Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jean tate, charge separation and the resultant electric fields (including double layers) and electric currents ARE the electric comet! :thumbsup:

Since the start of this thread charge separation around comets has been DENIED, now...

Is the comet nucleus causing charge separation of the solar wind plasma?

Err, no. Zero prizes for being thick, eh? What we need, dear, is rock. And there is none, eh, woo boy?
What we need is EDM (lol) on the nucleus. Now, let's be honest, only an idiot would believe that, eh?
Anything else to add to this woo, Solly child? Lol.
 
So I choose to leave the nucleus is rock debate until such time we all are on the same page wrt charge separation around a comet, is this ok?


Of course you do, because the bulk densities of comets, measured eight ways from Sunday, are far below that of rock. Of course you'd rather have everyone discuss your current derail/distraction/red herring. You'd rather discuss anything but the many fatal flaws in the electric comet "theory".
 
So I choose to leave the nucleus is rock debate until such time we all are on the same page wrt charge separation around a comet, is this ok?
We are on the same page. It is only you who is persisting with abysmal ignorance, ignorant fantasies and lies which is never Ok.

Plasmas have separated charges.
Plasmas do not ""violate" quasi-neutrality.
Deluded fantasies about basic plasma properties do not support the insanity of the electric comet.

The neutral comet nucleus might cause some more or some less charge separation of the solar wind plasma. My guess is that increased turbulence = more mixing = less charge separation.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic.
 
Last edited:
Not so hard now was it.

So we are all on the same page wrt charge separation!
 
Not so hard now was it.

So we are all on the same page wrt charge separation!

Have you actually read anything and understood anything that was discussed in the last 10 pages?

And just the fact that charge separation may occur, does not mean that the EC would be "the correct theory" nor that any electric fields that might occur can do the magical stuff that that the EC idea posits.
 
Of course you do, because the bulk densities of comets, measured eight ways from Sunday, are far below that of rock. Of course you'd rather have everyone discuss your current derail/distraction/red herring. You'd rather discuss anything but the many fatal flaws in the electric comet "theory".

The nucleus is charged & polarised.
Rosetta is also charged.

Parallels between electrostatic and gravitational fields

Coulomb's law, which describes the interaction of electric charges: some math stuff that won’t past but knock yourself out if that’s your thing...

Is similar to Newton's law of universal gravitation: more maths stuff...


This suggests similarities between the electric field E and the gravitational field g, or their associated potentials. Mass is sometimes called "gravitational charge" because of that similarity.

Electrostatic and gravitational forces both are central, conservative and obey an inverse-square law.

And as far as i’ve read only one ‘law’ was taken into account wrt the RSI experiment.

And therefore your precious last strong hold of bulk density...

It looks like rock, hard like bedrock, described as bedrock ( a WELL consolidated(and 75% Porous????) Refractory(Olivine, CAI, Carbonates, Clays...and other rocky like stuff) with an extremely high percentage of “organics”(chains of H,O & C) thrown into the mix for good measure (and completeness)

Is looking shaky, especially in light of our NEW friend 1I/2017 U1!

It has a dark red color, similar to objects in the outer Solar System. ʻOumuamua showed no signs of a comet tail despite its close approach to the Sun, but has since undergone non-gravitational acceleration consistent with comet outgassing(outgassing????). It has significant elongation and rotation rate, so it is thought to be metal-rich with a relatively high density.

non-gravitational acceleration????

This suggests similarities between the electric field E and the gravitational field g, or their associated potentials. Mass is sometimes called "gravitational charge" because of that similarity.

What’s the charge on 1I/2017 U1 or 67P?

Then we can bang on again about comets being rocks!
 
So, we have The Man, Reality Check and Jean Tate all now agreeing on how pervasive charge separation is and when you talk magnitudes it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET is but a infinitesimally small part of the whole.
 
Have you actually read anything and understood anything that was discussed in the last 10 pages?

And just the fact that charge separation may occur, does not mean that the EC would be "the correct theory" nor that any electric fields that might occur can do the magical stuff that that the EC idea posits.


and yet they separate!

Majical stuff?? Sound like Reality Check! :)
 
and yet they separate!

Majical stuff?? Sound like Reality Check! :)

Aaaaannndddd........? So what? Where is your electric woo? Where is your rock? Et cetera. A pointless diversion. The electric comet doesn't exist. There is zero evidence for it, nor even a viable mechanism for the woo it requires.
 
And as far as i’ve read only one ‘law’ was taken into account wrt the RSI experiment.

And therefore your precious last strong hold of bulk density...

No. For the hard of thinking, the spacecraft kept doing those measurements, and kept successfully orbiting the comet based on those measurements. Fail. Unless you can tell us what the charge on the comet was to negate 80% of its mass. You can't, because the maths is beyond you, so why not just shut up, yes?
 
Then we can bang on again about comets being rocks!

No, we can't. For the excessively stupid, I'll repeat; there is no rock. As (not) seen by various instruments. So, really, really dumb argument. Try again.
 
So, we have The Man, Reality Check and Jean Tate all now agreeing on how pervasive charge separation is and when you talk magnitudes it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET is but a infinitesimally small part of the whole.

So, tell us what (and how) it might be powering anything at a comet. And what is the evidence for it? How is it turning non-rock into rock? How is it creating water (among other things) that shouldn't be there according to the idiot Thornhill? How is it creating electric woo at the surface which remains invisible to instruments that would detect it? How is it causing the density of the comet to appear to be half that of water? Why is this woo not happening to asteroids on comet-like orbits?
Any chance of you ever answering those questions?
 
Well accelerating dust of the surface of a comet for starters.

Why can dust not be electrically accelerated of the surface?
 
So, we have The Man, Reality Check and Jean Tate all now agreeing on how pervasive charge separation is and when you talk magnitudes it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET is but a infinitesimally small part of the whole.

the you should start to actually "talk magnitudes", thankyouverymuch
 
Well accelerating dust of the surface of a comet for starters.

Why can dust not be electrically accelerated of the surface?

Like, again, talk magnitudes, etc.

EC magic works soooo well, when you don't put numbers on it.
 
Yep, that's what produces the arc.



Only as related to the ambipolar fields mentioned some time ago. The problem is the conductivity of a plasma in general doesn't really tend to support the build up of static charges.



Absolutely, again that is the arc discharge. The normally non-conductive air is turned into a plasma thus conducting the discharge current. Sustained until the potential difference drops below the breakdown threshold of the normally non-conductive media.




"form and sustain" may be kind of a chicken and egg which came first question but certainly an electrostatic potential can result from a double layer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)#/media/File:Double_layer_formation.png

ETA:quote

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)








Yep, again the breakdown of the normally insulating media (air) into a plasma for the arc discharge would certainly be "kinetic plasma effects"




Heck, then "the ELECTRIC COMET" must be way behind as the answers to your questions were all just basic electricity stuff.




Given again that the real dependence is on the magnitude of charge separation around a comet, not just charge separation itself, and the basic nature of your questions above, I'm not sure if you're even in the same book.
All very sensible and rational.

If you read Sol88’s posts in this thread, and earlier, you may find that what he means by certain key terms - such as “charge separation” - differs in rather important ways from what you (and physics textbooks and papers) mean (Sol88 is not unique in this regard, IMHO it’s widespread among EU fans). It’s one reason why threads like this go on for what seems like forever.
 
So, we have The Man, Reality Check and Jean Tate all now agreeing on how pervasive charge separation is and when you talk magnitudes it can become powerful enough to power...The ELECTRIC UNIVERSE of with THE ELECTRIC COMET is but a infinitesimally small part of the whole.
No Sol88, just no.

I would like to ask you, politely, to refrain from this kind of behavior; I may be mistaken but I think it violates the ISF’s membership agreement.

Turning to substance, what do you mean by “charge separation”? Please answer with detail, preferably quantitative detail.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom