Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh darn, DW News discredits the study because they don't consider it an actual study, but DW is neutral on the hypothesis.

Google translatedI can't read the captions to the true/false meter but I am totally guessing that's what it is. If you move the needle it looks like vote tallies. Maybe people reading this thread speak German and can fill us in.

ETA Maybe the meter is a referendum on the web site.

One side says:
And the other side says:Google translate leaves a lot to be desired.


Here's a link to the 105 page pdf but I don't know how to translate it. Does anyone else know?

scroll down to Studie zum Ursprung der Coronavirus-Pandemie


Edited to add from the Focus link:

I do not speak zee Deutsch, but it would be unusual not to have an English version of a scientific publication. It's the lingua franca for global sharing. Even most pre-prints use English. If it has merit, we should see a translation very soon.
 
More from TaiwanNews:

WHO inspector's 'natural hosts' experimented on in Wuhan lab There are a lot of specifics about the lab. Given it is unclear about the cred of the source, I'm just quoting this:
Meanwhile, an Australian geneticist who publishes scientific papers under the name Zhang Daoyu told Taiwan News in an email that the ferret-badger ACE2 receptor cannot bind to the S1 subunit of the spike protein. He added that animals cannot be infected with the disease in-vivo, and adaptations in them give a very different receptor-binding motif (RBM) than what is currently seen in SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.

Another of Daszak's claims is that rabbits were sold at the wet market and the animals "turn out to be quite susceptible to SARS-CoV-2." However, Zhang said that since the currently observed RBM of SARS-CoV-2 does not efficiently use ferret-badger ACE2 and is not optimal for binding to rabbit ACE2, this rules out the possibility the virus may have "naturally" adapted to these two species.....


From a conference the Institute's expert spoke at:
In an archive of the company's deleted press release, it stated that "Beijing Huironghe Technology Co., Ltd. has been deeply involved in the field of inhalation toxicology for many years." As a "special sponsor," the company demonstrated its "main oral and nose inhalation exposure systems."
Could be routine purging of old stuff. Needs checking for which I'm not going down that additional rabbit hole.


And mixed whether the Taiwan News is reliable:
What Daszak does not mention is that in 2019, a member of Shi Zhengli's team, assistant researcher Hu Ben (胡犇), embarked on high-risk GOF research on coronaviruses and chimeras in humanized mice at WIV. According to a researcher who goes by the pseudonym Billy Bostickson, and who is in contact with Taiwan News: "This research involved 'novel' bat coronaviruses inoculated into immuno-suppressed mice with humanized features, such as hACE2, and possibly humanized lungs, bone marrow, etc..."

No information about this research has been released to the public since the start of the pandemic, including data on the eight chimeric viruses WIV had been infecting the mice with. In fact, all the WIV institute's databases have been offline since the start of the pandemic for alleged "cybersecurity issues," including 100 unpublished sequences of bat betacoronaviruses, which need to be sequenced by international scientists, according to Bostickson.
If it was online and now it isn't, that seems like reliable news as it is easily checked.

But their source might as well be anonymous. Keep in mind the news source did rebut their own anonymous source.
 
Last edited:
This looks interesting and before you all go discounting what I'm posting here, keep in mind I am trying to post what I'm finding as I look for more objective evidence. I don't think all of this is unreliable even if some is:

Taiwan News
Researchers have uncovered accounts from the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) scientists and applications for patents for bat breeding that refute World Health Organization (WHO) inspector Peter Daszak's claims that the lab does not house live bats captured in the wild.

An international network of researchers and scientists investigating the origins of the coronavirus pandemic who call themselves DRASTIC (Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID-19) have found evidence from Chinese media reports that in fact the WIV scientists captured bats alive and kept them inside the lab. The lab has also filed two patents for cages to be used in bat breeding and one for lab accidents just before the start of the pandemic.

British zoologist and the president of EcoHealth Alliance Peter Daszak is the only individual to be part of both the WHO and The Lancet teams investigating the origins of the Wuhan coronavirus pandemic. However, he has long-term professional and financial ties with the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) spanning two decades and valued in the millions of dollars, which represents a conflict of interest.

Daszak has some rebuttal Tweets that no live bats were at the Institute, some deleted, you can all look for yourselves about that part of the report.


However, the team at DRASTIC uncovered comments made at a conference in 2017 by the director of the Center for Emerging Infectious Diseases at WIV, Shi Zhengli (石正麗) — also known as "Bat Woman" — claiming that she had experimented on live bats with Nipah. The Nipah virus is a highly infectious disease carried by bats that can easily be transmitted to other animals and humans and have a high mortality rate. ...

In an article posted on Sixth Tone in May of 2018, the news site interviewed WIV scientist Luo Dongsheng, who is part of a working group at the lab that sequences coronaviruses and enters the data into a genetic database. Luo describes the process of exploring Taiyi Cave in Xianning, Hubei Province, and collecting horseshoe bat samples and the bats themselves....

There are screenshots of things including this one:
In an archived article from ScienceNet.cn which has since been scrubbed from the internet, WIV scientist Zhang Huajun praised Shi for helping to feed the bats while the interns were out for the Lunar New Year holiday:

More:
In addition, an open-source intelligence consultant discovered that the WIV has filed at least two patents that appear to point to a bat breeding program in the lab. The first patent was filed in June of 2018 and was called "A kind of carnivorism bat rearing cage." The patent was granted in April of 2019.

There is a lot of good evidence there which suggests the lab has lied about housing live bats at the facility. It doesn't look like the usual tabloid fake news. These patents can be checked.

Here are two more with the last one being quite odd:
The second patent describes an artificial breeding method of feeding insectivorous bats with predatory insects, ensuring their safe "overwintering," and ensuring a "high breeding rate and survival rate." A third patent, filed in November of 2019, just one month before the first COVID-19 cases in Wuhan were announced, is an instrument designed to quickly stop the bleeding on a finger if it had been injured while working pathogenic viruses in a biosafety lab.

When I was a kid I was bit by someone's pet (hamster I think or a similar animal). It made two tiny little puncture wounds in my finger tip that spurted arterial blood. It wasn't scary because the punctures were so small and I remember watching it for a bit, showing it to the kids there before I put a bandaid on. I wonder what bat bites look like? Sorry, I digress...


I think that's enough rabbit holes for now.
 
Daszak's company, Eco Health Alliance, partnered with the Wuhan lab (by invitation from China) in the SARS research- specifically looking into the bat caves in Yunnan.

https://www.ecohealthalliance.org/2...ke-viruses-spilling-over-into-people-in-china

He might be forthright as he sees it, but there is a serious conflict of interest there.

eta: I should mention that Eco Health Alliance also has a grant from the US NIH- though not specific to China. Wuhan also had US money for research, and there is a partnership with Duke Medical (yeah the NC school) with both of them. Duke has a campus in Wuhan. Like many relationships, it's complicated.

Still, Daszak seems to be bending over quite a bit in China's favor. I think I'll go google what other scientists think of his responses. .....
 
Last edited:
From the WSJ bios of the WHO team, including Daszak.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/who-are-the-covid-investigators-11613401955

His (Daszak's) interest is understandable. The British-born U.S. citizen has deep ties with the WIV. Millions of U.S. government dollars went to his organization to fund research at the Chinese institution. Mr. Daszak, who has consistently defended the Chinese government, didn’t respond to a request for comment.

“You’re looking for small clusters of outbreaks that went to a clinic because they were severe and their symptoms were just like Covid,” Mr. Daszak said during a CNN interview from Wuhan earlier this month. “That didn’t happen. We didn’t see that in the data earlier than December.” Never mind that Washington said it found exactly that at the WIV.

While Mr. Daszak touted the “really remarkable openness from China,” other experts from the WHO committee complained about political pressure and uncooperative hosts blocking access to important data. The Australian team member Dominic Dwyer in particular deserves credit for speaking candidly.

eta: Emails show Daszak coordinated a letter discounting lab theories as 'crackpot' early on in Feb 2020. Wow, that is very early to discount any origin hypothesis!

https://www.independentsciencenews....ts-statement-on-natural-origin-of-sars-cov-2/
 
Last edited:
More Taiwan News but the podcast they are reporting on is embedded in the article

From Dec 2019 podcast uncovered by DRASTIC:
At the 28:10 mark of the podcast interview, Daszak states that researchers found that SARS likely originated from bats and then set out to find more SARS-related coronaviruses, eventually finding over 100. He observed that some coronaviruses can "get into human cells in the lab," and others can cause SARS disease in "humanized mouse models."...

When Racaniello asks what can be done to deal with coronavirus given that there is no vaccine or therapeutic for them, Daszak at the 29:54 mark appears to reveal that the goal of the GoF experiments was to develop a pan-coronavirus vaccine for many different types of coronaviruses.

More:
Based on his response, it is evident that just before the start of the pandemic, the WIV was modifying coronaviruses in the lab. "You can manipulate them in the lab pretty easily." What he then mentioned has become the telltale trait of SARS-CoV-2, its spike protein: "Spike protein drives a lot of what happens with the coronavirus, zoonotic risk."

Daszak mentions the WIV's collaboration with Baric: "and we work with Ralph Baric at UNC [University of North Carolina] to do this." As has been suggested by proponents that SARS-CoV-2 is a chimera made in a lab, he speaks of inserting the spike protein "into a backbone of another virus" and then doing "some work in the lab."

Providing evidence of the creation of chimeras for the sake of a vaccine, he states "Now, the logical progression for vaccines is, if you are going to develop a vaccine for SARS, people are going to use pandemic SARS, but let’s try to insert these other related diseases and get a better vaccine.”...

In a presentation titled "Assessing Coronavirus Threats," which was delivered four years before the pandemic in 2015, Daszak points out that experiments involving humanized mice have the highest degree of risk. Demonstrating his close ties with the WIV, he also listed the lab as a collaborator at the end of the presentation.
 
Last edited:
This is from the Aussie version of Spectator. I think the US version if they are related is a right-leaning news magazine.

Covid cuckoo clock - Australia is stuck in a viral Groundhog Day

It's mostly about treatments saying if you can't beat them treat them while lamenting shut down economies. But there is this:
And while the WHO team in Wuhan is being taken to visit museums, Dr Steven Quay, a top medical scientist, has published a paper concluding that there is a 99.8 per cent chance that Sars-Cov-2 escaped from a lab, that some of the early patients may have been part of a vaccine trial and that if this is the case, the research may have been part of a bioweapons program. This confirms the work of numerous scientists including a group of internet sleuths who use the jocular moniker DRASTIC (Decentralised Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating Covid-19) and who, over the last year, were able to piece together the evidence to show that the original bat virus was found in an abandoned mine in Mojiang and brought to Wuhan where it was made more infectious at the Wuhan Institute of Virology. It escaped between September and November 2019 and the Chinese government and its scientific shills in top Western universities have been engaged in a shameful cover-up ever since.
There's an assertion that Western universities are involved in a coverup. That plus the Steven Quay paper really drift off into CT territory. ( Bolded just so you know I am trying to be objective here even though I know some of you don't believe that.)

Is there a link to the Quay paper here? The number 99+% certainty rings a bell.
 
Always more rabbit holes to chase down:

Bibiography of COVID origin news reports

The links are embedded so go to the list yourself, plus people get annoyed if I post bibliographies. Some of them look like valid links like:
Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. Did the SARS-CoV-2 virus arise from a bat coronavirus research program in a Chinese laboratory? Very possibly. Milton Leitenberg. June 4, 2020....

The Washington Post. State Department cables warned of safety issues at Wuhan lab studying bat coronaviruses. Josh Rogin. April 14, 2020....

Houston Chronicle. UTMB scientist acknowledges safety risks at Chinese lab doing coronavirus research. Nick Powell. April 23, 2020. ...

Newsweek. The controversial experiments and Wuhan lab suspected of starting the coronavirus pandemic. Fred Guterl, Naveed Jamali and Tom O’Connor. April 27, 2020.

The Washington Post. State Department releases cable that launched claims that coronavirus escaped from Chinese lab. John Hudson and Nate Jones. July 17, 2020. ...

NBC News. Report says cellphone data suggests October shutdown at Wuhan lab, but experts are skeptical. Ken Dilanian, Ruaridh Arrow, Courtney Kube, Carol E. Lee, Louise Jones and Lorand Bodo. May 9, 2020. ...

The New York Times. In Hunt for Virus Source, W.H.O. Let China Take Charge. Selam Gebrekidan, Matt Apuzzo, Amy Qin and Javier C. Hernández. November 2, 2020....
Gawd, so much research is hard to trust, one more Trump gift that keeps on giving. The WA Po cites cables more than once. But that bibliography has all kinds of interesting avenues.

Useful notes from one of the science news papers
Genome sequence comparisons of viral samples from different patients infected by SARS-CoV-2 have revealed an identity rate of 99.98%, indicating that the strain emerged in humans very recently.
That makes sense, a fact I think we can rely on.

Interesting:
In addition, one fragment of this genome proved to be totally identical to another, made up of 370 nucleotides, sequenced in 2016 from samples collected in 2013 at a mine in China’s Yunnan province where three miners had died of severe pneumonia.
There's a review of all of the stuff we know and that has been discussed here including:
Isn’t there a risk that this last hypothesis may uphold the conspiracy theories about the Covid-19 pandemic?
É.D.: Studying the origin of SARS-CoV-2 is a scientific process that cannot be equated with a conspiracy theory. At the same time, I would like to underline the fact that, as long as no intermediate host has been identified, the scientific community cannot rule out the possibility of an accidental leak.

There's a lot of discussion about CTs including this:
Meanwhile, faced with the difficulty of understanding the origin of this pathogen, we have conducted phylogenetic analyses in collaboration with bioinformaticians and phylogeneticists. Their findings show that three of the four insertions observed in SARS-CoV-2 can be found in older coronavirus strains. Our study clearly shows that these sequences appeared independently, at different times in the evolutionary history of the virus. This data invalidates the hypothesis of a recent and intentional insertion by a laboratory of those three sequences.
But I'm not sure "intentional" rules out all chimera research. And in fact the paper continues:
That leaves the fourth insertion, which produces a furin protease cleavage site in SARS-CoV-2 that is not found in the other viruses of the SARS-CoV family. Consequently, the possibility cannot be ruled out that this insertion results from experiments designed to allow an animal virus to jump species to humans, since it is well known that this type of insertion plays a key role in the propagation of many pathogens in humans.


In any case, whether the virus is natural or not, the very fact that this question can now be seriously considered calls for a critical review of the reconstruction tools and methods being used in today’s research laboratories, and of their potential use in “gain-of-function” experiments.

That paper is well worth reading. I'm looking at more links from the bib.
 
Last edited:
Is there a link to the Quay paper here? The number 99+% certainty rings a bell.

Isn't that what the German scientist you posted about earlier said. Maybe this group are just saying this number.

So the theory now is that Ratg13 has been modified somehow to make Covid-19?

Is this the whole "gain of function" theory?

I think I'll just point out that the podcast in that Taiwan News link is TWiV (This Week in Virology). The host, Vincent Racaniello, has mentioned these types of theories in episodes I have listened to. I posted an episode in this thread, in fact. He doesn't find them compelling.

Also, the EcoHealth Alliance
focuses on diseases caused by deforestation and increased interaction between humans and wildlife. The organization has researched the emergence of diseases such as Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS), Nipah virus, Middle East Respiratory Syndrome (MERS), Rift Valley fever, and Ebola virus.
Link

They are mentioned in the book I am reading, Spillover, by David Quammen in relation to looking for the Ebola reservoir and about the interaction between forest life in Africa and how it got into humans and gorillas. In the book, there is also a big mystery surrounding how similar viruses ended up in the Philippines where they also seem to have a non-human reservoir. Much of the point of the book is just how incredibly difficult it is to discover the ways in which viruses can emerge from their reservoir hosts.

PeterDaszak is also mentioned in the book:
Peter Daszak is a British zoologist and an expert on disease ecology, in particular on zoonosis. He is currently president of EcoHealth Alliance, a nonprofit non-governmental organization that supports various programs on global health and pandemic prevention with headquarters in New York City. He is a researcher, consultant, and public expert in the cause and spread of zoonotic disease outbreaks like that of COVID-19, Ebola, Nipah virus, and other zoonoses

Link

I think it is a bit simplistic just to say, "Oh, he worked with the Wuhan lab before. Conflict of interest! Not to be trusted!"

Besides, here are the members of the group:

Members of the international team:

Prof. Dr. Thea Fisher, MD, DMSc(PhD) (Nordsjællands Hospital, Denmark)
Prof. John Watson (Public Health England, United Kingdom)
Prof. Dr. Marion Koopmans, DVM PhD (Erasmus MC, Netherlands)
Prof. Dr. Dominic Dwyer, MD (Westmead Hospital, Australia)
Vladimir Dedkov, Ph.D (Institute Pasteur, Russia)
Dr. Hung Nguyen-Viet, PhD (International Livestock Research Institute (ILRI), Vietnam)
PD. Dr. med vet. Fabian Leendertz (Robert Koch-Institute, Germany)
Dr. Peter Daszak, Ph.D (EcoHealth Alliance, USA)
Dr. Farag El Moubasher, Ph.D (Ministry of Public Health, Qatar)
Prof. Dr. Ken Maeda, PhD, DVM (National Institute of Infectious Diseases, Japan)
The international team also includes five WHO experts led by Dr Peter Ben Embarek; two Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) representatives and two World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) representatives.

So it is not as if it is just one lackey for the Chinese who is a part of this mission.

Link

I have to wonder if these DRASTIC scientists ("This confirms the work of numerous scientists including a group of internet sleuths who use the jocular moniker DRASTIC (Decentralised Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating Covid-19)") are the AE911 of Covid. Do they actually have the necessary qualifications? Or are they trying to fool people by simply having Dr or PhD in their title?

For example, who is Dr Steven Quay?
Dr. Steven Quay has 360+ published contributions to medicine and has been cited over 10,000 times, placing him in the top 1% of scientists worldwide. He holds 87 US patents and has invented seven FDA-approved pharmaceuticals which have helped over 80 million people. He is the author of the best-selling book on surviving the pandemic, Stay Safe: A Physician's Guide to Survive Coronavirus. He is the CEO of Atossa Therapeutics Inc. (Nasdaq: ATOS), a clinical-stage biopharmaceutical company developing novel therapeutics for treating breast cancer and COVID-19.

Link

I'm underwhelmed.

Who is Roland Wiesendanger?

Roland Wiesendanger (born October 5 1961 in Basel) is a German physicist, specializing in nanoscience. Since 1993 he has been a full professor at the University of Hamburg, Germany, where he established a National Center of Competence in Nanotechnology.

A physicist specializing in nanotechnology?

What makes him a reliable source?

Again, we have seen this before with Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth
 
October 2014: US suspends risky disease research- Government to cease funding gain-of-function studies that make viruses more dangerous, pending a safety assessment.
https://www.nature.com/news/us-suspends-risky-disease-research-1.16192

Given the US ban on the risky research following lab leaks in the US, any research would have moved to labs outside the US. No wonder I could not find much done here after 2015.

November 2015: Engineered bat virus stirs debate over risky research
Lab-made coronavirus related to SARS can infect human cells.
https://www.nature.com/news/engineered-bat-virus-stirs-debate-over-risky-research- 1.18787#/b1

The paper of the second one has this note:

Editors’ note, March 2020: We are aware that this article is being used as the basis for unverified theories that the novel coronavirus causing COVID-19 was engineered. There is no evidence that this is true; scientists believe that an animal is the most likely source of the coronavirus.

I do tend to believe the majority of scientists who have looked at it and determined it is not engineered- at least not the dice and splice way.
At the same time, I wonder why there was so much 'don't consider this theory!" so early when everything was speculation....and still is!
 
I think it is time to assume that the existence of the viral lab in Wuhan and the emergence of covid 19 in Wuhan are connected.
The onus should be on the investigators to demonstrate no connection.
 
Last edited:
NYT COVID articles still free access: IN HUNT FOR VIRUS SOURCE, W.H.O. LET CHINA TAKE CHARGE

This is why the WHO report needs to be taken with a grain of salt. The article is a study in how politics in this case interfered royally with the science.

As it praised Beijing, the World Health Organization concealed concessions to China and may have sacrificed the best chance to unravel the virus’s origins. Now it’s a favorite Trump attack line. ...The search for the virus’s origins is a study in the compromises the W.H.O. has made....

“Divisions between and within countries have provided fertile ground for this fast-moving virus to grow and gain the upper hand,” the W.H.O.’s director general, Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, said in a statement to The Times. He said political attacks had undermined the world’s response. “Leadership in a crisis such as this requires listening, understanding, trust and moving forward together.”
Kind of sums up the mess that's been made of looking for the origin.

Daszak's name shows up again:
“This is part of the Chinese psyche — to demonstrate to the world that they do the very best science,” said Peter Daszak, a disease ecologist and president of EcoHealth Alliance in New York. “But in this case, it didn’t work. And I think that is the reason why we don’t know much more.”

While Trump picked a fight with China over their initial response and Xi didn't want China to look like their surveillance was flawed, looking for the origin was lost in the shuffle.
On the origins of the virus, the experts mostly shifted the onus to China, asking the government to prioritize a “rigorous investigation.” But they also assured people that numerous investigations were underway.

“It was an absolute whitewash,” said Lawrence O. Gostin, a professor of global health law at Georgetown University. “But the answer was, that was the best they could negotiate with Xi Jinping.”...

Privately, Dr. Tedros told colleagues and others that he felt stuck between China and the United States. He compared them to two playground bullies....

“It is difficult to do this work in a politically intoxicated environment,” Dr. Ryan, the organization’s emergency director, said at a news conference later that day.

“It is hard for scientists to do what they have to do and want to do in situations like this,” he said.

Not much in the article that is helpful looking at the origin science. But it is important to understanding the WHO investigation. And I don't think a list of the WHO team members rebuts the political interference.
 
Last edited:
By the way, there is a more recent podcast episode with Peter Daszak, which you might be interested in (I haven't watched it yet, though)...

https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-623/#comments

In the comments, I noticed this...


So what's the story?

Well, apparently a joint British and Norwegian team claimed the virus showed elements of being man-made.

Then, in steps Vincent...

"The paper is nonsense," said Vincent Racaniello, Ph.D., professor of virology at Columbia University. "The manuscript is replete with incorrect science."

"It is absolutely 100% impossible that SARS-CoV-2 was made in a laboratory. The elements in the virus, SARS-CoV-2, all came from bat SARS-like CoVs that circulate in nature," Racaniello told ABC News.

What? But, wait, ... isn't he part of the International Global Conspiracy of Virologists along with all the others who are fiercely closing ranks to support the Wuhan Institute of Virology due to...what reason? Funding or something? Being secret Communists? Saving face?

Well, the researchers of this brave study made a prediction...

This time, the allegation stemmed from a team of researchers from Britain and Norway, who warned in a research paper that current efforts to make a coronavirus vaccine are likely to fail because scientists have fundamentally misunderstood the virus SARS-CoV-2 that causes COVID-19.

I guess we will have to wait and see if a vaccine ever gets made... oh wait!

Why would they say this, then?

The British/Norwegian team -- also working on a vaccine -- argued that their vaccine approach was likely to work where other existing efforts would fail. They claim the virus' RNA sequence has elements that appear man-made, or artificially inserted, and that their vaccine, Biovacc-19, will take these purported elements into account.

hmmmm....

Anyway, here come those so-called experts. The virologists!

"No scientist or group of scientists created this virus in a laboratory. That would require insight into [viral] pathogenesis and protein engineering that does not exist," said Robert Garry, Ph.D., virologist at Tulane University.

Garry explained that much of the genetic material of the virus that caused COVID-19 is similar to that found in viruses sampled from animals, and was unknown to science until after the pandemic, ruling out the possibility the virus was created beforehand in a lab.

The genetic material and genetic changes to the novel coronavirus are "all what you would expect from natural evolution and an animal source," said Amesh Adalja, MD, infectious disease fellow and senior scholar at Johns Hopkins Center for Health Security.

"There've been multiple rumors and conspiracy theories," he said. "And I do think you'll probably see more."
 
Well, no one here has yet made a pet theory of an engineered virus but it's always good to have all the info. Thanks for the links that shed a bit more light on what scientists are thinking.

That said, there is still the notion of a natural novel virus being linked to the lab, or the researchers who collaborated. Not engineered- or done in a 'controlled but natural' way (which from what I know is pretty unlikely but I am not a virologist).

Anthrax, smallpox, and even the plague have leaked from labs...and those were not engineered.
 
Last edited:
Here are the two Quay papers:

Zenodo. Where Did the 2019 Coronavirus Pandemic Begin and How Did it Spread? The People’s Liberation Army Hospital in Wuhan China and Line 2 of the Wuhan Metro System Are Compelling Answers. Steven Carl Quay. October 28, 2020. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.4119262

Zenodo. A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived. Dr. Steven Quay. January 29, 2021.

https://zenodo.org/record/4477081#
Wuhan Institute of Virology analysis of bronchial lavage specimens from ICU patients at Wuhan Jinyintan Hospital in December 2019 contain both SARS-CoV-2 and adenovirus vaccine sequences, consistent with a vaccine challenge trial.

In the acknowledgements:
I want to thank a Twitter group called #DRASTIC for many useful discussions that found their way into this document. Dr. Martin Lee, Ph.D., Adjunct Professor of Statistics at UCLA provided statistical support throughout this work. H. Lawrence Remmel provided input on the adenovirus vaccine as a dual target vaccine. I want to thank D.A. for originally suggesting performing a Bayesian analysis on the work I had done on SARS-CoV-2 and for his facilitation of the review of this work by a diverse group of scientists and policy makers. In all cases, however, this is my own work product.

From the executive summary:
Given the strong sentiment in the scientific community in favor of a zoonosis and the massive effort undertaken by China to find the natural animal source, one can assume that any evidence in favor of a natural origin, no matter how trivial, would become widely disseminated and known. This provides a potential evidence bias within the scientific community in favor of a natural origin which isn’t quantifiable but should be kept in mind.

This becomes especially important background....

The starting probability for origin of SARS-CoV-2 was set with the zoonotic or natural hypothesis at 98.8% likelihood with the laboratory origin hypothesis set at 1.2%. The initial state was biased as much as possible towards a zoonotic origin...

The most significant evidence provided herein is the finding from RNA-Seq performed by the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) of lavage patient samples collected on December 30, 2019.3 These ICU patients were the subject of the seminal paper, entitled, “A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin,” from Dr. Zhengli Shi and colleagues that first characterized SARS-CoV-2.4 This author has confirmed that the RNA-Seq of all five patients contained SARS-CoV-2 sequences. Surprisingly the specimens also contained the adenovirus “pShuttle” vector, developed by Chinese scientists in 2005 for SARS-CoV-1.5 Two immunogens were identified, the Spike Protein gene of SARS-CoV-2 and the synthetic construct H7N9 HA gene.6 Hundreds of perfectly homologous (150/150) raw reads suggest this is not an artefact. Reads that cross the vector-immunogen junction are identified. An example of the read contigs for CoV-2 is shown in this figure:
So Zhengli Shi's own work.


Controls:
Two patients from the same hospital who had bronchial lavage on the same day but had their specimens sent to the Hubei CDC did not have adenovirus vaccine sequences.

With CoV-2, every one of the more than 294,000 virus genomes sequenced can be traced back to the first genomic cluster and in the first patient in that cluster, a 39-year-old man who was seen at the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) Hospital about one mile from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. The CoV-2 pandemic has the phylogenetic signature of one pure virus sequence infecting one human, with human-to-human spread thereafter; there is just the one and only jump into the human population ever seen. This lack of posterior diversity has been alluded to by Dr. Shi, by the WHO, and by other prominent virologists; they just never take that critical piece of the evidence to the next the proper inference.

The virus in a true zoonosis also contains the signature record of the gradual changes and adaptions it made in the protein key, the Spike Protein, it uses to unlock human cells and cause infection. With SARS-CoV-1 the Spike Protein had fewer than one-third of all the changes it would later develop by the time it became an epidemic. With CoV-2 the Spike Protein was almost perfectly adapted to the human lock, using 99.5% of the best amino acids possible
So no gradual changes in the human infection and earlier I posted a reference to the fact that the genetic evidence is this pathogen has only been in the human population recently.

So it was a perfect match on the first jump? Quay compares this to SARS (1) which was not. I'm going to leave it to the people in this thread who "are not impressed" to sift through this scientific paper and find the faults in it. I'm not seeing them.
 
Isn't that what the German scientist you posted about earlier said. Maybe this group are just saying this number.
Nope, I tried to edit that post but I was too late.

So the theory now is that Ratg13 has been modified somehow to make Covid-19?

Is this the whole "gain of function" theory?
GoF is the type of study. Your oversimplification is underwhelming. ;)


I think I'll just point out that the podcast in that Taiwan News link is TWiV (This Week in Virology). The host, Vincent Racaniello, has mentioned these types of theories in episodes I have listened to. I posted an episode in this thread, in fact. He doesn't find them compelling.
He doesn't find who compelling and who cares? Listen to the couple minutes flagged in my link if you want to address the podcast.


... I think it is a bit simplistic just to say, "Oh, he worked with the Wuhan lab before. Conflict of interest! Not to be trusted!"
Good because NO ONE SAID THAT. :rolleyes:


...
I have to wonder if these DRASTIC scientists ("This confirms the work of numerous scientists including a group of internet sleuths who use the jocular moniker DRASTIC (Decentralised Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating Covid-19)") are the AE911 of Covid. Do they actually have the necessary qualifications? Or are they trying to fool people by simply having Dr or PhD in their title?
Again you try to discredit links by ad hominems.


For example, who is Dr Steven Quay?

Link

I'm underwhelmed.
Did you look at the research paper? Without looking at his work, I bet you are underwhelmed.:rolleyes:

I posted a link to the paper.


Who is Roland Wiesendanger?

A physicist specializing in nanotechnology?

What makes him a reliable source?

Again, we have seen this before with Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth
You need to keep up. We're past this now.
 
By the way, there is a more recent podcast episode with Peter Daszak, which you might be interested in (I haven't watched it yet, though)...

https://www.microbe.tv/twiv/twiv-623/#comments

In the comments, I noticed this...

So what's the story?

Well, apparently a joint British and Norwegian team claimed the virus showed elements of being man-made.

Then, in steps Vincent...

What? But, wait, ... isn't he part of the International Global Conspiracy of Virologists along with all the others who are fiercely closing ranks to support the Wuhan Institute of Virology due to...what reason? Funding or something? Being secret Communists? Saving face?

Well, the researchers of this brave study made a prediction...
Would you please take this crap to the CT thread? Some of us here are actually having an evidence-supported discussion and this sarcastic ad hom language is not moving the discussion forward.
And I don't want to watch a podcast you haven't listened to unless you flag segments you think are relevant. It suggests you aren't reading our posts where manmade was discussed. See post #149
This data invalidates the hypothesis of a recent and intentional insertion by a laboratory of those three sequences.
But I'm not sure "intentional" rules out all chimera research. And in fact the paper continues:
 
Last edited:
Here are the two Quay papers:

Zenodo. Where Did the 2019 Coronavirus Pandemic Begin and How Did it Spread? The People’s Liberation Army Hospital in Wuhan China and Line 2 of the Wuhan Metro System Are Compelling Answers. Steven Carl Quay. October 28, 2020. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.4119262

Zenodo. A Bayesian analysis concludes beyond a reasonable doubt that SARS-CoV-2 is not a natural zoonosis but instead is laboratory derived. Dr. Steven Quay. January 29, 2021.

https://zenodo.org/record/4477081#


In the acknowledgements:


From the executive summary:So Zhengli Shi's own work.


Controls:


So no gradual changes in the human infection and earlier I posted a reference to the fact that the genetic evidence is this pathogen has only been in the human population recently.

So it was a perfect match on the first jump? Quay compares this to SARS (1) which was not. I'm going to leave it to the people in this thread who "are not impressed" to sift through this scientific paper and find the faults in it. I'm not seeing them.

A non-peer-reviewed Word document by a non-expert, written in October 2020 that apparently nobody in the relevant fields of expertise has found interesting enough to follow-up on?

And it's 198 pages.

What's your TL;DR on this?
 
Would you please take this crap to the CT thread? Some of us here are actually having an evidence-supported discussion and this sarcastic ad hom language is not moving the discussion forward.
And I don't want to watch a podcast you haven't listened to unless you flag segments you think are relevant. It suggests you aren't reading our posts where manmade was discussed. See post #149

I said "which you might be interested in (I haven't watched it yet, though)."

If you are not interested in some virologists talking to each other and prefer DRASTIC instead, then that's fine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom