Health/Wealth Inequality

The Don

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Nov 27, 2002
Messages
39,885
Location
Sir Fynwy
Yet another article highlighting that the poor have much lower life expectancy than those who are well off:

The life expectancy gap between rich and poor people in England has been widening for nearly two decades.

The rich stay healthy longer. The poor die younger.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-44985650

In this case the report is based on information from England, a country which has the NHS and where the benefits system has not yet been completely gutted (though by comparison to many European counties it's pretty poor).

This report makes me think twice because I spent my formative years in Middlesbrough (and suffered very poor health) until my parents moved to somewhere less than an hour away where my health was much better and where life expectancy for men is more than five years longer.
 
If the poor subsist on Big Macs and cigarettes, then it's no wonder they die young.

I live on a council estate and quite often hear my neighbours coughing their lungs up because of that disgusting addiction.
 
I’d like to see some evidence for this assertion:

The poor are dying younger because they have less money in order to live a healthy life. They have more pressures on them, they have more insecurity and they have less control over their life

Many have sufficient money to buy cigarettes and alcohol. You don’t need money to undertake simple exercises like walking. Less control of their lives? How?

I was born and brought up in a slum. I saw many people making excuses for their predicament rather than making fairly simple decisions to alleviate it. I’m still seeing it I’m afraid.
 
Never ceases to amaze me how fast a discussion on a major social issue descends into finger-wagging.
 
Never ceases to amaze me how fast a discussion on a major social issue descends into finger-wagging.

It pretty much starts out as finger wagging.

1. There is a problem.
2. It's someone's fault. Pick one:
a. government
b. individuals



It would be interesting to see if life expectancy gaps are wider in the US than in Europe. My hypothesis would be that it is wider, because in addition to lifestyle differences between rich and poor, we have a greater gap in our access to health care. (I think)
 
Whatever. The article had assertions without evidence. Are you happy with this? I’m not.

I would think that there are a number of ways in which the assertions are self-evidently true.

1. Do the poor have less money than the rich?

Um...yes, by definition!

2. Do they have more pressure, less security and less control?

I expect they do if they do not have much money to save, or to invest, and do not own their own houses, live in crime-ridden areas, and have little choice about which schools to send their children, and for those children to get good education and to go to university etc...
 
Chicken? Egg?

There may be a genetic inter-relation. Bad genes= Poor health = lower ambition.

It's tough to be ambitious when you don't feel well.

The NHS is pretty egalitarian, I wonder what else is? Study the health of military academy graduates? Or is there too much selection bias of healthy enrollees?
 
I see this as fitting in nicely with right-wing ideals. Those that can afford proper health care and lifestyle should prosper.
Those that cannot should go off to a corner somewhere and die. Quietly if possible.
 
I see this as fitting in nicely with right-wing ideals. Those that can afford proper health care and lifestyle should prosper.

Health care is not the primary differentiator in life expectancy in developed countries. Lifestyle is. This isn't a mystery. Smoking, drug abuse, diet, exercise... all these have a lot more to do with how long you are likely to live than how many blood tests you get or any other differentiator in health care provisions.

The poor tend to make worse lifestyle choices than the rich. This too isn't a mystery. There's all sorts of debate about why exactly they do that, who (if anyone) to blame for it, and most importantly, what to do about it. But lifestyle is the primary differentiator here.

Take, for example, the issue of obesity. Obesity is a major factor in all sorts of life-shortening health issues (diabetes, cardiovascular disease, etc). In the US, and probably in the UK as well, the poor are more obese than the rich. This isn't because of any difference in health care access. With exceptions so rare as to be lost in the statistical noise, doctors cannot get patients to lose weight. The rich are not less obese because of better health care. They are less obese because of better diet and exercise. Again, there's debate about why that is, but it's pretty damn clear that it isn't because of better health care for the rich.
 
Discussions could go so much better if functional literal causes and moralistic blame were not considered the same thing.

One interesting factor that I think warrants discussion is that (in general, exceptions exist, yeah I see all your "well akschuallys" and you all just ever so clever for pointing them out even though they don't change the point I'm making...) is that preventive care is cheaper than restorative care, as in it is generally cheaper to stay healthy then to get back to healthy.

But this also means that missing an early preventative treatment because you don't have X amount of money at Y time can create a snowball effect. Don't have enough to get a cavity filling because you can't pony up the 130-300 dollars today? Say hello to a thousand dollar root canal 6 months or a year from now. Can't afford a vaccination? Get ready to pay for the disease.

I've long argued that poor is less about X amount of money over Y amount of time and more about having X amount of money at the exact moment you need X amount of money. This is true of a lot of thing, but I think health is one of the more prominent ones.
 
One interesting factor that I think warrants discussion is that (in general, exceptions exist, yeah I see all your "well akschuallys" and you all just ever so clever for pointing them out even though they don't change the point I'm making...) is that preventive care is cheaper than restorative care, as in it is generally cheaper to stay healthy then to get back to healthy.

It it a "well akschually" if your statement is, in general, false?

Because it is false, in general. The exceptions are not the cases where it's more expensive, the exceptions are the cases where it's cheaper.

The reason that preventive care is more expensive is that, with few exceptions, you can't target it with precision. You have to apply it to lots of people who don't actually need it in order to find the people who do need it. Preventive care can be worthwhile because it can lead to better health outcomes. But cost isn't a valid justification for it, because it's not cheaper.

There are things like better diet and exercise which do provide cost savings in addition to improved outcomes, but the health care system is not an effective means of providing these things.

Don't have enough to get a cavity filling because you can't pony up the 130-300 dollars today?

That's... not preventive care.

Can't afford a vaccination?

I don't know anyone who has ever skipped vaccinations because of the cost.
 
I don't know anyone who has ever skipped vaccinations because of the cost.

Because your view of "cost" is too narrow. It's not just the cost of the vaccine, it's when you are poor you can't take the time off of work, you can't afford to get the car fix to drive to the clinic, etc and etc.

Yes bad decision making plays a part in this, that's basically a truism it's so meaningless.

But figuring out who to blame, as nice as it feels, doesn't fix the problem.
 
Take, for example, the issue of obesity. Obesity is a major factor in all sorts of life-shortening health issues (diabetes, cardiovascular disease, etc). In the US, and probably in the UK as well, the poor are more obese than the rich. This isn't because of any difference in health care access. With exceptions so rare as to be lost in the statistical noise, doctors cannot get patients to lose weight. The rich are not less obese because of better health care. They are less obese because of better diet and exercise. Again, there's debate about why that is, but it's pretty damn clear that it isn't because of better health care for the rich.

Ziggurat; said:
The reason that preventive care is more expensive is that, with few exceptions, you can't target it with precision. You have to apply it to lots of people who don't actually need it in order to find the people who do need it. Preventive care can be worthwhile because it can lead to better health outcomes. But cost isn't a valid justification for it, because it's not cheaper..

Did I say "genetics" LATELY?

There is a gene for EVERYTHING, including mental issues and addiction. And no doubt ambition.

And especially the diabetes/obesity/artery disease/lipidemia gene. It's called "Insulin Receptor Substrate" gene, IRS-1.

The science is called "Pharmacogenetics", which will partner with Nutrigenomics. . We have the data now, and the retail lab test cost is about $100. But we need AI level computing to sort it all out. The day is coming. Soon.

I expect Google to burst onto the scene any day. IBM has "Watson" for general medical diagnosis, but genes is more complex, and Google has bigger hardware and bigger data banks.

And we have the Mormon associated companies. Heavy into genetic genealogy, but their data banks include the full data from the retail tests. And the Mormons are quite inbred, so have greater numbers of genetic diseases- that they want to get control of.

I suspect the biggest HMO, Kaiser, to lead the way. Private industry with BILLIONS to save. And Kaiser has a cash reserve of billions, to fund a lot of digits. They will be followed quickly by the One Payer systems, like NHS, Canada,.... at about the time it becomes mainstream for other systems in America.

At which time we will need to institute population controls, but that is a whole 'nuther can of worms.
 
The poor tend to make worse lifestyle choices than the rich... They are less obese because of better diet and exercise.
...which are mostly not choices distinguishing between the poor and the rich. People can only eat what they can afford to eat, in both money and time spent on preparation, and they can only spend as much time & energy on exercise as is left over from working.
 
of course, there is some direct link. but... er... I will be judged... Maybe the poor are poor because their are poor not only money-wise?
 
Did nobody notice the OP is about the UK? Where health care (including dental) and preventative treatments (alcohol, smoking and drug addiction) are covered by the NHS? Where there is welfare safety net for all?

Massive amounts of public money goes to health care in the UK. Unlike the US people don’t go broke accessing health services or don’t have to starve after losing their jobs.

Yes, this is a complex issue, but why is that many poorer people don’t access health services to counter addictions which are shortening their lives?
 
Yes, this is a complex issue, but why is that many poorer people don’t access health services to counter addictions which are shortening their lives?

Because even if it's free doctors and shots and check ups and colonoscopies are either boring or unpleasant and tacos and bacon never stop being delicious.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom