Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?

Cheetah

Master Poster
Joined
Feb 4, 2010
Messages
2,934
Location
South Africa
Healthy Men: Why are we ignoring the epidemic of white male suicides?


In 2000, the suicide rate among all females was 4 per 100,000. In 2016, that rate was 6 per 100,000—a 50% increase. Over the same period, the rate for males grew from 17.7 per 100,000 to 21.4 per 100,000, an increase of 21%. So yes, the female suicide rate grew more quickly than the male rate, and there needs to be some serious investigation into what's driving that increase. However—and this is a really big however—while the rate of females taking their own lives increased by 2 per 100,000, the rate of males increased by nearly 4 per 100,000. In actual numbers, there are, again, at least 3.5 male suicides for every female one.


So why aren't we getting the full story behind the epidemic of suicides? There are a number of factors, chief among them is the fact that reporting the truth about who's committing suicide would require acknowledging that the contemporary narrative—in which men in general and white men in particular are a universally privileged class and have no legitimate problems—is false. Ignoring the very real issues facing men in this country and continuing to tell men that they should be stoic, that their problems aren't as big as everyone else's, and to never ask for help is killing people. Tens of thousands every year.


I had no idea.
 
Because it's White men. Who gives a **** about them? It's their way of owning up to the privilege lives they've enjoyed throughout history. They realize they are a malevolent force of nature and are creating a better world by ceasing to exist.

The patriarchy doesn't talk about our problems. We just handle them.
 
Apparently we suck at it

Unless you’re proud of the suicide rate being so high


And that's it in a nutshell, really. Men aren't allowed to talk about their feelings, to admit to being anything but strong, self-sufficient, and... well... "manly". Any who do are derided, ridiculed, and bullied. The partriarchal worldview of men does not permit then to ask for, or even need, help with anything; so it's no wonder that they end up losing the ability to cope with life.

Add to that the absolute crap state of mental healthcare in this country, and you have a recipe for this sort of quiet desperation and loss. A great deal of suicidal people are suffering from some sort of mental illness, and have no resources available to deal with it, or what few resources exist are beyond their reach, or too difficult for them to obtain.

How we deal with people on the edge, who are suicidal, is even worse. Rather than understanding their misery, their desperation, their hopelessness, and trying to so something to improve opportunities for suicidal people to get help; suicidal people are derided as "selfish" and "not caring about the people they leave behind", and whinging about "having to clean up the mess", and so on and so forth. There's been more than a little of that attitude evidenced on this very forum.

Even talking about it, let alone doing anything about it, would require drastic changes to the culture of this nation.
 
Last edited:


What do you mean when you say "we"?
I don't think that we men are ignoring the epidemic, but an awful lot of men are in denial about it.
I can recommend listening to a couple of TED or TEDx talks:

How I Unlearned Dangerous Lessons about Masculinity

Machismo Hurts Men, Too

Why I’m Done Trying to Be ‘Man Enough’:

The Mask of Masculinity:

Why Modern Masculinity Is Basically Flawed
 
Totally don't care.

I do.
In fact, I did this painting recently based on the very subject, admittedly without knowing about the increase in white male suicide, trying to depict a resulting sad reaction from it - "The Suicide" Acrylic on Board 122 cm x 56 cm.

[IMGw=500]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=317&pictureid=12283[/IMGw]
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Because it's White men. Who gives a **** about them? It's their way of owning up to the privilege lives they've enjoyed throughout history.


Men as such were never privileged. Rich men and powerful men were, which made many unprivileged men take their frustrations out on the even less privileged: women, blacks, homosexuals etc. Only then do men become "a malevolent force of nature": When they try to live up to the macho ideal of the true manly heman. The irony is that these men will rather become self-pitying snowflakes (or even kill themselves) than reject the ideal that's killing them:

They realize they are a malevolent force of nature and are creating a better world by ceasing to exist.
 
Men as such were never privileged. Rich men and powerful men were, which made many unprivileged men take their frustrations out on the even less privileged: women, blacks, homosexuals etc. Only then do men become "a malevolent force of nature": When they try to live up to the macho ideal of the true manly heman. The irony is that these men will rather become self-pitying snowflakes (or even kill themselves) than reject the ideal that's killing them:

Is that a "white" thing?
 
Cancel Culture

I've seen more than a few articles about the suicide rate of older white males. More generally, life expectancy for the demographic has started to decline for the first time in a long, long time (the opioid epidemic plays a significant role). I had not heard that the suicide rate for females increased by 50%. There have also been plenty of articles about the rise in teen suicide.
 
Yeah, this whole rat race thing doesn't seem to be working out so well. Improved social security through a better tax policy might help.
 
Yeah, this whole rat race thing doesn't seem to be working out so well. Improved social security through a better tax policy might help.

Sounds interesting.

The "whole rat race thing" is people producing enough wealth to survive, plus some left over to enjoy the life they've bought, plus some left over to pass along to the government to pay for infrastructure and support people who aren't (yet) in a position to produce enough wealth to survive on their own.

In that light, it's kind of interesting to try to imagine a world where people work less, but there's more extra wealth left over to support people more. Assuming that's what you meant. If you meant something else, I apologize.
 
Methods have a lot to do with disparity in suicide rates between men and women. Women tend to take a bunch of pills or turn the gas on. Men, in the USA, use a gun. I suspect the relative rates of attempts are much closer.
 
Sounds interesting.

The "whole rat race thing" is people producing enough wealth to survive, plus some left over to enjoy the life they've bought, plus some left over to pass along to the government to pay for infrastructure and support people who aren't (yet) in a position to produce enough wealth to survive on their own.

In that light, it's kind of interesting to try to imagine a world where people work less, but there's more extra wealth left over to support people more. Assuming that's what you meant. If you meant something else, I apologize.

Hey, look. Here's some people who aren't in the rat race at all but are still making ridiculous amounts of money on the backs of people who are. Maybe we could use some more of that wealth. Like, just a little bit.
 
Hey, look. Here's some people who aren't in the rat race at all but are still making ridiculous amounts of money on the backs of people who are. Maybe we could use some more of that wealth. Like, just a little bit.

Ridiculous?
 
White guys, damned if you do, damned if you don't.

Excel in life? "Privileged"

Don't excel in life? White trash.

Yea I can see how that gets to people.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom