The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Out dated and incorrect Haser model has led you to believe comets are mostly ice.

But our understanding is evolving toward mainly rock

Liar. Nobody believes comets are mostly ice. And there is no rock at comets. This is your own idiotic strawman. Quit lying.

We’ve now got data from in situ observations from 67P...

Surface localization of gas sources on comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko based on DFMS/COPS data

Which trumps a 1950’s model based on observations from Earth.

Another strawman. I keep telling you, nobody is still following the 1950's model. You are arguing with your own strawman, nobody else. Pointless. Stop listening to the idiot Thornhill, and get a mind of your own.

Comets have a dribble of water that can be more than accounted for via hydrated minerals and CO2 from carbonates.

Electric fields anyone?

More lies. There is plenty of water, and other ices. And you are talking crap about hydrated minerals. How are you getting the water out? Don't be so bloody stupid. And where is this in the idiot Thornhill's model? Show me the temperature recordings at a comet necessary to get water of hydrated minerals. Stop making crap up, just because your idiotic model failed, and your religion is dead.

Grid-free 2D plasma simulations of the complex interaction between the solar wind and small, near-Earth asteroids

Now one wonders how charged dust is emitted from the nucleus...


Poor jd116, useing out dated and incorrect models.

Idiocy. So why aren't asteroids all sporting comae? Duh! Making crap up again. You lost. Hard luck.
 
Last edited:
Sweet as:D

Now how hard was that to admit the total failure of whipple’s sublimation model.

You know your model.


On the other hand electric fields are required for an ELECTRIC COMET, just like the one you refuse to acknowledge in operation at comet67P.

:D

Anything electrical going on at comets, Jonesdave116?
 
Last edited:
Electric fields champ!

You know the one you refuse to acknowledge. :D

Because all of a sudden we are talking the electric comet model by default and not the outdated Dirtysnowball.

If we are not comparing the ELECTRIC COMET to The Dirtysnowball then we are comparing the ELECTRIC COMET to the evolving mostly rock model with electric fields.:blush:

Err, the electric comet failed. 100%. As proven. No rock, no discharges, no EDM, lots of ice and gas. You lost. Give up. You are boring.
 
Sweet as:D

Now how hard was that to admit the total failure of whipple’s sublimation model.

You know your model.


On the other hand electric fields are required for an ELECTRIC COMET

:D

Anything electrical going on at comets, Jonesdave116?

Nobody is talking about Whipple's model. And hasn't been for decades. And sublimation is an observed fact. So stop lying. The electric comet failed. As shown. Get over it, and stop boring everyone to death with your inane crap.
 
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12091612#post12091612


Dude I’ve got icy receding cliffs, great big ones! surely that beats a bit of fluffy snow here and there.

[qimg]https://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-red/s3fs-public/mnt/medialibrary/2010/11/17/snowstorm_strip.jpg[/qimg]

Now I’ve tried to find some literature from J.Sunshine or M.A’Hearn on these obviously icy cliffs but nix.

You’d think they be doing a song and dance on all this sublimating icy cliffs stuff.

[qimg]https://photojournal.jpl.nasa.gov/jpeg/PIA13862.jpg[/qimg]

What the hell is this crap about? Are you drunk?
 
Now I’ve tried to find some literature from J.Sunshine or M.A’Hearn on these obviously icy cliffs but nix.

You’d think they be doing a song and dance on all this sublimating icy cliffs stuff.

Haven't tried very hard, have you?

The nucleus of Comet 9P/Tempel 1: Shape and geology from two flybys
Thomas, P. et al. (incl. A'Hearn, M. & Sunshine, J.)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0019103512000851

Changes observed between the two missions are primarily due to backwasting of scarps bounding one of these probable flow deposits.
 
Thought icy cliffs sublimated, now it’s backwasting?

What’s that jd116?

You have no idea, do you? Why are you still posting here? Go look up what was observed at 67P with regard to cliffs. Sublimation, weakening, collapse, sublimation, weakening..................... get it? Throw in thermal stress, as well.
 
No, they did not mention the obviously icy cliffs are sublimating.

Just flows and backwasting.

No sublimation.

No ambipolar electric field either.
 
No, they did not mention the obviously icy cliffs are sublimating.

Just flows and backwasting.

No sublimation.

No ambipolar electric field either.

Why don't you stop talking crap, and email any of those authors? Those things are seen at 67P. And ambipolar fields are a total irrelevance.

The brighter sections may be the result of the erosion removing more of the darker lag materials either by scarp
collapse or small-scale sublimation pressure removing crusts.
 
Last edited:
You have no idea, do you? Why are you still posting here? Go look up what was observed at 67P with regard to cliffs. Sublimation, weakening, collapse, sublimation, weakening..................... get it? Throw in thermal stress, as well.


Not needed when it has an ambipolar electric field. :thumbsup:
 
A little lesson on sublimation;

Different ices will sublimate at different temperatures. The temperatures at which they sublimate depend on atmospheric pressure. This is virtually zero at a comet. So, in a vacuum, water ice will sublimate if it reaches ~150 K. Carbon dioxide ice will sublimate at ~70 K, and carbon monoxide at ~30 K. If any of those ices attain that temperature in vacuo, they will sublimate. They can do nothing else. The pressure is too low to go through a liquid phase. The same process will occur on Mars, where there is CO2 and H2O ice. However, the conditions on Mars approach the triple point of water, at times. Under those conditions, water ice could go through a liquid phase, but will generally just sublimate. CO2 will always sublimate. If you've seen dry ice at a disco, that is likely carbon dioxide ice sublimating.
The ices at comets, and elsewhere, cannot fail to sublimate at the relevant temperatures, any more than water in your kettle can fail to boil at 100 Celsius at sea level, or ice removed from your freezer will fail to melt above 0 Celsius. Sublimation can basically be thought of as boiling, without going through a liquid phase.
The resulting gas expands at a velocity determined by its molecular weight, via the ideal gas laws. For water that is ~700 m/s. A bit lower for CO2. These velocities will be affected by the mean free path of the molecule. That is, the distance it can travel before hitting another atom or molecule, and thus being slowed. On Earth, at sea level, that will not be very far. On a comet, in near vacuum, it will be quite a reasonable distance.
For some reason, Thornhill thinks sublimation is something made up by scientists to explain cometary outgassing. It is not. It is a physical fact. It can be observed on Earth, as in various comet experiments, such as KOSI. Where it is also seen to lift dust. In those experiments, we can provide a vacuum, and the relevant temperatures, but we cannot provide the cometary gravity.
It is also seen at comets, as we can see dust entrained in gas 'jets', such as at Hartley 2. And at 67P, as an outburst was observed, and the gas reached the spacecraft some minutes before the dust, as the dust has a much lower velocity.
In summary, there is nothing particularly mysterious about sublimation. It isn't rocket science.
 
You said Whipple’s model dead and buried.
Another strawman. I keep telling you, nobody is still following the 1950's model. You are arguing with your own strawman, nobody else. Pointless. Stop listening to the idiot Thornhill, and get a mind of your own.


Then go on to describe Whipple’s sublimation model as a valid model.
The resulting gas expands at a velocity determined by its molecular weight, via the ideal gas laws. For water that is ~700 m/s. A bit lower for CO2. These velocities will be affected by the mean free path of the molecule. That is, the distance it can travel before hitting another atom or molecule, and thus being slowed. On Earth, at sea level, that will not be very far. On a comet, in near vacuum, it will be quite a reasonable distance.

Is this the mainstream model or not?


Because the latest papers saying it’s wrong.
 
Last edited:
You said Whipple’s model dead and buried.


Then go on to describe Whipple’s sublimation model as a valid model.

Is this the mainstream model or not?

Of course sublimation is the driver of the dust coma. What the hell else would it be? The difference, since Whipple published, is that the dust/ ice ratio has become more constrained. That there is ice, and that it sublimates, is not in question.
 
Is this the mainstream model or not?

There is only one model. It is in the scientific literature. Written by scientists. Based on observation, measurement, and viable science. Nobody is challenging that model. Scientifically illiterate Velikovskian loons on crackpot websites are hardly a challenge. Especially when they lie. Which they do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom