The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Stop prevaricating. The Italian not guilty under article 530,1 does NOT mean actively 'innocent' ; as in the UK and the USA, it means the prosecution has failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

In Italy virtually 99.999% of 'not guilty' verdicts are under 530.1, with the relevant sub paragraph quoted.

Stop trying to fabricate that 530,2 is a run of the mill 'not guilty' as we understand it.


You've got reliable statistics to back up this "virtually 99.999% of not-guilty verdicts are under 530.1", I am assuming?

Wait a minute. What on Earth am I assuming?? You've got no such statistics, have you Vixen? You#re just making stuff up, aren't you?

(And your "...with the relevant sub paragraph quoted" is fatuous rubbish. Again, I implore you to actually do some research (you claimed to be exemplary at research HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA): look at the ACTUAL TEXT of Section 530 of the Italian Code of Criminal Practice (hell - it's been quoted to you enough within these threads already!!). Paragraph 530.1 - that's to say Section 530 Paragraph 1 - is one short paragraph of text. There are no "sub paragraphs". Arrant nonsense.)
 
It is exactly similar to the Scottish law 'not proven'.

As courts are supposed to come to a decision this rubric is being phased out.

In fact, it is astonishing that the Marasca court pulled it out of the hat. It was the only way it could get the pair out of jail. And it is as illegal and bent as a nine-bob note.


NO IT IS NOT EXACTLY SIMILAR TO THE SCOTTISH "NOT PROVEN".

Please try to get an education.

I and others have carefully explained within these threads time and time again what the true situation is.


(Oh and the Marasca panel verdict/reasoning was absolutely not "illegal" or "bent as a nine bob note". But if you and your little pro-guilt colleagues like to keep thinking that it was, well that's your (ill-educated, low-intellect, hopelessly partisan) prerogative of course....)
 
Last edited:
She was friends with Vanessa, who lived in Milan at the time.

Say no more.

Vanessa was sacked from the Carabinieri for tampering with the evidence.

I'd like to know where you got the idea that Mrs. Popovic was a friend of Vanessa's or had ever even met her. What evidence do you have of this? None. Just like you have no evidence of the jacket or the cap and a multitude of other false claims.

Vanessa was not fired from the carabinieri for "tampering with evidence". She was fired for daring to defend her brother over her fellow carabinieri.

Rome, July 5 - Tonight, in the transmission Tabloid, broadcast on Italia1 at 21.00, we talk about the affair occurred to the Lieutenant of the Carabinieri Vanessa Sollecito. The officer, after six years of service in the Army and another 4 between the Navy and the Air Force, on April 20th 2009 was declared "unsuitable" by the Commission for the aptitude tests of the National Selection and Recruitment Center of the General Command of the Army of the Carabinieri as part of the "Special Procedures aimed at the stabilization of officers in fixed position, auxiliary to the special and technical-logistic roles of the Carabinieri". As a result, she was dismissed and placed outside the Carabinieri Army.
https://www.grnet.it/sicurezza/cara...arla-stasera-su-italia-1-con-lavvocato-carta/

Vanessa had outstanding credentials and had been rated "above average" by the Carabinieri previously.

Stop making things up. Your penchant for doing so is well established. Just stop it.
 
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black. Vixen has lied so many times we'd need a calculator to keep up.

Of course, Vixen avoids all the very credible reasons why she should accept the testimony as truthful, not least of which being the investigators who worked so hard to try to convict Amanda and Raffaele never disputed the testimony.

I notice Vixen has now moved up from being suspicious to certainty that "it never happened". Of course, had the investigators had any doubts about this testimony they could have tracked down the driver of the bus that evening and confirmed Popovic's mother tried to send the suitcase. And this, of course, renders this blathering comment from Vixen moot;

"They were not under any risk as nobody can prove that there never was any suitcase due to be placed on the bus, as it never happened."

Imagine if the investigators interviewed the bus driver and s/he stated no one ever tried to send a suitcase on the bus. That would certainly be a problem for someone who claimed they tried to do that and were told by the driver they couldn't. But Vixen just ignores this and claims there was no risk in lying to help cover for someone she didn't know.

But Curatolo, Quintavalle, Capezzali... yeah, they're all credible and beyond reproach.

Try and leave an unattended suitcase on any public transport in Europe and you'll get the bum's rush.


Hahaha 'Popovich says people do this in Serbia all the time'.


Talk about gilding the lily.


Of course they do, Janna.
 
This is an astonishingly, laughably incorrect assertion.

Or perhaps you can actually show me reliable, credible statistics on the relative proportions of acquittals in Italian criminal courts which are under 530.1 and 530.2. Oh, what's that? You don't HAVE any such statistics? And you've just pulled a bogus "fact" straight out of your backside to try to bolster your argument? Ah, thought so.

Wot? Vixen would just make up "facts" to suit her purpose? Noooooo… tell me it ain't so!:jaw-dropp
 
From the post-mortem, it was clear there were at least two knives involved. One, similar to the one Raff had on his person at the questura was deemed responsible for the relatively smaller stab wounds on the left side of the victim's neck and a large kitchen knife for the fatal wounds on the other side of the neck.

How this pair sleeps at night escapes me.


This is totally incorrect. Do you come to this errant belief on account of poor education of the facts, or an inability to conduct cogent analysis, or some other reason?

In fact, the true situation is this:

All of the knife wounds are actually consistent with one, narrow-bladed knife with about a 12-15cm blade length.

Perhaps you have confused yourself (!) owing to the prosecution's assertion that the Sollecito kitchen knife was wielded in the murder. Because if that knife truly WAS used (it was not, but for now let's fantasise eh?), then the wound analysis shows that this knife simply could not have inflicted all the wounds - and therefore if one accepts that the Sollecito kitchen knife was used, then one also has to accept that at least one other knife was also used (because Sollecito's kitchen knife was too big to have made at least one of the wounds).

But if you come to understand that the Sollecito kitchen knife was NOT used in the murder - and there is not one iota of credible, reliable evidence pointing to its use - then in fact the wounds are all entirely consistent with the use of just one, smaller knife. Which is what happened. And it was Guede's knife. With Guede wielding the knife. All by himself.
 
As Williams would say... round and round we go.

So let's try this one more time.

https://www.brocardi.it/codice-di-procedura-penale/libro-settimo/titolo-iii/capo-ii/sezione-i/art530.html?utm_source=internal&utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=articolo&utm_content=nav_art_prec_top

This is NOT wikipedia, this is straight from the Italian CPP. I copied Article 530 (all four paragraphs) here for your convenience but by all means, please use the link to go read for yourself. You'll notice there are these handy-dandy "<- ART.PREVIOUS" and "ART.NEXT ->" links on both the top and bottom of each page. That should assist you as you find your way to Article 530.2, where you can then copy/paste the content here.

OR.... you can just admit you are wrong and be done with it. You're choice. I'll just kick back with some popcorn and enjoy the action.


The combination of a) inept knowledge/understanding of the actual facts and b) extreme intellectual dishonesty embedded within this particular pro-guilt argument is verging on truly breathtaking. It's at once both pathetic and belief-beggaring. And it's increasingly a waste of time trying to counter with actual fact and coherent analysis - because the same old lies, misrepresentations and strawmen come back just the same, with even more chutzpah and rampant dishonesty, time and again.

Quite astonishing to observe. Shameful, but astonishing.
 
Try and leave an unattended suitcase on any public transport in Europe and you'll get the bum's rush.


Hahaha 'Popovich Popovic says people do this in Serbia all the time'.


Talk about gilding the lily.


Of course they do, Janna Jovana.

Indeed, Jovana's mother did "get the bum's rush" when she tried to leave the suitcase on the bus in Milan. But are you now an expert on what is done in Serbia, too?

And, please, get her name right.

Talk about just making things up: you have provided no evidence whatsoever that Vanessa S even knew Jovana's mother or that she did not try and send Jovana a suitcase.
All you've proved, yet again, is your blind need to disbelieve anything and everything that supports innocence but believe anything and everything that does not. Can you say "extreme confirmation bias"?
 
From the post-mortem, it was clear there were at least two knives involved. One, similar to the one Raff had on his person at the questura was deemed responsible for the relatively smaller stab wounds on the left side of the victim's neck and a large kitchen knife for the fatal wounds on the other side of the neck.

How this pair sleeps at night escapes me.

Wrong again.

Mignini was convinced that the positions of the injuries on the body showed without doubt there had been more than one attacker. He pointed to the wounds on the front, left and right of Meredith’s neck and asked Lalli: ‘Look here, surely these were caused by two different knives?’

‘Well, my guess is that they were caused by the same knife,’ Lalli replied, pointing with his index finger to show how he believed each of the three wounds had been inflicted.
Follain, John. A Death in Italy: The Definitive Account of the Amanda Knox Case (Kindle Locations 1660-1662). St. Martin's Press. Kindle Edition.

Why you keep posting falsehoods escapes me. Hmmmm...no, not really.
 
Great tweet here. It is a reproduction of the court testimony in which Amanda Knox confesses that she offered Patrick Lumumba's name freely and voluntarily, without any pressure from the police.

https://twitter.com/Robyn__Duncan/status/960449261300305921

Bang goes another PR lie.


Oh. Dear.

Are you (and that cast-iron nutter Duncan) incapable of objective research/analysis? Or is this a wilful attempt to misdirect/deceive? Because it has to be one or both of these things, Vixen.

This section of trial transcript is very specifically in respect of Knox's memorandum from the daytime on 6th November. The one in which she actually states explicitly that she has huge doubts over what she was told to "remember" in her earlier statements.

If you (or Duncan) actually go back earlier in Pacelli's courtroom exchange with Knox, you will clearly see that when he is questioning her over the build-up to her critical 1.45am "confession/accusation", she does indeed explicitly and specifically state on the stand that she was instructed by the police to "remember" that she'd met up with Lumumba, and that she was mistreated by the police as part of their "persuasion" tactics. Knox cannot make it clearer to Pacelli that she indeed was severely pressurised by the police in the build-up to her (as memorably put by Perugia Police Chief De Felice) "buckling" and "confirming what (the police) already knew to be correct".

Bang goes another pro-guilt lie eh, Vixen. Really quite some piece of work.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, Jovana's mother did "get the bum's rush" when she tried to leave the suitcase on the bus in Milan. But are you now an expert on what is done in Serbia, too?

And, please, get her name right.

Talk about just making things up: you have provided no evidence whatsoever that Vanessa S even knew Jovana's mother or that she did not try and send Jovana a suitcase.
All you've proved, yet again, is your blind need to disbelieve anything and everything that supports innocence but believe anything and everything that does not. Can you say "extreme confirmation bias"?


You'd think, wouldn't you, that someone whose "arguments" got shot down in flames EVERY SINGLE TIME, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, would perhaps dial back the brazen chutzpah and, y'know, try to actually do some proper research and checking before trying again.

But not in the bizzaro-world of pro-guilt commentary, it would appear.........
 
You'd think, wouldn't you, that someone whose "arguments" got shot down in flames EVERY SINGLE TIME, WITHOUT EXCEPTION, would perhaps dial back the brazen chutzpah and, y'know, try to actually do some proper research and checking before trying again.

But not in the bizzaro-world of pro-guilt commentary, it would appear.........

But that's the problem, LJ. In that bizzaro world, facts don't matter. Evidence doesn't matter. Truth doesn't matter. If they don't like the facts or evidence, they just make up their own. The fact they can't support those "facts and evidence" with proof matters not; they just keep repeating them. Such dishonesty.
 
I started to compile a list of all the provable falsehoods Vixen posted in the last six pages. After finding five or six on the first page alone, I decided it would take too much time. Besides, unlike the Washington Post that keeps tabs on the average of nine lies a day Trump tells, I don't have a staff.
 
Try and leave an unattended suitcase on any public transport in Europe and you'll get the bum's rush.


Hahaha 'Popovich says people do this in Serbia all the time'.


Talk about gilding the lily.


Of course they do, Janna.

It's Jovana Popovic. At least get that much correct.

So you've got nothing... no contradiction's in the account given by four different people; no explanation for how they got with Jovana and her mother to come up with this story within hours of the discovery of the murder; no evidence from the bus company to contradict Jovana's mother; no explanation for why Jovana and her mother would be willing to risk a conspiracy to conceal a murder charge for people they barely knew; no evidence that Michele contradicted Jovana about trying to contact him first. No surprise here.

Do you have any evidence to prove Jovana made the claim "people do this in Serbia all the time"? I've just read her court testimony, start to finish, and she never makes such a claim so I'm just wondering where you got this from? Surely you didn't just make that up... right? --RIGHT???

Leave an unattended suitcase? So now you're trying to couch this as if she tried to pull a typical terrorist tactic. Nice try (well, not really, but..) but that's NOT what she was trying to do. She asked the bus driver if she could put the suitcase on the bus for her daughter to receive in Perugia. For whatever reason she thought she might be able to do this and apparently she was told it was not allowed. Bum rush? More colorful hyperbole to make your point, I suppose. Much more likely she was politely advised that was not allowed. How does the phrase "gilding the lily" apply here?
 
It is exactly similar to the Scottish law 'not proven'.

As courts are supposed to come to a decision this rubric is being phased out.

In fact, it is astonishing that the Marasca court pulled it out of the hat. It was the only way it could get the pair out of jail. And it is as illegal and bent as a nine-bob note.

Vixen complains the supreme court acted illegally. The link below shows the numerous Italian laws which were broken by the police/proscution and PGP had no problem with police/prosecution acting illegally. How does Vixen explain the hypocrisy of attacking the supreme court for acting illegaly but slavishly supporting corrupt police/prosecutors who acted illegally and PGP feel it is perfectly acceptable for Italian laws to be broken when it works against Amanda and Raffaele.

http://www.injusticeanywhereforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3161&sid=3db6831fa24e71fca9d2aad8f22e0415

Vixen complains the supreme court were bent. The links below show the numerous abuses committed by the police/prosecution. Can Vixen explain the hypocrisy of attacking the supreme court for being corrupt whilst slavishly defending corrupt police/prosecutors who didn't tape the interrogations of Amanda and Raffaele, denied access to lawyers, didn't explain Amanda and Raffaele their rights, abused Amanda, Raffaele and Lumumba during the interrogations, fed false information to the media, destroyed evidence, engaged in the massive of suppression of evidence and committed perjury and have no problems with corruption when it works against Amanda and Raffaele.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11071314#post11071314
 
It's Jovana Popovic. At least get that much correct.

So you've got nothing... no contradiction's in the account given by four different people; no explanation for how they got with Jovana and her mother to come up with this story within hours of the discovery of the murder; no evidence from the bus company to contradict Jovana's mother; no explanation for why Jovana and her mother would be willing to risk a conspiracy to conceal a murder charge for people they barely knew; no evidence that Michele contradicted Jovana about trying to contact him first. No surprise here.

Do you have any evidence to prove Jovana made the claim "people do this in Serbia all the time"? I've just read her court testimony, start to finish, and she never makes such a claim so I'm just wondering where you got this from? Surely you didn't just make that up... right? --RIGHT???

Leave an unattended suitcase? So now you're trying to couch this as if she tried to pull a typical terrorist tactic. Nice try (well, not really, but..) but that's NOT what she was trying to do. She asked the bus driver if she could put the suitcase on the bus for her daughter to receive in Perugia. For whatever reason she thought she might be able to do this and apparently she was told it was not allowed. Bum rush? More colorful hyperbole to make your point, I suppose. Much more likely she was politely advised that was not allowed. How does the phrase "gilding the lily" apply here?

There is no evidence Jovana's mother knew anyone in the Sollecito family. That Vanessa was a "friend" of hers is just another piece of fantasy pulled out of Vixen's repository of made up "facts" aka "her nether region".
I'm shocked! Shocked, I tell ya!
 
It was entirely illegal for the Supreme Court to annul the conviction. In a serious crime such as a murder, they do not have the jursidiction to dismiss charges, where a defendant has fairly been found guilty in a fair trail.

We're oddly getting somewhere.

The Italian Supreme Court in 2015 probably did think all the trials up until that point had been "fair".

But that's not the point is it? If you will quit posting tired talking points from Nick van der Leek and or the remaining online hate sites....

..... you'll see that what Cassation said, was that even if the evidence that Nencini cited to support his decision was true, that even then Nencini shouldn't have convicted.

A "fair" trial should have acquitted, and what had been unfair had been Nencini's faulty legal reasoning.

You always leave that part out. Stop reading Harry Rag, Peter Quennell and Nick van der Leek, because they are badly misinterpreting the final acquittal and exoneration.
 
Last edited:
We're oddly getting somewhere.

The Italian Supreme Court in 2015 probably did think all the trials up until that point had been "fair".

But that's not the point is it? If you will quit posting tired talking points from Nick van der Leek and or the remaining online hate sites....

..... you'll see that what Cassation said, was that even if the evidence that Nencini cited to support his decision was true, that even then Nencini shouldn't have convicted.

A "fair" trial should have acquitted, and what had been unfair had been Nencini's faulty legal reasoning.
You always leave that part out. Stop reading Harry Rag, Peter Quennell and Nick van der Leek, because they are badly misinterpreting the final acquittal and exoneration.

A clarification. Not only did the Marasca CSC panel fault the Nencini appeal court's legal reasoning, they also found that the Nencini court judgment had violated Italian law and the Italian Constitution. Thus, it would be erroneous to state that they had even "probably" considered the Nencini judgment fair.

For example, in Section 4.1 and 4.2, without explicitly mentioning CPP Article 192 in that section, the Marasca CSC panel MR agrees with the appellants that the Nencini court violated that law by the improper use of DNA profile data, not obtained in accordance with international standards, and thus not properly usable to establish a fact. The MR attacks the DNA evidence as deficient in lacking reliability and repeatability, and thus not able to establish a fact. CPP Article 192.2 states: The existence of a fact cannot be inferred from circumstantial evidence unless such evidence is serious, precise, and consistent.

In Section 4.3 and 4.3.1, the MR criticizes the way that the results of Guede's trial was used in the Nencini judgment, as a violation of CPP Article 192.3, which requires corroborating evidence to confirm the reliability of such alleged evidence from an accused co-conspirator. The Marasca CSC panel MR goes on to point out, in Section 4.3.2, that this use of Guede's trial results or his unexamined statements also violates the Italian Constitution, Article 111, Clause 4, as well as several laws (CPP articles) elaborating on that constitutional provision.
 
Guys you're missing the bigger picture. Vixen is conceding that Popovic's testimony is damning to the prosecution's timeline and crime scenario. Since no court rejected Popovic she's practically conceding reasonable doubt.
 
Guys you're missing the bigger picture. Vixen is conceding that Popovic's testimony is damning to the prosecution's timeline and crime scenario. Since no court rejected Popovic she's practically conceding reasonable doubt.

You're right, I did miss that. Walk us through that....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom