David Mo
Philosopher
Here's an interesting question:
Can someone be reasoned out of agnosticism (we don't know whether or not there are gods), into hard atheism (there is definitely no gods)? If so, why are people agnostic? If not, why are there hard atheists?
Think about it. Both groups are (presumably, though I don't want to presume anything about anyone) coming from a position of empiricism, so both are looking at the same set of data from the same philosophical position. So what is the determining factor that one side is either ignoring or accepting, that the other group doesn't?
Before a stupid battle starts because each of us understand the word "atheism" in a different way, I would try to fix the content of GDon's question, which I find really interesting.
The baron of H claims that there is definitely no gods.
Mr. J.H claims that he doesn't know whether or not there are gods.
Why some people (call them baronites) agree with the baron of H. and other (let call them heichites) agree with Mr. J.H.?
My answer:
I see two possibilities:
Either baronites and heichites don't agree about facts or they don't agree about what is a justified belief. I supose that the usual disagreement resides in the latter option.