Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

The joke, when I read this about 100% certain and that some claim that is not possible, then they who claim is not possible, they are 100% certain that 100% certain claims are not possible.
Ironically that is 100% certain. There are actual proofs for it. I'm surprised you're unfamiliar with the argument, it tends to get drug out again every time a theist reads the first half of Godel, Escher, Bach.
 
It's up to you whether or not you bother answering the questions you were asked.

You've been quick to criticise any system other than Dawkins, but you have been unable to answer criticisms of his system or say why it is superior to others. It's entirely up to you whether you want to correct that situation. It's also entirely up to you whether you feel you need to get outside input in order to do so.

Although I think I have already answered your questions, I will try to give you more detailed answers to each specific question.

(1)Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)?
Dawkins does not limit himself to these seven points. He believes that they are the basic ones to distinguish between the one who claims that God exists and the one who claims that God does not exist. In the page of The God Delusion that I quoted he admits the possibility of including a subdivision like the one you mention.

(2)Why doesn't it account for people who may believe in more than one religion? Why doesn't it account for the differences between people who vaguely believe in the Christian God and those who vaguely believe in a general "something" up there?
Dawkins' list is aimed at establishing the positions between those who claim that God exists and those who claim that God does not exist. Your assumptions have nothing to do with this issue. A person who claims that several gods exist is as theistic as one who claims that only one exists. If a person claims that the "higher something" you mention is a god, he or she will be in the first categories. If he claims that the "something" is not a god or that he does not know it, it has nothing to do with the problem of theism and atheism. It's something else. It is like if you believe in fairies. It's another matter.

(3)What you believe the perfect system of categorisation to be?
I don't think there are perfect categorization systems. At least not on this subject. I think Dawkins' is preferable to others.

(4) One that is free from the criticism of being too strict that you're levelling at other systems?
Other definitions that have been offered here put different things in the same bag: for example, those who do not believe that God exists with those who claim that God does not exist. A system of definitions must prevent this type of failure in order to solve the main question.

Remember that the main issue is the difference between those who claim that you cannot know if God exists and those who believe they are justified in claiming that God does not exist. More or less categorically.

I hope you'll accept my answers this time. If you don't like them, I don't have any others. I'm sorry.
 
Last edited:
Could you explicate what you're saying, please? It seems like a reasonable paraphrase to me, so there's obviously a breakdown in communication between us somewhere.


We started here:

As soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world.
It's similar to when you meet people who claim to be Jesus Christ or Napoleon: You know that they're delusional, so you don't begin to consider if there might be slight resemblances between those guys and the paintings you've seen of J.C. and the French general/emperor.
It's not that we cannot be sure if there is a god or not. We actually know both that there is and what it is!


I'm not sure that's actually true.

Karen Armstrong's A History Of God is a very well-researched book which details how the Judeo-Christian God evolved (primarily) out of the Caananite god of war Yahweh, and how Judaism evolved out of that pantheistic religion. Armstrong was a nun, and had no agenda in writing the book, and it is noted for the thoroughness and depth of her research. In other words, even religious scholars don't question that the story she tells of the evolution of Christianity and the concept of the Judeo-Christian God is accurate. Yet many of those scholars remain Christians.

Anecdotally, I've heard from more than one source who has been to seminary school that this story, if not Armstrong's book itself, is taught there and that the students are given time after learning of this history to come to terms with it and reconcile it with their own faith. Many do.

So there you have people who have learnt that the God they believe in isn't a real being but is instead a construct created by humans which was created from an older, pantheistic religion - who then choose to carry on believing in that deity anyway, or who manage to rationalise some way to do so.

I suppose it's not that different to people who get taken in by fake cancer cures, or ponzi schemes, or the like. Once you've invested that much in something then it's easier psychologically speaking to rationalise away evidence that your beliefs are untrue than it is to admit to yourself and others that you've put so much faith in a lie.


I haven't read her book, but based on your description I don't see how it contradicts what I said: "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists."
When you begin to believe in any kind of god, you start with what you've heard, seen or experienced in other ways. You may base your god simply on the stories your parents tell you, you may pick up a Bible and start adding bits and pieces to your idea of god, or you can invent one on the spot like when the boy deified Harry Potter in Beslan. Basing a new god on a former version is how it often happens. Muhammad did that, and so did Luther and Joseph Smith.
Anyway, a god is always customized to the individual needs of the believer: igod.


You said that it was impossible to remain a believer once you'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". I gave you anecdotal examples of people who had remained a believer once they'd seen that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature existed". That's what contradicts your assertion.


I don't think that's what you have given me. You gave me anecdotal examples of religious people who had seen and understood that the idea of God evolves. That doesn't prevent them from believing that an actual god is somehow hidden behind all these different ideas. I guess they rationalize that the guys who believed in the God of War were ill-informed and didn't understand how loving and forgiving etc. the real Christian God is, the one and only ...


Yes, I said they rationalised it away. If your statement was simply "people who see that God is a man-made construct and don't rationalise that away in order to maintain their beliefs cease to believe in God", then it's tautologous.


It isn't! They think that God (the 'actual' one) was misunderstood by pre-Christians, which doesn't make him "a man-made construct."


Again, you're saying "if someone finds out that God is a man-made construct but continues to believe that God is not a man-made construct, then they will not believe that God is a man-made construct". That is tautologous.


Yes, that is tautologous, but it's also a strawman since it's not what I'm saying.


Could you explicate what you're saying, please? It seems like a reasonable paraphrase to me, so there's obviously a breakdown in communication between us somewhere.


Yes, there is a breakdown in communication. It occurs whenever you rephrase what I’m saying into something I’m not saying. See above!
 
If you don't explain yourself better, I don't know what kind of answer you was expecting.

The first step in answering the actual questions I asked would be to answer the questions that I asked.

The second step is to give a clarification. when I ask you for some clarification

Feel free to say what is unclear about any of the questions or comments in the post in question.

You'll have to wait a while. You're making things difficult. I will first need to consult my lawyer and my tax advisor. :rolleyes:

:D:D:D:D

This really is a hoot. We have a growing list of those that have some communication problems as defined by Squeegee. We, me included, should learn the error of our ways.:rolleyes:
 
Because that's one thing that Dawkins and other hard-core atheists have in common with believers: They all have a hard time understanding that a lot of us just don't give a damn! On the one hand, we don't believe in God(s), but on the other hand, we don't think it's a big deal. Zealous atheism is so twentieth century! Many of us have moved on!

Unlike Dawkins, Zuckerman has actually studied the phenomenon. Here are a couple of facts:

Denmark is said to be 72% irreligious and atheist: List of religious populations: Irreligious and atheist (Wikipedia)
Yet 76% of the population are members of the state church.


There you go with that stuff about not caring about what theists think again. You present this as though it were some kind of virtue. I hear a similar attitude, (although not strident *), when I converse with relations in Sweden.

As I see it the reason for this complacency, is in Scandinavia the battle has been won. In the USA and even Australia it has not been won. We have a chaplaincy program funded by the government, (our tax dollars), that has just recently been introduced for Christ's sake. We have just now had same sex marriage recognised - a development that was fought tooth and nail by the religious. We are still struggling with the question of legal abortion in some states, and I will give you a guess as to who is lined up in the no camp.

* Strikes me as interesting that one can be strident at complacency.:confused:
 
They do not "have certainty" ... there is not a certainty just for you and then a different certainty for the next person! .... "Certainty" means it's an absolute fact which is true for everyone. You are constantly talking merely about a persons opinion and trying to claim their opinion is known to them to be an absolute fact of certainty about the universe (about the existence of a god in this case).

Of course there is. Different people can be certain about mutually-exclusive things. A gambler in Vegas can be certain that she'll roll a 12 with her next throw. Whether she will or not is irrelevant to her certitude.


This is now at least the tenth time this has been explained for you, and it's primary school basic English - you have been constantly claiming that people make things into actual “certainty”, simply by declaring to themselves that something is a “fact” … you cannot make something a “fact” just because you idiotically claim it to be a fact … you do not make God become a certainty just because you say “it's certain, I know it's a fact, therefore he must now exist, because I have said so!” … you do not control the universe just by declaring things to be true … you do not prove evolution is untrue just by saying “I declare evolution to be untrue and that's a fact, I am certain of it” ….

… NO, you are most definitely not certain of it. It is NOT a certainty that evolution is untrue, and it is not certain that God exists. The very most you can really mean, whatever words come out of your mouth, is that you merely believe God exists … it's a belief … you may "feel" certain about it in your mind, but that's just your belief, that does not make your beliefs into actual facts or certainties about the world ... you cannot make your opinions into factual certainties of the world, just by very ignorantly and stupidly claiming things to be it to facts about this universe.

OK, there is no point in me reading the rest of whatever you have said, because what you are writing is constantly on the same level as the above, where you are just repeatedly making the same elementary mistakes in the use of English language – you need to learn what words like “certainty” and “fact” mean within proper use of the English Language … you do not make “God” come into actual existence as a “certainty” in this universe (that's what "fact & certainty" means, it means a factual certainty for everyone and everything in the entire universe, not just for your own individual opinion) merely by claiming “I know God exists, it's a fact, I am certain of it” … no, you absolutely DO NOT “know” God exists, and you cannot make it become a “certain fact” just by declaring “it's a fact, I know it!”.
 
There you go with that stuff about not caring about what theists think again.


There you go again with your tired old strawman.

You present this as though it were some kind of virtue.


As if what were some kind of virtue? Your strawman?

I hear a similar attitude, (although not strident *), when I converse with relations in Sweden.

As I see it the reason for this complacency, is in Scandinavia the battle has been won. In the USA and even Australia it has not been won. We have a chaplaincy program funded by the government, (our tax dollars), that has just recently been introduced for Christ's sake. We have just now had same sex marriage recognised - a development that was fought tooth and nail by the religious. We are still struggling with the question of legal abortion in some states, and I will give you a guess as to who is lined up in the no camp.

* Strikes me as interesting that one can be strident at complacency.:confused:


Exactly! The battle has actually been won, at least to some extent. Not by atheists, however, but by social reforms, the work of the trade-union movement. And it could easily be lost again - not really because of Christians or Muslims, but because of conservative politics.


ETA:
We have just now had same sex marriage recognised - a development that was fought tooth and nail by the religious.


When you say "we", I guess you're referring to yourself and all the Australian Christians, right?! Or would you rather cling to the delusion that "we" are a handful of atheists courageously taking on the Christian stormtroopers?!

Most Christians in Australia support marriage equality and want a free vote
 
Last edited:
(1)Why does Dawkins' scale only go from 1 to 7? Why doesn't it account for people who have never given the matter any thought (due to apathy, age, etc.)?
Dawkins does not limit himself to these seven points. He believes that they are the basic ones to distinguish between the one who claims that God exists and the one who claims that God does not exist. In the page of The God Delusion that I quoted he admits the possibility of including a subdivision like the one you mention.

Well, then, there you go. Makes me wonder why you argued against me when I said the same thing.
 
We started here:

Yes, back to "As soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world. " And I gave an example that contradicts that - people who found out that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine such a creature exists", but whodon't stop looking for him in the real world, which you dismissed because those people "rationalize[d] that the guys who believed in the God of War were ill-informed and didn't understand how loving and forgiving etc. the real Christian God is, the one and only".

Of course the people who continue believing have to rationalise away the evidence that their God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists". Otherwise they couldn't keep believing. That's what makes it tautologous.
 
This is now at least the tenth time this has been explained for you, and it's primary school basic English - you have been constantly claiming that people make things into actual “certainty”, simply by declaring to themselves that something is a “fact” … you cannot make something a “fact” just because you idiotically claim it to be a fact … you do not make God become a certainty just because you say “it's certain, I know it's a fact, therefore he must now exist, because I have said so!” … you do not control the universe just by declaring things to be true … you do not prove evolution is untrue just by saying “I declare evolution to be untrue and that's a fact, I am certain of it” ….

… NO, you are most definitely not certain of it. It is NOT a certainty that evolution is untrue, and it is not certain that God exists. The very most you can really mean, whatever words come out of your mouth, is that you merely believe God exists … it's a belief … you may "feel" certain about it in your mind, but that's just your belief, that does not make your beliefs into actual facts or certainties about the world ... you cannot make your opinions into factual certainties of the world, just by very ignorantly and stupidly claiming things to be it to facts about this universe.

OK, there is no point in me reading the rest of whatever you have said, because what you are writing is constantly on the same level as the above, where you are just repeatedly making the same elementary mistakes in the use of English language – you need to learn what words like “certainty” and “fact” mean within proper use of the English Language … you do not make “God” come into actual existence as a “certainty” in this universe (that's what "fact & certainty" means, it means a factual certainty for everyone and everything in the entire universe, not just for your own individual opinion) merely by claiming “I know God exists, it's a fact, I am certain of it” … no, you absolutely DO NOT “know” God exists, and you cannot make it become a “certain fact” just by declaring “it's a fact, I know it!”.

We are definitely going round in circles. You keep denying dictionary definitions of words while claiming that it's incorrect to use words to mean what they are defined as meaning. You also keep asserting that it's impossible for people to say that they are certain something is true unless it actually is objective fact - that it's impossible to believe something to be true unless it actually is objective fact. You also keep asserting that I think and have said things which I do and have not.

In other words, you keep ignoring or handwaving away all evidence that you are wrong in order to keep banging the same tin drum, simply repeating your straw men, ignorance, and downright bizarre anti-factualism. I'd like it if you'd stop doing this and would instead address what I've actually said, but it seems you will not.
 
Yes, back to "As soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world. " And I gave an example that contradicts that - people who found out that God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine such a creature exists", but whodon't stop looking for him in the real world, which you dismissed because those people "rationalize[d] that the guys who believed in the God of War were ill-informed and didn't understand how loving and forgiving etc. the real Christian God is, the one and only".

Of course the people who continue believing have to rationalise away the evidence that their God was "an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists". Otherwise they couldn't keep believing. That's what makes it tautologous.


That's what doesn't make it tautologous, and that's what I've explained to you several times by now: They never find out that God is an idea created by people to fulfill their need to imagine that God exists. What they do find out is that the idea of God has evolved over time. In your own words: "how the Judeo-Christian God evolved (primarily) out of the Caananite god of war Yahweh, and how Judaism evolved out of that pantheistic religion."
So you are the one who claims that the discovery that the idea of God evolves is the same thing as finding out that God is an idea created by people etc. It obviously isn't.
So let me explain it to you yet another way: That the idea of disease evolves isn't very difficult to discover - the ancients had their ideas and today we think very differently - but discovering that the idea of disease evolves doesn't mean that medical doctors have now concluded that disease doesn't exist! On the contrary, they know not only that it is, but also what it is.
See?! Recognizing that an idea evolves is not the same thing as recognizing that the thing that the idea is about doesn't actually exist. You are the one who has been claiming the identity of the two very different things in order to insist on the tautology of your strawman.

Of course, even nowadays, after the introduction and establishment of science-based evidence, the evolution of the idea of disease still plays an important role in the prevention and cure of diseases, but in the future money may play an even bigger role - and very often not on the side of progress and enlightenment!
 
Last edited:
More-or-less. I identify as someone who holds the view that any ultimate reality (such as God) is unknowable for sure.



Very much so.



No. I think the probabilities of a, c, & d are vanishingly small. I think the probability of b being untrue is vanishingly small.

This seems at odds with your professed agnosticism. You seem to be saying you DO know the ultimate nature of the universe (or have a very good idea of it): reality is materialistic
 
That's what doesn't make it tautologous, and that's what I've explained to you several times by now: They never find out that God is an idea created by people to fulfill their need to imagine that God exists. What they do find out is that the idea of God has evolved over time. In your own words: "how the Judeo-Christian God evolved (primarily) out of the Caananite god of war Yahweh, and how Judaism evolved out of that pantheistic religion."
So you are the one who claims that the discovery that the idea of God evolvies is the same thing as finding out that God is an idea created by people etc. It obviously isn't.

Of course it is. "What you think of as the One True Creator who is older than the universe, who is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, and who has been in direct communication with humans in that from, is actually just how the idea of three gods that you think are ridiculous became amalgamated into one due to the socio-political situation of the time" doesn't imply "but he's really true, really". That's why they need time off to be able to rationalise it, and that's why some of them don't and end up no longer being believers.
 
Well it's not.



I'm as sure as I am of anything that reality is materialistic. I still concede the possibility that I'm wrong.

But you profess to believe the ultimate nature of reality is unknowable. What knowledge about reality do you have that allows you to be so sure materialism is true? You're basing your strong belief on something, right?
 
Would you please stop using quotation marks unless they are actual quotations? And if they are actual quotations, would you please include references to whomever you're quoting? It was confusing even when you used quotation marks when rephrasing what I was (not) saying.


Of course it is. "What you think of as the One True Creator who is older than the universe, who is omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, and who has been in direct communication with humans in that from, is actually just how the idea of three gods that you think are ridiculous became amalgamated into one due to the socio-political situation of the time" doesn't imply "but he's really true, really". That's why they need time off to be able to rationalise it, and that's why some of them don't and end up no longer being believers.


You don't point out anything new here even though you seem to have persuaded yourself to think that it's new and radical. Christians are rationalizing all the time: for instance, when they have to console the Old Testament vengeful God with the New Testament father-of-J.C. God, or when they have to console the idea of a loving, forgiving and omnipotent God with the catastrophes that he has rain down upon even his worshippers, sometimes killing whole congregations.
In those cases, too, some of the survivors also tend to decide that there's probably no God after all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom