The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Seems the MUPUS team have shot their load early!

because it is disagreement with the latest paper!

Comets are not mostly ice but mostly rock, according to M.A'Hearn

STOP LYING. What the hell is wrong with you? Want me to email any of the Rosetta team about non-existent rock? Go away, you are bloody clueless.
 
Now of you go and work that conundrum out!

the dust to ice ratio is?

if 67P mass is 9.982^12kg and 75% porosity, how many kg of ice does 67p have?

Who cares? Your idiot high priest said there was none. He was wrong. Show us the discharges, show us the rock, and quit with the obfuscation. Your idiocy failed epically.
 
What type of terrain does Serqet, Khepry, Apis, Anhur, Wosret, Geb, Khonsu, Aker, Hathor, Maftet, Bastet, Anuket, Atum, Bes and Sobek contain?

Dust and ice. No rock. Next.
 
Now ask the super duper space plasma physicist how big the potential drop is.


Go on


These electric fields are powerfull enough to give us THE ELECTRIC COMET!

So why didn't it happen, you loon? Where is your rock, and where are your discharges? How many bloody times do we need to ask? Show us the evidence. Stop LYING. You have a serious problem.
 
Are you saying A'Hearn is wrong, jd116?

Your problem jd116 is to work out where all this "ICE" is coming from.

because if you not 100% up to speed on the latest

The ice is primordial. It is where we see it to be. As proven. On and below the surface. As shown in multiple papers which have been linked to, and you have failed to respond to, because of some mental illness that prevents you from recognising that your religion is dead. It was never alive. You got conned. Simples. Bye bye. Go have a cry.
 
2. People who are looking to use BAUT as a marketing platform for their alternative theories. Tell us your idea, that's fine. But we're not going to allow the forum to turn into a marketing vehicle for them. 30 days should be plenty of time to present your concept, deal with objections, answer anything else.

If only we had a similar rule here to prevent ISF being nothing more than a marketing tool for EU loons.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showth...cies-Regarding-Against-the-Mainstream-section
 
Your problem jd116 is to work out where all this "ICE" is coming from.

Seasonal exposure of carbon dioxide ice on the nucleus of 67P
Filacchione,G. et al
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2016/11/16/science.aag3161

Detection of exposed H2O ice on the nucleus of 67P
Barucci, M. A. et al
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.00551.pdf

BRIGHT ICE SPOTS ON THE NUCLEUS OF COMET 67PCHURYUMOVGERASIMENKO AS OBSERVED BY ROSETTA OSIRIS AND VIRTIS INSTRUMENTS
Barucci, M. A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016cosp...41E.152B

Porosity and water ice content of the sub-surface material in the Imhotep
von Allman, P.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1818371V

Infrared detection of exposed Carbon Dioxide ice on 67P CG nucleus
Filacchione,G. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1811930F

Relationship between inner coma water emissions and ice deposits in Comet 67P
Migliorini, A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..18.7911M

Exposed water ice on the nucleus of comet 67P
Filacchione,G. et al
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16190

The diurnal cycle of water ice on comet 67P
De Sanctis, M. C. et al
https://www.researchgate.net/public...f_water_ice_on_comet_67PChuryumov-Gerasimenko

Not to mention (which Thornhill didn't!) the ejection of ice grains at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11697482&postcount=3175

Now, bore off, and take your idiotic woo to thunderdolts, because you are out of your depth here.
 
Last edited:
So that's it no circuit because old mate didn't describe the whole cucuit?

That's your wee wee poor excuse?

Fail!

It is clear that you are under the impression that "circuit theory" (as advanced e.g. by Alfvén) means that you just (as an example) take Jesper Lindkvist's simulation, take the plot he made, and just draw in the "circuit". This, of course, make no sense, because in a circuit the currents can only flow along the circuit lines that you have drawn, and in a real plasma currents can flow in any direction, along the magnetic field or perpendicular to the magnetic field.
Circuit theory has its merits, that is not in question, but in order to be able to create a circuit description of a plasma physical process, you will have to know the how and what of plasma physics, in order not to mess up your circuit.
 
An irrelevant and stupid question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The porosity does not determine the mass of dust or ice. The high porosity is part of what shows that an electric comet made of actual rock is insane. The high porosity is part of what makes Sol88's obsession with "consolidated material", bedrock", "rock", etc. terms stupid.


Then what prey tell does determine the mass of the comet?

Remember now ice is a MINOR mass component.

So that leaves dust and porosity. :confused:

Good luck.
 
Fail!

It is clear that you are under the impression that "circuit theory" (as advanced e.g. by Alfvén) means that you just (as an example) take Jesper Lindkvist's simulation, take the plot he made, and just draw in the "circuit". This, of course, make no sense, because in a circuit the currents can only flow along the circuit lines that you have drawn, and in a real plasma currents can flow in any direction, along the magnetic field or perpendicular to the magnetic field.
Circuit theory has its merits, that is not in question, but in order to be able to create a circuit description of a plasma physical process, you will have to know the how and what of plasma physics, in order not to mess up your circuit.

As shown by Don Scott in his paper on Birkeland currents.

Is a current force free when perpendicular to the magnetic field?
 
Last edited:
Seasonal exposure of carbon dioxide ice on the nucleus of 67P
Filacchione,G. et al
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2016/11/16/science.aag3161

Detection of exposed H2O ice on the nucleus of 67P
Barucci, M. A. et al
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.00551.pdf

BRIGHT ICE SPOTS ON THE NUCLEUS OF COMET 67PCHURYUMOVGERASIMENKO AS OBSERVED BY ROSETTA OSIRIS AND VIRTIS INSTRUMENTS
Barucci, M. A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016cosp...41E.152B

Porosity and water ice content of the sub-surface material in the Imhotep
von Allman, P.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1818371V

Infrared detection of exposed Carbon Dioxide ice on 67P CG nucleus
Filacchione,G. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1811930F

Relationship between inner coma water emissions and ice deposits in Comet 67P
Migliorini, A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..18.7911M

Exposed water ice on the nucleus of comet 67P
Filacchione,G. et al
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16190

The diurnal cycle of water ice on comet 67P
De Sanctis, M. C. et al
https://www.researchgate.net/public...f_water_ice_on_comet_67PChuryumov-Gerasimenko

Not to mention (which Thornhill didn't!) the ejection of ice grains at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11697482&postcount=3175

Now, bore off, and take your idiotic woo to thunderdolts, because you are out of your depth here.

Irrelevant. New papers trump old assumptions.

With a dust to ice ratio of 6-100/1 and ice making up only a minor fraction mass wise...

Believe there to be slightly biased decisions when “we” already knew comets where MOSLTY ice.

Latest paper cast serious doubt on this assumption from the 50’s

But I’m happy your happy champ. :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
Fail!

It is clear that you are under the impression that "circuit theory" (as advanced e.g. by Alfvén) means that you just (as an example) take Jesper Lindkvist's simulation, take the plot he made, and just draw in the "circuit". This, of course, make no sense, because in a circuit the currents can only flow along the circuit lines that you have drawn, and in a real plasma currents can flow in any direction, along the magnetic field or perpendicular to the magnetic field.
Circuit theory has its merits, that is not in question, but in order to be able to create a circuit description of a plasma physical process, you will have to know the how and what of plasma physics, in order not to mess up your circuit.

What would you like to know?

How far down the tail do you expect these currents to flow?
 
Irrelevant. New papers trump old assumptions.

Are you blind? Those are observations, not assumptions. The ice excavated from Tempel 1 is not going to disappear. It happened. It was real. STOP LYING.

Believe there to be slightly biased decisions when “we” already knew comets where MOSLTY ice.

And another LIE.

Instruments don't lie, only you do that. And Thornhill.
 
Last edited:
So, let's have a recap;

Evidence for the electric comet = zero. Correct? No rock, no discharges, no radial electric field.
Busted flush. How about dealing with this, instead of posting crap about irrelevant things that are nothing to do with this deluded idiocy.
 
Latest paper cast serious doubt on this assumption from the 50’s

Science evolves, it is not a religion, unlike the baseless, unscientific, evidence-free crap that you believe. Cometary science has been evolving since we first visited comets in the 80's, long before your stupid Velikovskian cult was invented. And all your cult's high priests have done since its invention is lie. In doing so, they have convinced a number of scientifically illiterate clowns that they are right. And, let's face it; scientifically illiterate clowns are the only people who could possibly be convinced by such utter garbage. It is nothing more than a quasi-religion, with no science nor evidence to back it up.
 
What would you like to know?

How far down the tail do you expect these currents to flow?

That would not be the "how and what of plasma physics".
You will have to know where the currents flow and in what direction, and through what kind of regions, and how to translate those currents and regions into circuit components like: resistor, capacitor, inductance ... it is a serial circuit or are there multiple parallel circuits ... and so on and so on.
But I am sure you cannot grasp that, because you do not understand what "circuit theory" in plasma physics means.
 
At perihelion and just after, the dust-to-water mass ratio ranges from 6 to 100 (Fulle et al. 2016).

More LYING. This time by omission.
We have no observational constraint to exclude the possibility that the real dust loss rate of 67P at perihelion is strongly dominated by boulders of mass >1 kg, with a total dust mass loss rate close to 2 × 104 kg s−1, and a dust-to-water mass ratio close to 100.
Since this dust-to-water ratio is clearly conflicting with other dust-to-water estimates, e.g., the value of six measured for 67P at 3.6 au inbound (Rotundi et al. 2015), we discuss two possible alternative explanations for the OSIRIS observations of boulders.

They then go on to assess the water content of the boulders from observation, and conclude that the value of 6:1 is valid.
So, that is something else you need to quit lying about.

EVOLUTION OF THE DUST SIZE DISTRIBUTION OF COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO FROM 2.2 au TO PERIHELION
Fulle, M et al.
https://boris.unibe.ch/96910/1/Fulle_2016_ApJ_821_19.pdf
 
That would not be the "how and what of plasma physics".
You will have to know where the currents flow and in what direction, and through what kind of regions, and how to translate those currents and regions into circuit components like: resistor, capacitor, inductance ... it is a serial circuit or are there multiple parallel circuits ... and so on and so on.
But I am sure you cannot grasp that, because you do not understand what "circuit theory" in plasma physics means.

You forgot double layers!
 
You forgot double layers!

Right! if that is the only thing you can take home from my post, so be it.
This should be moved to the AAH section, as clearly you do not want to learn anything from me.
Every time you come with a post "explain it to the "lurkers"" and when I explain it to you the only thing you can do is complain and misinterprete.
You clearly are not interested in plasma physics, neither in the MHD, kinetic or circuit form, and do not want to learn what is applied when and what the results tell you.
And that is all good and fine, but you have wasted my time long enough.

Administrators, please move this thread to "Abandon All Hope".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom