There is No God (And You Know It)

If and only if we could expect God to leave such evidence, which, as you've so eloquently put it, depends on which definition of God you use.

Then God by those definitions by which God doesn't leave evidence (which is probably most of them) cannot be proven not to exist, therefore it cannot be proven that no God exists.

-Bri
 
Then God by those definitions by which God doesn't leave evidence (which is probably most of them) cannot be proven not to exist, therefore it cannot be proven that no God exists.

-Bri

Just as an aside: can you prove that you exist ? I can guarantee you can't if I ask you to prove it to me beyond any doubt. Personnally, I'll take reasonable doubt. I think it's possible to prove that God doesn't exist beyond reasonable doubt. Unless we alter "God" in a way that he's not God anymore. Anyway. I don't think either of us has anything more to add on the subject. You ?
 
Read up. Science can and does explain it.

Your original question was what purpose God might serve. Even if science can and does explain one possibility for the origins of the universe, that does not mean that God cannot have created the universe. But please post references that state what caused the big bang. While you're at it, please post references concerning what caused whatever caused the big bang.

By doing what that would be different from a godless universe ?

That wasn't your original question, it was what purpose might God serve. God might serve to provide us with free will. That would be different from a godless universe in that we have free will.

That's a common theist response. However, I don't see how you can claim that science can't explain it. We know how cells and genes work and why. What's the basis of your assertion ?

Even if you believe that science can explain how cells and genes work, science cannot create life. God's purpose might still be to create life. But please post a source that tells exactly how and why cells and genes work. Our knowledge of cells and genes is incomplete at best. Show me a reference that indicates that science understands how to create life from lifeless raw materials. Even if humans could create life, God's purpose might have been to create humans.

We know exactly what causes them. It doesn't make the prediction any easier because knowning what the factors are and detecting those factors continuously is not the same thing.

What are the factors? What causes those factors? No, we don't know all the factors that cause tornados or earthquakes, nor can we prove that God didn't cause them or the factors that caused them. So God's purpose might be to create tornados and earthquakes.

I know that. However, I don't see how a rational beign would expect other rational beigns to believe in something without any form of evidence. Is God insane ?

Not everyone would agree that there is no evidence for the existance of God. But even if there isn't, not all religions hold that God requires everyone to believe in him. Even those that do hold that God requires belief in him admit that the belief must come from faith, not knowledge.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Just as an aside: can you prove that you exist ? I can guarantee you can't if I ask you to prove it to me beyond any doubt. Personnally, I'll take reasonable doubt. I think it's possible to prove that God doesn't exist beyond reasonable doubt.

No I cannot prove that I exist.

You claim that you can prove that God doesn't exist beyond a reasonable doubt. Please provide any evidence (beyond a reasonable doubt or otherwise) that no God can possibly exist.

Unless we alter "God" in a way that he's not God anymore. Anyway. I don't think either of us has anything more to add on the subject. You ?

So choose a definition of God that you feel is "reasonable." How about a deist God that created the universe, and then no longer interferes with it except to judge us after we die? Or do you contend that a deist God isn't God?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
How do you know that some consequences to actions that are unnecessary?

It may very well be for the greater good for some people who choose to smoke crack and get pregnant to give birth to a baby addicted to crack.

It's no different than any other case that where someone causes suffering to another innocent human being. Having a choice between good and evil requires that a human be able to cause suffering. God may consider free will to be a greater good than a world without human suffering.

We've also already discussed Pontine tumors, which are no different than hurricanes and earthquakes -- human suffering which cannot be attributed specifically to human causes. Aside from the possibility that all of these are the result of human causes that we don't know about, these may also be for a greater good that we don't know about.

For every scenario you conjure up that you think precludes God from being omnibenevolent because of human suffering, I can give the same answer.

Some interesting observations on this topic come from the (theistic) philosopher James Beilby, who suggests, along with Stephen Wykstra and William Alston, the possibility that:

... the human epistemic situation is such that we are unable to make a sufficiently well-grounded determination that actual gratuitous evils in fact exist. In other words, as finite beings, humans do not have access to the breadth and depth of information necessary to determine whether or not the evils in question are in fact gratuitous. The outweighing goods associated with the evils in question may, after all, be beyond our ken. Following Alston, I shall call this argument the 'Agnostic Thesis' (hereafter AT).

The sorts of human cognitive limitations intimated by the AT are the following:

(1) Lack of data due to human isolation (both temporal and spatial).
(2) Complexity greater than we can handle.
(3) Difficulty of determining what is metaphysically possible or necessary in any given situation.
(4) Ignorance of values or qualities which, if present in a given state of affairs, would render that state of affairs intrinsically good.

Each of these limitations seems very reasonable given the epistemic predicament endemic to humanity.

Moreover, the plausibility of the AT is bolstered by the fact that many times an evil which has appeared to be gratuitous is later discovered to have (previously inscrutable) justifying goods. ...

Briefly, I must emphasize that the AT does not commit the theist to any sort of general scepticism regarding our cognitive abilities. In invoking AT to handle the [empirical problem of evil], I have merely claimed that human cognitive faculties are not suited to the particular task to which [certain atheologians have] applied them. The atheist, in claiming that there is at least one instance of evil which has no justifying good, is undertaking an exceptionally difficult task. She is attempting to make a negative existential assertion concerning the parameters and contents of a particular territory of which she has insufficient knowledge. As such, the AT implies, presupposes, or reflects no more of a general scepticism regarding the possibility of human knowledge than does the claim that we don't know that there is life elsewhere in the universe.
Source: Beilby, J., "Does the Empirical Problem of Evil Prove that Theism is Improbable?," Religious Studies 32:315-323 (1996).
 
Last edited:
For every scenario you conjure up that you think precludes God from being omnibenevolent because of human suffering, I can give the same answer.

-Bri
But of course if I have faith in an absolutely benevolent God then this leaves me free to commit acts of evil. Since I believe that any act of evil has ultimately good consequences and that those consequences outweigh and negate the evil consequences, then I can commit evil in the safe knowledge that I am ultimately doing good.
 
But of course if I have faith in an absolutely benevolent God then this leaves me free to commit acts of evil. Since I believe that any act of evil has ultimately good consequences and that those consequences outweigh and negate the evil consequences, then I can commit evil in the safe knowledge that I am ultimately doing good.

The only "good" you are doing is exercising your free will. That doesn't preclude you from being responsible for your actions. In fact, quite the opposite since you could have chosen good over evil.

-Bri
 
The only "good" you are doing is exercising your free will. That doesn't preclude you from being responsible for your actions. In fact, quite the opposite since you could have chosen good over evil.

-Bri
But I did choose good over evil - I chose the good that I knew must ultimately ensue from any evil. And of course I am happy to be responsible for the ultimate good that I know will ensue.

If I administer a painful medicine to a child will I be punished for the immediate suffering I inflicted, or rewarded for the ultimate good that I believed would ensue?

If I truly believe in the absolute benevolence of God there is no difference.
 
But of course if I have faith in an absolutely benevolent God then this leaves me free to commit acts of evil. Since I believe that any act of evil has ultimately good consequences and that those consequences outweigh and negate the evil consequences, then I can commit evil in the safe knowledge that I am ultimately doing good.
Here I think you may be assuming that a defense suited to the problem of natural evil necessarily applies to the problem of moral evil.

Bri was hypothesizing that every apparent natural evil may, thanks to God, ultimately result in a net good. Yet this hypothesis does not imply that an omnibenevolent God must (or is logically able to) parlay every distinct moral evil into a net good, as I see it. With respect to moral evil, God's benevolence arguably only requires that the created universe be superior to possible universes without free agency. It does not require that the universe be better off than it would have been had you not chosen to do evil. The greater good may have been served by your freedom to choose, but that doesn't mean that if God exists, each of your choices will serve good ends.
 
Your original question was what purpose God might serve. Even if science can and does explain one possibility for the origins of the universe, that does not mean that God cannot have created the universe. But please post references that state what caused the big bang. While you're at it, please post references concerning what caused whatever caused the big bang.

The big bang wasn't "caused".

As a starter, read this:

http://www.colorado.edu/philosophy/vstenger/Cosmo/OtherSide.html


That wasn't your original question, it was what purpose might God serve. God might serve to provide us with free will. That would be different from a godless universe in that we have free will.

Well, it's my question now. How would we provide us with free will. Even without a God, we can still make the same choices, so how is what different ?

Even if you believe that science can explain how cells and genes work, science cannot create life.

Really ? Why ? Because we haven't yet ? Or because we simply can't ? That's quite a leap between the two.

What are the factors? What causes those factors? No, we don't know all the factors that cause tornados or earthquakes, nor can we prove that God didn't cause them or the factors that caused them. So God's purpose might be to create tornados and earthquakes.

So, no matter how much we know about the universe you'll still claim that we don't "know all the factors". Well, you're pretty safe, there, aren't you ?
 
You claim that you can prove that God doesn't exist beyond a reasonable doubt. Please provide any evidence (beyond a reasonable doubt or otherwise) that no God can possibly exist.

Since I know that you wouldn't agree that any evidence I present would show that God couldn't reasonably exist, would you consider that some of the arguments I've already used show that the existence of God is less likely than his non-existence ?

So choose a definition of God that you feel is "reasonable." How about a deist God that created the universe, and then no longer interferes with it except to judge us after we die? Or do you contend that a deist God isn't God?

I have nothing against that definition. Of course, in order for it to have any meaning, souls would have to exist. And we also have a working theory on how the universe could have been created without God, making God unnecessary to the equation.
 
Bri
Oh, so now we're talking about only the Christian God. Mind you, this discussion would have no bearing on the existance of all gods and so it is somewhat off-topic.
:confused:
Did you read the opening post and linked article? Both were tacitly about the Christian god. Admittedly the thread has wondered a bit since then.

This is an appeal to emotion. Awful as it may seem, little Timmy's suffering might somehow increase the greater good.
How is it an appeal to emotion? How would little Timmy’s suffering increase the greater good.

ceo_esq
As for your first example, several solutions have been proposed to show that there is no necessary logical contradiction between divine foreknowledge and human freedom. I already gave you a link to a discussion of this.
I read the link, it presents nothing new or insightful. Foreknowledge, doesn’t even have to be divine, and freewill are mutually exclusive.

As for your second example, it appears to be an allusion to the logical problem of evil.
Close but no cigar.
God is said to have the trait omnibenevolent.
God orders his followers to bash in the heads of enemy babies with great joy, which is sadistic.
Therefore you have an omnibenevolent sadist.

As for your third example, I'm not sure what logical contradiction you think arises from it.
It’s more of a fundy example.
When something bad happens or a tough moral situation doesn’t go as expected god is said to work in mysterious ways. You’ve also get the standard response ‘god is so far above humanity that we can’t understand him or how he works’ or some other variation. Thereby making god inscrutable.
Fundys also claim that all moral codes and by extension laws originate from god.
So you get an inscrutable lawgiver.

Even God, if he really existed, couldn't figure out a square circle.
An you’ve just trumped omniscience.

Belz...
How does that prove that God broke the laws of logic?
It was given as an example of god already breaking the logical restraint.

What's free willed determinism ?
A completely deterministic universe in which the people have free will.

How can you have free will if the universe is completely deterministic ?
I’ve no idea. Ask the Christians that proclaim such.

Ossai
 
But I did choose good over evil - I chose the good that I knew must ultimately ensue from any evil. And of course I am happy to be responsible for the ultimate good that I know will ensue.

If I administer a painful medicine to a child will I be punished for the immediate suffering I inflicted, or rewarded for the ultimate good that I believed would ensue?

If I truly believe in the absolute benevolence of God there is no difference.

I never said that every evil action done by a human is for the ultimate good. I said that God allowing us to choose between good and evil might be for the ultimate good. If you choose evil, then you are in no way increasing the good in the world. The fact that you have free will had been established long before you made your choice and the good that came from allowing free will would be the same if you chose good or evil. Therefore, the net good in the world would be increased by your choosing good whereas it would be decreased by your choosing evil.

-Bri
 
Well, it's my question now. How would we provide us with free will. Even without a God, we can still make the same choices, so how is what different ?

Without free will, you can't make any choices at all. So prove that the world would be exactly the same with or without free will.

Really ? Why ? Because we haven't yet ? Or because we simply can't ? That's quite a leap between the two.

Because we haven't yet, and possibly can't. You asked me to give you possible purposes for God, and creating life might be one of them. Prove that it's not.

So, no matter how much we know about the universe you'll still claim that we don't "know all the factors". Well, you're pretty safe, there, aren't you ?

Very. Unless you feel that science will be able to control the weather any time soon. Even so, God's purpose could still be to control the weather.

-Bri
 
Since I know that you wouldn't agree that any evidence I present would show that God couldn't reasonably exist, would you consider that some of the arguments I've already used show that the existence of God is less likely than his non-existence ?

The statement wasn't that God couldn't reasonably exist, it was that it's impossible for him to exist (i.e. "There is no God" not "There probably is no God"). You have yet to provide evidence to back up the statement "There is no God." I don't think that I could calculate the probability of God's existance based on the arguments you have provided thus far.

I have nothing against that definition. Of course, in order for it to have any meaning, souls would have to exist.

Then unless you can provide evidence that souls can't exist, you cannot provide evidence that the deist God can't exist.

And we also have a working theory on how the universe could have been created without God, making God unnecessary to the equation.

An incomplete theory at best. Not to say that we won't come up with a "complete" theory someday, but it's certainly possible that we won't.

-Bri
 
Did you read the opening post and linked article? Both were tacitly about the Christian god. Admittedly the thread has wondered a bit since then.

The original poster incorrectly concluded that the article cited disproved the existance of all gods (as is clear from the title of the thread and the fact that the poster claimed that it was "perhaps the best argument for athiesm I've ever seen"). The thread "wandered" after the second post, where it was pointed out that the article uses an old and inconclusive argument against the existance of the Christian God.

How is it an appeal to emotion? How would little Timmy’s suffering increase the greater good.

How is "little Timmy's" suffering any different from the suffering of any other innocent human being? Why did you place the word "little" in front of Timmy's name when you had already made it clear that Timmy was a child?

-Bri
 
That doesn't even make sense. Where did you get that idea ?

There are "compatibilist" arguments that claim that some form of free will is possible even if determinism is true. Most of the arguments seem to change the definition of what most people consider to be "free will" in order to resolve moral delimmas that seem to arise from determinism, such as the question of how we can be responsible for what we do if we have no choice to do otherwise.

Here is a good article on the subject.

Ossai isn't quite correct in implying that Christians are compatibilists. Most Christians don't believe in determinism.

-Bri
 
Without free will, you can't make any choices at all. So prove that the world would be exactly the same with or without free will.

Talk about strawmen!! You're funny. You're assuming that, without God, there can be no free will. How is that ? I asked how a universe WITH a God be different than one WITHOUT one. How can we assume that free will cannot exist without God ? You made that assertion, not I.

Because we haven't yet, and possibly can't. You asked me to give you possible purposes for God, and creating life might be one of them. Prove that it's not.

I'm sorry, I don't have to answer a logical fallacy.

Very. Unless you feel that science will be able to control the weather any time soon. Even so, God's purpose could still be to control the weather.

Understanding weather implies controlling it ? I don't even see how controlling implies understanding, so you'll forgive me if I don't understand your assertion, here.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom