http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14
"As some of my friends would hasten to remind me, correlation does not mean causation. All three of the obvious constructions – that religion causes homicide, STD's, abortion, and child mortality; that people who experience homicide, STD's, abortion, etc. disproportionately turn to God; or that there is a common cause underlying both religious feeling and murderous damaging impulses – are all probably too simplistic to be true. This deserves further investigation."
If you read my sig line ("a condition which needs illusions") you won't be surprised to learn that I may be slightly biased in this question, but on the other hand: When a school in Beslan, Russia, was stormed by terrorists who held the children hostage for days, it was reported that on the first day the children despaired, on the second day they prayed to God and on the third day they prayed to Harry Potter!
James Randi has often stressed that religious people don't just want to believe, they actually need to believe! There is no reason to think that the children in Beslan were taken hostage because they believed. It's the other way round: They found themselves in a horrible situation which was out of their control and in order to cope psychologically with their fear and impotence, they created their own brand of religion on the spot.
"As some of my friends would hasten to remind me, correlation does not mean causation. All three of the obvious constructions – that religion causes homicide, STD's, abortion, and child mortality; that people who experience homicide, STD's, abortion, etc. disproportionately turn to God; or that there is a common cause underlying both religious feeling and murderous damaging impulses – are all probably too simplistic to be true. This deserves further investigation."
If you read my sig line ("a condition which needs illusions") you won't be surprised to learn that I may be slightly biased in this question, but on the other hand: When a school in Beslan, Russia, was stormed by terrorists who held the children hostage for days, it was reported that on the first day the children despaired, on the second day they prayed to God and on the third day they prayed to Harry Potter!
James Randi has often stressed that religious people don't just want to believe, they actually need to believe! There is no reason to think that the children in Beslan were taken hostage because they believed. It's the other way round: They found themselves in a horrible situation which was out of their control and in order to cope psychologically with their fear and impotence, they created their own brand of religion on the spot.