The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Elias Odelstad seems to think I’m on the money.
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

A totally insane lie.
  1. A delusion that a tweet is scientific literature.
  2. A delusion that Elias Odelstad would agree with anyone who is ignorant/deluded enough believe in the electric comet insanity.
  3. An insane lie about the contents of the tweet which is an image with mainstream points about cometary plasma of 67P and Halley.
    No electric comet insanity there.
  4. Many lies about what Sol88 has written here is the main insanity :eye-poppi!
    That image is a list of mainstream science that Sol88 is ignorant or deluded about. Thus
    Sol88 lies that he has written that the plasma environment of 67P is different from Halley.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that collisions are less important at 67P.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that warm electrons imply negative V/c
    Sol88 lies that he has written that E-fields are important for plasma dynamics.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that ions are faster than neutrals inside the diamagnetic cavity.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that ion-neutral friction is not responsible for the diamagnetic cavity.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that there is a dynamic and variable plasma environment with plenty of plasma waves.
 
Yeah, **** science!

Meh... just happy to see mainstream Dirtysnowballers acknowledge the fact ELECTRIC FIELDS are important for plasma dynamics.


How important? Electric comet important that requires there to be electric fields or Dirtysnowball important were there maybe electric fields but there not doing anything.

Olestad also shatters jd116’s make believe world of how the diamagnetic cavity forms.

Lost that one too jd116....


Double layers, here we come baby.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

A totally insane lie.
  1. A delusion that a tweet is scientific literature.
  2. A delusion that Elias Odelstad would agree with anyone who is ignorant/deluded enough believe in the electric comet insanity.
  3. An insane lie about the contents of the tweet which is an image with mainstream points about cometary plasma of 67P and Halley.
    No electric comet insanity there.
  4. Many lies about what Sol88 has written here is the main insanity :eye-poppi!
    That image is a list of mainstream science that Sol88 is ignorant or deluded about. Thus
    Sol88 lies that he has written that the plasma environment of 67P is different from Halley.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that collisions are less important at 67P.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that warm electrons imply negative V/c
    Sol88 lies that he has written that E-fields are important for plasma dynamics.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that ions are faster than neutrals inside the diamagnetic cavity.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that ion-neutral friction is not responsible for the diamagnetic cavity.
    Sol88 lies that he has written that there is a dynamic and variable plasma environment with plenty of plasma waves.

Are electric fields important reality check?
 
Meh... just happy to see mainstream Dirtysnowballers acknowledge the fact ELECTRIC FIELDS are important for plasma dynamics.


How important? Electric comet important that requires there to be electric fields or Dirtysnowball important were there maybe electric fields but there not doing anything.

Olestad also shatters jd116’s make believe world of how the diamagnetic cavity forms.

Lost that one too jd116....


Double layers, here we come baby.

Just give up with this idiocy, yes? It has already been explained how they think the DC forms at 67P. It is electron-neutral friction. Your problem is that a DC forms at all. That prevents the solar wind getting anywhere near the nucleus, and totally screws your water production mechanism woo. The lack of a magnetic signal tells us that no electric woo, such as EDM (lol), is happening within that cavity. It also shows us that the amount of vapour from sublimation is sufficient to produce a DC. Therefore it is no help to your failed woo, is it?
And if you think plasma physicists don't think electric fields are important in plasma, then you have obviously never read a text book on the subject. Which would explain why you know nothing about the subject, along with the rest of the EU wooists.
And you do not need electric fields. You need EDM (lol), you need discharges, you need Earth rock. You don't have it. You failed. Why are you still here?
 
Are electric fields important reality check?

Show me where any EU loon has written about electric fields at comets. And what they expect them to do. None of the idiots who wrote this garbage have clue one about plasma physics, do they?
 
Show me where any EU loon has written about electric fields at comets. And what they expect them to do. None of the idiots who wrote this garbage have clue one about plasma physics, do they?

Just happy to see you mob catch up, that’s all.
 
Just give up with this idiocy, yes? It has already been explained how they think the DC forms at 67P. It is electron-neutral friction. Your problem is that a DC forms at all. That prevents the solar wind getting anywhere near the nucleus, and totally screws your water production mechanism woo. The lack of a magnetic signal tells us that no electric woo, such as EDM (lol), is happening within that cavity. It also shows us that the amount of vapour from sublimation is sufficient to produce a DC. Therefore it is no help to your failed woo, is it?
And if you think plasma physicists don't think electric fields are important in plasma, then you have obviously never read a text book on the subject. Which would explain why you know nothing about the subject, along with the rest of the EU wooists.
And you do not need electric fields. You need EDM (lol), you need discharges, you need Earth rock. You don't have it. You failed. Why are you still here?

Electron neutral friction... :rolleyes:


Sol88 lies that he has written that ion-neutral friction is not responsible for the diamagnetic cavity.

Sol88 has always said ion neutral friction was not responsible for the diamagnetic cavity but the electric field does.

Seems a few mainstreamers agree.
 
Last edited:
So, let's do a word search in the Electric Comet woo poster by Thornhill & Talbott. 'Plasma' is what we'll look for, but only where they apply it to comets;

1)
Growing electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

Whoops, that would be the dust that is 'glowing'! Not a good start.

2) 
The jets’ explode from cometary nuclei at supersonic speeds and retain their
coherent structure for hundreds of thousands of miles. The collimation of
such jets is a well-documented attribute of plasma discharge.
Whoops again! You can't see the plasma. Once again, for the hard of thinking, that is sunlight reflecting from dust and sometimes ice.

3) 
The tails of comets reveal well-defined filaments extending up to tens of millions of miles without dissipating in the vacuum of space. This “violation” of neutral gas behavior in a vacuum is to be expected of a plasma discharge within the ambient electric field of the Sun.

That's dust, dummies! How many times?

4) 
The comet spends most of its time far from the Sun, where the plasma voltage is low relative to the Sun. In remote regions, the comet moves slowly and its charge easily comes into balance with its surroundings.
WTH is 'plasma voltage'? Where has it been measured? Why isn't it affecting asteroids on highly elliptical orbits? Another bunch of unscientific nonsense.

5) 
The comet's charge, developed in deep space, responds to the new environment by increasing internal electric polarization and by forming cathode jets and a visible plasma sheath, or coma.

Been there, done that. No cathode jets. Lol. No visible plasma sheath. Repeat after me; it is sunlight reflecting off of dust. Write it out 1000 times until it penetrates what counts for the collective EU brain.

6)
Most of the voltage difference between the comet and the solar plasma is taken up in a double layer of charge, called a plasma sheath, that surrounds the comet. When the electrical stress is great enough, the sheath glows and appears as the typical cometary coma and tail. Diffuse electrical discharges occur in the sheath and at the nucleus, radiating a variety of frequencies, including x-rays.

Oh dear! No double layer. And what 'voltage difference'? There isn't one. And why is this not happening at asteroids? And what 'electrical stress'? What the hell does that even mean? This garbage was obviously written by non-scientists. And the sheath does not 'glow'. That is sunlight........................................... you get the picture!

7) 
The highest voltage differences occur at the comet nucleus and across the plasma sheath. So where the sheath is most compressed, in the sunward direction, the electric field is strong enough to accelerate charged particles to x-ray energies. That may explain recent crescent-shaped x-ray images in relation to the comet nucleus and the Sun.

No voltage difference of any note. You might get a healthy one at asteroids, but.......well, you know! And nothing is being accelerated to x-ray energies. We have known for some years that those x-rays are from charge exchange between solar wind heavy ions and cometary neutrals.

8) 
All that is required to trigger the comet fragmentation is an electrical breakdown within the comet. And that breakdown in the comet may happen with any sudden change in the solar plasma environment. The more sudden the change in the comet's electrical environment, the more likely that flaring and fragmentation will occur. NASA scientists were astonished to observe a remarkable 300,000 km wide flare-up of comet Halley between the orbits of Saturn and Uranus. (Under the assumptions of the “snowball” theory the nucleus should be frozen and inert at that distance.) But in the electrical model the event was no accident. It followed some of the largest solar flares ever recorded.

Lol. These people obviously don't know the sublimation temperature of CO2 and CO! And 67P copped at least one solar flare. Nothing much happened, flaring up wise.

9) 
The electrical model also explains why we should expect long-period comets to put on a brighter display than short-period comets. The long-period comets spend a longer time in a region of lower plasma potential than the short-period comets. Consequently, their voltage difference on their approach to the Sun will be higher, leading to a brighter and more energetic discharge.

Haha. How is this 'plasma potential' arising in the quasi-neutral solar wind?


Well, that is most of the crap. Not gone well, has it?
 
Last edited:
Just give up with this idiocy, yes? It has already been explained how they think the DC forms at 67P. It is electron-neutral friction. Your problem is that a DC forms at all. That prevents the solar wind getting anywhere near the nucleus, and totally screws your water production mechanism woo. The lack of a magnetic signal tells us that no electric woo, such as EDM (lol), is happening within that cavity. It also shows us that the amount of vapour from sublimation is sufficient to produce a DC. Therefore it is no help to your failed woo, is it?
And if you think plasma physicists don't think electric fields are important in plasma, then you have obviously never read a text book on the subject. Which would explain why you know nothing about the subject, along with the rest of the EU wooists.
And you do not need electric fields. You need EDM (lol), you need discharges, you need Earth rock. You don't have it. You failed. Why are you still here?


Do you need an electric field to have EDM on the surface of a comet?

Rhetorical :D

Yes you do.

Do we have any? Yes we do. Are these electric fields important for the plasma dynamics? Very important.

These electric fields that Olestad talks about affect the mostly rocky nucleus.

Can’t wait for Tusenfems confirmation of this fact in his new paper.
 
Just happy to see you mob catch up, that’s all.

Catch up with what? Show me where any EU loon has written about electric fields at comets. Show me one EU plasma physicist, for that matter. There is nothing to catch up on. You lot do not understand plasma physics, and real plasma physicists do. End of story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom