Sweden's liberal pandemic strategy questioned as Stockholm death toll mounts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Famous and very appropriate quote:
“Your right to swing your arms ends just where the other man’s nose begins“
 
Beyond that, once prevalence is right down low, a real eradication effort can begin. The Faroes have already done it. Iceland, New Zealand and Australia are progressing in that direction. We'll see more of this as countries realise that it can be done and the benefits of doing it. Countries that initially thought it was impossible and decided just to let the virus rip are reconsidering fast. The long term benefits are becoming clearer by the day.


I hope that Denmark will continue in that direction. After a bit of confusion at the beginning of the local outbreak, that seems to be the strategy that they will stick with: testing tracing and quarantines:
Nu kan alle danskere blive coronatestet (DR.dk, May 18, 2020)
Now all Danes can get tested for coronavirus

Outdoor walks and jogging were never banned during the lockdown, but I don't see (indoor) dancing and in particular salsa or other couples dances return any time soon after I saw this on CNN today: More than 100 infections linked to fitness classes in South Korea, study finds.
However, I have already seen outdoor zumba classes in Copenhagen, and one of the local Cuban salsa teachers has promised to come up with some kind of outdoor salsa in a week or two. :)
 
Famous and very appropriate quote:
“Your right to swing your arms ends just where the other man’s nose begins“


But you know that it's up against, 'It's my goddamn right to infect everybody else!'
 
I agree the situation is not at all like Typhoid Mary. This is an epidemic/pandemic of a novel disease with the potential to affect our lives in some quite profound ways.
I'm not sure that the disease is likely to impact a very large percent of the population in profound ways. Its the reaction to it that is doing that. This isn't exactly the black death.

There are two possible outcomes of this, which will both probably happen to different extents in different countries. One is that the virus is not vigorously suppressed and over the following months and years it continues to affect more and more people. It won't go away on its own. In the end epidemic spikes will stop, or occur only in a more limited way more locally, and the virus will become endemic. That means that nobody who has not had the infection, and increasingly those who have had it but whose immunity has now waned, will be forever at risk of catching it. We know it can kill even young people and is deadly in the elderly. Probably including elderly people who already had it earlier in their lives.
Yes, business as usual like flu. That is clearly socially acceptable since we tolerate it with flu.

We face a future of constant social distancing, face masks and reluctance to go into anyone else's home or even an indoor airspace occupied by other people. Group leisure activities, particularly for the elderly, will be a thing of the past. Choir practices - forget it. Concerts, cinema, birthday parties, nightclubbing? Do you fancy your chances? Going into a care home will be a move to be dreaded. This is the future those who favour letting the virus "move through the population" (and kill maybe 0.5% of the population on the way) are promoting, whether they realise it or not. A future where we may be measuring deaths in the hundreds a week rather than the hundreds a day (and they say more people die in car accidents so why bother), and many people's lives are dominated by efforts not to become one of these statistics.
The only way you can get that is if you keep preventing the vast majority of people from being infected. So long as that is the case, sure I can see this running forever. The more people who've had it, surely the more outbreaks will be self limiting?

That is a public health disaster. All these years spent eradicating TB and polio and smallpox and whatever else, and we want to countenance this? A virus which takes a terrible toll on anyone who has managed to make it to collect their pension, which causes death, permanent lung damage, post-viral fatigue syndrome, Kawasaki syndrome and even absent these gives a fair proportion of people who catch it a pretty serious illness for several weeks. That is the future the people who just want to be allowed to take their own risks are ushering in, for all of us.
I don't think we stopped the world in this way to eliminate any of those diseases. As you say later on, the only real plan is a vaccine. India, Africa etc don't seem likely to be able to tackle this by contact tracing, so the future is the same regardless. Were we all to behave like Sweden or New York, the end game is the same.

On the other hand we have the situation with vigorous suppression and elimination. Break the initial epidemic spike with a lockdown, get the numbers low enough for contact tracing teams to handle them, and stamp this thing out wherever and whenever it rears its ugly head. This isn't and has never been a uniform epidemic. It's lots of little outbreaks in towns and villages and social groups. Get into these where they surface and break the chains of transmission by contact isolation. Maybe you need to impose very strict isolation conditions on a small area for a short time, maybe you need to test everyone in an entire city (as Wuhan is doing right now to stamp out a flare-up), but you do what you need to do.
Maybe, but we aren't going to be able to use the level of authoritarian control measures they use in Asia and I doubt our ability to eliminate the virus globally in this way anyway. So we wait on a vaccine, and the endgame is presumably similar regardless of the strategy.

In the mean time the citizens unaffected by this, those whose villages are already clear and who haven't been near anyone infected, can live their lives in comparative security. Soft social distancing remains, but knowing that there hasn't been a new case in their area for several weeks is going to make people a lot happier. This is suppression and elimination, not eradication, but it is clearly practical.
I have no objections to soft social distancing. That seems to be doing the bulk of the work to keep the numbers down. I question the ability of government to enforce this much longer - see parks and beaches full of people. I just don't think it is remotely possible to control this globally.

Beyond that, once prevalence is right down low, a real eradication effort can begin. The Faroes have already done it. Iceland, New Zealand and Australia are progressing in that direction. We'll see more of this as countries realise that it can be done and the benefits of doing it. Countries that initially thought it was impossible and decided just to let the virus rip are reconsidering fast. The long term benefits are becoming clearer by the day.
All islands, the Faroes have a population of 50,000. The Faroes managing to get this down to zero tells us nothing about whether this is handlable globally. It's like pointing to getting 10% of the way to renewable energy, or 500m of hyperloop track and thinking that tells you the other remainder of the task is within your grasp.

This of course leaves the problem of international travellers, but that seems to be one the eradicating countries are willing to take on and tackle as an alternative to losing maybe 0.5% of their population and then having to live with this horrible disease present endemically. As more countries achieve successful suppression and elimination, the group of countries where relatively free travel can be resumed grows, which provides more incentive for other countries to join them. If your country hasn't done that, well, add a couple of weeks on to your trip to quarantine.
Lots of countries have porous borders. Maybe this can be done, but I am doubtful and the amount of time this is going to take with control measures in place messing with world trade is going to be huge. Good luck auditing China to make sure they aren't lying about any outbreaks they may have.

Those people who bleat about their personal freedom to run around rather than be constrained by the initial, epidemic-busting lockdown aren't just choosing to take a risk with their own health, but are presuming to choose the epidemic disease future for everyone in their country. Now I don't believe anywhere has taken a vote on this, but if a country did, and the endemic future was explained to them, I think the libertarians would lose.
It might depend how much you personalize the cost of removing the virus globally. It's also not obvious to me given that you think the virus can be wiped out in poorer countries with a vaccine, why not wiping it out in advance of a vaccine in the rich countries means it becomes endemic and we must live with it forever.

Indeed it is likely that a vaccine will be available some time in the next couple of years. This isn't going to stop the virus in its tracks, it's going to make the job of eliminating and eradicating it a hell of a lot easier and bring that within the reach of poorer countries that don't have the infrastructure or the resources to do efficient contact tracing and isolation. It's going to allow more countries to join the elite of the coronavirus free states, but it's not going to hand it to them on a plate. Meticulous public health measures will still be needed to see it gone for good.
I hadn't heard before that the plan was to isolate the ******** countries. They are going to collapse and starve.
 
I wonder whether countries closer to the equator will be able to capitalise on the relative safety of the outdoors in combating this. It might be more difficult in big cities of course, but rural tropical and subtropical areas could do many or even most things out of doors and really cut down transmission. (In fact I just had a friend remark to me that she's heard someone say that it's being speculated that Africa is faring relatively well so far because so much of life happens outside.)

Even in Mediterranean climates in the summer this could be done to great effect. This is a virus that is transmitted within the home and in crowded, poorly ventilated rooms. Cut out the crowded poorly ventilated rooms and you break the transmission where the virus is taken back into the home.
 
I'm not sure that the disease is likely to impact a very large percent of the population in profound ways. Its the reaction to it that is doing that. This isn't exactly the black death.


And it isn't really bad if it's not as bad as the plague, is it?

Yes, business as usual like flu. That is clearly socially acceptable since we tolerate it with flu.


In early March people could be forgiven for believing that Covid-19 wasn't worse than the flu. Not anymore.

The only way you can get that is if you keep preventing the vast majority of people from being infected. So long as that is the case, sure I can see this running forever. The more people who've had it, surely the more outbreaks will be self limiting?


We don't yet know how long the immunity will last.

I don't think we stopped the world in this way to eliminate any of those diseases. As you say later on, the only real plan is a vaccine. India, Africa etc don't seem likely to be able to tackle this by contact tracing, so the future is the same regardless. Were we all to behave like Sweden or New York, the end game is the same.


Which is why some countries have understood that behaving like Sweden is a bad idea. New York understood too late that the White House wasn't gonna do ****.

Maybe, but we aren't going to be able to use the level of authoritarian control measures they use in Asia and I doubt our ability to eliminate the virus globally in this way anyway. So we wait on a vaccine, and the endgame is presumably similar regardless of the strategy.


I live in one of the Danish hotspots. So far, I haven't noticed any "authoritarian control measures" around here. Why does it suddenly become a question of eliminating the virus globally unlike locally? Is there any contradiction between the two things? It can be cone locally. The Faroe Islands and Iceland were mentioned several times in this thread, and they are not exactly Asian. And if many more countries get the virus under control locally, it will be much easier to help out third-world countries that can't.

I have no objections to soft social distancing. That seems to be doing the bulk of the work to keep the numbers down. I question the ability of government to enforce this much longer - see parks and beaches full of people. I just don't think it is remotely possible to control this globally.


Parks and beaches are not the problem. See previous posts today in this thread about the spread of the virus outdoors. What you 'just don't think' is uninteresting unless you have an argument for what you just don't think.

All islands, the Faroes have a population of 50,000. The Faroes managing to get this down to zero tells us nothing about whether this is handlable globally. It's like pointing to getting 10% of the way to renewable energy, or 500m of hyperloop track and thinking that tells you the other remainder of the task is within your grasp.


Iceland? New Zealand? Or look at the Danish graphs and curves. Or here: Worldometers coronavirus Denmark. We aren't quite there yet, but we have been on our way after the lockdown started in mid-March. The number of deaths per day started dropping in early April and we are slowly, cautiously opening up after the lockdown.

Lots of countries have porous borders. Maybe this can be done, but I am doubtful and the amount of time this is going to take with control measures in place messing with world trade is going to be huge. Good luck auditing China to make sure they aren't lying about any outbreaks they may have.


Do you realize that you are trying to turn every difficulty into an impossibility? Yes, you are doubtful and it takes time, so ....
Are you aware that most countries let the transportation of goods continue? That it's just people that are prevented from crossing the borders - unless absolutely necessary and in that case looking forward to two weeks of quarantine? People are carriers, other stuff isn't.

It might depend how much you personalize the cost of removing the virus globally. It's also not obvious to me given that you think the virus can be wiped out in poorer countries with a vaccine, why not wiping it out in advance of a vaccine in the rich countries means it becomes endemic and we must live with it forever.


????

I hadn't heard before that the plan was to isolate the ******** countries. They are going to collapse and starve.


Are you actually concerned about these countries, or are you just pretending for the sake of the argument? Would you rather see them die from coronavirus and starve?
 
I wonder whether countries closer to the equator will be able to capitalise on the relative safety of the outdoors in combating this. It might be more difficult in big cities of course, but rural tropical and subtropical areas could do many or even most things out of doors and really cut down transmission. (In fact I just had a friend remark to me that she's heard someone say that it's being speculated that Africa is faring relatively well so far because so much of life happens outside.)

Even in Mediterranean climates in the summer this could be done to great effect. This is a virus that is transmitted within the home and in crowded, poorly ventilated rooms. Cut out the crowded poorly ventilated rooms and you break the transmission where the virus is taken back into the home.


The transmission rate in Africa south of the Sahara seems to have been considerably slower than in Europe.
 
Last edited:
Yes, we can! In Sweden, too!

I Ale kommun finns fem äldreboenden, alla i kommunal regi. Hittills har ingen av de 180 vårdtagarna blivit sjuk i covid-19 medan det i Göteborg, en halvtimme bort, har kommit in smitta på över hälften av stadens äldreboenden. Det förklaras med att man bland annat var snabbt ute med att införa besöksförbud, att vårdpersonal tidigt har fått testats för covidsmittan, men även det goda samarbetet med näringslivet i kommunen lyfts fram.
I Ale finns ingen covidsjuk på äldreboenden (SVT.se, May 18, 2020)
Translation:
In the municipality of Ale, there are five retirement homes, the municipality is in charge of all of them. So far, none of the 180 residents have come down with Covid-19, whereas in Göteborg, 30 minutes away by car, more than half of the retirement homes have been infected. The explanation is that, among other things, they introduced a ban on visits very early on, the staff was tested for coronavirus, but the cooperation with local businesses is also mentioned.
In Ale, nobody has Covid-19 in retirement homes
 
I think now that it's known that outdoor contact can be managed safely, a lot can be done with this. So far I think it's been more luck than anything, but if countries with good potential for outdoor working can really organise to achieve that then I think a lot can be done. Even in countries with less favourable climates it's something that's capable of being used to good effect.
 
And it isn't really bad if it's not as bad as the plague, is it?
Rolf was saying that coronavirus has the potential to affect our lives in quite profound ways. It seems to me that there are three ways a disease can impact our lives. There is the way in which all significant and potentially life threatening disease do, that they physically impact us directly when we get sick, or those around us get sick, but the odds of it doing so appear to be pretty low for any given person. On an individual level, I don't see that coronavirus is particularly special that way. (perhaps I was wrong?) I assumed that wasn't the profound impact Rolfe was talking about. Then you have direct societal effects. Black Death wiped out so many people it directly and profoundly impacted society, Coronavirus clearly doesn't have an impact like that. Finally you have the impact caused by our reaction. This seems to be where most of the impact for most people is felt. I took Rolfe to be meaning some conflated version of the last two.

The only way coronavirus is likely to impact most of us is the third of those options.

In early March people could be forgiven for believing that Covid-19 wasn't worse than the flu. Not anymore.
It depends in what way you mean it and I mean it. Imagine we are some amount of time in the future where all this has stabilized and suppose the attempt at containment has failed. Suppose further that we manage it like we manage the flu. How many deaths do you suppose there might be in the US annually from this? I'd like to understand what you are imagining.

We don't yet know how long the immunity will last.
Well, to the extent that you are doubtful about this, you really aren't talking about having a vaccine and being able to wipe this out in poorer countries, are you?

Which is why some countries have understood that behaving like Sweden is a bad idea. New York understood too late that the White House wasn't gonna do ****.
Let's not turn this into an argument about Trump. In any case, I don't see what not being able to contain it in India and Africa has to do with Sweden. If as you fear, immunity is impossible, then some natural equilibrium with the virus will eventually be reached.

I live in one of the Danish hotspots. So far, I haven't noticed any "authoritarian control measures" around here. Why does it suddenly become a question of eliminating the virus globally unlike locally? Is there any contradiction between the two things? It can be cone locally. The Faroe Islands and Iceland were mentioned several times in this thread, and they are not exactly Asian. And if many more countries get the virus under control locally, it will be much easier to help out third-world countries that can't.
A small island can clearly control this by controlling immigration in a way that larger, denser populations with more porous borders can't. Without a vaccine, good luck implementing social distancing and contact tracing in Kolkata. Have you seen what their transport system is like? Being able to do this in Faroe tells you less than half a percent of nothing about whether this can be done globally.

Parks and beaches are not the problem. See previous posts today in this thread about the spread of the virus outdoors. What you 'just don't think' is uninteresting unless you have an argument for what you just don't think.
People are told they are not allowed to go, but they go anyway. If you can't stop people gathering in public like that, I don't think you are going to be able to hold the line you want to hold as long as you want to hold it. It will differ by contry and culture of course.

celand? New Zealand? Or look at the Danish graphs and curves. Or here: Worldometers coronavirus Denmark. We aren't quite there yet, but we have been on our way after the lockdown started in mid-March. The number of deaths per day started dropping in early April and we are slowly, cautiously opening up after the lockdown.
Sure, the death rate is dropping in Sweden too. If you socially distance it drops. What hasn't been shown is that you can sustain the current way of living long term, or that we are capable of keeping it at contact tracing levels long term. If significnat numbers of people are ignoring the rules now, imagine how many will be ignoring it in 6 months.

Do you realize that you are trying to turn every difficulty into an impossibility?
Apologies for having a different opinion to you on whether this is going to work or not.

Yes, you are doubtful and it takes time, so ....
And all the while the cost grows higher. There is presumably some tipping point here?

Are you aware that most countries let the transportation of goods continue?
Yes.

That it's just people that are prevented from crossing the borders - unless absolutely necessary and in that case looking forward to two weeks of quarantine? People are carriers, other stuff isn't.
To be honest, I think the issue is going to be more porous borders than transportation of goods, and lack of compliance with social distancing rules within countries. Even our political leaders aren't able to stick to the rules. Who knows though? Plus richer European countries seem willing enough to import foreign labourers during the crisis. Are we really that comitted to locking this down?

But looking at transportation... imagine I want to transport a truck load of goods from Romania to the UK. Are you saying that at each country the trailer will be unhitched and a new cab and driver will continue the journey, or will somebody physically move with the goods from country to country? I don't know, so I'm asking. Again, we were transporting Romanian asparagus pickers across Europe a few weeks back, and those were people.

Are you actually concerned about these countries, or are you just pretending for the sake of the argument? Would you rather see them die from coronavirus and starve?
Shocking and unexpected as it may be, your side doesn't have the monopoly on caring. It doesn't seem to me like the central issue is whether people die from the coronavirus, or something else... but right now starvation is coming if things don't start returning to normal. Maybe it's worth it? I haven't seen a comparison.
 
Last edited:
Have there not even been false positives?

Also, are they doing this testing randomly, or is a lot of the testing on people related to the known cases? Maybe the testing is heavily skewed to finding people related to known cases?

While it's not random, my workplace has been given the option of testing tomorrow. We're a elderly care centre though so as I note, not entirely random.
 
Also, are they doing this testing randomly, or is a lot of the testing on people related to the known cases? Maybe the testing is heavily skewed to finding people related to known cases?

...random surveillance testing began around the country last month and is continuing to this day.

https://www.tvnz.co.nz/one-news/new...ance-covid-19-testing-stations-around-country

That's in addition to targeted testing of vulnerable groups of people, retesting people from existing clusters, and essentially anyone else that has symptoms and feel they need a test.
 
As an additional point, note that the contact tracer apps they're developing are being programmed to alert you to a possible contact if you've been within a certain distance of someone infected for a particular length of time. They're not worried about someone who has just walked past you. They're more concerned that you might have been on a bus with someone infected without realising it.

I think these apps are a useful adjunct to traditional contact tracing, particularly because they may pick up contacts you didn't know about or didn't think about. You could tell the contact tracer you had been on a particular bus, but then some way is needed to alert other people who were on that bus at that time. However they're a very blunt instrument. They don't take account of whether an encounter was indoors or out of doors, or of whether either party was wearing any sort of PPE, or of whether anyone was performing an aerosol-generating activity.

So I think England is going to be screwed if it thinks it can rely on an app (that many people are already vowing never to download) and skimp on the boots-on-the-ground traditional contact tracing protocol. And since we have a completely open border with England (well not so much right now but they'll never let us maintain border checks) I really hope they get their act together.
I agree with all this but I wanted to point out it's hard to do contact tracing at places like restaurants, movie theaters, airports and the like. You make a public announcement, "if you were at such and such at so and so time, contact public health." That works better when you are offering a vaccine or other treatment. If people think all you are going to do is quarantine them, I'm not sure what the compliance rate would be.
 
I wonder whether countries closer to the equator will be able to capitalise on the relative safety of the outdoors in combating this. It might be more difficult in big cities of course, but rural tropical and subtropical areas could do many or even most things out of doors and really cut down transmission. (In fact I just had a friend remark to me that she's heard someone say that it's being speculated that Africa is faring relatively well so far because so much of life happens outside.)

Even in Mediterranean climates in the summer this could be done to great effect. This is a virus that is transmitted within the home and in crowded, poorly ventilated rooms. Cut out the crowded poorly ventilated rooms and you break the transmission where the virus is taken back into the home.

There might be a lot of fresh air if you live in a warm climate, but diseases like TB which require close indoor setting to be transmitted are rampant in many 'open air' countries.

Countries with highest TB rates

I don't think the rumor is true that countries in Africa are faring well when it comes to COVID 19. Chances are better they aren't testing or counting.
 
By the way Sweden has saved billions of SEK for every single day that it has kept primary and lower-secondary schools open. Closing schools costs society a lot of money in the long run. Staff shortages are the main problem: many teachers are in risk groups and anyone who feels sick is supposed to stay home, but it's not like they are piling up dead.

Both Norwegian and Danish experts did not recommend the closing of schools but politicians felt pressured to conform to the "consensus" of shutting down everything.
 
By the way Sweden has saved billions of SEK for every single day that it has kept primary and lower-secondary schools open. Closing schools costs society a lot of money in the long run. Staff shortages are the main problem: many teachers are in risk groups and anyone who feels sick is supposed to stay home, but it's not like they are piling up dead.

Both Norwegian and Danish experts did not recommend the closing of schools but politicians felt pressured to conform to the "consensus" of shutting down everything.

I am sure the near Thirty-Seven Hundred dead are just thrilled that their sacrifice saved so much money for the wealthy and the Government.
 
By the way Sweden has saved billions of SEK for every single day that it has kept primary and lower-secondary schools open. Closing schools costs society a lot of money in the long run. Staff shortages are the main problem: many teachers are in risk groups and anyone who feels sick is supposed to stay home, but it's not like they are piling up dead.

Both Norwegian and Danish experts did not recommend the closing of schools but politicians felt pressured to conform to the "consensus" of shutting down everything.


And the attempts to reopen the schools now are completely bizarre and traumatizing to every child. They are made afraid of each other with the teachers wearing masks and themselves not allowed to play together. It is ridiculous and comes at a very high cost for society which is far greater than the plus in deaths Sweden has even if we attribute them totally to the not happened lockdown. We are talking under 4000 deaths most of them in categories that would have died from other causes sooner or later after all. You are lucky.
 
And the attempts to reopen the schools now are completely bizarre and traumatizing to every child. They are made afraid of each other with the teachers wearing masks and themselves not allowed to play together. It is ridiculous and comes at a very high cost for society which is far greater than the plus in deaths Sweden has even if we attribute them totally to the not happened lockdown. We are talking under 4000 deaths most of them in categories that would have died from other causes sooner or later after all. You are lucky.

Officer, I don't understand why you are arresting me for murder, all the people I shot would have died from other causes sooner or later after all.
 
Which is why I didn't say so: "in general people don't seem to get infected outside - unless they touch, hug, kiss, drink from the same glass or bottle, share a joint ...

You point out a hypothetical possibility that the coronavirus may be able to transmitted in that way. And for the same reason, running/jogging has been banned in my local park, Frederksberg Have. (Running and jogging as such hasn't been banned, however. It has been moved to the neighboring park, Søndermarken.)
I don't disagree with you, it just doesn't seem to be the way it happens, unless ...

As highly infectious as Covid19 is - said by some experts to be up to ten times more contagious than flu - it seems generally agreed that usually you need to spend some time with an infected person, perhaps in the same room for at least ten minutes to get infected, so I dare say nine times out of ten a chance encounter of someone in the street or in the shop is unlikely to give you much of a viral load.

However, there was a news story about a woman who died of Covid 19, in the risk group, whose son thought she must have got it from her once a week shop as she was isolated otherwise. Does seem to be incredibly bad luck.

Here in Finland high risk groups, including the over-70's can do their shopping first thing in the morning before official opening time, which seems a good idea. Not sure they should mix with healthcare professionals as they do in UK early opening, as a large percentage of them have been infected many without even realising. A study showed that someone coughing or sneezing in the next aisle can shower you with their aerosol, so that is probably true of someone sneezing or coughing in the street within yards of your passing.

Cheltenham was considered safe by UK scientists but is thought to have been the cause of a huge surge in infections in that region so IMV the reasoning is a little faulty that fresh air conveys some kind of protection. A crowd is a crowd.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom