Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Incorrect.

First line of the article: warning that it could collapse at any moment.

You don't get much more unequivocal than that.

Taiwan is understandably keen to present China in a negative light, and that's exactly what they're doing. The article contains inferences and claims that aren't supported by the evidence.

Applying for a patent for bat cages is not evidence of there being bat cages.

Bats being at the lab is neither evidence of breeding or inadvertent release of the virus.

And look at you, ignoring Daszak's blatant conflict of interest

The exact same claims were thrown at Fauci last year.

When you get some actual evidence, let me know.
 
First line of the article: warning that it could collapse at any moment.

You don't get much more unequivocal than that.

Taiwan is understandably keen to present China in a negative light, and that's exactly what they're doing. The article contains inferences and claims that aren't supported by the evidence.

Applying for a patent for bat cages is not evidence of there being bat cages.

Bats being at the lab is neither evidence of breeding or inadvertent release of the virus.



The exact same claims were thrown at Fauci last year.

When you get some actual evidence, let me know.
Heh
Coincidence in Charles Dickens is ncessary for plot.
Coincidence in Wuhan is necessary for a nonsensical denial of the obvious.
Walks looks quacks like a duck.

What is it?
 
Coincidence in Wuhan is necessary for a nonsensical denial of the obvious.

So obvious that no concrete evidence has been found, while supposition and assumptions rule.

I do find it more than a little ironic that you of all people are calling for conclusions without solid evidence.
 
So obvious that no concrete evidence has been found, while supposition and assumptions rule.

I do find it more than a little ironic that you of all people are calling for conclusions without solid evidence.

Your definition of "concrete evidence" leaves a bit to be desired.

Remember, you have no concrete evidence of a natural spillover either.

I'll have more to say when I get back from an appointment.
 
I haven't ever suggested there is.

That makes this position quite arbitrary:
TA said:
I don't think the evidence we have so far favours any of them.

Given the fact that SARS, MERS, Ebola and other coronaviruses have happened naturally, I think natural transmission is still the warm favourite.

Lab leaks have happened before.

You had to gin up an assertion the Taiwan Times was unreliable.

You overlook Daszak's conflict of interest.

And you admit there is no direct evidence it was spillover while using that same criteria of no direct evidence to refute the lab leak hypothesis.


Not to beat that dead horse just yet, I do recommend you take a closer look at how the more recent genetic analyses further rules out the pangolin as an intermediary host. Because it does.
 
You had to gin up an assertion the Taiwan Times was unreliable.

It's not an assertuion, it's factual that Taiwan Times will try to drag China through the mud at every opportunity it can find. I don't blame them, but I don't trust their position either.

You overlook Daszak's conflict of interest.

Nope. He's not the only person on the other side of the fence.

And you admit there is no direct evidence it was spillover while using that same criteria of no direct evidence to refute the lab leak hypothesis.

Maybe you need new glasses? I haven't refuted anything, and you even quoted me saying I think one scenario is more likely. I wouldn't be surprised if it came from the lab, I just think it's less likely than the other option.

Not to beat that dead horse just yet, I do recommend you take a closer look at how the more recent genetic analyses further rules out the pangolin as an intermediary host. Because it does.

It wasn't me banging the pangolin drum. I'm quite happy to rule them out.

If asked me for an intermediate species I'd go mustelids. We know for sure the disease is able to jump to and from mink & humans pretty readily and there are a hell of a lot of minks in China. Felines are possible as well. Civets have a bit of history there.
 
Lab leaks have happened before.

^^This. Many many times- even with top-rate protocols and safety equipment!
And the "many times" are just the ones we know about. There is no such thing as 100% safety.

SARS got out of the Beijing lab three times (really 4x as one incident involved 2 unrelated infections, weeks apart- of students who did not even work with viruses). SARS also got out once in Taiwan, once in Singapore.

For the novel coronavirus, Shi stated that she initially feared it was from the lab, but after finding no signs of safety slip-ups, she was then able to compare sequence data of viruses stored there against the newly published SARS-CoV-2 genome and found no matches.
Therefore, it could not have come from her lab.
She seemed relieved, stating "“That really took a load off my mind. I had not slept a wink for days.”

But... this reasoning seems at odds with her own investigation of a 2003 Hanta leak at a lab in Yunnan where 2 students were infected. Shi tested 6 wild rats from the immediate area to test for Hanta and all were negative. Her conclusion was that it came from from the lab.
In that case, it was a new Hanta virus, arising naturally from 2 rodent species in the lab kept in close proximity- then jumping to a human - all inside the lab. Several safety violations were addressed.

Here is the abstract (2010):
An outbreak of hemorrhagic fever with renal syndrome occurred among students in a college (College A) in Kunming, Yunnan province, China in 2003. Subsequent investigations revealed the presence of hantavirus antibodies and antigens in laboratory rats at College A and two other institutions. Hantavirus antibodies were detected in 15 additional individuals other than the index case in these three locations. Epidemiologic data indicated that the human infections were a result of zoonotic transmission of the virus from laboratory rats. A virus was isolated from rats in College A and the full-length genome sequence revealed that this was a new Hantaan virus isolate, designated strain KY. Sequence analysis of the three genome segments indicated that this new isolate is a reassortant derived from human and rat Hantaan viruses. Further sequence analysis of the medium (M) genome segment revealed that it originated from a recombination event between two rat Hantaan virus lineages.

These accidental infections were only discovered when the young students (in their 20's) became ill enough to require hospital care. I cannot think of an infectious pathogen 'escape' that was not discovered in this way.
If the same happened with SARS CoV-2, the infections would likely go unnoticed. This is just another one of many scenarios where the lab (or their field work) is the source.

We also know that the same idea of testing animals was done for SARS CoV-2 to find a spillover source leading to the Wuhan outbreak. They tested animals in the wild, in the market, and on farms and didn't find any that tested positive.
 
Last edited:
I was contemplating the universe for a bit today and it struck me what devastation has occurred (and is occurring) worldwide because of a careless act in a single lab. By single act I mean creating or isolating and propagating this and maybe other dangerous viruses. The actual accident is of course to blame. But the hubris to think you could study dangerous coronaviruses no worries, all you need to be is careful. ...

From the worldometer:
3,227,188 people have died so far from the coronavirus COVID-19 outbreak as of May 04, 2021, 05:25 GMT.

There are currently 154,195,608 confirmed cases in 220 countries and territories . The fatality rate is still being assessed.
And we know the real numbers are much much higher.

You let a dangerous virus loose in the world and more than 3 million people have died, hospitals overcrowded, not enough oxygen or ventilators or nurses .....

And somebody knows they did it, they know that virus is one they were working with. I hope someone eventually comes forward but I can't imagine they will now as long as they know they can cover it up.
 
Last edited:
^^This. Many many times- even with top-rate protocols and safety equipment!
And the "many times" are just the ones we know about. There is no such thing as 100% safety.

SARS got out of the Beijing lab three times (really 4x as one incident involved 2 unrelated infections, weeks apart- of students who did not even work with viruses). SARS also got out once in Taiwan, once in Singapore.

For the novel coronavirus, Shi stated that she initially feared it was from the lab, but after finding no signs of safety slip-ups, she was then able to compare sequence data of viruses stored there against the newly published SARS-CoV-2 genome and found no matches. Therefore, it could not have come from her lab. She seemed relieved, stating "“That really took a load off my mind. I had not slept a wink for days.”

Don't her actions and her concerns and the fact that she voiced them not sound completely reasonable to you?


But... this reasoning seems at odds with her own investigation of a 2003 Hanta leak at a lab in Yunnan where 2 students were infected. Shi tested 6 wild rats from the immediate area to test for Hanta and all were negative. Her conclusion was that it came from from the lab.
In that case, it was a new Hanta virus, arising naturally from 2 rodent species in the lab kept in close proximity- then jumping to a human - all inside the lab. Several safety violations were addressed.

Here is the abstract (2010):

I don't understand how they are at odds. Presumably the virus in the second case can be isolated from the lab rats themselves.

I think we have already seen an argument for why the virus did not come from the lab in this case which is that the viruses they had sequenced were not similar enough.

These accidental infections were only discovered when the young students (in their 20's) became ill enough to require hospital care. I cannot think of an infectious pathogen 'escape' that was not discovered in this way. If the same happened with SARS CoV-2, the infections would likely go unnoticed. This is just another one of many scenarios where the lab (or their field work) is the source.

We also know that the same idea of testing animals was done for SARS CoV-2 to find a spillover source leading to the Wuhan outbreak. They tested animals in the wild, in the market, and on farms and didn't find any that tested positive.

I think lab escapes have sometimes been noticed in other ways such as sending the wrong vials to people, or when a researcher accidentally stabs themselves with a syringe.

It should be pointed out as well that some viruses just appear in unexpected places. This has happened, for example, with Ebola.
 
I was contemplating the universe for a bit today and it struck me what devastation has occurred (and is occurring) worldwide because of a careless act in a single lab. By single act I mean creating or isolating and propagating this and maybe other dangerous viruses. The actual accident is of course to blame. But the hubris to think you could study dangerous coronaviruses no worries, all you need to be is careful. ...

From the worldometer: And we know the real numbers are much much higher.

You let a dangerous virus loose in the world and more than 3 million people have died, hospitals overcrowded, not enough oxygen or ventilators or nurses .....

And somebody knows they did it, they know that virus is one they were working with. I hope someone eventually comes forward but I can't imagine they will now as long as they know they can cover it up.

This is truly beyond the evidence.

You are now asserting for a fact that it was a lab leak, that specific scientists know about it and that there is a cover-up of this fact.
 
...
I think we have already seen an argument for why the virus did not come from the lab in this case which is that the viruses they had sequenced were not similar enough.
That evidence is promoted by Daszak who has a significant conflict of interest. Also one of the main researchers at the WIV said none of her study samples match the circulating COVID.

But at the same time papers they published in recent years contradicts the denial and the Chinese government in quite a haste took a ton of genetic evidence off the place it had previously been where researchers had access.

We've posted a lot of sources that contradict the denial and when the WHO team went to check they weren't allowed to see very much.


It should be pointed out as well that some viruses just appear in unexpected places. This has happened, for example, with Ebola.
That the initial source was in the vicinity of the lab is a very unlikely coincidence. I'm not sure why you think ebola inexplicably occurred. It's been traced to direct contact with bats in the area. Not sure there's an area with ebola that doesn't have those bats.
 
Last edited:
This is truly beyond the evidence.

You are now asserting for a fact that it was a lab leak, that specific scientists know about it and that there is a cover-up of this fact.
You're right. I did wander in that direction in my Universe contemplating. It was a train of thought not meant to be an evidence based proven conclusion.

But nonetheless there is a lot of evidence supporting my Universe contemplation.
 
That evidence is promoted by Daszak who has a significant conflict of interest.

I don't understand what you mean.

The closest relative that we know about is RaTG13, which is something like 96% similar to SARS CoV2. It was you who pooh-poohed the similarity and pointed out that chimpanzees were 96% similar.

Other virologists (not just Daszak) but most others such as Linfa Wang and many others say that there is no way to get from RaTG13 to SARS CoV2 with current technology.

Also one of the main researchers at the WIV said none of her study samples match the circulating COVID.

Indeed.

But at the same time papers they published in recent years contradicts the denial

Do you mean Shi Zhengli actually published a paper showing that her study samples matched Covid?


and the Chinese government in quite a haste took a ton of genetic evidence off the place it had previously been where researchers had access.

Apparently they took that database down in September 2019, did they not? That doesn't help the case unless you can show that Covid was around back then?


That the initial source was in the vicinity of the lab is a very unlikely coincidence. I'm not sure why you think ebola inexplicably occurred. It's been traced to direct contact with bats in the area. Not sure there's an area with ebola that doesn't have those bats.

Yes, almost certainly from bats, but Ebola outbreaks are sporadic and sometimes emerge in unusual locations:

The huge Ebola epidemic that struck West Africa between 2013 and 2016 took the world by surprise. The virus had never been found in the region; all previous Ebola outbreaks were in countries in Central Africa or Sudan. And it posed a mystery: Where did the virus, called Ebola Zaire, come from?
Now, scientists may have an answer. Near the mouth of an abandoned mineshaft in Liberia, they caught a bat that was likely infected with Ebola Zaire. The researchers didn't isolate the virus itself but found about one-fifth of its genome in the animal; it's too early to tell whether it's exactly the same strain as the one that ravaged the region. Still, “This is an important new lead and it should be followed up extensively,” says Fabian Leendertz, a veterinary epidemiologist at the Robert Koch Institute in Berlin who was not involved in the work.

The finding also sheds new light on the natural history of Ebola, which has befuddled scientists for decades, says Jon Epstein, a veterinary epidemiologist at EcoHealth Alliance in New York City and a member of the PREDICT consortium that made the discovery. “It is really our first evidence of any bat carrying Ebola Zaire virus in the region,” Epstein says. “It allows us to take a deeper look and try to understand where this virus came from.”

Link

But remember that we have known about Ebola since the 1970s but it has taken a long time to get to the point where we can really know how it spreads.

There is a further mystery and that is that Ebola has a number of strains and there is one kind that affects primates other than humans, and it exists in The Philippines. Ironically it was discovered in a US lab when a scientist was examining a macaque imported from the Philippines:

Reston virus (RESTV) is one of six known viruses within the genus Ebolavirus. Reston virus causes Ebola virus disease in non-human primates; unlike the other five ebolaviruses, it is not known to cause disease in humans, but has caused asymptomatic infections.[1][2][3] Reston virus was first described in 1990 as a new "strain" of Ebola virus (EBOV).[4] It is the single member of the species Reston ebolavirus, which is included into the genus Ebolavirus, family Filoviridae, order Mononegavirales.[5] Reston virus is named after Reston, Virginia, US, where the virus was first discovered.

RESTV was discovered in crab-eating macaques from Hazleton Laboratories (now Covance) in 1989. This attracted significant media attention due to the proximity of Reston to the Washington, DC, metro area and the lethality of a closely related Ebola virus. Despite its status as a level-4 organism, Reston virus is non-pathogenic to humans, though hazardous to monkeys

Link
 
Last edited:
You're right. I did wander in that direction in my Universe contemplating. It was a train of thought not meant to be an evidence based proven conclusion.

But nonetheless there is a lot of evidence supporting my Universe contemplation.

Okay, fair enough. I was wondering about that, because I had assumed that you were still only assuming the lab leak was only one of a number of possible hypotheses.
 
A new article strongly suggesting that the origin might be a Chinese lab. No idea how legit it is, but it is a scientific article;

On the Origin of SARS-CoV-2: Did Cell Culture Experiments Lead to Increased Virulence of the Progenitor Virus for Humans?
BERND KAINA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1313-1326; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12384

I couldn't find much discussing how credible the journal is, but the highlights of this particular issue do not look promising.

picture.php
 
I don't understand what you mean.

The closest relative that we know about is RaTG13, which is something like 96% similar to SARS CoV2. It was you who pooh-poohed the similarity and pointed out that chimpanzees were 96% similar.

Other virologists (not just Daszak) but most others such as Linfa Wang and many others say that there is no way to get from RaTG13 to SARS CoV2 with current technology.

Indeed.

Do you mean Shi Zhengli actually published a paper showing that her study samples matched Covid?

Apparently they took that database down in September 2019, did they not? That doesn't help the case unless you can show that Covid was around back then?

Yes, almost certainly from bats, but Ebola outbreaks are sporadic and sometimes emerge in unusual locations:

Link

But remember that we have known about Ebola since the 1970s but it has taken a long time to get to the point where we can really know how it spreads.

There is a further mystery and that is that Ebola has a number of strains and there is one kind that affects primates other than humans, and it exists in The Philippines. Ironically it was discovered in a US lab when a scientist was examining a macaque imported from the Philippines:

Link

I hate going over the whole damn thread full of evidence to again address the same issues.

Yes it was Sept 2019, about the time of the first case as calculated by the genetic history clock.

What past papers show is the WIV was researching live coronavirus including encouraging the development of chimeras and propagating the virus in human lung cells.

Did ebola emerge near a lab studying it? :rolleyes:

And the Reston incident is an historical case in point that fortunately resulted in a dodged bullet so I'm not sure why you are bringing that up.
 
I couldn't find much discussing how credible the journal is, but the highlights of this particular issue do not look promising.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=82&pictureid=12826[/qimg]
I haven't looked at the article yet and I was trying to find the editorial board and haven't found that either, but the articles in the current journal don't look like the featured articles.

https://iv.iiarjournals.org/
LATEST ARTICLES
Retrospective Study of the Effects of Post-nasal Drip Symptoms on Cough Duration
TAKEO NAKAJIMA, TATSUYA NAGANO and YOSHIHIRO NISHIMURA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1799-1803; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12440

Rare Nivolumab-associated Super Hyper Progressive Disease in Patients With Advanced Gastric Cancer
YUTARO KUBOTA, KIYOSHI YOSHIMURA, KAZUYUKI HAMADA, YUYA HIRASAWA, MIDORI SHIDA, MAKOTO TANIGUCHI, HIROTO MATSUI, HIROTSUGU ARIIZUMI, TOMOYUKI ISHIGURO, NORIHIRO SUZUKI, RYOTARO OHKUMA, TAKEHIKO SAMBE, HIROO ISHIDA, ATSUSHI HORIIKE, SATOSHI WADA, JUNJI TSURUTANI, SANJU IWAMOTO, NAOKI UCHIDA, YUJI KIUCHI, SHINICHI KOBAYASHI and TAKUYA TSUNODA
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1865-1875; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12449

A Potential Pathogenic Link Between Cancer of Female Reproductive System and Infertile Women Treated With Assisted Reproduction Techniques
MICHAIL DIAKOSAVVAS, ZACHARIAS FASOULAKIS, THOMAS NTOUNIS, ANTONIOS KOUTRAS, KYVELI ANGELOU, GEORGIOS TSATSARIS, ATHANASIOS SYLLAIOS, NIKOLAOS GARMPIS and EMMANUEL N. KONTOMANOLIS
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1393-1399; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12391

Long-term Response After Stopping Immunotherapy in a Patient With Metastatic Renal Cancer
BOGDAN HAINEALA, ANCA ZGURA, CAMELIA DIACONU, CLAUDIA MEHEDINTU, XENIA BACINSCHI and RODICA MARICELA ANGHEL
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1805-1810; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12441

Bioluminescence Imaging of Matrix Metalloproteinases-2 and -9 Activities in Ethanol-injured Cornea of Mice
SEUNG-BO PARK, SEUNG HYO JUNG, HENGZHE JIN, SU JUNG KIM, YUNKYOUNG RYU, KYUNG-JIN LEE, BOKYUNG KIM, HYUN JIN SHIN and KYUNG-JONG WON
In Vivo May 2021, 35 (3) 1521-1528; DOI: https://doi.org/10.21873/invivo.12405 ...
And so on....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom