... the human epistemic situation is such that we are unable to make a sufficiently well-grounded determination that actual gratuitous evils in fact exist. In other words, as finite beings, humans do not have access to the breadth and depth of information necessary to determine whether or not the evils in question are in fact gratuitous. The outweighing goods associated with the evils in question may, after all, be beyond our ken. Following Alston, I shall call this argument the 'Agnostic Thesis' (hereafter AT).
The sorts of human cognitive limitations intimated by the AT are the following:
(1) Lack of data due to human isolation (both temporal and spatial).
(2) Complexity greater than we can handle.
(3) Difficulty of determining what is metaphysically possible or necessary in any given situation.
(4) Ignorance of values or qualities which, if present in a given state of affairs, would render that state of affairs intrinsically good.
Each of these limitations seems very reasonable given the epistemic predicament endemic to humanity.
Moreover, the plausibility of the AT is bolstered by the fact that many times an evil which has appeared to be gratuitous is later discovered to have (previously inscrutable) justifying goods. ...
Briefly, I must emphasize that the AT does not commit the theist to any sort of general scepticism regarding our cognitive abilities. In invoking AT to handle the [empirical problem of evil], I have merely claimed that human cognitive faculties are not suited to the particular task to which [certain atheologians have] applied them. The atheist, in claiming that there is at least one instance of evil which has no justifying good, is undertaking an exceptionally difficult task. She is attempting to make a negative existential assertion concerning the parameters and contents of a particular territory of which she has insufficient knowledge. As such, the AT implies, presupposes, or reflects no more of a general scepticism regarding the possibility of human knowledge than does the claim that we don't know that there is life elsewhere in the universe.