jonesdave116
Philosopher
- Joined
- Feb 26, 2015
- Messages
- 6,222
One would also note Dr Anariba’s electrochemical water production needs a potential difference, a driving voltage for it to be even considered.
Anariba is a proven idiot.
One would also note Dr Anariba’s electrochemical water production needs a potential difference, a driving voltage for it to be even considered.
Now, jd116, jt, Fred, what say Ye to this evidence? Again.
No. Not now, not ever.
We are, in this thread, discussing the Electric Comet Theory (or model, EC for short).
It is very hard to have such a discussion, partly because of your obsession with the logical fallacy False Dichotomy, but, these days, mostly because you keep contradicting yourself, sometimes more than once in the same day!
For example, one day it’s ROCK, with a bulk density of ~3-5; next day it’s mostly space with ROCK in between. One day it’s charging and discharging in a radial electric field centered on the Sun; next day it’s kinetic plasma effects local to the comet. And so on. And on. And on ...
But whatever it is, it resembles religion more than science.
Long since past time to close this thread, or more it to a more suitable board. Admins: please do so.
And you have no mechanism to get water vapour, nor how to turn it into ice. Only an idiot would believe that. Do you believe it Sol? I expect you do.

Yeah, nah I’m sticking to comets being MOSTLY actual real ROCK ~2.5gm/cm3 of which a majority seems to be, in the case of Tempel 1 hydrated minerals, carbonates at refractory materials.
Errr, far too hot. You need ~ 600 C to bake water out of hydrated minerals. The ice and water at Tempel 1 was well below that. Idiotic argument. Try again.
Sorry perhaps you like to find the relevant temp recorded at Tempel 1 for the impact of the copper projectile into solid rock.
I’ve seen 3500K, is that hot enough for you?
Which has been proven 100% to be wrong. So who gives a damn what an unqualified wooist thinks? And, as has already been explained, the porosity is ~ 75%.
One of the observers was the Spitzer Space Telescope, a NASA mission that takes pictures in the infrared part of the spectrum. In the burst of light after the collision, Spitzer detected specific colors of infrared light that indicated that Tempel 1 contained clays and carbonates, the minerals of limestone and seashells.
Clays and carbonates both require liquid water to form.
"How do clays and carbonates form in frozen comets where there isn't liquid water?" said Carey M. Lisse, a research scientist at the Applied Physics Laboratory at Johns Hopkins University who is presenting the Spitzer data today at a meeting of the Division for Planetary Sciences in Cambridge, England. "Nobody expected this."
Spitzer also detected minerals known as crystalline silicates. Astronomers had already known that comets contain silicates, but silicates line up in neat crystal structures only when they are warmed to 1,300 degrees Fahrenheit -- temperatures reached at around the orbit of Mercury -- and then cooled.
So this is bull?
So at Tempel 1, you had the above solid rocky constituents with a invoked minor mass fraction of ice at ~25% total volume what constitutes the other 75%?
Because even someone like me with 0 maths skills can see comets are mostly...what jd116?
Totally irrelevant. Nothing to do with the density or porosity. Try to learn science. You are making a tool of yourself. Again.
I've just told you. It is ~ 75% porous. Comprende? As evidenced by the density. And the measurements from MUPUS, etc. I am not going through this crap again with someone who has the memory of a bloody firefly. Read the literature.
Perhaps you should put the shovel down, champ!
What constitutes the majority of a cometary nucleus jd116?
Yet another, rather dramatic, shifting of the basics of EC.Yeah, nah I’m sticking to comets being MOSTLY actual real ROCK ~2.5gm/cm3 of which a majority seems to be, in the case of Tempel 1 hydrated minerals, carbonates at refractory materials.
My question to you cob, if a comet is ~25% mostly dust with a minor mass component of “ice” then what exactly constitutes the other 75%?
![]()
Usual blatant lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.We are reading from the same page.
Comet 67P had a temporary (when it was far from the Sun), relatively tiny amount of charged dust on its surface.Usual irrelevant and insanely lying questions to derail from derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
My post has no charged dust.
We have been through Sol88's "charged dust" insanity before. The vast bulk of a comet is ices and neutral dust under the surface. Comets with low activity may have some charged dust on their surface. Comets should have a temporary relatively tiny amount of charged dust on their surface.
Dust, if you are talking about mass. Vacuum if you are talking about volume. What are you talking about? Do you know? Does anybody? Bloody unlikely, I'd say.
Yet another, rather dramatic, shifting of the basics of EC.
Can you present a quantitative case for consistency between your latest version of EC, and relevant quantitative observational results, on the density of comets?
I think the answer is “no”. Yet another reason to move this thread to a more appropriate home in ISF.
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.One would also have to wonder what effect the ambiploar electric field would have on this charged dust on the surface of comets?