Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Where are the ʻOumuamua jets, coma and tails predicted by you

Where’s the jets then, cobber?
What makes this question stupid is that it is his electric comet delusions that predict that ʻOumuamua must be an active comet with a coma, tails and jets :jaw-dropp!

ʻOumuamua has a hyperbolic orbit that took it from outside of the Solar System to 0.25534±0.00007 AU. His delusions include that that rocks travelling from the outer system to close to the Sun become comets. So:

13 July 2018 Sol88: Where are the ʻOumuamua jets, coma and tails predicted by your electric comet?

No one expects a coherent or rational answer but we may be surprised to not get more ignorance, fantasies, delusions, insults or lies as an answer.

At last something to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Hey Sol88, any reason why you are avoiding answering questions?
Why bother?

It's very simple: Comets are rocks discharging in the solar wind....


Do you have any kind of physical evidence to support your ridiculous claim? Perhaps a peer-reviewed paper? Maybe some results from a simple laboratory experiment? Why don't you get the good folks at SAFIRE to knock something together for you?

Take a 100 kg rock! I suggest a dry sandstone! Stick it inside a vacuum comparable to that measured at 2 AU! Establish an electric field of any strength deemed appropriate by your model! Inject a 400 km/s "charge separated" hydrogen plasma (with a density consistent with that measured at 2 AU) over your test rock and measure the EM emissions! Don't forget to also measure the dust and water production generated by your electric discharges! So SIMPLE! So INEXPENSIVE! And yet, no one from the "eu" ever considered doing something like this?

Ya! I know!

Why bother?


I'll wager the results of such a simple experiment will never see the light of day! Eh? Why would a religious organization like Thunderbolts want to stop their gravy train? No doubt, Wally needs a new pair of shoes!

Sol88! Isn't it about time the electric "priests" of your religion started doing some real science?

Why bother?


After all, there will be absolutely no credit for the "eu" if the mainstream figures all this out first! :yikes:

Are we having fun, yet? :D

Sol88! A serious question for you - How much money have you spent on Thunderbolts merchandise?

I know! ..... I know! Never mind!

Why bother?
 
Last edited:
Settle Grettle, I Just asked a question!

Why bother?


What in laymens terms are the kinetic plasma effects that would be expected?

Why bother?


I don't know why you're getting so prickly?

Why bother?


Indeed! Why bother with the electric comet? Why bother with the electric star? And why bother with the electric universe?

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

I'm still waiting for some scientific explanations! If this simple task is beyond your skill set, say so! We can then ignore your noise and seek out someone with more appropriate scientific credentials!

Sol88! This thread is all about the electric comet! It is up to you, as the resident "ec" expert, to present something that would motivate this mainstream scientist to start writing grant applications and research proposals to study your electric comet, electric star, and electric universe!

Throw me a frickin' bone, here!

Another serious question, Sol88 - What am I missing? I have decades of experience in science and engineering? What am I missing? What are you not telling me that I need to know? Why are you holding back? Do I have to pay an electric universe initiation fee to gain access to the sacred knowledge? PM me if this is the case!

If there is something truly Earth shattering about electric universe geology, help me out, please!

Why bother?


Sincerely! Sol88, I would like to thank you in advance for all the science you are about to bestow on us! I am so looking forward to your predictive eccentricity model!!!
 
Last edited:
Do you have any kind of physical evidence to support your ridiculous claim? Perhaps a peer-reviewed paper? Maybe some results from a simple laboratory experiment? Why don't you get the good folks at SAFIRE to knock something together for you?

Take a 100 kg rock! I suggest a dry sandstone! Stick it inside a vacuum comparable to that measured at 2 AU! Establish an electric field of any strength deemed appropriate by your model! Inject a 400 km/s "charge separated" hydrogen plasma (with a density consistent with that measured at 2 AU) over your test rock and measure the EM emissions! Don't forget to also measure the dust and water production generated by your electric discharges! So SIMPLE! So INEXPENSIVE! And yet, no one from the "eu" ever considered doing something like this?

Ya! I know!




I'll wager the results of such a simple experiment will never see the light of day! Eh? Why would a religious organization like Thunderbolts want to stop their gravy train? No doubt, Wally needs a new pair of shoes!

Sol88! Isn't it about time the electric "priests" of your religion started doing some real science?




After all, there will be absolutely no credit for the "eu" if the mainstream figures all this out first! :yikes:

Are we having fun, yet? :D

Sol88! A serious question for you - How much money have you spent on Thunderbolts merchandise?

I know! ..... I know! Never mind!

As opposed to purchasing mainstream peer reviewed papers?

It’s all for free on the net.

Maybe you’d like to brush up a little before we proceed?
 
Indeed! Why bother with the electric comet? Why bother with the electric star? And why bother with the electric universe?

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

I'm still waiting for some scientific explanations! If this simple task is beyond your skill set, say so! We can then ignore your noise and seek out someone with more appropriate scientific credentials!

Sol88! This thread is all about the electric comet! It is up to you, as the resident "ec" expert, to present something that would motivate this mainstream scientist to start writing grant applications and research proposals to study your electric comet, electric star, and electric universe!

Throw me a frickin' bone, here!

Another serious question, Sol88 - What am I missing? I have decades of experience in science and engineering? What am I missing? What are you not telling me that I need to know? Why are you holding back? Do I have to pay an electric universe initiation fee to gain access to the sacred knowledge? PM me if this is the case!

If there is something truly Earth shattering about electric universe geology, help me out, please!




Sincerely! Sol88, I would like to thank you in advance for all the science you are about to bestow on us! I am so looking forward to your predictive eccentricity model!!!


Silica, hydrated, plasma- google it’s your friend.

Happy to help.
 
I thought we'd ask the expert?

Why bother?


Sol88, from what I've read thus far, you don't give a rats ass what experts have to say! For example,

1) Does the electric comet violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... YES!
2) Does the electric star violate basic laws of physics/plasma physics? ... YES!
3) Can the "eu" defined electric comet be a real "physical" object? ... NO!


As you'll note, Tusenfem has already provided a short and accurate response to three very simple questions! Now I ask you, what's not to like about the gentleman's testimony?

By the way, for my contribution to this little soap opera ...

The electric comet violates basic laws of physics!

The electric star violates basic laws of physics!

The electric comet is physically impossible!

The electric star is physically impossible!

Any thoughts or science based rebuttal, Sol88?
 
Maybe you’d like to brush up a little before we proceed?

Why bother?

Sorry, Sol88, I do not feel like being your personal slave/servant/librarian/conscience/whatever any more.


I have wasted far too much time searching for something that does not exist on the internet! I want the real "eu/ec" science! Where is it? Where's the math? Where's the physics? I can find nothing! ANYWHERE! It's access must be restricted to those who have paid the requisite initiation fee!

Come on, Sol88! There must be something! Cough it up! Stop hiding the math and physics!

You claim eccentricity is still viable? PROVE IT!

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

Can't be done, can it? Impossible! No physics exists that would allow one to model the behaviour of your electric comet! Or it's precursor, the electric star!

PS - Jean Tate, a thousand apologies for stealing your quote and using it thus! It seemed apropos considering the circumstances!
 
Oh an Indagator
A comet is an icy small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing.
Are they? :)

Word here is, the dirtysnowball, Whipples model, is outdated according to tusenfem and co.


Your embedded quote, while overly simplistic, describes the skeletal frame of what we know about comets! And as for Whipple's model, published in 1950, there are parts that are still valid, while other parts needed to be updated as our "vision" improved! This of course is all off topic, though, as we are really here to discuss YOUR electric comet model!

As an aside, Whipple developed his model based on observations of non-gravitational perturbations in comet Encke's orbit! Leading edge stuff in the day! Furthermore, we know, from observation and in situ measurement, that comet's are made of dusts (the dirty part) and volatile ices (the snowy part - my personal preference is to use the term ice over snow)! Now, if we form the dusts and amorphous volatile ices together into an object that looks vaguely ball like, we can call it ... A COMET! Go figure!
 
As opposed to purchasing mainstream peer reviewed papers?

It’s all for free on the net.


Sol88! If you consider yourself an "amateur" scientist, find a seat at your public library, or better still, a university close to home. Talk to people! Ask questions! Be polite! There are many ways to avoid paying for peer reviewed papers.

As for your second point --- there is ABSOLUTELY NO "eu" SCIENCE ON THE NET! That's the problem! I want science! Math! Physics! I want to be able to make predictions! My first degree is in engineering! My science is tempered by my need to exploit nature! To date, I find the electric universe is devoid of science! It is best described as religion! When will the "eu" decide to start doing science! You know,

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

There are far too many problems with your electric comet to cover in a few minutes or a few posts! You've been at this for over nine years with nothing to show for it! Let's see what we can do to change that fact in the next six months! I ask you to make a genuine effort to answer my questions, as well as all others! For example, with respect to charge separation,

How do rocks do this separation? In detail, please.


To answer this, you will need to reference the "Eccentricity" Table HERE.

Where in an eccentric orbit does charge separation occur? Does it occur throughout the orbit? Or only close to the Sun? Is the objects composition important in how charge separation operates? What values of eccentricity control charge separation? Deca et al (2017) shows that sublimating volatile ices are required inputs into the cometary charge separation mechanism? Are you now claiming that comets are made of volatile ices? I don't think melted rock pellets will produce the required ionosphere. It's time for the "ec" and Sol88 to start doing some real science!
 
Last edited:
Silica, hydrated, plasma- google it’s your friend.

Happy to help.

Tis true! Google (and all other search engines) are our friend! Problem is, there is ABSOLUTELY NO "eu" SCIENCE ON THE INTERNET! I suspect there is a secret code, or "handshake" needed to access the deep, "dark" electric comet science!

Happy to help? Are you sure? PROVE IT! I have questions that only someone well versed in "ec" science will be able to answer! I'm going to call on your nine plus years of experience! Show me where the science is! Now, because the electric comet violates basic laws of physics (i.e., it cannot exist), I would expect grad level physics, or brand new physics, is required to make sense of what is going on here! There is nothing simple about your model! If it can be modeled, I fear it will be "full to bursting" with epicycles!

My minimum for a passing grade?

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

Show me the money, Sol88! Show me the money!
 
i would hope you are clever enough to look at a figure and mentally compare the sw and com electrons and ions

So how far from the nucleus did you say before the electrons and ions “get together” per J.Decca’s paper?

So if I predicted cometary plasma double layers, does that mean I can claim the credit for them when they are PROVEN? The internet never forgets.

At the moment YOU still call them Ambipolar electric fields.

Double layers, how long have I been bang’n on about them?

Now, there they are! :thumbsup:
 
Tis true! Google (and all other search engines) are our friend! Problem is, there is ABSOLUTELY NO "eu" SCIENCE ON THE INTERNET! I suspect there is a secret code, or "handshake" needed to access the deep, "dark" electric comet science!

Happy to help? Are you sure? PROVE IT! I have questions that only someone well versed in "ec" science will be able to answer! I'm going to call on your nine plus years of experience! Show me where the science is! Now, because the electric comet violates basic laws of physics (i.e., it cannot exist), I would expect grad level physics, or brand new physics, is required to make sense of what is going on here! There is nothing simple about your model! If it can be modeled, I fear it will be "full to bursting" with epicycles!

My minimum for a passing grade?

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

Show me the money, Sol88! Show me the money!

Standard plasma physics.

Problem is mainstream tend to “dumb it down” a little wrt to charge separation in space plasmas, MHD is their biggest balls up. Especially when the EC are well electric!

And I hear “real plasma” is very hard to mathematically model. So simplify and make a few assumption.

So what do you know as the basics for space plasma?

We had this huge argument going with the resident “expert” on standard plasma physics and the use of MHD.

I said it’s crap and not valid at a comet (MHD), the “expert” argued black and blue MHD is still valid.

Problem was the “expert” was WRONG!

So I can’t sit around and wait for the “experts” to tell the plebs how a dirtyiceball works.

Have a read up on Proton implantaion into Silicon Dioxide. :thumbsup:
 
Tis true! Google (and all other search engines) are our friend! Problem is, there is ABSOLUTELY NO "eu" SCIENCE ON THE INTERNET! I suspect there is a secret code, or "handshake" needed to access the deep, "dark" electric comet science!

Happy to help? Are you sure? PROVE IT! I have questions that only someone well versed in "ec" science will be able to answer! I'm going to call on your nine plus years of experience! Show me where the science is! Now, because the electric comet violates basic laws of physics (i.e., it cannot exist), I would expect grad level physics, or brand new physics, is required to make sense of what is going on here! There is nothing simple about your model! If it can be modeled, I fear it will be "full to bursting" with epicycles!

My minimum for a passing grade?

Using electrostatics, electrodynamics, and orbital mechanics, show how eccentricity is responsible for the charging and discharging of your electric comet!

Show me the money, Sol88! Show me the money!


PROVE IT????


To you? Like Uncle Wal not my job to prove it. If it does not hold any merit for you then nothing i’m Going to do or say is going to ‘Prove it’ to you.

What my goal is to basically have a “internet never forgets” where the EC model is being validated by the mainstream.

J.Decca’s paper and indeed all the new 2017/18 papers are all plasma plasma plasma, which at least is better than ice ice ice.
 
J.Decca’s paper and indeed all the new 2017/18 papers are all plasma plasma plasma, which at least is better than ice ice ice.

Lol. And where is the plasma coming from? Sublimated ices! So, I assume we can take it that you have zero scientific mechanisms, along with zero evidence, to present in favour of this mythology based woo? Which is as we have always said. So, why waste 9 years on here, and a few more at BAUT, banging on about something that has no scientific merit?
 
Have a read up on Proton implantaion into Silicon Dioxide.

No. You have a read up on it, and present the results here. Numerically. Where are you getting protons from? How many do you need? Stop making up crap, and actually do some science.
 
Like Uncle Wal

Who couldn't find his own backside with an extra pair of hands, and said nothing about proton implantation, or H2O. He said it was OH, and was being mistaken for water. Wrong, eh? Neither did he say anything about hydrated minerals. That is your invention.

......not my job to prove it.

Well, more and more it is becoming your model, and you have so far given us no viable mechanism for the required woo, nor have any evidence for it. So, why should anybody halfway scientifically literate even bother with it? You might as well say God did it, or magic fairies.

If it does not hold any merit for you then nothing i’m Going to do or say is going to ‘Prove it’ to you

Correct, because you haven't got a clue what you're taking about.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom