Religion's value questioned

dann

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Feb 2, 2004
Messages
24,860
http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14
"As some of my friends would hasten to remind me, correlation does not mean causation. All three of the obvious constructions – that religion causes homicide, STD's, abortion, and child mortality; that people who experience homicide, STD's, abortion, etc. disproportionately turn to God; or that there is a common cause underlying both religious feeling and murderous damaging impulses – are all probably too simplistic to be true. This deserves further investigation."

If you read my sig line ("a condition which needs illusions") you won't be surprised to learn that I may be slightly biased in this question, but on the other hand: When a school in Beslan, Russia, was stormed by terrorists who held the children hostage for days, it was reported that on the first day the children despaired, on the second day they prayed to God and on the third day they prayed to Harry Potter!

James Randi has often stressed that religious people don't just want to believe, they actually need to believe! There is no reason to think that the children in Beslan were taken hostage because they believed. It's the other way round: They found themselves in a horrible situation which was out of their control and in order to cope psychologically with their fear and impotence, they created their own brand of religion on the spot.
 
James Randi has often stressed that religious people don't just want to believe, they actually need to believe! There is no reason to think that the children in Beslan were taken hostage because they believed. It's the other way round: They found themselves in a horrible situation which was out of their control and in order to cope psychologically with their fear and impotence, they created their own brand of religion on the spot.
A swing and a miss.

Randi's statement about religious people means a need not under duress,
but ordinary daily living.
 
The problem I have with the supposed positive influence of religion is that the influence is inconsistant. That is, that the same set of beliefs and doctrine can result in such disparate behavior. The example I use in discussion is Catholicism. The same book, same doctrine, same belief and the same devotion to the Pope led Mother Terresa to go to India and devote her life to the care of the poor, deseased and orphaned, and also led Torquemada to torture and murder hundreds of thousands of his countrymen.
To conclude that the same belief led to both behaviors seems difficult. It would seem to make much more sense that belief only furnished a form for behavior that was based on character. Had Torquemada appeared at a different time and place he might well have done the same job for Hitler or Stalin that he did for the Pope.

My $0.02

Robert Klaus
 
A swing and a miss.

Randi's statement about religious people means a need not under duress,
but ordinary daily living.
My point exactly if you combine the two examples: When ordinary daily living is "a condition which needs illusions", people start inventing them. And "the demand to give up the illusion", i.e. skepticism, is futile, illusory, if we don't try to do anything about these conditions.
The problem I have with the supposed positive influence of religion is that the influence is inconsistant.
The problem with the alleged positive influence of religion is the same problem you have with other drugs ("opium of the people"). Like in the case of the children in Beslan, you manipulate with your mind in order to accept conditions that you ought to try to abolish. It is the remedy that you turn to when you cannot see any other way out - and at the same time it makes you unable to find another solution to the problem which you turn into a test of your belief. (Job!)
 
And religion even has the withdrawal symptoms in common with drugs, in particular when your condition needs illusions:

http://www.skepticreport.com/mystics/confessionswoo.htm
"So that brings me to date. Still have to keep a check on the MTM. If it raises its head again in times of stress, I will say stop, that was the old Sharon, and have a word with myself. To be honest, I haven't found the cross-over easy. I know it will get easier and that my mind is well on its way to being re-programmed." (MTM = Magican-Thinking Monster)
 
[If you read my sig line ("a condition which needs illusions") you won't be surprised to learn that I may be slightly biased in this question, but on the other hand: When a school in Beslan, Russia, was stormed by terrorists who held the children hostage for days, it was reported that on the first day the children despaired, on the second day they prayed to God and on the third day they prayed to Harry Potter!
There are no Muggles in foxholes.
 
It has been pointed out before in this forum that the sentence, "there are no atheists in foxholes", is a very good argument against foxholes, and not against atheism, since foxholes, obviously, are a condition where you need illusions.
And apparently it isn't even true:
http://www.valleyskeptic.com/atheist_foxhole.html
I don't consider it an example for imitation. I think that the Swenson cartoon much better illustrates the rational way to behave in a situation like that. But completely avoiding the situation in the first place would be preferable ...
 
Being an atheist, of course, I would like to believe the results of this study. My problem with this study is that many other factors could explain the results, aside from faith. Comparing the US to Japan or Norway, factors such as guns, or racial inequities, could also be at the heart of these disparities in wealth, social disfunction, crime and murders.

Were these factors even taken into account before the "correlations" were drawn?
 
In chapter seven of The Corrosion of Character, http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/t...bs_b_2_1/102-8077331-8316952?v=glance&s=books (which is not a book about religion), Richard Sennett describes how a group of middle-aged IBM programmers made redundant turn to religion in order to explain (away) their 'failure', their lack of success: the comforting thought that they turn to when their way of interpreting their world as successful programmers is suddenly made impossible by the new circumstances. They don't become gun nuts and neither religion nor race was the reason why they were laid off in the first place.
 
I can recommend Steve Kowit's article The Mass Suicide of the Xhosa. A Study in Collective Self-Deception. It sheds light on the mass suicide (100.000!) of the Xhosa people who were not simply victims of self-deception, but prior to that victims of genocidal colonialism.

Skeptic, Volume 11, Number 1, 2004. - www.skeptic.com
(And for Scandinavians: www.skeptica.dk/2005/kowit.htm)
 
Is it really religion that should be questioned

Whilst I am of the same ilk as most who read this web site, I don't see religion as the problem. Most religions only ever preach peace as their man theme.

I have always believed that it is the church (all denominations) that cause the problems.

If they weren't around brainwashing the poor unfortunates into believing their way is the cure for all ills and that the big wispy chap in the sky is on their side, most of the world's problems would disappear.

I would like to know what the results would be if you took the church out of all the ethnic violence that has occured down through the ages. I don't think Ireland would be where it is and I am quite sure Israel and the Palestinians wouldn't be going at it hammer and tongs. Would we still have the same problems in the Balkans and Russia?

No radical Imans, Ayatollahs, priests, padres etc.. no terrorists ??

PB

"never confuse religion with the church"
 
"never confuse religion with the church"
Unfortunately the church is an integral part of religion. It is in the nature of religion to produce churches, the same way it is in the nature of religion to produce miracles and for believers to be offended when you point out the most obvious discrepancies and inconsistencies in their reasoning. Think about it! In any other situation people would be thankful for your help: 'Oh, I see, the red light doesn't mean that I'm supposed to go out into the intersection, and you're right, that large truck actually is going to cross it in a few seconds.' Or: 'I'm not from this country, so I didn't know that you're not supposed to put mustard on strawberry-flavored ice cream!'
They would never blame you and say, 'You are entitled to your beliefs, so don't interfere with mine!'

Religion is something else entirely! You don't believe because it helps you get around in and use and enjoy the real world, but because you are not content with the workings of the world and feel unable to change them. You believe in order to comfort yourself: Behind (above, whatever) it all, everything is good! God is in his heaven (or Harry Potter is hiding somwhere in his cloak of invisibility). And you feel that you need this idea so much, you fear losing it and therefore condemn all the evil people who threaten it.
And it is so very easy to lose because it is not based on what you actually know about the world, but on what you don't want to know.

This is the reason why religion with its vague, flimsy ideas is protected from criticism (blasphemy) in a way that no other idea is. (Evolution, for instance!) And it is the reason why it makes sense to take precautions before you start criticizing it:
"I'm happy to sign this, but should you use any of it for SWIFT, please use my initials only. I don't relish the hateful mail and other retaliation I might receive from those loving, gentle people who model themselves after Christ." http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14

And this is also the reason why you need miracles as well as gurus and churches! You need something in the real world to confirm your ideas, to make them seem to be more than delusions. You need your crying Madonnas and religious figures of authority! You are a confirmation junkie.

Your idea of the church
"brainwashing the poor unfortunates into believing their way is the cure for all ills"
is false. The church doesn't usually claim that religion cures anything, it only says that believing makes you able to bear all the trials and visitations of the many ills that you are exposed to. It is the opium of the people! And the addicts need their dealers!
The faith healers who actually do claim that they cure all ills are only able to convince their congregations of their powers, because they want to believe in the first place. Their brainwashing techniques aren't very subtle.

Your distinction between (true?) religion and the church is just as sound as the hopes of some Germans from 1933 to 1945 that if only Hitler knew, he would put a stop to the atrocities committed by some of his henchmen. That was the belief that kept them going and made them accept the atrocities.
(And, no, I'm not saying that religion and fascism are the same thing!)
 
Unfortunately the church is an integral part of religion.
Uh huh, just which "religion"? By making such a universal claim, it becomes already wrong.
It is in the nature of religion to produce churches,
Really? In animist religions, just for example, churches are very much a rarity.
 
Are you talking about the edifice, Masklin? I am talking about the institution!

Even in animist religions you have witch doctors, shamans, or diviners, somebody other than you who represents the delusion that you want to believe in, i.e. the personification, the manifestation, of the powers that you want to believe in. A hierarchy of popes, bishops, high priests etc. is a question of the size, not the contents, of a religious congregation!
 
Are you talking about the edifice, Masklin? I am talking about the institution!
I was talking about your universal claim regarding implicitly "all" religion per se.
Even in animist religions you have witch doctors, shamans, or diviners,
Sometimes, not always. And these still do not add up to your claim of a "church" or an integral part of "religion".
. A hierarchy of popes, bishops, high priests etc. is a question of the size, not the contents, of a religious congregation!
The Quakers are big in numbers but low in hierarchy. Same with the Congregationalists.
 
Last edited:
I was talking about your universal claim regarding implicitly "all" religion per se.
If nobody else shares your faith, you probably don't have a church. You may have some kind of altar, however. Even Jeffrey Dahmer, who had no co-religionists, had one of those.

Sometimes, not always. And these still do not add up to your claim of a "church" or an integral part of "religion".
Yes, they do!

The Quakers are big in numbers but low in hierarchy. Same with the Congregationalists.
Compared to Catholics, Protestants are low in confessionals!
YES, Masklin, all religions are different! Is that the point you want to make?
And yet all religions are religions ...
 
PS
I was talking about your universal (!) claim regarding implicitly (!) "all" (!) religion per se. (My (!)s, dann)
This sounds like Popper's swan argument, but unlike Popper's stupid ideas of what constitutes science, a serious ornithogist doing research on swans would never make the claim "All swans are white!!!" and then go out into the world and try to "falsify" (or verify) his "hypothesis". A serious ornitholgist would describe the object of his research, and in the case of swans he would note that they are white. It's as simple as that.
If somebody came along and presented him with a black (or even a tartan) swan, he would therefore be surprised, but it would not make him tear up the results of his research since they had now been falsified.
He would study this new black (or whatever) swan, try to find out what constitutes and causes this aberration, and add the new knowledge to the one already gained in his previous research.
(BTW, any ornithologist would know that young swans aren't white!)

If I describe homo sapiens and say that they have four limbs, two arms and two legs, and walk in an upright position, I don't make any 'universal (!) claim regarding implicitly (!) "all" (!) mankind per se'. Therefore I wouldn't be surprised to meet a paraplegic or a victim of thalidomide: www.thalidomide.ca

Karl Popper wasn't very bright ...
 
BTW, welcome to the discussion, Masklin! You are rather old new blood! :)
Thanks. I haven't posted here in a while. My blood is as fresh as a daisy.
YES, Masklin, all religions are different! Is that the point you want to make?
And yet all religions are religions ...
Not quite. The point I wanted to make is that I have never really seen any case for lumping in all religions together into one special category based on moral judgment of them.
As for having no, primitive, nascent or overt highly developed organization, they're all over the place, so religions can't be lumped together just on a basis of organization; moreover, there's nothing there that they do not share with other forms of human organization -- or lack of it.

It seems to me you want to say there is a special category under which you can lump all religions, specifically as religions, and on that basis make a moral judgment or observation with ethical implications that applies to each and every religion. But I don't see that as possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom