Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
We seem to have this by this great consensus.

The consensus is clearly we don't know where Covid came from. A vocal minority may give the appearance of consensus, but it's illusory, as I shall explain to you.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 scientists were studying how a virus might jump from bats to people.

They had been studying them for decades. https://virologyj.biomedcentral.com/track/pdf/10.1186/s12985-015-0422-1.pdf

And not just coronaviruses - bats are, as Ace Ventura once said "Evil spawn of Satan!"

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 a virus jumped from bats to people.

Incorrect. There was an intermediary.

It is absolute coincidence it was the same place.

It wasn't necessarily even a coincidence. The fact that the first super-spread of Covid happened in the same city doesn't mean the first case was.

Fine, but my premises must be wrong somewhere.

They are. You've staked a position based on flawed evidence and loose assumptions.

The irony in that is very deep.
 
NBC News last month:U.S. still hasn't ruled out lab accident origin for Covid because China hasn't been transparent
...But the director general of the WHO appeared to walk back that definitive statement a few days later, saying that "all hypotheses remain open and require further analysis and study."...

...Intelligence officials counter that one key lab, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, removed from public view a database of 22,000 virus samples for security reasons, and has not allowed a detailed look at the lab's notes or other records.

They say it's suspicious that the virus outbreak arose in Wuhan, a hub of virus research in China, while the bats that commonly carry coronaviruses are typically found in caves a thousand miles from that city.

They note that scientists also have not found a host animal that could have transferred the virus to humans, after a year of looking....


Then there is the Aussie who TA decided ruled the lab origin out:
One member of the team, Australian microbiologist and infectious diseases expert Dominic Dwyer, told NBC News that the scientists didn't get all the data they sought from the Chinese government, and that team members disagreed about various aspects of what they saw and heard.

"There were tense moments and disagreements and, you know, arguments about what things meant and so on, between both sides," Dwyer said. "And some of that is just because the data isn't strong enough to give a single, a great conclusion."

Dwyer says the team was given "aggregated data," as opposed to detailed, line-by-line case information, for the 174 known Covid cases from Wuhan in December....

Several members of the WHO team told NBC News they were provided with just 13 DNA sequences from the 174 cases. Of those, five had small genomic differences, suggesting a wider pool of virus, Dwyer said, though the sample was so small it was hard to draw conclusions.
Doesn't sound like a mic drop to me. Perhaps "throwing a bucket of cold water on conspiracy theorists" was just that, the CTers who are peddling the purposeful creation of a bioweapon hypothesis.

Despite the frequent framing of the lab leak hypothesis as 'extremely unlikely', it appears that drilling down finds more language of 'can't be ruled out'.
 
Last edited:
An oped summary that is pretty thorough:

C-Net: The twisted, messy hunt for COVID-19's origin and the lab leak theory - Did COVID-19 leak from a Wuhan lab? A tangle of conspiracy and politicking has complicated the investigation into the pandemic's origin.

Absolutely CTers and politicians have muddied the waters.
... the "lab leak theory" has wended its way back into the spotlight.

Over the last year, that theory has become increasingly difficult to ignore. Coincidences and circumstantial evidence continue to build, pointing to the Wuhan institute as a potential starting point. But the theory, and a dearth of information, has also helped spawn baseless conspiracies, like the notions that COVID-19 is a bioweapon or that it was used as a cover to install 5G across the world. ...

Investigating a possible accidental lab leak is a valid line of inquiry. Proponents of the lab leak theory argue that without a full accounting of the work performed at the WIV we may never truly know where the coronavirus came from -- and that could stifle our efforts to prevent the emergence of the next pandemic. To understand why a lab leak is so plausible to so many, we must stitch together clues, stretching a decade into the past.
A valid line of inquiry is what this thread is about.

The Caves: in 2009 a cluster of mine worker's deaths from pneumonia were investigated by the researchers from the WIV.
At both locations, the samples were screened for pieces of genetic material from a range of infectious agents, including coronaviruses. One sample, dubbed "BtCoV4991," looked similar to the virus that caused SARS in 2002. It was entered into an online database known as GenBank in 2016 and, for the most part, it was forgotten about.

But when SARS-CoV-2 emerged in Wuhan in December 2019, the miners and BtCoV4991 were thrust back into the spotlight.

China clamped down on BBC and AP reporters looking into the pneumonia deaths at the caves.

The scientists at the WIV stated none of their research included anything close to COVID 19, and they also claimed they only had
"All researchers have is chunks of the virus' genetic code. "This virus exists only as a virtual sequence in the computer,"
But in 2018 the WIV was working with in vivo specimens. And there is evidence (posted upthread) they were working with live bats, not just looking at virtual genomes.

But the fact that relatives of the SARS-CoV-2 virus were discovered so far from Wuhan and then researched at the WIV has placed constant scrutiny on Shi Zhengli's work and the safety protocols in Chinese laboratories.

Pangolins:
One specific genetic fragment of this virus was similar to that seen in SARS-CoV-2. Such a match, scientists said, made the pangolin a "probable origin" of the pandemic.

But it is not a "consensus".
And the pangolin coronavirus data was unusual. Chan and her collaborator Shing Zhan studied the sequences, highlighting a number of inconsistencies between the major studies and questioning missing or unpublished data in a preprint paper posted to bioRxiv. She points to one Nature paper as "dishonest" and says it involves "scientifically unacceptable" practices like publishing samples under different names and the inclusion of deceptive figures. On Nov. 11, Nature added an editors' note to that paper, alerting readers to these concerns. An investigation is ongoing, though the authors have stated these were honest mistakes.

In light of these oddities, and earlier research examining the pangolin coronaviruses, microbiologist Roger Frutos believes the creatures should be "exonerated." Yet, as recently as Jan. 8, the pangolin is still being brokered as a potential starting point in the origins of COVID-19 by Shi Zhengli and other scientists.

Any continued focus on the pangolin, Frutos notes, risks misleading investigations into the origins of the disease. But he also says, even discounting the pangolin's relevance, we may be looking at the emergence of COVID-19 from the wrong angle.

There's a long discussion about natural spillover events vs lab leaks and the involved WHO research team and conflicts of interest.

Then we come to this:
What makes discussing the lab leak theory so uncomfortable -- and potentially dangerous -- is how often it's aligned with more extreme, often sinophobic or nationalistic conspiracy theories around the emergence of SARS-CoV-2. ...

This lack of certainty has allowed conspiracy theories to fester, particularly on social media, where misinformation and a skewering of facts are prevalent. "It's not necessarily a conspiracy to consider a lab leak scenario," says Andersen, the virologist from Scripps, "but most theories about lab leaks are indeed conspiracy theories."
This is why I'm trying so hard to keep this evidence based discussion separate from the CT discussions.

These are conspiracies. But some arguments against an accidental leak have unfairly mixed the conspiracies with legitimate lines of inquiry. An accidental leak should be given equal weight, when there's no clear evidence against it. Yet the mess of adjacent conspiracies has seen most scientists shy away from the topic altogether.

From what I see the "vast majority" of virologists don't want to get involved in the debate. After all, the crazies are involved:
The constant questioning is wearing down researchers. For scientists like Andersen, countering misinformation around the origin story has been "extremely distracting and time consuming." One prominent virologist, Angie Rasmussen of Georgetown University, wrote in Nature Medicine that she has experienced threats of violence and sexual assault for debunking misinformation.

Further:
A serious, reputable investigation is required.

The WHO mission in Wuhan is not prepared to do so.
It will, a spokesperson says, examine hospital records and map activities and items traded at Huanan and other seafood markets. But even if the investigation was giving serious thought to alternative hypotheses like an accidental leak, so much time has elapsed since COVID-19's emergence that we may have missed our window. "I'm afraid it's too late for the lab leak theory to be seriously investigated," says Suryanarayanan, from US Right To Know. "That said, I don't think people should give up on that."
 
I guess this pre-print abstract is of interest to those who want to know more about the origins of Covid:

Although a variety of SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses have been identified, the evolutionary origins of this virus remain elusive. We describe a meta-transcriptomic study of 411 samples collected from 23 bat species in a small (~1100 hectare) region in Yunnan province, China, from May 2019 to November 2020. We identified coronavirus contigs in 40 of 100 sequencing libraries, including seven representing SARS-CoV-2-like contigs. From these data we obtained 24 full-length coronavirus genomes, including four novel SARS-CoV-2 related and three SARS-CoV related genomes. Of these viruses, RpYN06 exhibited 94.5% sequence identity to SARS-CoV-2 across the whole genome and was the closest relative of SARS-CoV-2 in the ORF1ab, ORF7a, ORF8, N, and ORF10 genes. The other three SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses were nearly identical in sequence and clustered closely with a virus previously identified in pangolins from Guangxi, China, although with a genetically distinct spike gene sequence. We also identified 17 alphacoronavirus genomes, including those closely related to swine acute diarrhea syndrome virus and porcine epidemic diarrhea virus. Ecological modeling predicted the co-existence of up to 23 Rhinolophus bat species in Southeast Asia and southern China, with the largest contiguous hotspots extending from South Lao and Vietnam to southern China. Our study highlights both the remarkable diversity of bat viruses at the local scale and that relatives of SARS-CoV-2 and SARS-CoV circulate in wildlife species in a broad geographic region of Southeast Asia and southern China. These data will help guide surveillance efforts to determine the origins of SARS-CoV-2 and other pathogenic coronaviruses.

Link
 
From the full paper (just click on download pdf and it will open):
From May 2019 to November 2020, a total of 283 fecal samples, 109 oral swabs and 112 19 urine samples were collected from bats in Yunnan province, China. The majority of 113 samples were collected from horseshoe bats,
Interesting that collection started before the pandemic. Not saying this has anything to do with a jump, mind you. This analysis was related to COVID-19 regardless of the collection dates. They went back through specimens which makes sense if you are looking for the original jump.

The researchers are from a couple places in China (not Wuhan) one from Taiwan and a couple from the US (IIRC, I wasn't counting).

I saw this before but don't see that it moves the ball down the court except to say, we're all screwed. :p

Kidding, there are lots of potential sources from bats to pangolins but none look to be definitively the hot trail.
 
Last edited:
From the full paper (just click on download pdf and it will open):Interesting that collection started before the pandemic. Not saying this has anything to do with a jump, mind you. This analysis was related to COVID-19 regardless of the collection dates. They went back through specimens which makes sense if you are looking for the original jump.

The researchers are from a couple places in China (not Wuhan) one from Taiwan and a couple from the US (IIRC, I wasn't counting).

I saw this before but don't see that it moves the ball down the court except to say, we're all screwed. :p

Kidding, there are lots of potential sources from bats to pangolins but none look to be definitively the hot trail.

I think that it provides part of the bigger picture that many virologists have been warning about. Essentially it is a similar picture to what David Quammen talks about in Spillover (by the way I recommend reading the book. I think it is currently only five or six dollars on Kindle last time I checked).

The big picture is that, yeah, we could be screwed. The evolutionary picture of it coming into more and more contact with humans if we don’t address some serious ecological and agricultural policies and our relationship with wildlife, suggests that it could be an even bigger problem than if it escaped from a lab. I think the idea here is that we will be lucky if it is just a lab escape, because if not there are many more and deadlier pandemics in the pipeline.
 
I don't see those being mutually exclusive. :(

True. A bigger tragedy could be of work to prevent the bigger tragedy is shut down because it is considered too dangerous. I think that could be one of the reasons the majority of virologists are so keen to play down those fears. It seems that scientists who were most concerned about gain of function research are some of those who are saying it is a possibility it escaped from a lab because that is the thing they warned about.
 
True. A bigger tragedy could be of work to prevent the bigger tragedy is shut down because it is considered too dangerous. I think that could be one of the reasons the majority of virologists are so keen to play down those fears. It seems that scientists who were most concerned about gain of function research are some of those who are saying it is a possibility it escaped from a lab because that is the thing they warned about.
Do we have one shred of evidence the research has prevented any potential pandemics?

I am not suggesting the research should be stopped. There's some evidence work at the lab led to a rapid identification of COVID-19 which was then shared around the world and used to develop vaccines.


But if we do find the smoking gun was fired from any lab, be it the WIV or some other nearby lab we aren't hearing as much about, then a major effort to prevent future such accidents is called for. It's probably called for anyway.
 
Do we have one shred of evidence the research has prevented any potential pandemics?

I am not suggesting the research should be stopped. There's some evidence work at the lab led to a rapid identification of COVID-19 which was then shared around the world and used to develop vaccines.


But if we do find the smoking gun was fired from any lab, be it the WIV or some other nearby lab we aren't hearing as much about, then a major effort to prevent future such accidents is called for. It's probably called for anyway.

Yes. Action is needed because the hunt for viruses and formulation of plans to prevent serious spillovers is, at least according to many virologists, understaffed and underfunded.
 
Jamie Metzl, who I think organized that recent letter, has appeared on the Joe Rogan podcast.

He explains why he thinks a lab leak is a strong possibility...



...and also about the pushback against the lab leak hypothesis. He talks quite a bit about Peter Daszak as well:

 
That is an excellent discussion. They should be in the OP. It clearly explains all the points I've been trying to make here. He verbalizes what the paper said that I linked to in 263 for anyone that doesn't have the time to watch the videos. I highly recommend people watch the videos though.

Makes me curious now to see what people are saying in the CT origins thread. Can you see why I've tried to push the CT stuff out of this thread? A few people here slipped a bit in, in a knee jerk fashion. I understand that, we're all programed to question what doesn't sound evidence supported. But sometimes we are wrong.

I want to thank Sherkeu for getting me thinking about the circumstantial evidence the first outbreak started near the WIV. That's when I started looking at the lab leak hypothesis as plausible.
 
Last edited:
That is an excellent discussion. They should be in the OP. It clearly explains all the points I've been trying to make here. He verbalizes what the paper said that I linked to in 263 for anyone that doesn't have the time to watch the videos. I highly recommend people watch the videos though.

Makes me curious now to see what people are saying in the CT origins thread. Can you see why I've tried to push the CT stuff out of this thread? A few people here slipped a bit in, in a knee jerk fashion. I understand that, we're all programed to question what doesn't sound evidence supported. But sometimes we are wrong.

I want to thank Sherkeu for getting me thinking about the circumstantial evidence the first outbreak started near the WIV. That's when I started looking at the lab leak hypothesis as plausible.

You are most welcome. :)
I found it so curious that what seemed like very valid connections were labeled "Conspiracy!". Each bit of news I learn that gives insight out about why is was discounted early on seems to place an actual CT on those who steered the narrative away from taking a serious look at any connection to the lab.

For China to push origin theories that reduce culpability is a given- plenty of evidence that they are about as transparent as a tar pit- but the motives of the global scientists, ie the "experts", is interesting. There seems to be some "greater good" reason for it in not hampering future virus research by focusing on what is still the next big risk (negligent animal trade across regions) and not what might actually have happened.
 
I wondered about what was going on in those caves and small villages in Yunnan. Surely there is a story there. Seems the AP tried, unsuccessfully, to get that story.

China clamps down in hidden hunt for coronavirus origins

The area is of intense scientific interest because it may hold clues to the origins of the coronavirus that has killed more than 1.7 million people worldwide. Yet for scientists and journalists, it has become a black hole of no information because of political sensitivity and secrecy.

A bat research team visiting recently managed to take samples but had them confiscated, two people familiar with the matter said. Specialists in coronaviruses have been ordered not to speak to the press. And a team of Associated Press journalists was tailed by plainclothes police in multiple cars who blocked access to roads and sites in late November.


And while many countries tested thousands of 2019 flu samples, China did not (or at least has not disclosed data).
The Chinese government is also limiting and controlling the search for patient zero through the re-testing of old flu samples.

Chinese hospitals collect thousands of samples from patients with flu-like symptoms every week and store them in freezers. They could easily be tested again for COVID-19...
“They’d be crazy not to do it,” Yip (of US CDC in China) said. “The political leadership will wait for that information to see, does this information make China look stupid or not? ... If it makes China look stupid, they won’t.”

But in China, scientists have only published retrospective testing data from two Wuhan flu surveillance hospitals. The data includes just 520 samples out of the 330,000 collected in China last year.

Chinese researchers found that a child over a hundred kilometers from Wuhan had fallen ill with the virus by Jan. 2, suggesting it was spreading widely in December. But earlier samples weren’t tested, according to a scientist with direct knowledge of the study.

“There was a very deliberate choice of the time period to study, because going too early could have been too sensitive,” said the scientist, who declined to be named out of fear of retribution.

Another article mentioned that much of the patient data they did publish on flu cases were mostly children sick in Jan 2020. While it was useful to know how children were affected, the dearth of pre-2020 sample testing is a glaring omission.
(here is the 4/20 published study of 366 children:
Detection of Covid-19 in Children in Early January 2020 in Wuhan, China https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmc2003717)
 
Last edited:
You are most welcome. :)
I found it so curious that what seemed like very valid connections were labeled "Conspiracy!". Each bit of news I learn that gives insight out about why is was discounted early on seems to place an actual CT on those who steered the narrative away from taking a serious look at any connection to the lab.

For China to push origin theories that reduce culpability is a given- plenty of evidence that they are about as transparent as a tar pit- but the motives of the global scientists, ie the "experts", is interesting. There seems to be some "greater good" reason for it in not hampering future virus research by focusing on what is still the next big risk (negligent animal trade across regions) and not what might actually have happened.

You don't need to put scare quotes around the word "experts".

Peter Daszak, Zhengli Shi, Kristian Andersen, Ian Lipkin, Vincent Racaniello, Eddie Holmes, Angela Rasmussen, Linfa Wang, Hume Field, Malik Peiris etc... are experts. Given that they are experts, it is probably worth paying attention to them.

Generally speaking, they don't seem to be that interested in talking about it, presumably because there are other things to talk about. Vincent Racaniello, for example, simply says this...

https://youtu.be/AwPbA2k3Ub0?t=5222
 
You don't need to put scare quotes around the word "experts".

Peter Daszak, Zhengli Shi, Kristian Andersen, Ian Lipkin, Vincent Racaniello, Eddie Holmes, Angela Rasmussen, Linfa Wang, Hume Field, Malik Peiris etc... are experts. Given that they are experts, it is probably worth paying attention to them.

Generally speaking, they don't seem to be that interested in talking about it, presumably because there are other things to talk about. Vincent Racaniello, for example, simply says this...

https://youtu.be/AwPbA2k3Ub0?t=5222

Those aren't "scare quotes". I meant it to accentuate the "actual" leading experts in the field. Maybe there is some "scare quote" internet grammar guide I missed because I was accused of it last week as well- and did not intend it then either.

I may switch to some other "syntax" for emphasis. :confused:
 
Those aren't "scare quotes". I meant it to accentuate the "actual" leading experts in the field. Maybe there is some "scare quote" internet grammar guide I missed because I was accused of it last week as well- and did not intend it then either.

I may switch to some other "syntax" for emphasis. :confused:


I’d suggest using bold or italics for emphasis. Quotes in a text format are generally used for actual quotes, or considered like air quotes in voice conversation (scare quotes or indicating sarcasm)

Just my $.02 :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Virus host shifts are generally associated with novel adaptations to exploit the cells of the new host species optimally. Surprisingly, Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) has apparently required little to no significant adaptation to humans since the start of the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic and to October 2020. Here we assess the types of natural selection taking place in Sarbecoviruses in horseshoe bats versus the early SARS-CoV-2 evolution in humans. While there is moderate evidence of diversifying positive selection in SARS-CoV-2 in humans, it is limited to the early phase of the pandemic, and purifying selection is much weaker in SARS-CoV-2 than in related bat Sarbecoviruses. In contrast, our analysis detects evidence for significant positive episodic diversifying selection acting at the base of the bat virus lineage SARS-CoV-2 emerged from, accompanied by an adaptive depletion in CpG composition presumed to be linked to the action of antiviral mechanisms in these ancestral bat hosts. The closest bat virus to SARS-CoV-2, RmYN02 (sharing an ancestor about 1976), is a recombinant with a structure that includes differential CpG content in Spike; clear evidence of coinfection and evolution in bats without involvement of other species. While an undiscovered “facilitating” intermediate species cannot be discounted, collectively, our results support the progenitor of SARS-CoV-2 being capable of efficient human–human transmission as a consequence of its adaptive evolutionary history in bats, not humans, which created a relatively generalist virus.

Link
 
We seem to have this by this great consensus.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 scientists were studying how a virus might jump from bats to people.

Somewhere in the world in late 2019 a virus jumped from bats to people.

It is absolute coincidence it was the same place.

Fine, but my premises must be wrong somewhere.

Corona viruses in bats in that region have been recognised as dangerous and a risk for making the jump from bats to humans even before the SARS outbreak 20 years ago. OF COURSE the Wuhan lab is studying this issue. China only has 2 BSL-4 labs where live viruses can be studied and this one is located in a known high risk area. In fact studying this known risk is likely a major reason why the lab was built in the first place.

The fact that a virology lab is studying viruses tells us absolutely nothing about whether this is where the viruses came from because this is what BSL-4 labs do and they would be doing it REGARDLESS of where the outbreak occurred.

As to why the outbreak and lab are in exactly the same city, there is a little coincidence there but you also need to take into account that:
- Since SARS, another bat virus jumping to humans has been considered highly probabaly and possibly inevitable.
- the region is a high risk for this type of event so it makes sense for this lab to be doing the work.
- not only is the city in an area where bat viruses could jump to humans, there are cultural practices like live animal markets where infected animals are brought into close contact with a large number of people.

If we narrow down where this "inevitable" crossover is likely to occur to a large city, in that region of China where live animal markets are still the norm and Wuhan looks like a probable epicenter for any such event. It's no coincidence e at all that is where China would center it's research.
 
From the full paper (just click on download pdf and it will open):Interesting that collection started before the pandemic.

Identifying bat viruses in China has been an ongoing research topic since SARS, because a virus like Covid has emerging there been a known risk for at least that long.

What is actually most telling is that for all the samples collected in that time Covid-19 was NOT one of them. For it to get into a lab in the first place someone needed to have collected it, so finding either in the wild or in the previously collected samples should be relatively straightforward. The fact that no really close ancestor has yet been identified suggests Covid was never collected and never in a lab and therefor could not have escaped from one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom