Religion's value questioned

PS
This sounds like Popper's swan argument, but unlike Popper's stupid ideas of what constitutes science,
Out of interest, Popper's falsification theory does not really apply to much of science, but what makes you think it was "stupid"?
He would study this new black (or whatever) swan, try to find out what constitutes and causes this aberration, and add the new knowledge to the one already gained in his previous research.
Are you aware of the huge controversy that surrounded cladistics when it first became established in biology, say during the 70's to mid-90's? There was a great deal of infighting inside the scientific world into how things should be classified and related.
Karl Popper wasn't very bright ...
Again, what makes you say this? Popper's falsificationism may have well be wrong, as with others' attempts, such as verficationism (which is what you seem to ascribe to), experimentalism, naive and various forms of more sophisticated realism, logical positivism, etc. etc. etc., yet all these attempts were interesting attempts at describing what science is, at defining science; and they are all worthy of study in the history of science.
So what makes you say Popper was not "bright"? His writings seem to me to be quite intelligent. Obviously, we would both agree "intelligent" does not always equal "correct"? And more, there does not seem to be any one form -- such as verificationism or falsificationism -- which describes all science at all, so we simply do not have one single "correct" answer yet.
 
Again, what makes you say this? Popper's falsificationism may have well be wrong, as with others' attempts, such as verficationism (which is what you seem to ascribe to), experimentalism, naive and various forms of more sophisticated realism, logical positivism, etc. etc.
Please explain to me how you can verify something if you can't falsify it. If you have no way to create a potential for a negative outcome, then all of verification is tautological.

Do tell.
 
Please explain to me how you can verify something if you can't falsify it. If you have no way to create a potential for a negative outcome, then all of verification is tautological.
Do tell.
Please explain what logical connection your posted question has to mine that you quoted? You seem to have misread my post. Do tell.

Allow me to repeat what I said in your quoted bit in different words, and a bit additonal:
Verificationism (which is what dann seems to advocate) as an attempt to describe all of science may well be wrong (though some branches of science still use it).
Falsificationism (which is what Popper once advocated) as an attempt to describe all of science may well be wrong (though some branches of science still use it).
Various other theories such as logical positivism, experimentalism, etc. etc. as attempts to describe all of science may well be wrong (though some branches of science still use various forms of them).

None of that adds up to a base for dann's assertion that Popper was not "bright" or whatever.
Now tell me what logical connection your question has to what I posted.
 
Not quite. The point I wanted to make is that I have never really seen any case for lumping in all religions together into one special category based on moral judgment of them.
I try to avoid moral judgment.

As for having no, primitive, nascent or overt highly developed organization, they're all over the place, so religions can't be lumped together just on a basis of organization; moreover, there's nothing there that they do not share with other forms of human organization -- or lack of it.
Who lumps religion together on the basis of organization? There is something there that they don't share with other forms of human organization: They are religions, other organizations are not.

It seems to me you want to say there is a special category under which you can lump all religions, specifically as religions, and on that basis make a moral judgment or observation with ethical implications that applies to each and every religion. But I don't see that as possible.
Then you shouldn't use the word religion all the time! Religion is the special category under which you can lump all religions, specifically as religions. That is the reason why they are called religions - and not poetry, politics or mudwrestling!
 
I try to avoid moral judgment.
Hmmm? Seems to me you're making moral judgments about "religion" in a big way in your OP and posts. Plus you made a judgment about Popper as well; not quite a moral one, you simply described him as being not "bright"; I wouild be interested to know why, as I said in my response above.
Who lumps religion together on the basis of organization? There is something there that they don't share with other forms of human organization: They are religions, other organizations are not.
You started off claiming all religion had a form of inherent hierarchy. That is a claim regarding basis of organization.
Fine, you seem to agree with me now that it is more complex than that, but could you please describe what makes them "religions"? What are all do they all have in common? BTW, why do you use the word "religion" all the time?
Religion is the special category under which you can lump all religions, specifically as religions. That is the reason why they are called religions - and not poetry, politics or mudwrestling!
Please let me know the cogent attributes that enable the classification.
 
Out of interest, Popper's falsification theory does not really apply to much of science, but what makes you think it was "stupid"?
The basic mistake is that reality, the object of science, appears twice in this equation: on the one side as the object of science, on the other side as the key with which you compare your research in order to decide if you were right (verification) or wrong (falsification). (I don't want to to into the alleged impossibility of verification etc.)
If I use the swan argument to elaborate: When the imaginary ornithologist is presented with the black swan, he wouldn't simply accept it as the falsification of his (albeit, very stupid, as mentioned above) hypothesis. He would study this new object - and maybe reach the conclusion that he was dealing with a very deformed crow!
Instead of object and key, you have two objects!

Are you aware of the huge controversy that surrounded cladistics when it first became established in biology, say during the 70's to mid-90's? There was a great deal of infighting inside the scientific world into how things should be classified and related.
Yes. New and more precise tools, in this case bio-genetics, showed the scientists in the field that some of their classifications were wrong. Different groups of plants or animals exposed to approximately the same environmental influences may adapt to these, i.e. evolve to look alike (convergence) - and sometimes look so much alike that it fools the researchers. The genetical differences or similarities, however, once established, proved them right or wrong. What is your point? That science makes mistakes? I never claimed that it didn't.

Again, what makes you say this? Popper's falsificationism may have well be wrong, as with others' attempts, such as verficationism (which is what you seem to ascribe to), experimentalism, naive and various forms of more sophisticated realism, logical positivism, etc. etc. etc., yet all these attempts were interesting attempts at describing what science is, at defining science; and they are all worthy of study in the history of science.
So what makes you say Popper was not "bright"? His writings seem to me to be quite intelligent. Obviously, we would both agree "intelligent" does not always equal "correct"?
I think that is the only correct equation: If it was false, it was not intelligent. That does not mean that you cannot see and empathize with what made somebody reach a false, i.e. unintelligent, conclusion, and you may even find it very understandable in the specific circumstances. The mistakes made by Popper, however, are not the outcome of a lack of data or a flawed scientific apparatus. He was biased.

And more, there does not seem to be any one form -- such as verificationism or falsificationism -- which describes all science at all, so we simply do not have one single "correct" answer yet.
The correct (and not the "correct") answer is: Science creates knowledge, its research results in the understanding of its object which science explains. This is what unites all science, but of course its methods vary: A telescope is of no use if you're writing a thesis on the works of Shakespeare.
But science is very different from religion or literature - and it usually isn't very hard to tell them apart!
 
Last edited:
Hmmm? Seems to me you're making moral judgments about "religion" in a big way in your OP and posts.
Where? How?

Plus you made a judgment about Popper as well; not quite a moral one, you simply described him as being not "bright"; I wouild be interested to know why, as I said in my response above.
Patience! Let me deal with one post at a time!

You started off claiming all religion had a form of inherent hierarchy.
Now you're repeating your favorite argument "all"! Why is that so important to you? If this is your only argument: "universal (!) claim regarding implicitly (!) "all" (!) religion per se (!)", then I've already exploded it!

That is a claim regarding basis of organization.
Fine, you seem to agree with me now that it is more complex than that, but could you please describe what makes them "religions"?
No, I disagree with your attempt to bring in "all" etc. as an argument. Why don't you criticize what I actually write, instead of hanging on to this strawman? This is what I said about religion. Please make up your mind why it annoys you so!

dann: Religion is something else entirely! You don't believe because it helps you get around in and use and enjoy the real world, but because you are not content with the workings of the world and feel unable to change them. You believe in order to comfort yourself: Behind (above, whatever) it all, everything is good! God is in his heaven (or Harry Potter is hiding somwhere in his cloak of invisibility). And you feel that you need this idea so much, you fear losing it and therefore condemn all the evil people who threaten it.
And it is so very easy to lose because it is not based on what you actually know about the world, but on what you don't want to know.

This is the reason why religion with its vague, flimsy ideas is protected from criticism (blasphemy) in a way that no other idea is. (Evolution, for instance!) And it is the reason why it makes sense to take precautions before you start criticizing it:
"I'm happy to sign this, but should you use any of it for SWIFT, please use my initials only. I don't relish the hateful mail and other retaliation I might receive from those loving, gentle people who model themselves after Christ." http://www.randi.org/jr/200510/102105herbs.html#14

And this is also the reason why you need miracles as well as gurus and churches! You need something in the real world to confirm your ideas, to make them seem to be more than delusions. You need your crying Madonnas and religious figures of authority! You are a confirmation junkie.

Please let me know the cogent attributes that enable the classification.
I don't see anything wrong with any of my cogent attributes so far!
 
A jaundiced eye

The thing that bugs me the most about this study was the choice of indicators of a "bad society" that the author made. His choices were:
  • homicide,
  • sexually transmitted disease,
  • teen pregnancy,
  • abortion, and
  • child mortality
Of those 5, four are things known to be problems in the United States. It's almost as though he cherry-picked the indicators he wanted to use to prove his point.

How about things like the standard of living of the impoverished, as compared with the impoverished's standard of living in other countries? Or governmental oppression? Or women's rights? Or the rights of minorities and fringe groups? How come none of those were chosen among the indicators of how "bad" or "dangerous" a society is? Because the U.S. is actually doing pretty well when measured by those standards, perhaps?
 
... It´s only a saying

I don't know why he didn't include poverty. I definitely would have if I were going to make a similar study. I am not so sure about the rights of either women or minorities and fringe groups since rights are often just nice to look at on paper. It doesn't help a pregnant HIV infected teenage mother on welfare much that Condoleezza Rice has been able to make it into office, I think. Nor does it help impoverished black people in general that they have the same rights as white Wall-Street executives. A reason why poverty should have been included as an indicator.
But when you do a study, you are not always able to pick and choose the indicators. And I suppose the five indicators mentioned are fairly unambiguous and easy to get hold of in most countries. Another reason could be that the same indicators have already been used to compare the individual states in the USA.

Are you sure about the standards of living of the impoverished in the USA as compared to other countries? Which other countries are you thinking of? Third-World countries and/or Canada, Europe and Japan? Being impoverished isn't fun anywhere - www.gegenstandpunkt.com/english/poverty.html - and in New Orleans recently the impoverished appeared to be exactly that - impoverished!
 
The thing that bugs me the most about this study was the choice of indicators of a "bad society" that the author made. His choices were:
  • homicide,
  • sexually transmitted disease,
  • teen pregnancy,
  • abortion, and
  • child mortality
Of those 5, four are things known to be problems in the United States. It's almost as though he cherry-picked the indicators he wanted to use to prove his point.

How about things like the standard of living of the impoverished, as compared with the impoverished's standard of living in other countries? Or governmental oppression? Or women's rights? Or the rights of minorities and fringe groups? How come none of those were chosen among the indicators of how "bad" or "dangerous" a society is? Because the U.S. is actually doing pretty well when measured by those standards, perhaps?

Yeah, good points.
 
Can anyone please name a scientific discipline that studies unfalsifiable things ? Otherwise this whole side discussion is pointless. I've never heard any serious opposition to falsificationism. How could there be ? Science only studies the material, and the material is falsifiable by definition.


How about things like the standard of living of the impoverished, as compared with the impoverished's standard of living in other countries? Or governmental oppression? Or women's rights? Or the rights of minorities and fringe groups? How come none of those were chosen among the indicators of how "bad" or "dangerous" a society is? Because the U.S. is actually doing pretty well when measured by those standards, perhaps?

It is ? That's news to me, and I've collected a lot of statistics on the United States. Got any concrete numbers to back this up ?
 
Last edited:
Can anyone please name a scientific discipline that studies unfalsifiable things ?
Cosmology, for instance.

Otherwise this whole side discussion is pointless. I've never heard any serious opposition to falsificationism. How could there be ?
My opposition above is very serious!
http://www.gegenstandpunkt.com/dansk/hypotese.htm
http://www.skeptica.dk/2002/poulsen.htm
http://www.skeptica.dk/2000/simonsen.htm#Kampen om menneskets oprindelse
(Only in German and Danish, unfortunately, but we are dead serious!)

Science only studies the material, and the material is falsifiable by definition.?
That would be a weeeeeiiird definition of material. I bet you won't be able to find it anywhere. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Material (You aren't thinking of the band, are you?)
In the case of the empoverished and religion, however, I do my best to live up to Popper's ideas: Let's abolish not only poverty, but also "homicide, STD's, abortion," (involuntary) "and child mortality", or at least lower them significantly. Give the empoverished decent standards of living, health care etc., control of their destinies. Make the future safe for them and their children. If that does nothing to lower the number of religious people, you've proved me wrong!

It is? That's news to me, and I've collected a lot of statistics on the United States. Got any concrete numbers to back this up ?
He probably doesn't!
 
Dann is hard to argue with, but the basic premise seems to be that people who don't agree with him are stupid.

Popper did not agree with Marx, but that does not make either one stupid.
Ignorant misuse of an anecdote about black swans does not Popper stupid either. Agreeing with dann does not make Marx smart.

I'll sort these things out sooner or later.

Popper and Marx: although at wide variance on many things, are both easy to read and very intelligent. They share a quality that everyday people can approach their ideas and understand, agree with them or not.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/saturday_review/story/0,3605,691156,00.html
 
Where did the opponents of falsificationism go ? All I'm hearing are a few crickets.
I'm still here. Why do you need more than one? What's wrong with my arguments so far? I mean, apart from the fact that you don't like them? Have you got an objection against them that you'd like to make?

Or are you - like Kopji - going to pretend that the only thing I've said so far is that Popper was stupid? And that he was stupid because he didn't agree with Marx? Would you please point out to me where I claim (or imply) that!

Kopji, maybe you believe in your "basic premise", but I'd like to see you point out the errors in my arguments against Popper. So far I haven't seen a single serious argument from any of you.
 
"Until about 30 years ago scientists mostly believed that their task was to find as many examples as they could to confirm their theories. Now they realise that they have to look for examples that are apparently inconsistent with them. Karl Popper is to blame, and particularly his slogan "No number of sightings of white swans can prove the theory that all swans are white. The sighting of just one black one may disprove it." Scientists now look for black swans and if they cannot find any, they can feel reasonably confident that their theory is right, although not yet proved. It is, in the present state of knowledge, the best approximation to the truth."
http://www.guardian.co.uk/saturday_review/story/0,3605,691156,00.html
Thank .... anybody but Popper that scientists don't do what this article claims! Cosmologists, astronomers and physicists don't follow Popper's example, they don't come up with stupid hypotheses like, "All black holes are black!", and they don't spend the rest of their lives looking for pink ones in order to falsify their own ideas! Instead they behave like scientists. Based on the premises of physics they reach the conclusion that black holes exist. The laws of physics decree the existence of these weird objects. Since they know that this idea doesn't constitute proof that they are actually out there, they start looking for them outside the world of theory, in the real universe. And since it goes without saying that you cannot actually see a black hole, they look for other signs that they are there. And apparently they are.
Other scientists, still based only on the premises of physics, conclude that black holes aren't completely black. Certain particles 'evaporate' from them, escape from their gravity wells. And astronomers may come up with ideas of ways of detecting this 'evaporation'. And this new idea doesn't really falsify the old idea of black holes, despite the fact that scientists used to believe that all black holes were completely and utterly black, that nothing whatsoever could escape their gravity once caught up in one.

Nor did Darwin 'invent' the 'hypothesis' of evolution and then spend the rest of his life trying to discover organisms that weren't the result of evolution in order to disprove himself: falsification! One example of a living organism that weren't the result of evolution, also wouldn't prove evolution wrong. I have a hard time even imagining a thing like that, but let's say that some kind of intelligent alien designer landed on the planet a long, long time ago (or yesterday, for that matter) and released a self-replicating organism that didn't change from generation to generation, then (and I stress once again how imaginary this idea is) it would be unique (unless the designer had released two or three, of course), but it wouldn't do anything to falsify the theory of evolution. It would just present scientists with a new object of research, different from life as we know it, which was what Darwin studied.

Nor do you, Kopji, spend a lot of time trying to come up with examples that might prove Popper wrong, do you? You do??? No, you do the exact opposite: You try to prove me, and not your 'hypothesis' wrong, and that is the way it should be: You think that I'm wrong, and you try to prove it!

And there is no reason to despair! There is no reason why we should fear that falsificationism will ruin science, no matter how hard it tries! Scientists usually don't really care what philosophers tell them. If they did, they wouldn't be scientists!
Popper wasn't very bright!

PS The notion that scientist used to think "that their task was to find as many examples as they could to confirm their theories", is so naïve that I won't even go into that. As many (!) as they could, indeed!

PPS Could we get back to religion, now?
 
Last edited:
Falsification seems like just a tool, probably one of many. Popper's point was not that everything needed to be falsified, but that science consists of a dialectic involving conjecture and refutation. I don't see how that process is any different than what cosmologists do.

'anti reductionist commie' is a colorful label. :)
The world is large and full of different ideas and perspectives.

And I am happy to return this thread to the regular program...
 
No other objections? Having to make your own is boring, but OK!

'How come people like Bush or Blair seem to need to believe? I mean, they're not exactly poor and they are two of the most powerful people on Earth! And they don't really have to worry about
  • homicide,
  • sexually transmitted disease,
  • teen pregnancy,
  • abortion, and
  • child mortality
Even if they screw around, they are old enough to know the rational way of protecting themselves from STDs and pregnancy, they have private teachers for their own children who can tell them about these things if they don't feel up to it themselves, they have no problems with health care or poverty (as far it concerns them personally) and it doesn't seem to bother them that other people are impoverished - unless, of course, it results in minor disasters like recently in New Orleans which is slightly embarrassing.
They do have reason to worry about homicide, however (in their case it would probably be called assassination), but they have a whole staff of people to worry on their behalf. They don't have to rely on the power of prayers as the only protection for themselves and their relatives.
So how come they got religion? It seems to contradict your ideas of people in need who therefore need to believe. The super rich and powerful people don't seem to live in 'conditions which need illusions', do they?'
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom