Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

The contradiction in terms that I see is this one:

We should also assume that all atheists are rationalists by definition, which remains to be seen.


How can you say that it "remains to be seen" when you know that it has already been seen to be untrue?!

There you have Nietzsche, atheist and irrationalist... and close to Nazism in many ways.


I have already mentioned the Danish atheist Helmuth Nyborg and his Nazi friends:

At bruge professor Helmuth Nyborg som ekspert i intelligens er som at bruge Heinrich Himmler som ekspert vedrørende måder at omgås jøder, mener lektor og ph.d ved psykologisk institut i Aarhus Klaus B. Bærentsen
Dansk presse bør være mere påpasselig i sine kildevalg (Kristeligt Dagblad, Dec. 5, 2013)
"Using professor Helmuth Nyborg as an expert on intelligence is like using Heinrich Himmler as an expert on ways of handling Jews, says associate professor and ph.d. at the Institute of Psychology in Aarhus"
The Danish press should be more careful about its choice of sources

(To refer to a Christian newspaper may be frowned upon in this context, but their reporting is usually pretty straightforward, for instance when they reported from an actual fight that CFLarsen and I got into with a bunch of woos 15 years ago: Fight broke out at new age meeting (Nov. 3, 2003))

Helmuth Nyborg ærestaler for amerikanske racister (Forskerforum, Aug. 30, 2017)
Helmuth Nyborg honorary speaker for American racists
(The researcher of extremism Joe Lowndes from Oregon University is a witness)

Nazi-ros til Helmuth Nyborg (og DR2) (eugenik.dk, Feb. 13, 2011)
Nazi praise for Helmuth Nyborg (and DR2)

Den 3. juni 2011 (eugenik.dk, Mar. 25, 2017)
Helmuth Nyborg with holocaust deniers and Nazi sympathizers

Mensa Denmark also appear to love the guy: pdf. from Mensa (eugenik.dk, 2004)
 
The only thing that defines people as atheists, and is common to all atheists, is that they aren’t theists. Why people are atheists is irrelevant. Whether one type of atheist is more or less rational than another doesn’t make one any more or less an atheist than the other. So what if the reason some are atheists isn't rational? It doesn’t make atheism irrational.
 
Last edited:
It doesn’t make atheism irrational.


Did anybody claim that it did? In this context, the point is that Helmuth Nyborg is an alt-right atheist.
But let me elaborate a little:
Christians don't have to be any more irrational than atheists. Sure, their Christianity isn't rational, but the rest of the time they may be much more rational than many atheists.
And a similar thing can be said about atheists. Let's take Helmuth Nyborg as an example: His atheism may be rational. (I don't know, I didn't look into his reasons for being an atheist.) But the rest of the time, which is most of the time, he's just a dick. And in my opinion, his atheism just isn't very interesting.
 
Last edited:
Did anybody claim that it did? In this context, the point is that Helmuth Nyborg is an alt-right atheist.
My posts have nothing to do with Helmuth Nyborg. He's your pet hate that I have no interest in.
 
Last edited:
Actions are not the result of thoughts ........ OK then.

I think thoughtcrime is a very dangerous idea.

Must be good to be so gifted with the insight into other peoples innermost thoughts. Thoughts that have eluded so many others.

I'm going on what the consensus of historians is. You, on the other hand, are the one who is advocating for judging people not on what they do, but on what they think.

Have you forgotten what you wrote?

No. And, if you feel so inclined, you can reply to what I wrote rather than the straw man you created.
 
My posts have nothing to do with Helmuth Nyborg. He's your pet hate that I have no interest in.


Then you should have stayed out of it when I addressed something that David Mo wrote.
 
Even if I exist as part of a simulation or a brain in a vat or a character in some cosmic entity's dream, I still exist in that capacity.


Indeed, something still exists in that capacity (e.g. a computer created by some alien civilisation, and where the computer is programmed with entirely false beliefs/memories of a past human life) ... but in what sense is that "You"? ...

... it would not be a thinking human person, and it would not be who or what it thought it was at all. It would not be what Descartes meant when he said “I think, therefore I am” … he meant that those words proved that he himself must exist as a thinking human person.

But I agree there seems no way around the idea that "something" does exist, and I've argued that myself against several others here who raised the Brain-in-Vat (BIV) idea as support for saying that there may be no such thing as "reality" (i.e. they were saying that everything might be an illusion ... though even in the BIV example, the BIV or a computer still has to exist, and the creator of that BIV/computer also has to exist).

But that's actually not the same as saying "I think, therefore I am", and then claiming those words to be a proof that you (as the human writer/thinker) must exist. That's not a proof, because it actually begins by assuming that you do exist ... it actually just says "I exist, therefore I do exist", and that clearly seems like circular fallacious reasoning ... you cannot prove you exist just by that.
 
it actually just says "I exist, therefore I do exist", and that clearly seems like circular fallacious reasoning ... you cannot prove you exist just by that.


No, that is not what it actually just says. It actually says that "I think", which implies that there's something, a 'first-person narrator', doing the thinking = I exist (or am).
 
Then you should have stayed out of it when I addressed something that David Mo wrote.
My post wasn't a direct response to any other post including yourself or David Mo. This thread isn't all about you and your pet hate.
 
The "they" in my post that you quoted.

Perhaps English isn't your first language?


And who are the "they" in your post? (I can see that childish taunts aren't below you, but apparently thinking isn't native to you ...)
 
And who are the "they" in your post? (I can see that childish taunts aren't below you, but apparently thinking isn't native to you ...)
It doesn't matter. The "they" are obviously the "other people".

However - The "they" are the "those" that spend time endlessly debating whether or not the reasons some people are atheists are irrational. Why do you think they do it?

I experience you as being annoyingly arrogant. Perhaps it's a cultural divide thing?
 
Last edited:
The "they" are the "those" that spend time endlessly debating whether the reason some people are atheists are irrational. Why do you think they do it?


I would say, "the reason ... is irrational."
But what do I know. English isn't my first language ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom