"Until about 30 years ago scientists mostly believed that their task was to find as many examples as they could to confirm their theories. Now they realise that they have to look for examples that are apparently inconsistent with them. Karl Popper is to blame, and particularly his slogan "No number of sightings of white swans can prove the theory that all swans are white. The sighting of just one black one may disprove it." Scientists now look for black swans and if they cannot find any, they can feel reasonably confident that their theory is right, although not yet proved. It is, in the present state of knowledge, the best approximation to the truth."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/saturday_review/story/0,3605,691156,00.html
Thank .... anybody but Popper that scientists
don't do what this article claims! Cosmologists, astronomers and physicists don't follow Popper's example, they don't come up with stupid hypotheses like,
"All black holes are black!", and they don't spend the rest of their lives looking for pink ones in order to falsify their own ideas! Instead they behave like
scientists. Based on the premises of physics they reach the conclusion that black holes exist. The laws of physics decree the existence of these weird objects. Since they know that this idea doesn't constitute proof that they are actually out there, they start looking for them outside the world of theory, in the real universe. And since it goes without saying that you cannot actually
see a black hole, they look for other signs that they are there. And apparently they are.
Other scientists, still based only on the premises of physics, conclude that black holes aren't completely black. Certain particles 'evaporate' from them, escape from their gravity wells. And astronomers may come up with ideas of ways of detecting this 'evaporation'. And this new idea doesn't really falsify the old idea of black holes, despite the fact that scientists used to believe that
all black holes were completely and utterly
black, that nothing whatsoever could escape their gravity once caught up in one.
Nor did Darwin 'invent' the 'hypothesis' of evolution and then spend the rest of his life trying to discover organisms that weren't the result of evolution in order to disprove himself: falsification! One example of a living organism that weren't the result of evolution, also wouldn't prove evolution wrong. I have a hard time even imagining a thing like that, but let's say that some kind of intelligent alien designer landed on the planet a long, long time ago (or yesterday, for that matter) and released a self-replicating organism that didn't change from generation to generation, then (and I stress once again how
imaginary this idea is) it would be unique (unless the designer had released two or three, of course), but it wouldn't do anything to falsify the theory of evolution. It would just present scientists with a new
object of research, different from life as we know it, which was what Darwin studied.
Nor do you, Kopji, spend a lot of time trying to come up with examples that might prove Popper wrong, do you? You do??? No, you do the exact opposite: You try to prove
me, and not your 'hypothesis' wrong, and that is the way it should be: You think that I'm wrong, and you try to prove it!
And there is no reason to despair! There is no reason why we should fear that falsificationism will ruin science, no matter how hard it tries! Scientists usually don't really care what philosophers tell them. If they did, they wouldn't be scientists!
Popper wasn't very bright!
PS The notion that scientist used to think
"that their task was to find as many examples as they could to confirm their theories", is so naïve that I won't even go into that. As many (!) as they could, indeed!
PPS Could we get back to religion, now?