The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
In fact if you really want the quote that gets me all frothy; how do you read that, steenkh?
?

In my reading if h2o ions are being neutralised (not positively charged any more) by cometary electrons, does that not just make it neutral water?

Along with solar wind protons becoming neutral hydrogen by pinching and electron.

Oh dear! Lol. You really should keep away from plasma stuff. I'm no expert, but even I can understand what is being said there. They are talking about overall quasi-neutrality. The H2O+ is not becoming neutral H2O! This is a four fluid model. It means the solar wind electrons as a whole are balancing the cometary ions. So, we have + - + - + - + -, etc, etc. Just as we see in the quasi-neutral solar wind, sans comet. There are sufficient electrons to balance the charge of the ions over a volume > the Debye length. Please tell me that we don't have to explain quasi-neutrality to you!
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Comets are mostly consolidated refractory material.
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Usual insane lies about comets.
Two (2) comets are consolidated ices and refractory material with the refractory material dominating at 67P (at least 17% ices) and probably dominating at Tempel 1 (up to 50% water ices). He has been told this many times thus the insanity of the lie.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

EM is the dominant force not gravity.
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

An insanely delusional statement showing that he has never seen a dropped object :jaw-dropp!

Gravity dominates between neutral objects. Gravity dominates between weakly enough charged objects. It needs a certain amount of charge to make EM dominate over gravity. Gravity works for all bodies on the solar system, natural and artificial without the need for EM. That includes comets!
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Divide by zero = singularity
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Irrelevant and ignorant delusions about singularities.

Sol88 has the delusion that singularities in gravity and electromagnetism (they both obey an inverse square law that blows up as r -> 0) somehow makes only gravity invalid :jaw-dropp!

Sol88 has the ignorant delusion that a singularity is a divide by zero error when high school children know not to divide by zero. A singularity is a quantity tending to infinity as a parameter goes to a limit. Coulomb's law for the force between charges goes to infinite as r goes to zero.
 
Sorry mate iPad autocorrect.

Anyhoo,

Diurnal variation of dust and gas production in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at the inbound equinox as seen by OSIRIS and VIRTIS-M on board Rosetta

What say ye champ?


Dirtysnowball?


Evidence says Mmmmmmmm.... your a clever cookie. ;)

Yet another paper that you are failing to understand. Read the whole thing.

No strong temporal correlation between total dust brightness and water production rates is found, despite water being still the main driver of dust activity at this period in time. The observed increased water activity in the Southern regions with strong seasonal variations, with respect to model expectations, is likely to be attributed to regional changes of volatile content or access to this. The best explanation for the drastic decrease in dust brightness when consolidated regions are illuminated is a quenched dust activity due to the high cohesion of surface material. These observations show that, when 67P is approaching perihelion, the dust activity cannot be understood based on water-driven activity alone.*

*From a bit further up the paper;

A more thorough investigation in the near future demands application of more sophisticated thermo-physical models to treat not only non-uniform properties of the nucleus subsurface but also activity of multiple volatile species.

You need to start understanding these papers before quoting them.
 
Last edited:
EM is the dominant force not gravity. EU never said gravity does not exist.

Wrong. Gravity totally dominates at these scales. Hence why they could put Rosetta in bound orbits based on the gravity measured from the RSI experiments. No electric woo is affecting those orbits. Of a charged, metallic spacecraft!
 
Oh dear! Lol. You really should keep away from plasma stuff. I'm no expert, but even I can understand what is being said there. They are talking about overall quasi-neutrality. The H2O+ is not becoming neutral H2O! This is a four fluid model. It means the solar wind electrons as a whole are balancing the cometary ions. So, we have + - + - + - + -, etc, etc. Just as we see in the quasi-neutral solar wind, sans comet. There are sufficient electrons to balance the charge of the ions over a volume > the Debye length. Please tell me that we don't have to explain quasi-neutrality to you!

Well then it wasn't quasi-neutral at the comet then was it champ!

Which is the whole point of the electric comet.

Cheers again.

:thumbsup:
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Usual insane irrelevant questions not about his electric comet insanity.
Usual insane lies about his electric comet insanity - maybe :p!
He suggests that his thunderbolts cult prophets are insane enough to think plasma cannot be quasineutral at comets. In the real world, plasmas are quasineutral above the Debye length scale and not below it. That is a few meters for comet coma.
 
Last edited:
Well then it wasn't quasi-neutral at the comet then was it champ!

Which is the whole point of the electric comet.

Cheers again.

:thumbsup:

No, it isn't. You need EDM (lol), electric discharges and rock. Given that you are batting 0 from 3 on that count, you have failed, haven't you?
 
Not really, remember charge seperation can not happen.

Like your myopic view of electric currents.

Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.

are there any electric fields in space, jonesdave116?

Decca’s paper was a boon for the Electric comet, along with all the following papers confirming electric fields and currents at comets.

145kv potential drop at P1 Halley should have been a warning, but alas mainstream still trying to smash a round peg into square hole.

Hilarious.

Anywhoo, happy to have electric fields, charge separation, electric currents, charged dust (complex plasma) and a nucleus composed of consolidated dust.

All we need for an ELECTRIC COMET.

I’d say that’s looking pretty good, not so for a sublimating Dirtysnowball!
 
<snip>

a boon for the Electric comet, <snip>

All we need for an ELECTRIC COMET.

<snip>
Ah yes, like the mythical bunyip ...

Born from the union of nonsense and anti-science ...

Provided a comfortable living for some scam artists ...

Even set South Australia on fire (SAFIRE)! ... :p
 
Not really, remember charge seperation can not happen.

Like your myopic view of electric currents.

Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.

are there any electric fields in space, jonesdave116?

Decca’s paper was a boon for the Electric comet, along with all the following papers confirming electric fields and currents at comets.

145kv potential drop at P1 Halley should have been a warning, but alas mainstream still trying to smash a round peg into square hole.

Hilarious.

Anywhoo, happy to have electric fields, charge separation, electric currents, charged dust (complex plasma) and a nucleus composed of consolidated dust.

All we need for an ELECTRIC COMET.

I’d say that’s looking pretty good, not so for a sublimating Dirtysnowball!

Nope. You need EDM (lol), you need electric discharges, and you need planetary rock. Three strikes and you're out. And currents in cometary comae is hardly news. I think a certain plasma astrophysicist may have written a paper with that very title. So, we do not need lessons from the EU plasma ignoramuses. Not a single person involved in this electric comet scam has any qualifications in plasma physics. Or astrophysics. Or planetary science. Or anything remotely related to comets and their environment.
That is why they have been wrong about every single thing that they have predicted for comets. That is why they kept schtum when the Tempel 1 impactor blasted out thousands of tonnes of solid ice. And when shed loads of the stuff was seen and detected at Hartley 2. Hell, they were still telling us there was no H2O two decades after it was first definitively detected at Halley by the Kuiper Airborne Observatory! And many detections since then.
So, nope. What you have there is a complete failure, wrapped up in lies and obfuscation. Not bad going for a decade and a half of spamming this crap all over the interweb! You must be proud! Unfortunately, you are still batting zero. Your woo died on Independence Day, 2005.
 
Last edited:
are there any electric fields in space, jonesdave116?

What difference does that make to your failed woo? The solar wind has an associated electric field. We've kind of known about that for some time! The magnetic field (the IMF) is moving. Therefore, complete this equation; ? = -v x B. Your problem is that you don't understand electric fields. Or what they are doing. Like your idiotic claim that an ambipolar field would accelerate negatively charged dust, when the bloody thing is only set up to retard negatively charged electrons, and therefore accelerate positive ions!
So, who doesn't understand plasma physics?
And the claim that the solar wind electrons are turning H2O+ into neutral water!
So, who doesn't understand plasma physics?
I'm sure there is mountains more where Tusenfem has told you that you don't know what you're talking about. However, you get the point.

Decca’s paper was a boon for the Electric comet,......

Then why you are too chicken to discuss it with Indagator? The very thing you denied being there (cometary gases) is required for Deca's paper to make any sense. Where are you getting charge separation from? What is separating?
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

An insane insult when plasma basics are easy for anyone with a brain to understand. Anyone who can read Wikipedia can understand the basics. Anyone who can reads a physics textbook can understand the basics. That excludes anyone believing in the electric comet insanity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom