Health/Wealth Inequality

Yes, and if you are on a minimum wage, working a 12 hour shift with public transport to and from work and live somewhere with inadequate cooking or refrigeration facilities, which you would struggle to get fixed (due to the cost, the time and the reliance on public Transport), then non-junk food is less accessible.

Water is generally at least as accessible as soda. Accessibility isn't always the issue.

There are lots of reasons why it's easier to make better choices when one has more choices due to wealth.

True. But more money for the NHS or any other health care services won't change that.
 
You have confused correlation with causation.


Are you suggesting that the unvaccinated boys make their families poor by not being vaccinated against HPV? (Yes, I know: What you mean is that poor people are stupid and ignorant and therefore poor and unvaccinated!)
That you deny the actual causation doesn't mean that I confuse correlation with causation.
 
Water is generally at least as accessible as soda. Accessibility isn't always the issue.



True. But more money for the NHS or any other health care services won't change that.

However the Sure Start programme of New Labour did improve early years education for the most disadvantaged and did help in slightly levelling the playing field.
 
Are you suggesting that the unvaccinated boys make their families poor by not being vaccinated against HPV? (Yes, I know: What you mean is that poor people are stupid and ignorant and therefore poor and unvaccinated!)

Uh... no. That isn't what I mean.

That you deny the actual causation doesn't mean that I confuse correlation with causation.

You have yet to establish what the actual causation is. And you clearly have confused correlation with causation, since you have only demonstrated the former but have claimed the latter.
 
However the Sure Start programme of New Labour did improve early years education for the most disadvantaged and did help in slightly levelling the playing field.

Are you sure of that?

I'm not familiar with "Sure Start", but at least by name it sounds like the US program "Head Start". Unfortunately, despite considerable resources going into Head Start, it has proven to be a failure, with no real long-term positive effects.
 
Are you sure of that?

I'm not familiar with "Sure Start", but at least by name it sounds like the US program "Head Start". Unfortunately, despite considerable resources going into Head Start, it has proven to be a failure, with no real long-term positive effects.

The programmes are similar. From wiki:

The initiative originated from HM Treasury,[2] with the aim of "giving children the best possible start in life" through improvement of childcare, early education, health and family support, with an emphasis on outreach and community development.

Assessment of effectiveness came to the conclusion that the effects were significant but small.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sure_Start#Evidence_concerning_effectiveness
 
If the poor subsist on Big Macs and cigarettes, then it's no wonder they die young.

I live on a council estate and quite often hear my neighbours coughing their lungs up because of that disgusting addiction.

I can't agree. How much is a packet of cigarettes these days, £5? A Big Mac is about £3 just for one meal.

For the same money, you can buy good healthy food to last a week. For example, a loaf of bread, rice, beans, onions, red/green pepper, tomatoes, mushrooms, quorn. Sauce: two spoons of powdered curry mixed in with vinegar and oil and poured into the onion mix: no need to buy expensive sauces.
 
I can't agree. How much is a packet of cigarettes these days, £5? A Big Mac is about £3 just for one meal.

For the same money, you can buy good healthy food to last a week. For example, a loaf of bread, rice, beans, onions, red/green pepper, tomatoes, mushrooms, quorn. Sauce: two spoons of powdered curry mixed in with vinegar and oil and poured into the onion mix: no need to buy expensive sauces.

My kid is working a summer job that has her on a long commute. It isn't a tough job and she has a full lunch break and decent hours. Still, she was just complaining yesterday about how hard it is to plan everything she has to get done on the weekend because she is just too tired to run errands after work. She was eating a cinnamon bagel with ham and cheese for lunch because she ran out of bread and hadn't had time to go shopping.

I was proud that she hadn't just given in and gone for fast food at lunch. But she knows it is a short term hardship and she is going back to class in a few weeks. So she is sticking to her plan of saving some money.

If she were a single mom and was working two 20 hour jobs instead of one cush 40 hour job it would be even worse. And is was her permanent state fo affair, at least as far as she could see, it would be far worse.

Depression and desperation do not increase logical decision making.
 
Vixen: Your suggestion is good, IF the person has refrigeration and a freezer, food preparation space, food cooking space and equipment, the money to buy that curry powder and the bottle of oil, as well as all the other ingredients, and the time and energy to fix food in between jobs.

At least around here, there's no way you could buy all those ingredients for £5, and if you're trying to feed a family, that would be a single meal - my kids would have polished that off and looked for more when they were teens.
 
Did nobody notice the OP is about the UK?

In this case the report is based on information from England, a country which has the NHS and where the benefits system has not yet been completely gutted (though by comparison to many European counties it's pretty poor).

...I'm pretty sure that everybody that read the OP knows that it was based on information from the UK.

Where health care (including dental) and preventative treatments (alcohol, smoking and drug addiction) are covered by the NHS? Where there is welfare safety net for all?

Hmmm, maybe somebody mentioned this?

In this case the report is based on information from England, a country which has the NHS and where the benefits system has not yet been completely gutted (though by comparison to many European counties it's pretty poor).

Add to that the austerity, which was introduced in 2007, and maybe the reality is that your perception of how the the poor in the UK have it and how they actually have it are two very different things.
 
The programmes are similar. From wiki:



Assessment of effectiveness came to the conclusion that the effects were significant but small.

The word "significant" is statistician jargon. It means they have confidence that the near uselessness will be proven over again if the study gets repeated. It does not mean "worthwhile" or "important".
 
Can you make it worse by withholding funds?

Probably. Inefficient and unproductive processes don't magically become efficient and productive when you cut off their funding.

On the other hand, if you make your processes more efficient and productive, you'll probably end up reducing costs without having to withhold funding. And with reduced costs, you can reduce funding, or transfer funding to other goals that are now achievable because you have more money. You can potentially even get funding increases, having now demonstrated your ability to design and implement processes that are efficient and productive.

One thing you can do, if you want to withhold funding, is to identify discrete processes, figure out which ones aren't doing anything, and withhold the funding of those specific useless processes. Any time you can find waste and stop funding it, you're making an improvement. The people getting paid to work in wasteful processes may see it differently, but they're part of the problem. The good ones will hopefully appreciate the opportunity to put their skills to some legitimate use.
 
Sure, but 1) it's not simply about money, and 2) you can't fix it with more health care spending.


So it's only about money in a complicated way? How exactly?
Of, course you can fix it with more health care spending. That you don't like the solution doesn't mean that it doesn't solve the problem.
 
Why would withholding funding from hospitals affect people's dietary choices?


Because people eat at hospitals. Sometimes they are also advised about dietary choices at hospitals, and apart from hospitals, food costs money, too.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom