And considering it is in the trump admin- I immediately considering its an attack of the unicorns- or maybe its an attack of the rainbow ponies-

both of which president chump would consider true...(and far more likely)

(says a lot about the way the 'rest of the world' considers your 'chimp in chief' these days)

I really am of the opinion that this was an early chump in charge attack on Obama, nothing more

It was in the early days of the trumpff administrations after all, when we all expected 'some' sanity in the white house

Now of course we all know better- there is no sanity in the white house, just a delusional old man who appeals to the racist/sexist/ anyist elements of the USA
 
Last edited:
In the last week alone I have suffered ALL of the symptoms...


I'm sorry, but I left out the whole list of symptoms mentioned in the Australian link:

Since the phenomenon was first documented in Cuba in 2016, US diplomats have reported symptoms including headaches, nausea, vertigo and temporary hearing loss, with tests of some suggesting physical changes to the brain's white-matter tracts, which allow parts of the brain to communicate.
US embassy 'sonic attack' cases 'the placebo effect in reverse', mass hysteria expert says (ABC News, July 2, 2018)


I hope that you didn't suffer all of them, especially not the "physical changes to the brain's white-matter tracts," which, by the way, are very hard to diagnose without an autopsy! :)

I already quoted the list of most common symptoms (Wikipedia) in a much earlier post, but I think it's probably time to do so again in case you spot somebody down under looking suspiciously Cuban!
 
Last edited:
... just a delusional old man who appeals to the racist/sexist/ anyist elements of the USA


You should not dismiss the possibility that he himself may have been the unfortunate victim of a Cuban attack that caused "physical changes to the brain's white-matter tracts, which allow parts of the brain to communicate." :)
 
And the warning from the State Department has already been crowned with success. There’s a new victim of the 'attacks' on U.S. citizens in Guangzhou:

A U.S. private citizen who visited China has reported symptoms like those of U.S. diplomats afflicted with a mysterious illness in Havana and Guangzhou, a U.S. State Department official said on Thursday.
U.S. private citizen cites mystery illness symptoms after China visit (Reuters/MSN.com, July 7, 2018)
 
The alleged cognitive impairments of the US diplomats

The Guardian quotes a letter in The Journal of Neurology, July 2018, Volume 265, Issue 7, pp 1706-1707, by Sergio Della Sala and Robert D. McIntosh: Cognitive impairments that everybody has
The letter in The Journal of Neurology is behind a pay wall, but the article in The Guardian isn't. However, I'm afraid to quote too much so this will have to do. I link to the whole article.
Sergio Della Sala and Robert McIntosh are neuroscientists at the University of Edinburgh, and they criticize the study by the doctors at the University of Pennsylvania published in the Journal of the American Medical Association as "seriously flawed" when it claims the idea of concussion in people who didn't receive any blows to the head:

... much of the evidence the doctors used to propose a new concussion-like syndrome came from six diplomats who each took 37 cognitive tests. The tests looked at visual and auditory attention, working memory, language, reasoning, movement and other cognitive abilities.
In their report, the US doctors reveal that all six embassy staff who had the full battery of tests had some brain impairment or another. But Della Sala and McIntosh say anybody who took the tests would have been classed as impaired.
They point out that it is standard practice with cognitive tests to measure people’s performance against others in the population. Often, a person has to score in the bottom 5% to be considered impaired. But the US doctors set the threshold at 40%, meaning that by definition, four in 10 who take the test will be “impaired”.
Della Sala and McIntosh ran a simulation that looked at the probability of passing all 37 tests when the threshold for failure was set so high. “The chances that somebody will be without an impairment is zero,” Della Sala said. “We ran the simulation 1,000 times, and never, ever is there one single individual who appears to be normal. They are all classed as impaired.”
He added: “I’m not denying that they may have discovered a new syndrome, but the point is that the evidence they have provided is nonscientific. The paper is faulty. Even if the results are preliminary, a threshold that verges on half the population is unheard of. I cannot see how any reviewer could have looked at the data and said they are fine. This is not a little thing. It is a threshold unknown in science or clinical practice.”
In their Journal of Neurology paper, the scientists conclude: “With the criteria used, the neuropsychological symptoms of the proposed new syndrome have a worrying lack of specificity: everybody is affected.”
Cuba calls on US and Canada to investigate ’sonic attack’ claims (The Guardian, May 29, 2018)
 
There still ain't nobody here but us crickets ...

... and a couple of cicadas:

But once evidence that the incidents might not be confined to Cuba emerged with the Guangzhou case, U.S. officials reviewed other health complaints, including one of the child of an American couple posted to another consulate in China, according to officials. That also turned out to be negative, although a State Department medical team is still in China visiting all U.S. diplomatic missions there to conduct screenings of employees and family members who ask for them.
As of late last week, nearly 200 have taken the offer up to date, although only a handful — less than a dozen — have been evacuated to the U.S. for further review by neurological experts at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia.
What's that sound? Singapore scare highlights US concern (Life Magazine US, July 1, 2018)


Kenneth Merten, the acting principal deputy assistant secretary for Western Hemisphere Affairs, told lawmakers that U.S. investigators continue to examine the source of health problems for 26 Americans.
"We don’t know who is responsible and we don’t know what is responsible for this," Merten said during a House Foreign Affairs Committee hearing.
He added that the investigation is "still very much evolving."(…)
Reps. Ed Royce (R-Calif.) and Eliot Engel (D-N.Y.) — the Foreign Affairs Committee chairman and ranking member, respectively — said they planned to meet with Deputy Secretary of State John Sullivan on Wednesday afternoon and would discuss the health incidents with him.
State Dept: No answers in sonic attacks in Cuba, China (The Hill, July 11, 2018)


Branstad said he is “very concerned” about reports of unexplained ailments that have afflicted American diplomats in China. Reports have suggested those health problems are similar to ailments reported with American staff at the U.S. Embassy in Havana.
U.S. State Department officials last month said the agency was evacuating some Americans from Guangzhou for further health screenings. That followed the initial evacuation of a government employee who had reported hearing strange noises in his apartment and was exhibiting symptoms of brain injury.
Branstad said he had been evaluated but noted that “in my case, it was no problem.” He said 22 government employees had been sent to the University of Pennsylvania for additional medical review.
“We’ve had one confirmed case that is comparable to Havana,” said Branstad, adding that “it’s got to do with noise that is similar to cicadas is what we’ve been hearing. They have several theories but have never determined yet exactly what’s caused it.”
Branstad urges farmers to 'take the long view' in U.S.-China trade dispute (The Gazette, July 14, 2018)
 
Last edited:
"The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has joined the investigation"

The move to add the CDC to the probe comes as frustrated congressional leaders, including House Foreign Affairs Chairman Ed Royce, R-Calif., and Democratic counterpart Eliot Engel, D-N.Y., have called on the State Department to enlist the health organization's aid and send it to Havana to help the investigation.

“Why has the CDC not yet been deployed to Cuba?” Engel said Wednesday. “It certainly seems to me we should if we want to get to the bottom of this. I don’t understand why that hasn’t happened.”
Royce said he and Engel will meet Wednesday with Deputy Secretary of State John Sullivan, who leads the task force, to discuss the issue further.
CDC joins investigation into ‘sonic attacks’ in Cuba and China (McClatchy DC Bureau, July 11, 2018)


The irony!
AAAS-Cuba partnership in health diplomacy celebrated in U.S. release of 'MEDICC Review' special edition (American Association for the Advancement of Science, July 6, 2018)
 
An article in The American Ethnologist (Wikipedia) describes how the mass-psychogenic-illness case at the Le Roy was stopped when the girls were prevented from access to the social media:

Just a few weeks after the so-called mystery illness was introduced to the public, news stories about Le Roy came to an abrupt halt. From the beginning, the two leading neurologists associated with the Le Roy cases, Dr. Laszlo Mechtler and Dr. Jennifer McVige, had provided therapy that included strong prohibitions on “texting and friending” (Eakin 2012). When the number of students affected rose from 12 to 19 after the case went national, neurologists issued a statement that media coverage exacerbated the girls’ symptoms and, through social media mimicry, might create new victims among an already impressionable population. Indeed, Dr. Mechtler overtly blamed the media for the “continued hysteria” and urged parents to “take away the social media and segregate [children] from friends who may be afflicted” (Owens 2012aa). The local media took these warnings seriously.
Buffalo NBC affiliate WGRZ, for instance, publicly announced that “if not showing the teens and their tics will help, then we’re in.. . .We’ve decided to do this because the doctors say it is best for the kids in this situation” (2012c).
Without support from local news stations, the national media were unable to sustain interest in the case.
Mass hysteria in Le Roy New York: How brain experts materialized truth and outscienced environmental enquiry (Researchgate/American Ethnologist, Nov. 2015)


However, it also points out the willingness of the media to readily believe the experts rather than the victims in this particular case was due to the low status of the girls:

The neurologists’ expertise was magnified bystate administrators and journalists whose audiences were already primed to accept it by media valorizations of brain science and popular ideas regarding the behavior of teenage girls. As the case unfolded, parents and afflicted teenagers who contested this expertise became framed as demonstrating small-town ignorance of contemporary psychiatry (Dominus 2012; WGRZ 2012a).
We argue that the diagnosis of mass psychogenic illness prevailed because it served both a professional need to revalidate psychiatry as clinical neurology and a media investment in the popularization of “brain science.” Both of these projects relied on and reinforced gender, age, and class stereotypes and protected powerful political and economic interests by diverting attention away from questions of responsibility and legal liability. In addition, the diagnosis appealed to the very human hope for a cure. But it also prevailed because the opposing discourse was weak: Toxic layering not only complicates causality but also, by its nature, generates audience fatigue, becoming banal.


They chose to treat patients afflicted with flailing limbs, stutters, and seizures with what they understood to be the best of modern Western medicine: abstention from social media, prescription sedatives and antidepressants, and individualized counseling sessions to help release the stress of everyday life in rural America.
The process of discovery that the community, local scientists, and media engaged in over the Le Roy health problems suggests that the U.S. public is hesitant to pursue explanations based on industrial toxicity. This insight begs for a larger examination of environmental inquiry in late capitalism. The ready dismissal of known local toxins at the school building and in the community points to broader public fatigue regarding the resolution of toxic harm, whether with respect to causality, remediation, treatment, or liability. Brain science, packaged in brilliant colors for media consumption, serves up a much simpler and more immediate explanation than a thesis alleging toxic causation in a multiply toxic landscape.


Unlike the case of the high-status ”trained diplomats,” whose symptoms are not as readily dismissed – in particular when the cause is hypothesized to be a hostile commie attack instead of ordinary ”industrial toxicity”.

Mass hysteria among trained diplomats is unlikely.
 
Last edited:
The spiritual awakening of U.S. diplomats in Havana and Guangzhou?

Well, it isn’t less plausible than the health-attack idea:

Some felt vibrations, and heard sounds — loud ringing or a high-pitch chirping similar to crickets or cicadas. Others heard the grinding noise. Some victims awoke with ringing in their ears and fumbled for their alarm clocks, only to discover the ringing stopped when they moved away from their beds.

The attacks seemed to come at night. Several victims reported they came in minute-long bursts.

Yet others heard nothing, felt nothing. Later, their symptoms came.
OP (quotatation from the NYT in the OP, Sep. 17, 2017)


Have you ever gone through a time where you hear vibrations in your ear? Or perhaps a buzzing sound with high pitched frequency? If you have, did you ever question yourself about why you are witnessing such experiences, or what they might mean? It is a concerning matter, and you would want to know why such things happen to you! The ringing in ears spiritual awakening is a sign off from the Divine signaling a greater change in life. However, on the other hand, it may mean that you have a serious medical condition too. So, what it is real?
A SIGN OF SPIRITUAL AWAKENING OR A SERIOUS MEDICAL CONDITION? (Blog of the Angels, June 29, 2018)
 
Last edited:
"The ringing in ears spiritual awakening is a sign off from the Divine signaling a greater change in life."
Apparently, I have been touched by the divine tinnitus for years! :D
 
Me too! And I wouldn't have the time for all the great changes in my life that the ringing is supposed to signal. Unless he's actually serious and not just lacking in linguistic proficiency when he writes about the deity signing off. In my case the deity signed off several decades ago …
 
As of Sunday 12 August 2018, all world travel advisories – except the White House – consider Cuba safe and suggest travelers merely exercise normal preparation and planning measures when visiting Cuba.
Donald Trump is the only world leader who imposes prohibitions and warnings on travel to Cuba upon his people.
No other nation supports Trump’s “sonic attack” travel warning against Cuba. No scientist or doctor believes the alleged “sonic attacks” are possible, indeed most consider the story to be science fiction, and many doubt the claimed events ever took place.
Cuba travel safety and warnings (Cuba Explorer, Aug. 12, 2018)


I would add one word to the last sentence, though: "No serious scientist or doctor believes the alleged “sonic attacks” are possible, ..."
 
Three senior State Department officials made an unannounced trip to Havana, Cuba, amid new concerns "attacks" injuring 26 U.S. government personnel and their families may be continuing.
Acting Assistant Secretary of Western Hemisphere Affairs Francisco Palmieri, Acting Deputy Under Secretary for Management William Todd, and Assistant Secretary for Diplomatic Security Michael Evanoff traveled to Havana "to visit embassy personnel in light of new health attacks against U.S. diplomats at Embassy Havana," a State Department spokesperson told CBS News.
They left Cuba Tuesday afternoon.
Top State officials visit Cuba, probe new health ”attacks” (CBS, July 24, 2018)


I haven't been able to find out if they discovered anything, but I notice that, unlike CBS News, they insist on calling the alleged attacks "health attacks" without the quotation marks.
 
As it has been over a year now, I'm getting the feeling that this surely must be the longest-enduring case of "mass hysteria" in our times. All of the most popular-known cases I've been able to find seem to have durations measuring days, or weeks at most.
 
Well, not if you consider it to be more than one case: Havana and Guangzhou (not counting Uzbekistan and Singapore).
As SkepticGinger can probably tell you, the sick-building syndrome is alive and well to this very day - but not in the same building.

However, what keeps the U.S. embassy syndrome alive is probably the way it's handled by U.S. politicians:

Response to outbreaks
Timothy F. Jones, of the Tennessee Department of Health, recommends the following action be taken in the case of an outbreak:
• Attempt to separate persons with illness associated with the outbreak.
• Promptly perform physical examination and basic laboratory testing sufficient to exclude serious acute illness.
• Monitor and provide oxygen as necessary for hyperventilation.
• Minimize unnecessary exposure to medical procedures, emergency personnel, media or other potential anxiety-stimulating situations.• Notify public health authorities of apparent outbreak.
• Openly communicate with physicians caring for other patients. • Promptly communicate results of laboratory and environmental testing to patients.
• While maintaining confidentiality, explain that other people are experiencing similar symptoms and improving without complications.
• Remind patients that rumors and reports of "suspected causes" are not equivalent to confirmed results. • Acknowledge that symptoms experienced by the patient are real.
• Explain potential contribution of anxiety to the patient's symptoms. • Reassure patient that long-term sequelae from current illness are not expected. • As appropriate, reassure patient that thorough clinical, epidemiologic and environmental investigations have identified no toxic cause for the outbreak or reason for further concern.Some responses by authorities to MPI are not appropriate. Intense media coverage seems to exacerbate outbreaks. Once it is determined that the illness is psychogenic, it should not be given credence by authorities. For example, in the Singapore factory case study, calling in a medicine man to perform an exorcism seemed to perpetuate the outbreak. Mass psycogenic illness: Response to outbreaks (Wikipedia)


Remember that so far nothing whatsoever seems to indicate that any kind of attack has taken place: No motive, no weapon, no residue of toxins. And even when the favourite hypothesis, the "sonic attack" is completely and utterly debunked, U.S. politicians are still adamant that the various symptoms must have been caused by a an attack. Why?! The only thing that keeps this thing going is the insistence of U.S. politicians that it's an actual thing. Much like all the alleged crimes committed by "Crooked Hillary", the "Deep State" etc.
 
As it has been over a year now, I'm getting the feeling that this surely must be the longest-enduring case of "mass hysteria" in our times. All of the most popular-known cases I've been able to find seem to have durations measuring days, or weeks at most.


I don't know why this case didn't immediately occur to me since I've already mentioned it in this thread as one of the most recent cases of mass hysteria/mass psychogenic illness in my own country:

Ekstra Bladet said:
Tre år efter det landsdækkende vaccine-stop bliver unge piger igen vaccineret mod livmoderhalskræft. Ligeledes er pigernes voldsomme symptomer pludselig forsvundet.
(…)
I 2015 fik HPV-centeret på OUH 330 henvendelser fra piger med bivirkninger. I 2017 fik Niels Fisker blot fem.
- Fire af dem kunne jeg afvise med det samme, den femte fik en tid, men valgte selv at aflyse. Så jeg har ikke tilset nogle i 2017 med mulige bivirkninger fra vaccinen, siger overlægen.
(...)
- De symptomer, pigerne oplevede, er symptomer, vi altid har kendt til, men som vi aldrig har kunnet give en årsag på. Der har aldrig været en sammenhæng mellem symptomerne og vaccinen.
- Blandt andet oplever mange andre piger de samme slags symptomer som de vaccinerede piger, selvom de ikke selv har fået vaccinen, siger Niels Fisker.
Hvorfor så mange i 2015 gav HPV-vaccinen skylden for deres pludselige hovedpiner, træthed og hukommelsestab, skyldes ifølge overlægen, at det er tilstande, lægerne ikke har kunnet finde en årsag på.
Pludselig forsvandt pigerne med HPV-bivirkninger: Det var en social epidemi (Ekstra Bladet, Feb. 5, 2018)


My translation:

Three years after the nation-wide vaccine stop, young girls are again vaccinated against cervical cancer. Likewise, the extreme symptoms of the girls have suddenly disappeared.
(…)
In 2015, the HPV Center at Odense University Hospital (OUH) was contacted by 330 girls who reported side effects. In 2017, there were only five.
- In four of the cases, I could immediately deny (that they were due to HPV vaccination), the fifth one got an appointment (to be examined), but she chose to cancel it. So I haven't seen anybody with possible side effects from the vaccine, the chief physician says.
(...)
- The symptoms experienced by the girls are symptoms that we have always known about but have never been able to say what causes them. The symptoms and the vaccine were never connected.
For instance, many other girls have the same kind of symptoms as the (HPV) vaccinated girls even though they never had the vaccine, says Niels Fisker.
According to the doctor, the reason why so many girls in 2015 blamed the HPV vaccine for their their sudden headaches, fatigue and memory loss is that there are conditions whose causes the doctors haven't been able to find.
Suddenly the girl with HPV side effects disappeared: It was a social epidemic


Those stupid Danish MDs! When they are confronted with conditions that they are unable to explain, they should have done what any responsible doctor in the USA would do:
Blame the bloody Cubans!
 
Mass hysteria at the U.S. embassy in Havana and the U.S. consulate in Guangzhou

In April 2017, the embassy clued in all members of its diplomatic corps and advised people to sleep in the middle of a room, away from windows.
"Everybody was in a frenzy about it," says a second U.S. diplomat who was stationed in Havana at the time with young children. "We had a big window in the front of the house. It was a horrible feeling. We just thought, ‘Oh my God, we're in harm's way,’" she says. "You start to feel paranoid."(...)
The Department of State dispatched Hoffer and University of Miami physical therapist James Buskirk to Havana in April 2017 to perform tests on several dozen of the remaining personnel. "A lot of people at the embassy wanted reassurance they weren't affected," Buskirk says. None had experienced symptoms, and they all scored normally on the tests.
(...)
People's state of mind determined whether they developed symptoms, the first diplomat asserts. "I don't know anybody who at one point thought we were under no risk and then subsequently decided that they were a victim."Sonic attack or mass paranoia? New evidence stokes debate over diplomats’ mysterious illness (Sciencemag.org, June 20, 2018)


I already quoted this in post 435, but I think it becomes much more interesting when viewed on the background of the initial reactions to the alleged sonic attacks:

Mass hysteria among trained diplomats is unlikely.


In this context, it is also interesting to see what Vox wrote in June, 2018:

And for mass hysteria, it would mean other US diplomats in China feared so much about what happened to their colleagues that they’ve effectively worried themselves sick.
It’s unclear if victims told each other what they were experiencing, and if that made others feel that they had similar symptoms.
What’s happening to US diplomats in Cuba and China? (Vox, June 8, 2018)


Yes, that is indeed what it would mean, isn't it?
 
Last edited:
From Science Alert:

"Once you say there's been an attack, you can't back up," general director of the Cuban Neuroscience Centre, Mitchell Joseph Valdés-Sosa, told The Verge earlier in the month.
"Would they be willing to recognise that they've made a mistake? They've got themselves into a corner, and they don't know how to pull out."What if there never was any attack? (Science Alert, July 3, 2018)
 
Letters in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) "raising concerns"

In February, the Journal of the American Medical Association published a study by University of Pennsylvania researchers that attempted to understand what could have caused these symptoms. It didn’t deliver a conclusive answer, and now the same journal has published four letters by 10 scientists raising concerns about the first medical study’s accuracy. It’s just the latest chapter in what has already been a bizarre saga.

In the letters published on Tuesday, scientists noted that the original study improperly interpreted some cognitive test results and failed to conduct important tests on hearing and balance.
(…)
Back in February, Frank Bures unpacked the science behind mass hysteria for Slate, arguing that humans have historically been susceptible to the phenomenon, even if we often fail to recognize it. In that article, Bartholomew noted that the conditions in Cuba were ripe for a case of mass hysteria: “This is a small, close-knit community in a foreign country that has a history of being hostile to the United States. That is a classic setup for an outbreak of mass psychogenic illness.”
What Caused Cuba’s Sonic Attacks? We still don’t know, but scientists are debating it within the pages of the JAMA. (Slate, Aug. 14, 2018)


The letters also challenged the idea that a disorder or mass psychogenic illness is somehow less real or more the fault of the individuals involved than, say, a concussion. “Although diagnostic caution is warranted, functional neurological disorders are common genuine disorders that can affect anyone,” wrote Jon Stone and Alan Carson of Edinburgh and Stoyan Popkirov of Bochum, adding, “including hardworking diplomatic staff.”
(…)
In a response published in JAMA immediately below the letters, the University of Pennsylvania team defended its work, writing that the chronic symptoms they found “are entirely different” from those seen in mass psychogenic disorders. They also said they “must continue to withhold certain sensitive information,” although they do not say why and do admit the US State Department cleared the study as a public health matter.
Scientists Are Still Fighting Over What Made US Diplomats In Cuba Ill - The Journal of the American Medical Association published letters today critical of a study it published six months ago claiming that US diplomats in Cuba had suffered brain injuries.] (Buzzfeed News, Aug. 14, 2018)


Link to the actual letters and the response in JAMA, Aug. 14, 2018. You have to scroll down quite a bit before you find them on the page:
Neurological Symptoms in US Government Personnel in Cuba
Robert Emerson Bartholomew, MA, MA, PhD
JAMA. 2018;320(6):602. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.8702

Neurological Symptoms in US Government Personnel in Cuba
Jon Stone, PhD; Stoyan Popkirov, MD; Alan J. Carson, MD
JAMA. 2018;320(6):602-603. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.8706

Neurological Symptoms in US Government Personnel in Cuba
Robert D. Shura, PsyD; Jason A. Kacmarski, PhD; Holly M. Miskey, PhD
JAMA. 2018;320(6):603. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.8698

Neurological Symptoms in US Government Personnel in Cuba
Gerard J. Gianoli, MD; James S. Soileau, MD; P. Ashley Wackym, MD
JAMA. 2018;320(6):603-604. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.8713

Neurological Symptoms in US Government Personnel in Cuba—Reply
Stephen Hampton, MD; Randel L. Swanson II, DO, PhD; Douglas H. Smith, MD
JAMA. 2018;320(6):604-605. doi:10.1001/jama.2018.8737
JAMA, August 14, 2018, Vol 320, No. 6, Pages 519-612
 
As it has been over a year now, I'm getting the feeling that this surely must be the longest-enduring case of "mass hysteria" in our times. All of the most popular-known cases I've been able to find seem to have durations measuring days, or weeks at most.


I don't have access to the full text of all the letters mentioned in the post above this one, but the letter from Jon Stone, PhD, Stoyan Popkirov, MD, and Alan J. Carson, MD, says:

Functional disorders are typically persistent and commonly coexist with, or are triggered by, minor pathophysiological or psychophysiological processes. In many functional neurological disorders, initial sensory discomfort together with anxiety and heightened attention trigger maladaptive processes that lead to persistent symptoms. For example, persistent postural perceptual dizziness usually has a vestibular trigger. Acoustic shock, described in professional telephone operators, is triggered by an unexpected loud noise and includes persistent ear pain, headache, tinnitus, dizziness, imbalance, noise sensitivity, and anxiety at similar frequencies to the Cuban cohort. Long duration suggests nothing about etiology.Jon Stone, PhD, Stoyan Popkirov, MD, and Alan J. Carson, MD (JAMA)


And in another letter Robert E. Bartholomew writes:

They also dismiss mass psychogenic illness because there was nor rapid onset and recovery. However, the second most common type of mass psychogenic illness begins slowly and persists for months or years and often features neurological symptoms.
Robert Emerson Bartholomew, MA, MA, PhD (JAMA)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom