Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Lies about Tom Bridgeman's calculation which is mass versus charge

If you do Tom, maybe you could readdress your calculation in light of the recent findings from the Rosetta mission.
10 July 2018: Lies about Tom Bridgeman's calculation which is mass versus charge which "recent findings" do not change.

Electric Comets III: Mass vs. Charge is an answer to "How much charge would that take to make a dense object appear to be a given lower mass object?"
The result is a constraint on the product of the charges of the Rosetta spacecraft and the nucleus of 67P.

ETA
A similar calculation is done by Harvey in comments in the GIADA investigates comet’s “fluffy” dust grains article with measured values plugged in for the spacecraft. "Which gives a voltage on 67P from Q/C of around 35 GIGAVOLTS."
Bridgeman has the comment in his article
If so, it means a singly charged particle starting at the Sun accumulates 35 GeV of energy by the time it reaches the comet. These energies make the particles extremely relativistic, speeds very close to the speed of light. This means EVERY single electron, EVERY single ion, is subjected to this potential difference, and they will be driven in opposite directions, one sunward, the other towards the comet.

At 35 GeV, this is NASTY hard radiation, well above the pair-production threshold (see Transforming Energy into mass: Particle Creation) for electrons and protons. If that were the case, we should see large amounts of antimatter where the electrons and ions strike.



Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic.
 
Last edited:
Irrelevant, repeated and lying "quasi neutrality" question to derail from delusions

Is quasi neutrality violated via the motion of the nucleus thru the solar wind?
10 July 2018: Irrelevant, repeated and lying "quasi neutrality" question to derail from his many comet delusions

He has been told many times over the last 9 years what a plasma is
This results in the important concept of "quasineutrality", which says the density of negative charges is approximately equal to the density of positive charges over large volumes of the plasma ...but on the scale of the Debye length there can be charge imbalance.
The Debye length of the solar wind is 10 meters. This makes it insane to talk about double layers tens of kilometers in scale.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic.
 
Last edited:
Idiot Thornhill & his mate: "The comet is discharging! And the density is measured to be wrong because of..........................electric woo".

Anyone with an IQ > 100: "If it's discharging, then the charge on the comet is lessening. N'est-ce pas? In which case, the charge on the spacecraft needs to change as well, eh? It needs to increase. Yes dummies? What does the data show?"

Jeepers, this is like spearing fish in a barrel. Really, really dumb. Why is this thread still open? We have one scientifically illiterate loon claiming crap for which there is no evidence, and this site just lets him keep on doing it. Eh?
Might I suggest a look at the rules of the ATM thread on Cosmoquest? Or is this just a spamfest for loons?
 
Last edited:
Idiot Thornhill & his mate: "The comet is discharging! And the density is measured to be wrong because of..........................electric woo".

Anyone with an IQ > 100: "If it's discharging, then the charge on the comet is lessening. N'est-ce pas? In which case, the charge on the spacecraft needs to change as well, eh? It needs to increase. Yes dummies? What does the data show?"

Jeepers, this is like spearing fish in a barrel. Really, really dumb. Why is this thread still open? We have one scientifically illiterate loon claiming crap for which there is no evidence, and this site just lets him keep on doing it. Eh?
Might I suggest a look at the rules of the ATM thread on Cosmoquest? Or is this just a spamfest for loons?


So you agree, there is charge separation and the violation of quasi-neutrality?
 
Idiot Thornhill & his mate: "The comet is discharging! And the density is measured to be wrong because of..........................electric woo".

Anyone with an IQ > 100: "If it's discharging, then the charge on the comet is lessening. N'est-ce pas? In which case, the charge on the spacecraft needs to change as well, eh? It needs to increase. Yes dummies? What does the data show?"

:confused::confused:

So simple and you completely balls it up!

If the comet was stationary you might be right but it’s not and you, Tom and Harvey are FULL of incorrect assumptions, such as...

Charge separation CANT happen.

Simple is it! :boggled:
 
An apparently fatal inconsistency between the ELECTRIC COMET model and hard, observational evidence?

Yes, it seems so ...

So that’s a yes? You do agree there is charge separation taking place at a comet?
 
Frankly, my dear, who gives a damn? What if there was? What is it doing? Why do you think Tusenfem is asking for data? That is, data that shows the impossible electric discharges from (to?) the nucleus. An explanation, using scientific data of why the density is measured as being half that of water. Data to show where rock has been detected. Data that shows why asteroids with comet-like orbits don't behave like comets. Et boring cetera.

Oh dear, touch a nerve?

Yes or no, is there charge seperation at comet 67P?

simple question, no maths involved, yes or no answer.

Or maybe another way of asking the same question

Do you, jonesdave116, reject charge separation at comets?

Though you could also say, I don’t know.
 
Last edited:
that is just dropping comments
please start real data analysis, otherwise there is no point for discussion
unless you can put in actual proof/data that shows you ideas have even a hint of realism, it is just dropping comments
what is intense? how intens? would that be feasible? what is observed? where are your data?

So do you agree there is charge separation happening around comets?

Can’t move forward with this discussion to you answer this question.

No charge separation = NO electric comet

Charge separation = THE ELECTRIC COMET!

So, I can see why everyone is avoiding the question.

So funny to watch. :)

Kind of reminds me of a story about Galileo Galilei

"And yet it moves they seperate " Galileo Galilei
 
Last edited:
fi8Ddi
 
may god this becomes mindnumbing stupid

That you can or will not answer the simple question of charge seperation and the violation of quasi-neutrality at comets?

Because if you agree, as per the latest papers, we can talk

Triggering of Buneman instability and existence of multiple double layers in laboratory plasma Prince Alex∗, Saravanan Arumugham, Suraj Kumar Sinha

And

Nonlinear evolution of Buneman instability and its implication for electron acceleration in high Mach number collisionless perpendicular shocks Amano Takanobu

And their role in the cometary dusty plasma environment.

Agreed?

Is there charge seperation so we can discuss further the ELECTRIC COMET?

No matter how mind numbingly stupid or childish it seems from a dirtysnowball, or the outdated model from the 1950’s by F.Whipple.

It’s obvious that all your followers need to here from YOU the super duper space plasma physicist and not ME the dumb arse cult following parrot.

Kinetic effects stemming from charge separation inc electron beams, worth discussing?
 
Last edited:
Charge separation = THE ELECTRIC COMET!

No, it doesn't. Read the pdf by Thornhill & Talbott. Read the predictions by the latter on this forum.
Electric comet = rock. Wrong.
Electric comet = EDM (lol). Wrong.
Electric comet = wandering arc discharges (wtf???). Wrong.
Electric comet = OH, not H2O. Wrong.
Etc.

Ergo, there is nothing left to discuss, as it has already been debunked to hell and back by scientific observation. Or lack thereof.
 
:confused::confused:

So simple and you completely balls it up!

If the comet was stationary you might be right but it’s not and you, Tom and Harvey are FULL of incorrect assumptions, such as...

Charge separation CANT happen.

Simple is it! :boggled:

Yes, it's quite simple. Where is your ~ 100 gigavolt charge on the comet? Doesn't bloody matter whether it's moving or not. It needs to offset gravity. Where in the equation are you inputting your nonsensical rubbish, and what effect does it have?
 
So that’s a yes? You do agree there is charge separation taking place at a comet?
How is that relevant to my questions about what the observed density of comets is? The density of solid rock comprised of iron, carbonates, olivine, etc?

If you have no intention of answering my questions, please be honest enough to say so directly.
 
No, it doesn't. Read the pdf by Thornhill & Talbott. Read the predictions by the latter on this forum.
Electric comet = rock. Wrong.
Electric comet = EDM (lol). Wrong.
Electric comet = wandering arc discharges (wtf???). Wrong.
Electric comet = OH, not H2O. Wrong.
Etc.

Ergo, there is nothing left to discuss, as it has already been debunked to hell and back by scientific observation. Or lack thereof.
You could also reference what Sol88 agreed is the ELECTRIC COMET model, in a series of posts I started some time ago.

Of course, Sol88 is free to change his mind, but redefining the ELECTRIC COMET model to be “charge separation” is just silly ... in thunderstorms there is charge separation; per Sol88’s new ELECTRIC COMET model, thunderstorms are electric comets! :p
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom