Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Huh. Where have I heard about lower potentials before?



You're both using similar terminology. Looks kind of like there's agreement.

Except for one small problem. Electrons are negatively charged.

Why is that a problem? Because it means that a potential energy well for electrons is actually a HIGHER voltage area, not a lower voltage area. So if electrons are trapped by the potential of the comet, that means that the comet is actually at a higher electric potential than the surrounding solar wind.

I do believe you have everything backwards.

The direction of the dc field suggests that at the outer boundary of the CP is positively charged, while the inner boundary is negatively charge
Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

What's the problem ziggurat?

Double layers , double layers....
 
i guess by the "totally ignorant" you mean yourself
trying, as usual, to combine two totally unrelated topics, current sheets generated by magnetic field gradients, and supra thermal electrons escaping the inner region of the comet and generating an ambipolar electric field (which is not a double layer)
i really need some time off here

Is this the same ambipolar electric field that is also trapping these electrons?

Is there more than one ambipolar electric field?

Is this ambipolar electric field the same as described by H.Laakso at Halley?

Are you able to tell the lurkers here about the "mystery" layer?

In the cometosheath, solar wind and cometary pickup ions are
both present. During the Giotto flyby of Halley, several unexpected features were observed in the electron measurements: three outer regions and two inner regions within the cometosheath. The central outer region was named the ‘mystery region’ and was characterized by enhanced electron temperatures and densities that dropped suddenly when crossing a ‘mystery’ boundary inbound to the comet nucleus (D’Uston et al. 1988; R`eme et al. 1988). Enhanced solar wind velocity and density were observed in this region as well (Fuselier et al. 1988). Theoretical models did not predict the mystery
region and boundary, and their origin is not explained (Coates 1997).

RPC observation of the development and evolution of plasma interaction
boundaries at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
K. E. Mandt,1,2‹ A. Eriksson,3 N. J. T. Edberg,3 C. Koenders,4 T. Broiles,1‹
S. A. Fuselier,1,2‹ P. Henri,5 Z. Nemeth,6 M. Alho,7 N. Biver,8 A. Beth,9
J. Burch,1 C. Carr,9 K. Chae,1 A. J. Coates,10 E. Cupido,9 M. Galand,9
K.-H. Glassmeier,4 C. Goetz,4 R. Goldstein,1 K. C. Hansen,11 J. Haiducek,11
E. Kallio,7 J.-P. Lebreton,5 A. Luspay-Kuti,1 P. Mokashi,1 H. Nilsson,12 A. Opitz,6I. Richter,4 M. Samara,13 K. Szego,6 C.-Y. Tzou,14 M. Volwerk,15
C. Simon Wedlund16 and G. Stenberg Wieser12


Why is it a mystery for a sublimating dirtsnowball?

What do you think maybe heating these electrons?
Originally Posted by Sol88 View Post
Well, i’d start by giving this paper a good going over, tusenfem.

Apossible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko doi:10.1093/mnras/stw3118


That paper has been discussed already, and it is a dud.
When asked, the authors do not know where their hot electrons come from.
 
Last edited:
Thanks.
My comment in brackets.

Just needed to emphasise the double layers above and the neutrals and the premise of the ELECTRIC SUN and clarifie 1a

Sorry there may be more clarifications but not wholesale changes. Pretty good summary otherwise, jt.
Here's my revised summary, incorporating your comments etc. Feedback appreciated.

The ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)
1) comets are rocky objects

1a) the rock is consolidated dust/rock/stone, a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids
1b) the rock has a bulk density in the range 1.9±1.1×103kgm−3
1c) the dust, after being electrostatically machined off of the surface, has a size in the range 80to800µm

2) comets have minimal to no "ice/s"

3) comets seek electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma

3a) the potential difference is anything you want except zero, up to a 105 range
3b) the plasma surrounding the comets starts at the comets' surfaces and ends at the heliopause
3c) comets themselves are negatively charged with respect to the local solar wind
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
4a) the Sun's radial electric field is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distance

5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge

5a) the electrostatically machined dust is usually negatively charged, but can also be positive (positively charged dust will return to the nucleus)

6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

7) neutrals go along for the ride (not everything is ionised at the same time/energy)


There's an addition which RC wrote and to which Sol88 gave a thumbs' up, but I'm not sure if it's part of the ELECTRIC COMET model (Theory) or not:

0) Comets and asteroids have been blasted from Earth by electric discharges during multiple Venus flybys in recent times to be recorded in myths. Thus comets are rocky bodies like asteroids. The name of the source planet varies according to which Thunderbolts prophet we look at, e.g. it may be Mars.
 
Thought i’d add this montage doing the rounds at the moment.

[qimg]https://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2018/04/rosettasurface.gif[/qimg]


Sublimating ‘Ice”?

Or

Dust charging and transport on airless planetary bodies X. Wang1,2, J. Schwan1,2, H.-W. Hsu1,2, E. Grün1,2, and M. Horányi1,2

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko T. I. Gombosi1,J.L.Burch2,andM.Horányi

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa,b

<snip>
It seems you forgot to mention the cosmic rays and background star field and ... :rolleyes:
 
Is this the same ambipolar electric field that is also trapping these electrons?

Is there more than one ambipolar electric field?

Is this ambipolar electric field the same as described by H.Laakso at Halley?

Are you able to tell the lurkers here about the "mystery" layer?



RPC observation of the development and evolution of plasma interaction
boundaries at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
K. E. Mandt,1,2‹ A. Eriksson,3 N. J. T. Edberg,3 C. Koenders,4 T. Broiles,1‹
S. A. Fuselier,1,2‹ P. Henri,5 Z. Nemeth,6 M. Alho,7 N. Biver,8 A. Beth,9
J. Burch,1 C. Carr,9 K. Chae,1 A. J. Coates,10 E. Cupido,9 M. Galand,9
K.-H. Glassmeier,4 C. Goetz,4 R. Goldstein,1 K. C. Hansen,11 J. Haiducek,11
E. Kallio,7 J.-P. Lebreton,5 A. Luspay-Kuti,1 P. Mokashi,1 H. Nilsson,12 A. Opitz,6I. Richter,4 M. Samara,13 K. Szego,6 C.-Y. Tzou,14 M. Volwerk,15
C. Simon Wedlund16 and G. Stenberg Wieser12


Why is it a mystery for a sublimating dirtsnowball?

What do you think maybe heating these electrons?
"up to a 105 range"

What range would that be, Sol88? 1μV to 0.1V? 1V to 105V?
 
Bumpity bump ...
Thanks for the many comments and clarifications on my summary of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory, as it also been referred to), Sol88.

Likely I won’t have a chance to fold them in to a revised version until tomorrow.

In the meantime... BUMP
Thanks Sol88, it's a nice, short, review paper.

Sadly, however, I did not see any "statement by Vorontsov-Velgaminov". Perhaps you could quote it?


We can?

I don't see how Belton (1999) helps you answer the question I asked. Here it is again:

Why are the different returns of periodic comets (as we call them today) regarded as the same object (a comet), rather than different ones?

Oh, and a reminder as to why this is important: the ELECTRIC COMET model, which I've just updated to include a recent post by you, starts with the word "comets". To have a discussion of this model, it is necessary - critical, in fact - that we all understand what this means (in the model). And in this context, knowing whether what is called, by astronomers, the "return" of a comet is the same "rocky object" or not.

Would you please answer the question in red?

And an answer on the “statement by Vorontsov-Velgaminov” would be nice too.
When can we expect some answers Sol88?

Lurkers want to know ... ;)
 
Bumpity bump ...

When can we expect some answers Sol88?

Lurkers want to know ... ;)

Sorry jean tate, i fail to understand what you are blathering about.

Please explain, in simple layman terms exactly what your question is.
 
It seems you forgot to mention the cosmic rays and background star field and ... :rolleyes:


No, these where acknowledged.

Where’s the “jets”? The ones we do see when we zoom out a ways.

I’ll give you a hint...

Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1, and H. U. Keller2
 
Sorry jean tate, i fail to understand what you are blathering about.

Please explain, in simple layman terms exactly what your question is.
Sigh.

Let’s try a really simple example.

In 1986, a comet appeared in the sky; perhaps you yourself saw it?

Everyone called it Halley’s Comet.

In 1910, a comet also appeared in the sky. It too was given the name, Halley’s Comet. Perhaps one of your elders saw it?

In 1986, there were others comets which appeared in the sky. Ditto in 1910.

In the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), are these two “Halley’s comets” the same “rocky object”?

If so, how - within the ELECTRIC COMET model - can you, Sol88, show that they are the same?

If not, why not?
 
Last edited:
A jets in quotes lie and lying question

Where’s the “jets”?
30 April 2018: A jets in quotes lie and lying question.
We have images of real jets made of gases and dust.
We have images of jets from sublimating ices from inside pits.

30 April 2018: He lies about a hint about jets
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Yu. V. Skorov1, L. Rezac1, P. Hartogh1, and H. U. Keller2 is not about jets.
 
Last edited:
A deluded "what we see when we zoom out a little" lie

And for context this it what we see when we zoom out a little
30 April 2018: A deluded "what we see when we zoom out a little" lie.
Amazing GIF shows dust and cosmic rays raining down on comet 67P
The images were captured over the course of 25 minutes on 1 June 2016, and processed by twitter user @landru79.


His other image has no date. Fine structure in the comet’s jets has that image with "OSIRIS wide-angle camera image acquired on 22 November 2014 from a distance of 30 km from Comet 67P/C-G".

That is the delusion that 1 June 2016 was 22 November 2014 :eek:!
 
Last edited:
Hmm, ...

One more, for the lurkers, Sol88, please put some values to your “range”.

1v to to 000’s Kv inbound to perihelion and the nucleus is discharging electrons.

I would expect a lower range 1v to 000’s v out to aphelion and the comet is receiving electrons.

You know ball park figures of a comet on a typical eccentric orbit

And you did see, did you not, tusenfem’s post on some amperages involved?
 
Last edited:
30 April 2018: A deluded "what we see when we zoom out a little" lie.
Amazing GIF shows dust and cosmic rays raining down on comet 67P



His other image has no date. Fine structure in the comet’s jets has that image with "OSIRIS wide-angle camera image acquired on 22 November 2014 from a distance of 30 km from Comet 67P/C-G".

That is the delusion that 1 June 2016 was 22 November 2014 :eek:!

So no jets in the Hapi region at any of those dates, ‘ol mate?

In fact a mission for you, if you choose to accept it, find as many animations of 67P as you can.

See if you can beat my 2 that I’ve found SINCE the end of the mission.
 
Sigh.

Let’s try a really simple example.

In 1986, a comet appeared in the sky; perhaps you yourself saw it?

Everyone called it Halley’s Comet.

In 1910, a comet also appeared in the sky. It too was given the name, Halley’s Comet. Perhaps one of your elders saw it?

In 1986, there were others comets which appeared in the sky. Ditto in 1910.

In the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), are these two “Halley’s comets” the same “rocky object”?

If so, how - within the ELECTRIC COMET model - can you, Sol88, show that they are the same?

If not, why not?

Spectroscopy and a stop watch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom