Sweden's liberal pandemic strategy questioned as Stockholm death toll mounts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Except that the only known case of outdoor transmission was from a fairly prolonged face to face conversation. Cigarette smoke doesn't carry virus particles. You won't get an infective dose of this virus from a momentary exposure to a whiff of aerosol downwind of someone. It doesn't work like that.

The three ways this virus can be transmitted.

  1. Large droplet transmission (Flügge droplets) is the commonest one. These droplets don't hang in the air but fall quite rapidly to the ground only a short distance and time from where they were expelled.
  2. Small droplet aerosols are serious when they happen but are uncommon. These droplets do not fall to the ground but are suspended in the air, remaining infective for perhaps 30 minutes. Crucially however they are only a risk indoors where a room may fill up with these aerosols and infect anyone in the airspace. They dissipate almost immediately out of doors. These droplets are produced during shouting, singing, coughing and sneezing so don't be in a room where anyone has been doing that.
  3. Fomite transmission is touch transmission. Again mainly indoors because the virus doesn't survive long in the sunlight and the drying effect of wind.
A crucial point is infective dose. One faceful of Flügge droplets from a single cough can transmit the virus. You need to breathe aerosol for some time before you get sufficient virus particles. Also fomite transmission needs an infective dose not just to be picked up but transferred from the hand to the mouth nose or eyes.

So out of doors is extremely safe so long as you don't talk (or shout or sing or cough or sneeze) right into somoene's face, don't hug or kiss or shake hands, and don't touch your face without washing your hands (or using hand sanitiser) first. Aerosol transmission is not going to get you in the fresh air.

I would argue that when you inhale someones cigarette fumes (as when one can smell it) you are inhaling what they have just exhaled. And this includes their germs.

Saying 'outdoors is extremely safe' is an exaggeration.
 
And the attempts to reopen the schools now are completely bizarre and traumatizing to every child. They are made afraid of each other with the teachers wearing masks and themselves not allowed to play together. It is ridiculous and comes at a very high cost for society which is far greater than the plus in deaths Sweden has even if we attribute them totally to the not happened lockdown. We are talking under 4000 deaths most of them in categories that would have died from other causes sooner or later after all. You are lucky.

Infantile comment.
 
I am sure the near Thirty-Seven Hundred dead are just thrilled that their sacrifice saved so much money for the wealthy and the Government.
This is pretty much the way all socialized medicine works. If the actuarial tables say you probably only have another couple of years of life in you, we don't spend $10M on treating the thing currently trying to kill you. The return on investment in terms of quality adjusted life years just isn't worth it. This ordinary calculation that we do every day has gone out the window because of politics.
 
There are a good number of sources, I'll try to look some up. In all the studies done so far, only one single case of outdoor transmission has been identified, someone in China who stood talking to someone who had just flown in from Wuhan before social distancing was in force.

Aerosol transmission can't occur in the open air. Fomites are a much smaller problem because the virus survives less well and the chances of a single object getting heavily contaminated are low. (I wouldn't trust a heavily-used cash dispenser mind you.) Flügge droplets are easily avoided by maintaining the 2 metre distance from anyone you're talking to.

You can't catch this from someone who just walks or runs or cycles past you. It has to be fairly heavy face-to-face contact, or breathing an aerosol for some time (not possible out of doors) or touching a heavily contaminated surface and then your mouth, nose or eyes. All these things happen inside and are unlikely to impossible in the open air.

The micromanagement of outdoor behaviour seen in this pandemic has been a bit irrational. It seems to have started with an attempt to avoid households mixing, and obviously it's easier to prevent people going into other people's houses if you make them stay in their own. It reached its absolute nadir in Spain where authorities went out and sprayed a beach with bleach to "keep the children safe" the day before kids were to be allowed out for a short time each day. Nobody had been on the beach in weeks, it was absolutely totally virus free, and they killed an entire ecosystem.

If you really don't want to catch this, simply do not be in any indoor space with another human being, and don't talk outdoors with close face-to-face contact with anyone. Choose large shops with a big air space, exercise social distancing, don't touch your face, and get in and out as fast as you can.

This virus is actually quite easy not to catch if you're not obliged to get up close and personal with people, or to work in a stuffy poorly ventilated room. It's one of the easiest things to eradicate that I've come across because it only requires some fairly doable behavioural modifications. I think this is becoming more and more realised, as countries understand that it's not rocket science it's just logistics, and actually it's a pretty nasty disease we'll be better off without.


I think you are overstating the case. When I have been outdoors recently I have rhinitis and sneezing. I am pretty confident this is due to birch pollen, as I have the associated allergy to cherries and other stoned fruit (although interestingly, not to hazlenuts, which is supposed to be part of this syndrome). OK so I am never far from a forest. Yet this hayfever happens regardless of whether a birch tree is nearby, so clearly fresh air is not the vacuum you claim, as all kinds of particles are in the air.

The virus, of course, needs a host. You will only catch it from said host. This applies indoors or outdoors. If someone is a host they are equally infectious outdoors or in.
 
I'm not sure that the disease is likely to impact a very large percent of the population in profound ways. Its the reaction to it that is doing that. This isn't exactly the black death.


Yes, business as usual like flu. That is clearly socially acceptable since we tolerate it with flu.


The only way you can get that is if you keep preventing the vast majority of people from being infected. So long as that is the case, sure I can see this running forever. The more people who've had it, surely the more outbreaks will be self limiting?


I don't think we stopped the world in this way to eliminate any of those diseases. As you say later on, the only real plan is a vaccine. India, Africa etc don't seem likely to be able to tackle this by contact tracing, so the future is the same regardless. Were we all to behave like Sweden or New York, the end game is the same.


Maybe, but we aren't going to be able to use the level of authoritarian control measures they use in Asia and I doubt our ability to eliminate the virus globally in this way anyway. So we wait on a vaccine, and the endgame is presumably similar regardless of the strategy.


I have no objections to soft social distancing. That seems to be doing the bulk of the work to keep the numbers down. I question the ability of government to enforce this much longer - see parks and beaches full of people. I just don't think it is remotely possible to control this globally.


All islands, the Faroes have a population of 50,000. The Faroes managing to get this down to zero tells us nothing about whether this is handlable globally. It's like pointing to getting 10% of the way to renewable energy, or 500m of hyperloop track and thinking that tells you the other remainder of the task is within your grasp.


Lots of countries have porous borders. Maybe this can be done, but I am doubtful and the amount of time this is going to take with control measures in place messing with world trade is going to be huge. Good luck auditing China to make sure they aren't lying about any outbreaks they may have.


It might depend how much you personalize the cost of removing the virus globally. It's also not obvious to me given that you think the virus can be wiped out in poorer countries with a vaccine, why not wiping it out in advance of a vaccine in the rich countries means it becomes endemic and we must live with it forever.


I hadn't heard before that the plan was to isolate the ******** countries. They are going to collapse and starve.

It's not like the Black Death in that that was caused by a bacteria strain. However, there are lessons we can learn from it. Black Death was at its worst in Europe after five or six years of torrential rain that caused disastrous flooding and crop failure. Many died of famine. This meant that when the Black Death made its appearance, children who had been born during the famine had a compromised immune system - lack of vitamins and nutrients - thus, as adults, whole populations succumbed very quickly to Black Death.

A key lesson is, keep your immune system strong. Eat a good diet, exercise and don't get fat!
 
It's not like the Black Death in that that was caused by a bacteria strain. However, there are lessons we can learn from it. Black Death was at its worst in Europe after five or six years of torrential rain that caused disastrous flooding and crop failure. Many died of famine. This meant that when the Black Death made its appearance, children who had been born during the famine had a compromised immune system - lack of vitamins and nutrients - thus, as adults, whole populations succumbed very quickly to Black Death.

A key lesson is, keep your immune system strong. Eat a good diet, exercise and don't get fat!
It's not like the black death in that it does not directly damage society and the economy. The main long term impact of the black death was reshaping the economic and social landscape of Europe. It did that pretty directly by halving the population over a century. Any long term impact from coronavirus will be caused by us deciding to change society.
 
Last edited:
I wonder whether countries closer to the equator will be able to capitalise on the relative safety of the outdoors in combating this. It might be more difficult in big cities of course, but rural tropical and subtropical areas could do many or even most things out of doors and really cut down transmission. (In fact I just had a friend remark to me that she's heard someone say that it's being speculated that Africa is faring relatively well so far because so much of life happens outside.)

Even in Mediterranean climates in the summer this could be done to great effect. This is a virus that is transmitted within the home and in crowded, poorly ventilated rooms. Cut out the crowded poorly ventilated rooms and you break the transmission where the virus is taken back into the home.

The other theory is that they have a young population.
 
By the way Sweden has saved billions of SEK for every single day that it has kept primary and lower-secondary schools open. Closing schools costs society a lot of money in the long run. Staff shortages are the main problem: many teachers are in risk groups and anyone who feels sick is supposed to stay home, but it's not like they are piling up dead.

Both Norwegian and Danish experts did not recommend the closing of schools but politicians felt pressured to conform to the "consensus" of shutting down everything.

Sorry to have to tell you. Sweden's economy is forecast to plunge by 6.5% anyway.
 
And the attempts to reopen the schools now are completely bizarre and traumatizing to every child. They are made afraid of each other with the teachers wearing masks and themselves not allowed to play together. It is ridiculous and comes at a very high cost for society which is far greater than the plus in deaths Sweden has even if we attribute them totally to the not happened lockdown. We are talking under 4000 deaths most of them in categories that would have died from other causes sooner or later after all. You are lucky.

Sheesh, the measures are only temporary. ISTM that the UK seeing its death toll drop - or so it seems as it believes the 840 deaths on 8 Apr 20 was the peak, thus ipso facto all other numbers, being lower gives the appearance of a 'falling rate' slope, when it might just have been a standard deviation outlier, a mathematical fluke, but still within the bounds of normal distribution - are now so fed up of its quasi-lockdown they are all rushing back to 'normality'.

As well as the quaint belief that one day's high number designates the 'peak' UK scientists also seem to believe that as children are at much lower risk of having the serious version of the illness, then it is safe for them to carry on back to school as normal (as long as they wash their hands).

This might well be true but ISTM the assumptions all these measures are based on are quite shaky.

So Finland's primary school children have been back at school since last Thursday for the last two weeks of term. Only between 50 - 70% turned up.
 
Sheesh, the measures are only temporary. ISTM that the UK seeing its death toll drop - or so it seems as it believes the 840 deaths on 8 Apr 20 was the peak, thus ipso facto all other numbers, being lower gives the appearance of a 'falling rate' slope, when it might just have been a standard deviation outlier, a mathematical fluke, but still within the bounds of normal distribution - are now so fed up of its quasi-lockdown they are all rushing back to 'normality'.
Have you looked at the graph?
 
By the way Sweden has saved billions of SEK for every single day that it has kept primary and lower-secondary schools open. Closing schools costs society a lot of money in the long run. Staff shortages are the main problem: many teachers are in risk groups and anyone who feels sick is supposed to stay home, but it's not like they are piling up dead.

Both Norwegian and Danish experts did not recommend the closing of schools but politicians felt pressured to conform to the "consensus" of shutting down everything.


1) With its reckless coronavirus strategy, Sweden has saved billions of imaginary SEKs every single day ...
2) ... in long run, according to Arcade22's wishful thinking and based on ... nothing at all, apparently.
3) As we all know by now (or ought to know, apparently), asymptomatic cases spread the virus just as well as symptomatic ones.
4) No, it's not like they are piling up dead. Nobody expected it to be like the plague, but an imaginary grotesquely exaggerated scenario can always be used to put any tragedy into perspective, can't it?!
5) You wouldn't happen to have any links to the alleged "Norwegian and Danish experts", would you?
6) And some links to the alleged "consensus" that the politicians allegedly felt pressured to comfort would be nice, too!
 
Last edited:
[...]On an individual level, I don't see that coronavirus is particularly special that way. (perhaps I was wrong?) I assumed that wasn't the profound impact Rolfe was talking about. Then you have direct societal effects. Black Death wiped out so many people it directly and profoundly impacted society, Coronavirus clearly doesn't have an impact like that. [...]

Last week I spoke to someone I know who lives in Madrid. He told me that he knows 15 people who have died of covid near him. (his workmate´s dad, his brother-in law´s dad etc. etc.) 15!!! He sounded quite worried, so even if he had not suffered the illness himself, he clearly felt its impact.
 
Cheltenham was considered safe by UK scientists but is thought to have been the cause of a huge surge in infections in that region so IMV the reasoning is a little faulty that fresh air conveys some kind of protection. A crowd is a crowd.


Cheltenham racecourse is full of bars and restaurants and viewing boxes and toilets and corridors and many people would have got there by public transport. There's probably not a single person there who was out in the open air the entire day.

Having said that, people in close proximity in the open air when there's a lot of animated conversation and shouting going on, is undoubtedly a risk of transmitting the virus. It's not the same as a casual encounter in a street or a footpath. I just don't think Cheltenham is any sort of a gotcha.

However, there was a news story about a woman who died of Covid 19, in the risk group, whose son thought she must have got it from her once a week shop as she was isolated otherwise. Does seem to be incredibly bad luck.


A shop is not outdoors. Shops vary in terms of risk and many people are disinfecting shopping bags and packaging as well as wearing gloves and handwashing. It's always possible that an aerosol might be present in a shop, although as you say it was very bad luck.

Shopping, if carried out with all due precautions, is not a high risk activity, but it is most certainly a risk and it's a completely different situation to open-air transmission.
 
Last edited:
Meanwhile, in the real world

After taming COVID-19, Iceland re-opens with confidence (ScienceBusiness, May 14, 2020)

COVID-19 lessons from Iceland: How one Nordic country has all but stopped the virus in its tracks (GeekWire, May 17, 2020) Many good graphs and curves showing the strategies of the Nordic countries.

Norway prime minister's message to travelers: If you don't have a work reason to come, we'll send you back (CNN, May 18, 2020)

April blev måneden med den højeste dødelighed i Sverige i 27 år (DR.dk, May 18, 2020)
April was the month with the highest mortality in Sweden in 27 years

Ægtepar afvist ved færgen: Måtte sejle hele vejen tilbage til Sverige (TV2, May 18, 2020)
Married couple with the ferry to Denmark turned away: Had to go all the way back to Sweden
 
Last edited:
The virus, of course, needs a host. You will only catch it from said host. This applies indoors or outdoors. If someone is a host they are equally infectious outdoors or in .
:boggled:

You ignored the sciencie bit about how the virus infects people. You need to inhale hundreds, if not thousands of viral particles to become infected.
It's the difference between smelling a waft of smoke as a smoker walks by outside and being in a room with a smoker. The difference in the amount of smoke you'd inhale is HUGE.
 
Last week I spoke to someone I know who lives in Madrid. He told me that he knows 15 people who have died of covid near him. (his workmate´s dad, his brother-in law´s dad etc. etc.) 15!!! He sounded quite worried, so even if he had not suffered the illness himself, he clearly felt its impact.

April 20 in this thread:
A colleague of mine died today from Covid19. He went home from work on april 3rd, was taken into intensive care over Easter and passed away this morning after seeming to get better over last week. He was 39 years old.
 
Last week I spoke to someone I know who lives in Madrid. He told me that he knows 15 people who have died of covid near him. (his workmate´s dad, his brother-in law´s dad etc. etc.) 15!!! He sounded quite worried, so even if he had not suffered the illness himself, he clearly felt its impact.
Spain has had around 28k deaths out of a population of 47 million. That's a death rate in the population of 0.06%. Obviously that isn't remotely evenly distributed, but your friend's experience is wildly atypical.
 
The virus, of course, needs a host. You will only catch it from said host. This applies indoors or outdoors. If someone is a host they are equally infectious outdoors or in.


Only if you kiss them - or shake hands with them and then put your fingers in your mouth afterwards.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom