There is No God (And You Know It)

The theists that define terms of the debate like "omnipotent," such as Aquinas and Maimonides, maintain no such thing, however. Maimonides is Jewish, but Aquinas is solidly within the Christian tradition, especially the Catholic part of it, so one could hardly claim that the God of Christianity is necessarily expected to do the illogical.

Interestingly, the word "omnipotent" doesn't appear in the Old Testimate, so some Jews don't necessarily believe God to be omnipotent. According to Wikipedia, the word only occurs once in the Christian New Testimate.

-Bri
 
I don't expect him to, either. I don't believe in God, mind you. But if he existed I'd expect him to be as we agreed. However I don't thing I personally know a christian who has ever admitted that his god COULDN'T do the impossible, logical or not.

Many Christians don't believe that God can do the logically impossible. Others hold that he is beyond logic and could change the rules of logic at will. The only thing that is known for certain is that we humans must operate within the rules of logic, and therefore to make an illogical, nonsense argument wouldn't lead us to any understanding of God.

-Bri
 
Many Christians don't believe that God can do the logically impossible. Others hold that he is beyond logic and could change the rules of logic at will. The only thing that is known for certain is that we humans must operate within the rules of logic, and therefore to make an illogical, nonsense argument wouldn't lead us to any understanding of God.

If god is beyond logic, nothing can lead us to an understanding of God.
 
I said suffering meaning both that caused by freewill and that not caused by freewill. How can you say that all suffering is good?

How do you know suffering isn't for the greater good? Those who believe in an omnibenevolent God might argue that all suffering is necessary for a greater good (such as free will).

There is no way to prove that a god doesn’t exist. At best we could prove that a specific god doesn’t exist, in this case one that is omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent.

The subject of the thread was that there is no God, so we are in agreement that the subject of the thread cannot be proven. In addition, nobody has yet been able to prove that an omnipotent, omniscient, or omnibenevolent God cannot exist.

To us a “square circle” is nonsense, to an entity that can change the laws of physics a “square circle” would be child’s play.
Now if you want to limit omnipotence to conform to the current laws of nature we know then a “square circle” is nonsense, but then so are quiet a few of the “miracles” in the bible.

No, "square" and "circle" are just words that represent different things, in this case mutually exclusive things that become meaningless when combined together. When you say that an omnipotent God should be able to create a "square circle" you have to define that term in order to even discuss whether or not God can create one, because I don't see it in the dictionary. Unless you define it, how can you say that God cannot create it? Surely God could add the term "square circle" to the dictionary as an alternate word for "kangaroo" and then, yes, God could create one. If that's not what you mean, then define the object you're saying God cannot create.

A "square circle" as you seem to be intending it would not only break the laws of nature, but would break the laws of logic because it's a self-contradicting term. Miracles mentioned in the Bible don't break the laws of logic unless you change the common definitions of things. For example, you could easily say that God cannot make a pig fly because by definition, a pig doesn't fly, and so if God did make a pig fly it would cease to be a pig. That redefines the word "pig" so that a "flying pig" is self-contradictory, and logically impossible. It is meaningless to use nonsense terms in an argument, because they make the argument nonsense.

Would changing or breaking the natural laws (physics, speed of light in a vacuum, etc) be a power?
If yes, then it’s illogical to limit omnipotence by the natural laws.
If no, then explain the “miracles” listed in the bible.

Yes, changing the laws of nature would be a supernatural power (if that's your question). An omnipotent God would not necessarily be limited by the laws of nature, but our understanding of him might be limited by the rules of logic. The miracles in the Bible certainly break the laws of nature, but are not logically inconsistent as described above.

They become conjuring tricks which grew through multiple telling, lies created in support of the stories or a combination of the two.

Quite possibly, but you cannot prove that they weren't actual miracles.

Sigh, so close.
I’m stating that an omnipotent entity could not only change the rules of logic but the rules of nature as well so that a square circle becomes physically possible.

Not necessarily. Most definitions of "omnipotent" don't require God to be able to change the rules of logic, although some do claim that God is beyond logic and therefore could change the rules of logic as you suggest.

I hold that either way, the term "square circle" is simply nonsense, so your argument is nonsense.

-Bri
 
If god is beyond logic, nothing can lead us to an understanding of God.

That's kind of the point of the argument that God is beyond logic, that we cannot fully understand God. Yet, that doesn't mean that God doesn't exist.

Even a God who operates completely within logic cannot be disproved.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Bri
Many Christians don't believe that God can do the logically impossible. Others hold that he is beyond logic and could change the rules of logic at will. The only thing that is known for certain is that we humans must operate within the rules of logic, and therefore to make an illogical, nonsense argument wouldn't lead us to any understanding of God.
But if god can do the logically impossible, then a logical argument would still not lead us to any understanding of god.

How do you know suffering isn't for the greater good? Those who believe in an omnibenevolent God might argue that all suffering is necessary for a greater good (such as free will).
Let me specify a bit and say unnecessary suffering isn’t for the greater good. Two examples specifically, crack babies and Pontine tumors.

The subject of the thread was that there is no God, so we are in agreement that the subject of the thread cannot be proven. In addition, nobody has yet been able to prove that an omnipotent, omniscient, or omnibenevolent God cannot exist.
An omnibenevolent god would either stop all evil, or if some evil were necessary then god would no allow unnecessary evil. I’ve already given two examples. If you can offer evidence that they are necessary evils, then do so.

No, "square" and "circle" are just words that represent different things, in this case mutually exclusive things that become meaningless when combined together.
Only when combined under our current system. Change the system and change the meanings.

If that's not what you mean, then define the object you're saying God cannot create.
I’m saying that even though to us a square circle is meaningless, god could change the meaning of the term or change basic geometric principles so that a square circle actually exists and has meaning.

Yes, changing the laws of nature would be a supernatural power (if that's your question). An omnipotent God would not necessarily be limited by the laws of nature, but our understanding of him might be limited by the rules of logic.
If an omnipotent god can change the laws of nature, what is stopping him from changing the laws of logic?

Not necessarily. Most definitions of "omnipotent" don't require God to be able to change the rules of logic, although some do claim that God is beyond logic and therefore could change the rules of logic as you suggest.
Explain how a god unlimited by the rules of nature should be limited by the rules of logic.

Ossai
 
Even a God who operates completely within logic cannot be disproved.

Well, as I said in another thread, I prefer, for practical reasons, to not demand absolute, 100% beyond any un-reasonable doubt certainty. I prefer the more pragmatic, "pretty damn sure" kind of certainty. Philosophically, there can always be doubt, but it's not of much use in day-to-day life (reality, whatever that is.)
 
If an omnipotent god can change the laws of nature, what is stopping him from changing the laws of logic?

That depends on whether or not we take "omnipotent" to mean "not limited to the laws of physics bu limited to the laws of logic", "not limited to the laws of logic" or "limited to the laws of physics."
 
But if god can do the logically impossible, then a logical argument would still not lead us to any understanding of god.

Correct, if God can do the logically impossible then we cannot ever fully understand God, assuming he chose to exercise this ability. Of course, doing the logically impossible isn't the definition of omnipotence used by many theists, but those who do use that definition would likely hold that understanding of God is impossible.

Let me specify a bit and say unnecessary suffering isn’t for the greater good. Two examples specifically, crack babies and Pontine tumors.

...

An omnibenevolent god would either stop all evil, or if some evil were necessary then god would no allow unnecessary evil. I’ve already given two examples. If you can offer evidence that they are necessary evils, then do so.

Crack babies are the direct result of human freedom of choice. Therefore, crack babies can be seen as a "greater good" if having free choice is seen as being a "greater good" than having no crack babies. Similarly, we cannot know for certain whether Pontine tumors or any other forms of human suffering serve some greater good.

I cannot offer definitive evidence that crack babies and tumors are necessary, but that's not the subject of the thread. The subject of the thread was about proving that God doesn't exist. In this case, some folks had conceded that not all notions of God can be disproven, but still held that an omnibenevolent God could be disproven. If you feel that an omnibenevolent God cannot exist, then you'd have to prove that there are "evils" in the world that are not necessary for some greater good. Given our limited knowledge of what constitutes the "greater good" much less what is necessary to achieve it, that would be a difficult task. Can you prove that crack babies and Pontine tumors aren't for the greater good?

Only when combined under our current system. Change the system and change the meanings.

...

I’m saying that even though to us a square circle is meaningless, god could change the meaning of the term or change basic geometric principles so that a square circle actually exists and has meaning.

You were asking the question based on our system of logic and our definitions of "square" and "circle," with specific expectations about what a "square circle" must be. If you weren't, then God adding the term "square circle" meaning "kangaroo" to the dictionary would be a sufficient answer. God can certainly make a kangaroo (and has, according to many). By adding changing the definition of "square circle" to mean "kangaroo," the term would cease to be a logical impossibility.

If an omnipotent god can change the laws of nature, what is stopping him from changing the laws of logic?

...

Explain how a god unlimited by the rules of nature should be limited by the rules of logic.

According to many, God is not limited by the rules of logic and nothing prevents God from changing the rules of logic. I'm just pointing out that being able to defy/change the laws of logic isn't necessary for omnipotence by most definitions.

-Bri
 
Well, as I said in another thread, I prefer, for practical reasons, to not demand absolute, 100% beyond any un-reasonable doubt certainty. I prefer the more pragmatic, "pretty damn sure" kind of certainty. Philosophically, there can always be doubt, but it's not of much use in day-to-day life (reality, whatever that is.)

I agree that very little can be proven beyond any doubt. When I said that even a God who operates completely within logic cannot be disproved, I meant that you cannot offer evidence that even comes close to supporting a claim of being "pretty damn sure" that such a God cannot exist. You may hold the opinion that such a God cannot exist, but you cannot support being "sure" of it.

-Bri
 
That depends on whether or not we take "omnipotent" to mean "not limited to the laws of physics bu limited to the laws of logic", "not limited to the laws of logic" or "limited to the laws of physics."

At the end of Contact (the book, not the movie) Carl Sagan gives a suggestion as to what would be absolute proof of god (if, by god, you mean not just the creator of the universe, but the creator of logic as well.)


Spoiler:
Hidden deep within transcendental numbers like pi were sequences of random digits that were not random -- when graphed, showed a circle or other geometric shapes, but billions of digits out. Much further downstream were more complicated messages, mirroring in a sense the message that contained the blueprints of The Machine.
 
Last edited:
Crack babies are the direct result of human freedom of choice. Therefore, crack babies can be seen as a "greater good" if having free choice is seen as being a "greater good" than having no crack babies. Similarly, we cannot know for certain whether Pontine tumors or any other forms of human suffering serve some greater good.

In what possible way could one see harm to the kid as proper result of another person's foolishness ? If anythig, the parent should be punished, no ? What does all this have to do with the kid. Did it have the freedom to choose whether or not to absorb this crap trough his system ?

I agree with your definition of omnipotence, by the way.
 
I agree that very little can be proven beyond any doubt. When I said that even a God who operates completely within logic cannot be disproved, I meant that you cannot offer evidence that even comes close to supporting a claim of being "pretty damn sure" that such a God cannot exist. You may hold the opinion that such a God cannot exist, but you cannot support being "sure" of it.

Of course. But operating with complete uncertainty all the time isn't very useful.
 
At the end of Contact (the book, not the movie) Carl Sagan gives a suggestion as to what would be absolute proof of god (if, by god, you mean not just the creator of the universe, but the creator of logic as well.)

Personnally I'd settle for a huge message written on the moon saying something like "God lives!", or a moral code that could be read by anyone with a telescope... and that would be intelligible by anyone, regardless of their native tongue. That'd be pretty telling. It wouldn't be absolutely certain, but it'd be the "pretty damn sure" kinda certainty I'm looking for.
 
How about "Sorry for the inconvieniance" written on the side of a mountain in gigantic burning letters? :P
 
In what possible way could one see harm to the kid as proper result of another person's foolishness ? If anythig, the parent should be punished, no ? What does all this have to do with the kid. Did it have the freedom to choose whether or not to absorb this crap trough his system ?

No, I never said it had anything to do with punishment at all. To the contrary, I said that it might be the result of human free will (i.e. the free will of the mother). In other words, perhaps God thinks it more important that we have freedom to choose between good and bad than for there to be no crack babies.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
No, I never said it had anything to do with punishment at all. To the contrary, I said that it might be the result of human free will (i.e. the free will of the mother). In other words, perhaps God thinks it more important that we have freedom to choose between good and bad than for there to be no crack babies.

Even if allowing the kid to be this way impairs its own free will ?
 
Well, that'd be pretty funny, but assuming God can create a world with ANY physical laws he wishes, I don't see why he couldn't make one where hurting other people is impossible.
An omnipotent agent could obviously create a world in which hurting other people is impossible, but each such possible world might have negative consequences for free will and free-will-related goodness. That's why I was trying to flesh out scenarios to see how such a world would operate.

For example, in a universe in which it were flatly impossible to actualize the intent to harm someone, would it really be possible to form the free, deliberate, and informed intention to harm someone in the first place? In the real world, if a small child points a gun at someone and pulls the trigger, we are inclined to think that the child did not actually form the free and deliberate intention to commit murder, because the child does not have an adult's familiarity with the phenomena of guns, injury, death, and so forth. Would the inhabitants of a world in which no one has ever seen or heard of (nor will ever see or hear of) someone's being harmed by someone else, be capable of freely forming the blameworthy intention to harm someone, or conversely the meritorious intention to spare someone from harm? The inhabitants would not be like robots, but they would arguably be deprived of free will of the adult variety, which might constitute a great loss.
 
An omnipotent agent could obviously create a world in which hurting other people is impossible, but each such possible world might have negative consequences for free will and free-will-related goodness. That's why I was trying to flesh out scenarios to see how such a world would operate.

Maybe, but in this world we are limited from doing anything we want as well. I don't think I need to start enumerating, but there are a great number of things I can't do. No matter how hard I try. Unless we're created omnipotent, we're limited anyway. The point is, our free will is limited by our physical possibilities. In a world where unnecessary evil (or any evil, depending on the world) would be impossible, we would still have free will, relative to the physical possibilities offered by that world.
 
Maybe, but in this world we are limited from doing anything we want as well. I don't think I need to start enumerating, but there are a great number of things I can't do. No matter how hard I try. Unless we're created omnipotent, we're limited anyway. The point is, our free will is limited by our physical possibilities. In a world where unnecessary evil (or any evil, depending on the world) would be impossible, we would still have free will, relative to the physical possibilities offered by that world.
Sure, but not having free will with respect to decisions about harming other people cuts out a disproportionate number of morally significant options, doesn't it? Maybe you need to have certain kinds of physical possibilities at least theoretically available to you in a given universe in order to have free will that is morally meaningful enough to constitute the very great good that most people hold adult human free will to be. A stripped-down free will that doesn't extend to choices about harming and sparing from harm is, in my view, of vastly reduced moral significance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom