Evolutionary advantage of Type 2 Diabetes?

I hate to kill your joke by asking you to explain it, but I have to ask : Where does not using birth control come in here, in this context?

It wasn't a joke. If you are looking for evolutionary history, the maybe two generations with birth control are insignificant.


Without birth control the population will increase until constrained by either starvation, predation/war or disease.

Historically, populations would have been on the edge of famine, unless something else had previously depleted the population or some new resources became available, whereupon the population would grow quickly until it hits its new limits.

There was plenty of scope for quick population increases - if a couple had ten children but eight died before they had children, a reduction in child mortality due to easier availability of food could have a huge effect.

In some ways this is what happened with the European population of the New World, especially North America.
 
But remember that exercise is also extremely important if you want to get rid of diabetes or pre-diabetes.
And it appears to be one of those cases where alt. med. might be right: Big Pharma doesn't want you to know about this! (But if you're pushing homeopathic remedies for diabetes or similar nonsense, that's one thing they have in common!)
Exercise prescription for patients with type 2 diabetes and pre-diabetes: A position statement from Exercise and Sport Science Australia (Journal of Science in Medicine and Sport, Jan. 2012, Volume 15, Issue 1, Pages 25–31)


Big pharma not wanting people to know about this would be a probably the explanation for why people aren’t widely aware that Type 2 Diabetes can be effectively managed without medication, by going specifically with a sub-surplus diet. (Provided that is true -- but is it? I don't see anyone, any research I mean, actually saying that. But then I haven't really looked myself, yet.)

I don’t want to derail this thread by talking any further about this here : but unlike many of the things we discuss here, this is of far more than just academic interest. I think I’ll go dig around a bit around this, see what I can find.
 
It wasn't a joke. If you are looking for evolutionary history, the maybe two generations with birth control are insignificant.


Without birth control the population will increase until constrained by either starvation, predation/war or disease.

Historically, populations would have been on the edge of famine, unless something else had previously depleted the population or some new resources became available, whereupon the population would grow quickly until it hits its new limits.

There was plenty of scope for quick population increases - if a couple had ten children but eight died before they had children, a reduction in child mortality due to easier availability of food could have a huge effect.

In some ways this is what happened with the European population of the New World, especially North America.


I could infer what you’re saying here from your earlier post, other than the birth control part, but I’d imagined you were joking when you said that!

So you’re saying we’ve evolved to cope with famine-like conditions, but evolution hasn’t equipped us very well to deal with times of ease and plenty, right? That’s an interesting thought! What other difficulties, other than Type 2 diabetes, might our current times of plenty be exposing us to, then, I wonder? (Obesity, for one, of course. But of course they’re related, those two, diabetes and obesity.)

Re. what you say about birth control, I’ll repeat what I’d asked earlier of another poster here : Are we sure that the two or so generations that have known extensive and effective use of birth control aren’t, in fact, enough to already have started the passing on of those genes? (I suppose I mean the principle of the thing, rather than about diabetes specifically -- this thread seems to indicate that Type 2 diabetes is unlikely to be a mutation that is passed on.) After all, how many generations would it take for a mutation to take hold, so to say, to actually start being passed on? Wouldn’t two further generations, or even just one generation following some mutation, be ample?
 
I’m sorry about your mother, David, and hope she’s doing better now.

Just to clarify, in your mother’s case, did she finally shift to a less-than-surplus diet, calorie-wise, and was this enough to take care of her situation, the diabetes part I mean, even in that advanced stage? Or does she need to take medication for her diabetes, over and above her changed diet?

After thirty years , she now doesn't take insulin or insulin stimulating drugs. This just happened in the last rear.

:)
 
But remember that exercise is also extremely important if you want to get rid of diabetes or pre-diabetes.
And it appears to be one of those cases where alt. med. might be right: Big Pharma doesn't want you to know about this!

respectfully disagree, I am not aware of any web pages that don't recommend changes in activity levels and diet.
Can you link to these medication adverts or other sources to support this claim.
:)
 
respectfully disagree, I am not aware of any web pages that don't recommend changes in activity levels and diet.
Can you link to these medication adverts or other sources to support this claim.
:)


They are getting there, but they are obviously not happy about it, so in this one, for instance, they recommend both a healthy diet and exercise, but they don't tell us that this is actually enough for large groups of pre-diabetes and early-stage type-2 diabetic patients: that they can cure themselves without medicine! Instead, it becomes a question of making the medicinal solution more efficient!
Vi ved i dag, at insulin fungerer bedre, når man dyrker regelmæssig motion. Diabetes-behandling (Novo Nordisk)

"Today we know that insulin works better when you exercise regularly."

Instead of following this advice, you should find out which blood-sugar group you belong to. In many cases, you may not need medicine at all!
In Denmark, fortunately, the public-service TV station has done much to promote the blood-sugar diet.
 
Last edited:
I could infer what you’re saying here from your earlier post, other than the birth control part, but I’d imagined you were joking when you said that!

So you’re saying we’ve evolved to cope with famine-like conditions, but evolution hasn’t equipped us very well to deal with times of ease and plenty, right? That’s an interesting thought! What other difficulties, other than Type 2 diabetes, might our current times of plenty be exposing us to, then, I wonder? (Obesity, for one, of course. But of course they’re related, those two, diabetes and obesity.)
I don't really like the phrase "evolved to" - it sounds a bit teleological (although it is hard to avoid). However, apart from that, then basically yes.

Up to the last half century, pretty much all of hominid evolution had been with populations growing until constrained. That could be predation (including war), or famine, or disease. Times of plenty wouldn't have lasted very long.

Even if they did - as long as any adverse affects occur too late to hinder the the organism's grandchildren's reproductive success, then there would be no selective pressure *against* the trait anyway.



Re. what you say about birth control, I’ll repeat what I’d asked earlier of another poster here : Are we sure that the two or so generations that have known extensive and effective use of birth control aren’t, in fact, enough to already have started the passing on of those genes? (I suppose I mean the principle of the thing, rather than about diabetes specifically -- this thread seems to indicate that Type 2 diabetes is unlikely to be a mutation that is passed on.) After all, how many generations would it take for a mutation to take hold, so to say, to actually start being passed on? Wouldn’t two further generations, or even just one generation following some mutation, be ample?



What is the selection pressure? Ten generations ago, an average couple might have had just over four grandchildren that survived to adulthood. Now it might be just under four in some parts of the world.

In between there would have been far more breeding grandchildren as the industrial and agrarian revolutions increased the number of surviving offspring, as well as the improved sanitation and medicine (I'd say these are less important, as well-nourished people are far better at surviving an infection, whilst someone without an infection can still be killed by starvation).​



The weaker the selection pressure, the more generations you need to evolve a trait. I am struggling to see what trait is selected for with birth control - possibly not using it, or being medically resistant to certain techniques. However, I would think that would be a very weak selective pressure.




As an aside, one might argue that there was some type of birth control practised by certain families in even medieval times - there was a reason lots of younger offspring of minor gentry ended up as monks or nuns. Infanticide was also practised in many societies.
 
The Lamarckian theory of evolution says that the parents who use birth control would have sterile children. :D
 
Big pharma not wanting people to know about this would be a probably the explanation for why people aren’t widely aware that Type 2 Diabetes can be effectively managed without medication, by going specifically with a sub-surplus diet. (Provided that is true -- but is it? I don't see anyone, any research I mean, actually saying that. But then I haven't really looked myself, yet.)

I don’t want to derail this thread by talking any further about this here : but unlike many of the things we discuss here, this is of far more than just academic interest. I think I’ll go dig around a bit around this, see what I can find.

Not necessarily sub-surplus, but low carb, definitely..

A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet to treat type 2 diabetes

The LCKD improved glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes such that diabetes medications were discontinued or reduced in most participants.
 
Last edited:
After thirty years , she now doesn't take insulin or insulin stimulating drugs. This just happened in the last rear.

:)


That's great! I mean I'm glad she's better now. And also, this is direct, first-person vindication of being able to manage even advanced diabetes without medication and via a sub-calorific-surplus diet (and exercise as well, I suppose).

Thanks for sharing.
 
The Lamarckian theory of evolution says that the parents who use birth control would have sterile children. :D


Wouldn't the theory actually be saying, instead, that people using birth control would end up having children who would, in their turn, use birth control as well?

Wait, did we just end up proving Lamarck's theory? :)
 
Not necessarily sub-surplus, but low carb, definitely..

A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet to treat type 2 diabetes


Lovely link, thanks for sharing.

Of course, it says "reduced medication", and also "substantially reduced medication", never 'medication entirely discontinued', but I suppose they were simply being careful. And of course, reduction of medication itself is so much better than stuffing yourself every day with pills (which is what people do in practice).

Yeah, the ketogenic diet I'm familiar with. This sub-calorific-surplus diet that came up here was new to me, but I have friends (more fanatically committed to the body beautiful and to fitness in general than I am) who are into the Warrior Diet, and who swear by keto.
 
That's great! I mean I'm glad she's better now. And also, this is direct, first-person vindication of being able to manage even advanced diabetes without medication and via a sub-calorific-surplus diet (and exercise as well, I suppose).

Thanks for sharing.

Advanced Type II diabetes and again it was a thirty year process and she was reluctant to even pretend there was an issue until she had her foot amputated. That was seven years ago, she just decided to gets serious the last three years.
 
Lovely link, thanks for sharing.

Of course, it says "reduced medication", and also "substantially reduced medication", never 'medication entirely discontinued', but I suppose they were simply being careful. And of course, reduction of medication itself is so much better than stuffing yourself every day with pills (which is what people do in practice).

Yeah, the ketogenic diet I'm familiar with. This sub-calorific-surplus diet that came up here was new to me, but I have friends (more fanatically committed to the body beautiful and to fitness in general than I am) who are into the Warrior Diet, and who swear by keto.

If you revisit my quote from the link, it does say:

" The LCKD improved glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes such that diabetes medications were discontinued or reduced in most participants. "
 
Another reason why it’s a good idea to try to cure diabetes type-2 by dieting and exercising:

small changes to existing formulas keep insulin prices high and generics out of reach — despite the fact that the original patent expired over 75 years ago. (…) Sanders and Cummings noted that patients paid more than three times as much for their insulin in 2013 than they had in 2002
Insulin – at what cost? (beyondtype1.org, Jan. 19, 2017)


One father testified that his 13-year-old son’s insulin jumped from $300 for a 90-day supply in 2017 to more than $900 in early 2018.
The Rising Cost of Insulin: “Horror Stories Every Day” (CBS News, May 9, 2018)


In 1922, Frederick Banting, Charles Best, and John Macleod celebrated the first insulin injection into a human, 14-year-old Leonard Thompson. Shortly thereafter, the trio agreed to partner with Eli Lilly and Company to help with production. (…) The trio didn’t patent their work on insulin therapy until after they entered this agreement, when they famously sold their rights to insulin to the University of Toronto for $3 in 1923. The goal of this early maneuvering of their intellectual rights to insulin therapy was to make sure one company didn’t have a monopoly on the drug therapy.
“They really worried about that even early on,” Dr. Lipska said.
It didn’t work. (…)
a vial of insulin cost $1.49 in 1972, which would be $8.86 now when adjusted for inflation. In 2004, that same vial would cost $60, and today it would go for roughly $300, she said. Improvements in performance are no longer justifying those spikes in prices, she said.
“The latest generations (of insulin) are not light years different from those we had about 10 years ago,” Dr. Lipska said
How Insulin Became So Expensive – A History (insulinnation.com, Jun. 21, 2017)
 
Last edited:
If you revisit my quote from the link, it does say:

" The LCKD improved glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes such that diabetes medications were discontinued or reduced in most participants. "


You’re right. Discontinued, yes, like you say -- and in as many as a third of the subjects, as they clarify elsewhere. My bad!

Keto diets are something we'd do well to take note of, it seems, and not just as some interesting piece of trivia, but as something we might try out ourselves. This particular dietary fad seems to be more than just another fad!
 
Keto gets a lot of bad rap from the doom and gloom crowd..

They need to ask " what are the physiological downsides, compared to being obese and diabetic ? " ..

I consider any long-term ketogenic diet to be extreme, with the possibility of adverse effects if not controlled for.

Low carb and high fat can be very effective for controlling obesity and diabetes also.. By ' high fat ', I do not mean excess calories;
I mean high in proportion to carbohydrates.
A lot of people don't' consider that between protein, fats and carbohydrates, only carbohydrates are not essential for life and health..
 
Last edited:
Problem is that there is not the one diabetes gene. It takes a confluence of several to cause the grief. Which allows for much individual variation of disease and side effects.

For example, lets say there common gene variants that at the root of my disease. Two are each in 50% of the population, two more are each in ten. 50% x 50% x 10% x 10%, and my combination is in only .25%, or 1 in 400. ( The same concept probably holds true for many many disease states- arthritis ? arteries? eczema? blue eyes? Democrats? :D )

One of my variants has to do with grehlin. I call it the "Voracious appetite gene". It's not uncommon, it just makes it hard for us to "just eat less". Doable, but hard. Add in an "insulin receptor anomaly", and you have diabetes.

Evolution wise, each of those variants may have an advantage. It's only the combination that causes malaise.
 
Last edited:
Keto gets a lot of bad rap from the doom and gloom crowd..

They need to ask " what are the physiological downsides, compared to being obese and diabetic ? " ..

I consider any long-term ketogenic diet to be extreme, with the possibility of adverse effects if not controlled for.

Low carb and high fat can be very effective for controlling obesity and diabetes also.. By ' high fat ', I do not mean excess calories;
I mean high in proportion to carbohydrates.
A lot of people don't' consider that between protein, fats and carbohydrates, only carbohydrates are not essential for life and health..

Ketos are the 4th macro-nutrient. If you are interested in long term, look up Dr. Peter Attia. And I am sure there are other Keto gurus.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom