Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
SG, you might like this.

I found a recent video that our friend, Dr Steven Quay, posted on Twitter which is of a conference about the Origins & Spread of Coronaviruses" and Zhengli Shi is one of the speakers.

At one point (I have linked to that point), a man in the audience at the beginning of the Q&A asks Dr Shi about the Ratg13 virus even saying, "4% is not that close when you consider that humans and chimps are 99% similar".

Then he seems to spitball an idea asking if it's possible that two viruses have somehow been combined or if any... *totally innocent question alert* ...virologists present have been doing any studies to see if they can get a higher match.

Zhengli Shi asks him to repeat.

During this, it looks to me at some point (during the reasking of the second part of the question) that the woman sitting in front of him looks up and gives some side-eye as though saying, "Are you seriously asking..."

From what I could get, Zhengli Shi answers the questions straight, saying she is not sure at all if it is the closest, as for the second, she talks about recombination in same cells. But she says they simply don't know yet...

then a guy on the panel, Malik, points out that this stuff takes a lot of time and much of the stuff that we do know about SARS etc... has come from Zhengli's work. He speculates that there will probably be something found in bats, but it is going to take a long time. It's not easy; it takes years.

https://youtu.be/LSISkvlesnA?t=11006
 
SG, you might like this.

I found a recent video that our friend, Dr Steven Quay, posted on Twitter which is of a conference about the Origins & Spread of Coronaviruses" and Zhengli Shi is one of the speakers.

At one point (I have linked to that point), a man in the audience at the beginning of the Q&A asks Dr Shi about the Ratg13 virus even saying, "4% is not that close when you consider that humans and chimps are 99% similar".

Then he seems to spitball an idea asking if it's possible that two viruses have somehow been combined or if any... *totally innocent question alert* ...virologists present have been doing any studies to see if they can get a higher match.

Zhengli Shi asks him to repeat.

During this, it looks to me at some point (during the reasking of the second part of the question) that the woman sitting in front of him looks up and gives some side-eye as though saying, "Are you seriously asking..."

From what I could get, Zhengli Shi answers the questions straight, saying she is not sure at all if it is the closest, as for the second, she talks about recombination in same cells. But she says they simply don't know yet...

then a guy on the panel, Malik, points out that this stuff takes a lot of time and much of the stuff that we do know about SARS etc... has come from Zhengli's work. He speculates that there will probably be something found in bats, but it is going to take a long time. It's not easy; it takes years.

https://youtu.be/LSISkvlesnA?t=11006
Thank you. I haven't watched it yet but I'm looking forward to it.
 
Just to bring something up that I have discovered.

There is a bit of a spat going on between David Gorski of Science-based Medicine and someone called Kevin McCairn in the comments. Apparently Kevin McCairn's main claim regarding SARS CoV2 is that it isn't a virus, but a prion.

Kevin McCairn looks like a pretty nasty individual as well as a whack-job and he seems to be an anti-vaxxer as well.

Anyhow, when I looked into him relating to Covid-19, it turns out he is the co-author of a pre-print paper with Rosanna Segreto and Yuri Deigin claiming that Covid-19 came from a lab.

Yuri Deigin is someone active on social media claiming the escaped from a lab theory and was on Bret Weinstein's podcast.

Honestly, when these are some of the people pushing the escaped from a lab theory, it looks more and more like Trutherism than ever.
 
Just to bring something up that I have discovered.

There is a bit of a spat going on between David Gorski of Science-based Medicine and someone called Kevin McCairn in the comments. Apparently Kevin McCairn's main claim regarding SARS CoV2 is that it isn't a virus, but a prion.

Kevin McCairn looks like a pretty nasty individual as well as a whack-job and he seems to be an anti-vaxxer as well.

Anyhow, when I looked into him relating to Covid-19, it turns out he is the co-author of a pre-print paper with Rosanna Segreto and Yuri Deigin claiming that Covid-19 came from a lab.

Yuri Deigin is someone active on social media claiming the escaped from a lab theory and was on Bret Weinstein's podcast.

Honestly, when these are some of the people pushing the escaped from a lab theory, it looks more and more like Trutherism than ever.
Which is why besides maybe a mention, this belongs in the CT thread.

We are trying at least, to discuss the evidence of the COVID origin. That some CTer thinks it originated in the lab is not relevant in this thread.

It's ignorant to proclaim it is a prion. This is what I think of that: :rolleyes: So anything else the guy has to say belongs in the other forum.

Why do you argue it's a CT instead of addressing the actual evidence pro or con? Are you having trouble understanding the difference?
 
Last edited:
Which is why besides maybe a mention, this belongs in the CT thread.

We are trying at least, to discuss the evidence of the COVID origin. That some CTer thinks it originated in the lab is not relevant in this thread.

It's ignorant to proclaim it is a prion. This is what I think of that: :rolleyes: So anything else the guy has to say belongs in the other forum.

Why do you argue it's a CT instead of addressing the actual evidence pro or con? Are you having trouble understanding the difference?

I'm flagging those people up just in case you find yourself reading their stuff or being referred to it. Best to know who they are. It's a public service.

Besides, even if they are crazy people, it doesn't mean it didn't escape from a lab.
 
Okay, now this is interesting...

A World Health Organization team investigating the origins of Covid-19 is planning to scrap an interim report on its recent mission to China amid mounting tensions between Beijing and Washington over the investigation and an appeal from one international group of scientists for a new probe.
The group of two dozen scientists is calling in an open letter on Thursday for a new international inquiry. They say the WHO team that last month completed a mission to Wuhan—the Chinese city where the first known cases were found—had insufficient access to adequately investigate possible sources of the new coronavirus, including whether it slipped from a laboratory.

Their appeal comes as the U.S.—which recently reversed a decision to leave the WHO—lobbies for greater transparency in the investigation, saying it is waiting to scrutinize the report on the Wuhan mission, and urging China to release all relevant data, including on the first confirmed infections in December 2019, and potential earlier ones.

Beijing, meanwhile, is pressing for similar WHO-led missions to other countries, including the U.S., to investigate whether the virus could have originated outside China and spread to Wuhan via frozen food packaging.

WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said on Feb. 12 that the team would release an interim report briefly summarizing the Wuhan mission, possibly the following week, with a full report coming weeks later. But that summary report has yet to be published and the WHO team is now scrapping that plan, said Peter Ben Embarek, the food-safety scientist who led the team. The WHO team plans to publish a summary along with the full, final report, he said. That final report “will be published in coming weeks and will include key findings,” a WHO spokesman said.

Link

Okay, so Steven Quay is actually one of the sigantories of the new open letter as well as Rossana Segreto and Bruno Canard.
 
I'm flagging those people up just in case you find yourself reading their stuff or being referred to it. Best to know who they are. It's a public service.

Besides, even if they are crazy people, it doesn't mean it didn't escape from a lab.
You mean in case I read it IN THE FUTURE? :rolleyes:

Take it to the CT thread, thank you.
 
Okay, now this is interesting...

Link

Okay, so Steven Quay is actually one of the sigantories of the new open letter as well as Rossana Segreto and Bruno Canard.
And McCairn is not one of the signatories.

So is it guilt by association now, Segreto and Canard wrote a paper or something with McCairn??:confused: That's what you are basing discrediting the the whole letter with 26 signatories (if I counted right) on it? Did you look at the credentials of the signatories? There are a large number of virologists, the folks you said did not support the lab hypothesis on that letter.

And these 2:
Bruno Canard, DR CNRS, molecular virologist, Aix Marseille University, France, (ORCID 0000-0003-4924-1991)...

Rossana Segreto, PhD, Department of Microbiology, University of Innsbruck, Austria (ORCID 0000-0002-2566-7042)


Here is the title of the preprint you think discredits 2 people on the list of 26 signatories based on the fact McCairn's name is on it.

An open debate on SARS-CoV-2's proximal origin is long overdue
Rossana Segreto (1), Yuri Deigin (2), Kevin McCairn (3), Alejandro Sousa (4 and 5), Dan Sirotkin (6), Karl Sirotkin (6), Jonathan J. Couey (7), Adrian Jones (8), Daoyu Zhang (9) ((1) Department of Microbiology, University of Innsbruck, Austria, (2) Youthereum Genetics Inc., Toronto, Ontario, Canada, (3) Synaptek - Deep Learning Solutions, Gifu, Japan, (4) Regional Hospital of Monforte, Lugo, Spain, (5) University of Santiago de Compostela, Spain, (6) Karl Sirotkin LLC, Lake Mary, FL, USA, (7) University of Pittsburgh, School of Medicine, USA, (8) Independent bioinformatics researcher, (9) Independent genetics researcher)
And where is Canard on there? My head is spinning trying to find where you discredited Canard. OTOH, he was mentioned in Ridley's blog that you tried to discredit???

You're going to have to be more specific here about who you are discounting and why. Thanks.

This is an excellent link, BTW so thanks for posting it.


Please take something away from this that maybe, just maybe you've lumped a whole slew of highly qualified virologists and other research experts into an idiot bag because someone on Science Based Medicine posted bizarre claims in the comment section just happened to have his name on an editorial with other legit scientists that a serious debate on the origin of COVID was long overdue.

Please correct me if I have that wrong.
 
Last edited:
.... There is a bit of a spat going on between David Gorski of Science-based Medicine and someone called Kevin McCairn in the comments. Apparently Kevin McCairn's main claim regarding SARS CoV2 is that it isn't a virus, but a prion.

Kevin McCairn looks like a pretty nasty individual as well as a whack-job and he seems to be an anti-vaxxer as well.

Anyhow, when I looked into him relating to Covid-19, it turns out he is the co-author of a pre-print paper with Rosanna Segreto and Yuri Deigin claiming that Covid-19 came from a lab.

Yuri Deigin is someone active on social media claiming the escaped from a lab theory and was on Bret Weinstein's podcast.

Honestly, when these are some of the people pushing the escaped from a lab theory, it looks more and more like Trutherism than ever.

I'm flagging those people up just in case you find yourself reading their stuff or being referred to it. Best to know who they are. It's a public service.

Besides, even if they are crazy people, it doesn't mean it didn't escape from a lab.

Okay, now this is interesting...

Link

Okay, so Steven Quay is actually one of the sigantories of the new open letter as well as Rossana Segreto and Bruno Canard.

I'm not metioning Canard, Quay and Segreto to discredit the letter at all. The opposite, if anything.

I think it is an interesting development as well as with the WHO's decision to shelve the report.
:rolleyes:

Moving forward: good, glad we cleared that up, and absolutely it is an interesting development. Maybe some people trying to dismiss the idea as a CT will think again.
 
Now, this bloke's an Aussie, so of course, I question his qualifications, experience and even what kind of human he is, but Professor Dominic Dwyer throws a huge bucket of cold water on the conspiracists.

Hate them or loathe them, one thing about Australians is they tend not to pull any punches, and I think the idea Covid came from a lab can be put to bed now: https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/he...ator-rubbishes-covid19-laboratory-leak-theory
 
From your link:
A World Health Organisation investigator looking into the source of Covid-19 in Wuhan says it's “extremely unlikely” the virus was released from a lab.

So one of the WHO investigators disagrees with the slew of virologists and other researchers/experts in relevant fields and you think that's the end of the discussion? Are you serious?

Here's his reasoning:
“To have a leak in a laboratory, you’ve got to be growing up the virus in large amounts. Many of these bat coronaviruses, at least the ones that are very closely related to the SARS coronavirus, actually haven’t been cultured in the lab; they’re only a genetic sequence rather than a live virus,” he said.
First, we don't know what the minimal infectious dose is.

Second, I posted evidence the lab was indeed working with live cultures.

It looks like your 'debunker' took the lab workers' word for it they had no bat coronavirus culture programs. But they reported they did in papers written before COVID pandemic started.

See post #229
 
Last edited:
From your link:


So one of the WHO investigators disagrees with the slew of virologists and other researchers/experts in relevant fields and you think that's the end of the discussion? Are you serious?

Here's his reasoning:First, we don't know what the minimal infectious dose is.

Second, I posted evidence the lab was indeed working with live cultures.

It looks like your 'debunker' took the lab workers' word for it they had no bat coronavirus culture programs. But they reported they did in papers written before COVID pandemic started.

See post #229

The vast consensus among almost all virologists seems to be that this was NOT a lab escape. The fact that there may be a few virologists that have questions about the lab does not change that.
 
The vast consensus among almost all virologists seems to be that this was NOT a lab escape. The fact that there may be a few virologists that have questions about the lab does not change that.

There you go again arguing with hyperbole instead of facts.
 
We seem to have this by this great consensus.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 scientists were studying how a virus might jump from bats to people.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 a virus jumped from bats to people.

It is absolute coincidence it was the same place.

Fine, but my premises must be wrong somewhere.
 
Seriously that is an appalling counter argument, do you say the same about the vast consensus between climate scientists regarding ACC?

That is established. It is not established that there is a "vast majority" of virologists who are of the belief the evidence is overwhelmingly against it being a lab accident.

There is the WHO team and their assessment has been questioned and there are virologists in China who deny it was the lab.

The vast majority have not weighed in.

Then there is a sizable number of virologists who want further investigation because they don't believe the lab accident has been ruled out.

I have asked angrysoba to provide evidence of this "vast majority" and his answer was that I should provide evidence instead. And now he repeats the assertion again.
 
Last edited:
We seem to have this by this great consensus.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 scientists were studying how a virus might jump from bats to people.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 a virus jumped from bats to people.

It is absolute coincidence it was the same place.

Fine, but my premises must be wrong somewhere.

Nicely summarized. :thumbsup:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom