The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
An irrelevant, insane and lying question to derail from his electric comet insanity

Explain how carbonates are formed in your mainstream model of comets.
An irrelevant, insane and lying question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The formation of carbonates in dust in the early, inner solar system has been part of the mainstream model of comets since 2006.
 
An irrelevant, insane and lying question to derail from his electric comet insanity

Any electric fields in space champ?
An irrelevant, insane and lying question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The irrelevant lie starts with the years of everyone telling Sol88 that there are electric fields in space. What make the question obviously insane is his persistent delusion that his electric comet works with arbitrary electric fields.

This is part of Lies yet again about what posters write so added to his electric comet insanity.
 
Last edited:
An irrelevant, insane and lying question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

The formation of carbonates in dust in the early, inner solar system has been part of the mainstream model of comets since 2006.

Stop wasting my coffee champ!

How did carbonates end up in a comet? Liquid water on a comet?

:D

Give it a real go. Theve been known about since 2006 and conveniently swept under the carpet because that is NOT how dirtysnowballs form!

You cant answer this simple question because it's not in standard mainstream cometary models! i.e the DIRTYSNOWBALL.
 
4.3 Concluding remarks
We have shown that the localized density enhancements reported by Eriksson et al. (2017) are common around comet 67P. Further more, they coincide with enhancement in the magnetic field and ion flux. These characteristics and their distribution in space are at least qualitatively similar to filaments emanating from the diamagnetic cavity in the hybrid simulations by Koenderset al. (2015).This study leaves some questions unanswered. Among these are the following.(i) Enhanced ion fluxes up to several hundred electronvolts as reported by Stenberg Wieser et al. (2017) coincide with the density and magnetic field pulses: the acceleration mechanism is unclear.
Plasma density structures at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Almost like there was a current flowing from/to the surface or something...
the acceleration mechanism is unclear.
fair dinkum!!! I wonder what could possible accelerate charged dust/ions/electrons?

really??? jebus H christos how hard can it be?


Sol88 tucks and rolls before being flamed by jd116 for not conforming to the view comets are MOSTLY ice.
 
Lurkers may have noticed reality checks counter arguments are becoming weaker and weaker in his defence of the dying dirtysnowball.
I don't see anybody "defending" the dirty snowball model from the 50'es. Right from the beginning of this thread it was made clear that the scientific modelling of comets has progressed since the original model. You are the only one obsessed with the dirty snowball, which is a clear strawman.

You seem to have this strange idea that if the outdated model is proven wrong, then the electric comet is somehow right, even though it is not a model, and has no predictive power, as shown by the complete lack of rock and electric charges measured in comets.
 
I don't see anybody "defending" the dirty snowball model from the 50'es. Right from the beginning of this thread it was made clear that the scientific modelling of comets has progressed since the original model. You are the only one obsessed with the dirty snowball, which is a clear strawman.

You seem to have this strange idea that if the outdated model is proven wrong, then the electric comet is somehow right, even though it is not a model, and has no predictive power, as shown by the complete lack of rock and electric charges measured in comets.


Great progress, what is the mainstream model for comets then, champ? Just a quick overview highlighting the key points.

A'Hearn understanding had progressed/evolved towards comets being MOSTLY ROCK.
(c) What are comets made of?
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative
model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high
as 6 have been cited [3,4].

Whats your take, do you agree or disagree?

We need two models to be able to compare. The electric comet may not be right, in which case MAINSTREAM need another model to compare Whipple's dirtysnowball too!

electric charges measured in comets.
 
Last edited:
I don't see anybody "defending" the dirty snowball model from the 50'es. Right from the beginning of this thread it was made clear that the scientific modelling of comets has progressed since the original model. You are the only one obsessed with the dirty snowball, which is a clear strawman.

You seem to have this strange idea that if the outdated model is proven wrong, then the electric comet is somehow right, even though it is not a model, and has no predictive power, as shown by the complete lack of rock and electric charges measured in comets.

Allways happy to ask another smart cookie what their take on what the difference between a COMET and an ASTEROID is?

Would you have a few dot points on the difference between a COMET and an ASTEROID?
 
I don't see anybody "defending" the dirty snowball model from the 50'es. Right from the beginning of this thread it was made clear that the scientific modelling of comets has progressed since the original model. You are the only one obsessed with the dirty snowball, which is a clear strawman.

You seem to have this strange idea that if the outdated model is proven wrong, then the electric comet is somehow right, even though it is not a model, and has no predictive power, as shown by the complete lack of rock and electric charges measured in comets.

I predict PLASMA DOUBLE LAYERS will be found in operation around comets!
 
Computed Electric Charges of Grains with Highly Irregular Shapes

6.

SUMMARY
We have shown that the charge of a single, very long
dust particle can be substantially higher (x12), and
charges of “pin-cushion”-like particles consisting of
many long rods can be even higher (x30), than the
charge of a spherical grain with the same volume and
electric potential. We also showed that field ion
emission is no problem and electrostatic disruption only
a marginal problem. We concluded that determining a
grain’s mass from its charge, as was done with the
Cassini data [5], tends to lead to an over-estimation of
the mass unless the grain’s shape is taken into account.

(PDF) Computed Electric Charges of Grains with Highly Irregular Shapes. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/public...harges_of_Grains_with_Highly_Irregular_Shapes [accessed Dec 03 2018].

Elongated dust...mmmmmmmm.
 
I predict PLASMA DOUBLE LAYERS will be found in operation around comets!

You don't know squat about comets, or plasma physics, so we can, and will, ignore that idiocy.
 
Would you have a few dot points on the difference between a COMET and an ASTEROID?

Composition and density, for the most part. Have a look at what Rosetta discovered at asteroids Steins and Lutetia. The vast majority of asteroids don't outgas, including those on very elliptical orbits, therefore debunking the idiot Thornhill's woo.
 
compare Whipple's dirtysnowball too!

That would be 'to'. Did you never attend school? I could well believe it. And that is a pathetic strawman. Try harder, woo boy.
 
Almost like there was a current flowing from/to the surface or something...

Nope. Impossible. Evidence? None, as usual. Stick to the day job, plasma physics appears to be beyond you.
 
Composition and density, for the most part. Have a look at what Rosetta discovered at asteroids Steins and Lutetia. The vast majority of asteroids don't outgas, including those on very elliptical orbits, therefore debunking the idiot Thornhill's woo.

But there are ones that do that have no ice :D

Next.


Are you feeling a little apprehensive that carbonates in comets are a little problematic for the dirtysnowball?

There is a very simple way out. Mainstream revise the standard falsifiable model of comets.


Seems we’ve all agreed, even steenkf, that the Whipple dirtysnowball model is dead.

Otherwise there is NO MIANSTREAM MODEL.

cant have your cake and it too. :boggled:
 
No, that is your strawman, you liar. STOP LYING.


Tuck and roll tuck and roll.

You knobs sit there behind your keyboards and vigorously defend comets are dirtysnowballs, Whipple’s 1950’s model, the MAINSTREAM model.

Then bag the crap out of me for using this very same model as a reference too be able to test COMPETING MODELS because it’s obvious it has some FATAL shortcomings.

Like quite a few papers I’ve linked have stated.
 
You knobs sit there behind your keyboards and vigorously defend comets are dirtysnowballs, Whipple’s 1950’s model, the MAINSTREAM model.

LIAR.


That is a strawman of your own making. STOP LYING. It is getting pathetic.
 

LIAR.


That is a strawman of your own making. STOP LYING. It is getting pathetic.


Can you not read?

I don't see anybody "defending" the dirty snowball model from the 50'es. Right from the beginning of this thread it was made clear that the scientific modelling of comets has progressed since the original model. You are the only one obsessed with the dirty snowball, which is a clear strawman.

You seem to have this strange idea that if the outdated model is proven wrong, then the electric comet is somehow right, even though it is not a model, and has no predictive power, as shown by the complete lack of rock and electric charges measured in comets.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom