The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I will not put up with your childish behaviour, Sol88! If the 'electric comet' is important to you, PROVE IT! Answer my questions! Answer Dr. A'Hearn's questions! PROVE to all that there is an 'electric comet' model! Sadly, I do expect you to continue to FAIL!

Optimistic :) Expect more childish behaviour, lies, obfuscation, misunderstanding and avoidance. Strike me down if I'm wrong.
 
Why do you think the dust is elongated?

And Charged?

Would you mind commenting on the total failure of the electric comet woo? As (dis)proven. No? Time to close the thread? Yes? No rock, no discharges, no radial electric field. Et boring cetera. Deal with it, woo boy.
 
Last edited:
Seriously? Is that the best you can do? A JOKE! ANOTHER COLOSSAL FAILURE, Sol88! Grade = F

I also note that your link is broken! :D It does not point to a peer-reviewed paper in A&A or MNRAS, it points to a 'religious' youtube propaganda video! True story!

Remember, the internet never forgets and everyone is watching your next move! I'll make a deal with you, Sol88!

ASSIGNMENT #001 of ....

Welcome to class, Sol88! If you were enrolled in an actual university course, you would have no more than four months to complete all the assignments and exams I am about to give you! You no longer have time to waste! This is your 'electric comet' thread, and the time has come to prove that you understand what your 'electric comet' is! Is the electric comet physically possible? You seem to think so!

PROVE IT!

1) Describe in detail, what YOU see in this OSIRIS NAC "telescope" image!

2) With respect to your 'electric comet' model, please provide one or two paragraph answers to each of Michael A'Hearn's five fundamental questions from A'Hearn - 2017 - Comets: Looking Ahead. As a reminder, they are ...

(a) Where did comets form? Be specific! I am looking for 'ec' location information here!
(b) How did comets form? Be specific! A plausible physical mechanism is required!
(c) What are comets made of? Be specific! Is composition homogeneous throughout an electric comet? Why does Dr. A'Hearn keep discussing volatile ices in the referenced paper?
(d) How are comets put together? Be specific! For example, discuss the porosity and bulk density of electric comets.
(e) How do comets work? Be specific! For example, how does your "cold" EDM produce fluffy dust?

I will not put up with your childish behaviour, Sol88! If the 'electric comet' is important to you, PROVE IT! Answer my questions! Answer Dr. A'Hearn's questions! PROVE to all that there is an 'electric comet' model! Sadly, I do expect you to continue to FAIL!

Regarding academics ... you've got a real problem on your hands! You see, as an educator, I can open the eyes of 80 to 300+ young minds every year! Turn them on to real, mainstream science! Problem? Mainstream science continues to grow in numbers and scope of material researched! The 'eu/es/ec' continues to whither and die! Sadly, there will always be a few that cling to their faith! The rest of the world moves forward! So, how's your recruiting quota holding up? Anyone on here want to throw in with Sol88?

THE DEAL, Sol88? Meet in the middle! Complete all of ASSIGNMENT #001 and I will "watch" your 'eu/es' porn video. What are you going to do, Sol88? Tough call! The only way you get me to "watch" your video is to answer the pointed electric comet questions listed above! What are you going to do? :D

This is funny now! Yes? YES!

I'll do my best.

you don't have to watch any videos but I was under the false impression that EMPIRICAL science was the king not theoretical. SAFIRE is empirical science.

any who,

a. nobody knows.
b. nobody knows.
c. As stated by A'Heran in the paper, mostly rock (carbonates, phyllosilicate's (hydrated minerals), refractory minerals with a minimal mass content from ice.
d. nobody knows.
e. charged rocky body on an epileptical orbits, discharging with the solar wind. coloumb"explosions" liberating CO, CO2 from the carbonates and h2o,OH from the clays, refractory minerals as fluffy elongated charged dust.

sorry I can't be more specific on a,b and d.

as for the nice picture, looks like a jet.

Jets contain amongst other things charged, elongated dust. one wonders what the ambipolar electric field has to do in all this?

SAFIRE
 
Last edited:
where does the dust come from and where does it go?

melting snowballs?

It comes from the nucleus. Have you not been paying attention? That is what comets are made of. Dust, ice and organics. Try to keep up. It is dust that shouldn't be there according to your idiotic woo.
Deal with the complete failure of your model (lol). Stop avoiding it.
 
e. charged rocky body on an epileptical orbits, discharging with the solar wind. coloumb"explosions" liberating CO, CO2 from the carbonates and h2o,OH from the clays, refractory minerals as fluffy elongated charged dust.

Hahahahaha. What a load of scientifically impossible, evidence-free crap. Try again.
 
Hahahahaha. What a load of scientifically impossible, evidence-free crap. Try again.

Where did the clays, carbonates and refractory minerals come from ‘ol mate?


You CAN NOT answer, this is fact not a lie :D

Give it your best go.

Otherwise Why not blasted of a planet. :thumbsup:
 
Where did the clays, carbonates and refractory minerals come from ‘ol mate?


You CAN NOT answer, this is fact not a lie :D

Give it your best go.

Otherwise Why not blasted of a planet. :thumbsup:

Idiocy. Squared. Blasted off a planet! Jesus H. Christ, only a moron could believe such garbage. Mechanism? Evidence? Your woo failed. 100%. Deal with it.
 
It comes from the nucleus. Have you not been paying attention? That is what comets are made of. Dust, ice and organics. Try to keep up. It is dust that shouldn't be there according to your idiotic woo.
Deal with the complete failure of your model (lol). Stop avoiding it.

Nope, mostly ROCK. :p

You invoked the ice?

The second mechanism has been already suggested to explain the outbursts observed by the Deep Impact mission on comet 9P/Tempel 1 that appear to occur near sunrise on a particular area, while extensive subsurface sources were invoked to explain the overall ambient outgassing as the observed area of exposed pure ice has a too-limited extent.
The diurnal cycle of water ice on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Ice, invoked? Maybe you could conjure up some dust?
 
Nope, mostly ROCK. :p

You invoked the ice?

The diurnal cycle of water ice on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Ice, invoked? Maybe you could conjure up some dust?

STOP LYING.


Can you not read? That paper is about the DIRECT detection of ice, you LIAR.
 
Idiocy. Squared. Blasted off a planet! Jesus H. Christ, only a moron could believe such garbage. Mechanism? Evidence? Your woo failed. 100%. Deal with it.

No I asked you howyou think the clays, carbonate and refractory minerals ended up being in a dirty snowball.

You are a complete and utter moron.


Can’t you answer a straight forward question?


Will you answer? Perfectly ok to say “I don’t know”. :D

I,e you can tell the truth.
 
You really are a LIAR, aren't you? What do you think GIADA and COSIMA were detecting for the whole mission?


Thought so.

Big mouth is all you have. Very sad. :(

Where did just the clays from your beloved Tempel 1 come from?

In your own time...
 
Invoke, is not science champ,no lie!

As well as being a proven LIAR, you are also blind, yes?
Don't make your LIES so easy to spot if you don't want to get called out for them.

Here you go, LIAR;

The spectral ratio (Fig. 2) between the spectrum of a pixel close to the shadow and the spectrum of an illuminated pixel shows the presence of a strong ice band extending from 2.7 μm to 3.6 μm....... The 3 μm water band is clearly present in all the pixels located at the border of the shadowed region.

NOW STOP LYING. It is pathetic, and childish. Grow up.
 
Thought so.

Big mouth is all you have. Very sad. :(

Where did just the clays from your beloved Tempel 1 come from?

In your own time...

You LIED!

You asked for dust detections, and I gave them to you. Go look up what GIADA and COSIMA were detecting, and quit with the pathetic LYING..
 
Big mouth is all you have. Very sad

No, woo boy, I have evidence to back up my statements. I do not need to continually LIE, as you do.

Seasonal exposure of carbon dioxide ice on the nucleus of 67P
Filacchione,G. et al
http://science.sciencemag.org/content/early/2016/11/16/science.aag3161

Detection of exposed H2O ice on the nucleus of 67P
Barucci, M. A. et al
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.00551.pdf

BRIGHT ICE SPOTS ON THE NUCLEUS OF COMET 67PCHURYUMOVGERASIMENKO AS OBSERVED BY ROSETTA OSIRIS AND VIRTIS INSTRUMENTS

Barucci, M. A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016cosp...41E.152B

Porosity and water ice content of the sub-surface material in the Imhotep
von Allman, P.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1818371V

Infrared detection of exposed Carbon Dioxide ice on 67P CG nucleus
Filacchione,G. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..1811930F

Relationship between inner coma water emissions and ice deposits in Comet 67P

Migliorini, A. et al
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016EGUGA..18.7911M

Exposed water ice on the nucleus of comet 67P

Filacchione,G. et al
https://www.nature.com/articles/nature16190

The diurnal cycle of water ice on comet 67P
De Sanctis, M. C. et al
https://www.researchgate.net/public...f_water_ice_on_comet_67PChuryumov-Gerasimenko
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom