that you shouldn't accept as true things for which there is no evidence. I don't claim to know how the universe came to exist - or even if that's a meaningful question. Believers in a creator-God do.

Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism). Believing the universe is godless is strong atheism.
 
Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism). Believing the universe is godless is strong atheism.
Not believing in god(s) is "default-atheism".

Not believing in god(s) because of lack of evidence/knowledge is "agnostic-atheism". (What I call "considered atheism". Theism has been considered and not accepted/rejected because of lack of evidence/knowledge).

Believing Concluding the universe is godless is "rational-conclusion-atheism".

Believing god(s) actually exist is "irrational-theism" (the only type there is)

I'm a "rational-conclusion-atheist".
 
Last edited:
As I described earlier, my belief in God is what I call a 'place holder' for an informal working hypothesis, which provides an explanation for certain things that satisfies me. The 'leap of faith' is accepting the hypothesis is true, rather than 'might be true, requires more evidence'. By 'accepting' I mean 'living and acting as though it were true', rather than doing nothing while awaiting further evidence.


That's interesting - the 'living and acting as though it were true' bit.

Could you describe how you live and act with this faith you embrace, as distinct from how you would live and act without the faith?
 
That's interesting - the 'living and acting as though it were true' bit.

Could you describe how you live and act with this faith you embrace, as distinct from how you would live and act without the faith?
Obviously, with more emotional satisfaction and comfort.

ETA - Perhaps you may also like to ask what the evidence is that precedes the "more/further evidence".
 
Last edited:
That's interesting - the 'living and acting as though it were true' bit.

Could you describe how you live and act with this faith you embrace, as distinct from how you would live and act without the faith?
It's a good question. Nothing big in differences, but many small things. I was a good man when I was an atheist, and I was the same good man when I was a theist (with the same bad traits either way). But a lot of small things became more important to me -- forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously. Not that I didn't believe in those things when I was an atheist, but becoming a theist put them into a solid foundation for me. I started to take other theological ideas like grace and mercy seriously also.
 
It's a good question. Nothing big in differences, but many small things. I was a good man when I was an atheist, and I was the same good man when I was a theist (with the same bad traits either way). But a lot of small things became more important to me -- forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously. Not that I didn't believe in those things when I was an atheist, but becoming a theist put them into a solid foundation for me. I started to take other theological ideas like grace and mercy seriously also.

Forgiveness only became even possible for me once I became an atheist. The naturalist perspective on free will kind of bakes forgiveness in.

Helping and stuff like that became monumentally more urgent for me once I lost faith in an afterlife and abandoned the idea of any sort of cosmic justice or a god to come help us or relieve suffering.
 
Believing Concluding the universe is godless is "rational-conclusion-atheism".

Ha! A lot of theists think they've concluded that god exists. Which is probably generally true, even if it's a case of "motivated reasoning."
 
As I described earlier, my belief in God is what I call a 'place holder' for an informal working hypothesis, which provides an explanation for certain things that satisfies me. The 'leap of faith' is accepting the hypothesis is true, rather than 'might be true, requires more evidence'. By 'accepting' I mean 'living and acting as though it were true', rather than doing nothing while awaiting further evidence.

Again, I see no difference between what you're saying and what I said.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom