The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Yes, it does.

Will you return the favour and answer my questions?
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is Sol88's insanity of expecting answers to his irrelevant questions. He asked a question about electric fields around asteroids when that is part of Sol88's electric comet insanity (comets are rocks like asteroids)) and for Sol88 to answer.
 
Hmm ... did I mention asteroids?

Does the version of EC you are currently promoting include a radial electric field centered on the Sun?

This is a very simple, straightforward question, directly relevant to the topic of this thread.
Yes, it does.
Yes, it does.
Thanks.

Will you return the favour and answer my questions?
I am very happy to try to answer any questions you have on the topic of this thread, the EC (and SAFIRE)! :)

However, everything I've learned about your version of the EC is from what you have posted here, so I'm not sure what help I could be.

So, back to the EC:

What, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?
 
Thanks.


I am very happy to try to answer any questions you have on the topic of this thread, the EC (and SAFIRE)! :)

However, everything I've learned about your version of the EC is from what you have posted here, so I'm not sure what help I could be.

So, back to the EC:

What, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?

The questions I asked were on YOUR model of a comet, the DIRTYSNOWBALL.

Is your understanding that they are MOSTLY ROCK or MOSTLY ICE?

i.e do you believe in the dirtysnowball?
 
Thanks.


I am very happy to try to answer any questions you have on the topic of this thread, the EC (and SAFIRE)! :)

However, everything I've learned about your version of the EC is from what you have posted here, so I'm not sure what help I could be.

So, back to the EC:

What, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?

Or show no features at all and still be considered comets, what about them ones ay?

But it does remind me of more of Sol88's personal insanity he has added to the electric comet insanity: Sol88's ʻOumuamua insanity.
ʻOumuamua is an interstellar object that Sol88 has brought up several times. It is probably an oddly shaped asteroid or maybe an ordinary asteroid with an odd surface. What it is not is a comet! ʻOumuamua was found after a fairly close encounter with the Earth and did not have a comet tail or coma.

The electric comet insanity includes that rocks like asteroids turn into comets because they travel from the outer to inner solar system through an imaginary electric field. ʻOumuamua travelled thru that imaginary electric field from outside of the solar system and ended up around an AU from the Sun. ʻOumuamua did not magically turn into a comet !

But it did show NON-GRAVITATIONAL ACCELERATION, commonly INVOKED to explain comets. :D
 
Last edited:
The questions I asked were on YOUR model of a comet, the DIRTYSNOWBALL.
News to me, Sol88. I was not aware that I had any such model. Where do you think I've been keeping it, in my Rolodex perchance?

Is your understanding that they are MOSTLY ROCK or MOSTLY ICE?

i.e do you believe in the dirtysnowball?
Irrelevant.

This thread is about "The Electric Comet Theory/SAFIRE", as it says in its title.

Back on topic (important edit added in bold): What, in the EC, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?
 
Thanks.


I am very happy to try to answer any questions you have on the topic of this thread, the EC (and SAFIRE)! :)

However, everything I've learned about your version of the EC is from what you have posted here, so I'm not sure what help I could be.

So, back to the EC:

What, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?

The electric field centered on the nucleus being strong enough for the comet to start EMITTING.

What's the composition and electric field strength at CERES? Any "outgassing"?
 
News to me, Sol88. I was not aware that I had any such model. Where do you think I've been keeping it, in my Rolodex perchance?


Irrelevant.

This thread is about "The Electric Comet Theory/SAFIRE", as it says in its title.

Back on topic (important edit added in bold): What, in the EC, other than the Sun's radial electric field, causes ROCK/mostly rock/rock objects, in elliptical orbits around the Sun, to exhibit comet features, such as a coma, and tails?

So you have faith in the dirtysnowball? I'm totally comfortable with that.

Myself on the other hand have serious doubts that it's valid?

Are you aware of the icy cliff of Tempel 1?

Very interesting from the dirtysnowball model perspective and that underneath them PURE ice was found.

PIA13862_modest.jpg

Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Cornell
Comparison of Deep Impact and Stardust photos of a smooth elevated feature on the surface of the nucleus showing recession of icy cliffs at the margins.

Where are the jets? This mechanism has been INVOKED at 67P but we see no ice like we see here. Are fractured cliffs the source of cometary dust jets? Insights from OSIRIS/Rosetta at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Christmas is nearly here and I do hope you've been good and the Easter Bunny is just round the corner.
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

The questions I asked were on YOUR model of a comet, the DIRTYSNOWBALL.
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is Sol88's insanity of expecting answers to his irrelevant questions. This is a thread about his electric comet and SAFIRE insanity. Sol88 has had over 12 years to leant abut real science. Sol88 has had real science explained to him many times. No one here is likely to fall for repeated insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.
 
Last edited:
So you have faith in the dirtysnowball? I'm totally comfortable with that.

Myself on the other hand have serious doubts that it's valid?

Are you aware of the icy cliff of Tempel 1?

Very interesting from the dirtysnowball model perspective and that underneath them PURE ice was found.

[qimg]https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpegMod/PIA13862_modest.jpg[/qimg]
Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/Cornell

Where are the jets? This mechanism has been INVOKED at 67P but we see no ice like we see here. Are fractured cliffs the source of cometary dust jets? Insights from OSIRIS/Rosetta at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Christmas is nearly here and I do hope you've been good and the Easter Bunny is just round the corner.

And WTF has that idiotic post got to do with anything? Least of all the 100% debunked EC woo?
 
The electric field centered on the nucleus being strong enough for the comet to start EMITTING.

What's the composition and electric field strength at CERES? Any "outgassing"?

What the hell is this crap? Emitting what? Jesus H. Christ, this is like discussing QM with a badger.
 
What's the composition and electric field strength at CERES? Any "outgassing"?

Only an idiot could pose such a question! What the hell has a piffling electric field got to do with outgassing? Seriously, how thick do you need to be? Deary me. Get a life. Get an education. Stop polluting this board with idiotic nonsense. Go away.
 
Usual insanity and an insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Or show no features at all and still be considered comets, what about them ones ay?
Usual insanity and an insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

A general insane lie that there are comets with no comet features.

This is Sol88's insanity about ʻOumuamua and an insane lie that ʻOumuamua was a comet. No tail or coma = not a comet.
Sol88's comet delusions start with the deluded Thunderbolts cult insanity. ...
39. Sol88's ʻOumuamua insanity (not a comet but his electric comet insanity says it should be)
 
Last edited:
Utter insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

The electric field centered on the nucleus being strong enough for the comet to start EMITTING.

What's the composition and electric field strength at CERES? Any "outgassing"?
Utter insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Solo88 is utterly ignorant about Ceres being a dwarf planet :jaw-dropp!.
 
Usual insanity and an insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Are you aware of the icy cliff of Tempel 1?
Usual insanity and an insane lie "that underneath them PURE ice was found" from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88's insane lie is that we have samples from underneath the Tempel 1 ice cliffs. We do have evidence that the ejecta from Deep Impact formed pure water ice grains during the first few hours after the impact. I suspect that was a result of the heat of the impact. But even if Tempel 1 has a composition including pure water grains, that is irrelevant to Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Utter insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Where are the jets?
Utter insanity and an insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88's insane lie is removing dates from an image or finding an image without the dates as given on the Tempel 1 Gallery image. The first image was taken 4 July 2005 and the second on 14 Feb. 2011 - over five years later!

There were jets during the second encounter (Stardust-Next) and they were traced back to an apparently eroding terraced scarp. Similarly we traced 67P jets back to fractured cliffs among other sites.
Return to Comet Tempel 1: Overview of Stardust-NExT results
Most of the jets observed during the SN flyby can be traced back to an apparently eroding terraced scarp.
 
Last edited:
Utter insanity and an insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88's insane lie is removing dates from an image or finding an image without the dates as given on the Tempel 1 Gallery image. The first image was taken 4 July 2005 and the second on 14 Feb. 2011 - over five years later!

There were jets during the second encounter (Stardust-Next) and they were traced back to an apparently eroding terraced scarp. Similarly we traced 67P jets back to fractured cliffs among other sites.
Return to Comet Tempel 1: Overview of Stardust-NExT results

What collimating them then? Gas disperses in a vacuum.

So many problems and inconsistencies with the dirtysnowball or the Dirty Snowball or even the icydirtball model...just make it up as you go along.

Molecular oxygen should have been fatal to Whipple's model, instead ad hoc invocations of WILD mixing, heating, moving, condensing, freezing, melting, hydrated minerals, carbonates and organics, it's :o
 
Only an idiot could pose such a question! What the hell has a piffling electric field got to do with outgassing? Seriously, how thick do you need to be? Deary me. Get a life. Get an education. Stop polluting this board with idiotic nonsense. Go away.


:jaw-dropp


Oh well...
 
What the hell is this crap? Emitting what? Jesus H. Christ, this is like discussing QM with a badger.


Get your 'ol mate, reality check to run a search on COMET + 67P + EMITTING see what pops up.

Interesting language.


Emitting, Electric fields, Rock, plasma circuits, comets, asteroids :thumbsup:
 
Get your 'ol mate, reality check to run a search on COMET + 67P + EMITTING see what pops up.

Interesting language.


Emitting, Electric fields, Rock, plasma circuits, comets, asteroids :thumbsup:

No, I don't need to Google anything to know that you are talking nonsense. As usual. The EC woo is dead. Finished. Not a jot of evidence, and not even a viable scientific mechanism for its puerile claims. Let it rot in peace.
 
Molecular oxygen should have been fatal to Whipple's model,

Why? You don't know what you are talking about. Molecular O has a very low sublimation temperature. As does CO. and CO2. Ergo, they cannot have existed on planetary surfaces. EC woo fails again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom