Perseverence porn

Rolfe

Adult human female
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
55,388
Location
NT 150 511
I found this article very thought-provoking.

To be clear, while we can admire the never-say-die attitude of those in tough conditions, this is no substitute for guaranteed public programs to help those in dire need. The problem with perseverance porn is not the brave subjects of the articles, but the lack of any journalistic scrutiny examining the failings of society that placed them in such desperate circumstances to begin with.


It's not just about healthcare, the topics cover education and even in one case providing a decent burial. I'm sure there are members who will defend this situation but I'm with the author of the article. A little girl being praised for selling $1,000 worth of lemonade to try to save her mother's life (she needs a kidney transplant that would cost $400,000) isn't a feel-good story and the media who attempt to portray it as that are complicit in perpetuating a cruel society.
 
Yes by all means keep the news negative at every cost, feel good stories have no place in this "if it bleeds it leads" Society. Actually, that's not the kind of world I want to live in. I want to hear positive stories once in awhile.
 
Last edited:
yep.

the headline
"local millionaire donates X to feed the homeless"​
is far more pleasing than
"why the hell is there no money to feed the homeless?
Why do we have homeless people when there are so many millionaires?"
​
 
Yes by all means keep the news negative at every cost, feel good stories have no place in this "if it bleeds it leads" Society. Actually, that's not the kind of world I want to live in. I want to hear positive stories once in awhile.


We aim to please, applecorped! So no laughing dog emoticon for your comment. We leave that to you. Instead you get the wonderful news about the modern way of battling cancer:

“The sweetest words my ears have heard!! MRD negative!! (no cancer) God is so good and to Him we give all glory and praise for Ellee’s health!!” wrote Ellee’s mom, Shauna Large.
(...)
“God is so good and to Him we give all glory and praise for Ellee’s health!! God has blessed us with supportive family and friends and access to the best hospital in the world for our Ellee bean,” she wrote.
Girl, 8, who opened lemonade stand for St. Jude while battling leukemia is now cancer free (Fox5, Sep. 23, 2019)


Some of us prefer universal health care ...
Hallelujah!

Let's all rejoice and forget about Facts and Statistics (Leukemia and Lymphoma Society)
 
I found this article very thought-provoking.


It's not just about healthcare, the topics cover education and even in one case providing a decent burial. I'm sure there are members who will defend this situation but I'm with the author of the article. A little girl being praised for selling $1,000 worth of lemonade to try to save her mother's life (she needs a kidney transplant that would cost $400,000) isn't a feel-good story and the media who attempt to portray it as that are complicit in perpetuating a cruel society.


There is a subcategory of this genre. In Denmark we call it "Ugens glade krøbling." (This Week's Happy Cripple)
We even have a song about it:
 
It's not just about healthcare, the topics cover education and even in one case providing a decent burial. I'm sure there are members who will defend this situation but I'm with the author of the article. A little girl being praised for selling $1,000 worth of lemonade to try to save her mother's life (she needs a kidney transplant that would cost $400,000) isn't a feel-good story and the media who attempt to portray it as that are complicit in perpetuating a cruel society.

News stories do this sort of thing sometimes - the latest is a fast food worker who walked to work every day, until her boss bought her a car. One caveat: I don't really know if the boss is a franchisee, or works for corporate - the former is likely struggling, while the latter should be able to provide better wages for all of their employees.

The other that comes to mind is Robert Smith, who paid the student loans for an entire graduating class at Howard University - and also challenged other classes to do donate and do the same. It's a proposal - but really, we shouldn't require giant loan packages just to get a degree.

I don't think that the point of these stories is to distract, however - they're often the "feel-good" story that local news shows use after weather and sports to close out the program, often after reciting the local murders, serial rapists, corrupt local councilmen, and so forth. The effect, though, can be the same as propaganda I guess, but these shows are often less about propaganda, and more about ratings to sell time to advertisers.
 
Last edited:
Sometimes people love and crave propaganda. That doesn't make the stories less propagandistic. People buy tabloids with these stories because they like them. It's much like religion. When (adult) people go to church, they do so of their own volition because they want and need to believe. That doesn't make religion any truer.
The point of these stories is to distract from the truth about reality that you don't want to know. That is their feel-good appeal. Just like religion.
Trump fans are lied to, but that is what they want.
 
Last edited:
One can simultaneously admire the bravery of the firefighters while regretting that there was a fire at all. You don't have to make a single judgment of what the best possible situation would have been, and then issue letter grades to all the participants based on how close they came to the ideal.
 
I found this article very thought-provoking.




It's not just about healthcare, the topics cover education and even in one case providing a decent burial. I'm sure there are members who will defend this situation but I'm with the author of the article. A little girl being praised for selling $1,000 worth of lemonade to try to save her mother's life (she needs a kidney transplant that would cost $400,000) isn't a feel-good story and the media who attempt to portray it as that are complicit in perpetuating a cruel society.


Enemy of the people!

Sure is a lot of this "complicit" stuff going on at the forum these days. "Perpetuating a cruel society"? Quite a claim!

Perseverance porn? People just need their daily dose of outrage I guess. I'm so horrified.

Here ya go:
:rolleyes:
 
I found this article very thought-provoking.




It's not just about healthcare, the topics cover education and even in one case providing a decent burial. I'm sure there are members who will defend this situation but I'm with the author of the article. A little girl being praised for selling $1,000 worth of lemonade to try to save her mother's life (she needs a kidney transplant that would cost $400,000) isn't a feel-good story and the media who attempt to portray it as that are complicit in perpetuating a cruel society.

Yet unfortunately it does make a lot of people feel good. People want to believe that people get what they deserve (belief in a just world) and that systems are fair and just (system justification). Evidence to the contrary creates dissonance, making systems seem unpredictable and raising the possibility that injustice can happen to anyone, including oneself. It happens in any area of injustice, including wrongful convictions - the reason some people react with such hostility to a claimed miscarriage of justice and any associated implications for the fairness of the system.

Typically systems are justified by blaming or derogating victims of misfortune and asserting that they received just deserts (when justice can't be restored or victims compensated). In this article some cases were compensated through the actions of others, therefore justice was restored and system justification maintained. Drawing attention to all those who didn't receive a happy outcome wouldn't sell stories as it provokes dissonance. If somebody were to draw attention to these cases they would likely be derogated (the fact that one homeless person can win scholarships proves those who don't are inferior or making excuses; if people can't get their friends/colleagues to help them that must say something about them as a person). Victim enhancement (suffering is good for the soul) is an alternative route to system justification when it is impossible to blame somebody for their plight. Nobody can find a way to blame a child whose mother needs a kidney transplant, but they can resolve dissonance through victim enhancement (how tragedy brings out the best in someone).
 
One can simultaneously admire the bravery of the firefighters while regretting that there was a fire at all. You don't have to make a single judgment of what the best possible situation would have been, and then issue letter grades to all the participants based on how close they came to the ideal.


The people who are deliberately crippling our ability to pick up the policies for wages, safety nets, education and healthcare that the rest of the first world have rely on selling charity or insane perseversence as the solution to these problems.

So it isn't like firefighters and the cause of the fires would be two totally unrelated things. To push the metaphor off the cliff, the people going around soaking everybody's houses in gasoline are successfully arguing that they don't need to stop doing that because dealing with fires should be firefighters' job.

That doesn't make the firefighters bad people, but it makes a news story that sells exactly the message that the gasoline pourers are relying on
 
The people who are deliberately crippling our ability to pick up the policies for wages, safety nets, education and healthcare that the rest of the first world have rely on selling charity or insane perseversence as the solution to these problems.

So it isn't like firefighters and the cause of the fires would be two totally unrelated things. To push the metaphor off the cliff, the people going around soaking everybody's houses in gasoline are successfully arguing that they don't need to stop doing that because dealing with fires should be firefighters' job.

That doesn't make the firefighters bad people, but it makes a news story that sells exactly the message that the gasoline pourers are relying on

And the ultimate sad fact under everything is that we are mortals trapped in physical bodies and cannot transcend those physical limitations imposed by reality. Should we therefore include in every report of every event a reminder that inexorable death will eventually claim us all?

Of course not, because it would be ridiculous to insist on always taking the widest possible view.
 
As far as social appetite for perseverance stories goes, that ain't new. Horatio Alger is perhaps the best example of the genre.
 
And the ultimate sad fact under everything is that we are mortals trapped in physical bodies and cannot transcend those physical limitations imposed by reality. Should we therefore include in every report of every event a reminder that inexorable death will eventually claim us all?

Of course not, because it would be ridiculous to insist on always taking the widest possible view.

Sure, we don't always need to take the wider view. But in these particular cases, there are pretty important practical issues at stake, and the toxic half of the political spectrum REALLY wants to push the narrow view to keep their hold on power.

In your existentialist, nihilist example, there's really no practical reason to invoke that wide view and there's no one pushing people away from it to their own detriment.

This is all to say, it's good to take a wide view when there's a reason to.
 
As far as social appetite for perseverance stories goes, that ain't new. Horatio Alger is perhaps the best example of the genre.

Its not an accident that those rags to riches stories were written for a fairly newly industrialized nation.

The idea that all the poor folks might be millionaires tomorrow if they just work hard enough has been a major tool to keep exploitation capitalism running smooth.
 
Its not an accident that those rags to riches stories were written for a fairly newly industrialized nation.



The idea that all the poor folks might be millionaires tomorrow if they just work hard enough has been a major tool to keep exploitation capitalism running smooth.
... As opposed to the capitalism you subscribe to and benefit from?
 
Yes by all means keep the news negative at every cost, feel good stories have no place in this "if it bleeds it leads" Society. Actually, that's not the kind of world I want to live in. I want to hear positive stories once in awhile.
Reality is reality, are you saying that you want a positive spin on things that aren't positive?

"Young girl with just one arm and no legs, pulls herself 2 miles to the nearest food bank and gets help from concerned citizens because they cared so much, aww, so heartwarming."

Is that what you're after?
 
There's something endearing about a community coming together to protect one of their own. This is what our Founding Fathers had in mind. We don't want the state to be our biggest health-care provider. No, in a truly just, engaged, civic-minded society, the biggest health-care provider is GoFundMe.
 
Or you could just exploit perseverance.

Of the 14 neurosurgeons and related specialists interviewed by*The Sydney Morning*Herald*and*The Age, not one questioned Dr Teo's excellent surgical skills. Instead, the*Herald*and*The*Age*can reveal they raised serious questions about his judgment, narcissistic behaviour, charging financially-stressed people exorbitant fees when some surgeries could be done for free in a public hospital, blaming others for keeping him from public hospitals when it is Dr Teo himself who has refused to operate in the public system, bad-mouthing his colleagues and inappropriate conduct in the operating theatre.

"It's my dream that you would suck my dick while I'm doing this operation. That's a direct quote," said one of his colleagues about Dr Teo's comments to a nurse during a brain surgery operation.

The whole story is worth reading. Offer people false hope for incurable cancer, charge them far more than they could possibly afford and live the high life off their perseverance.

If something goes wrong or they run out of money he just dumps the patient in the public system.

https://www.smh.com.au/national/brilliant-adored-flawed-dr-charlie-teo-unmasked-20190904-p52nwi.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom