Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
JFC Not every conspiracy is a conspiracy theory and we do have proven activity that a database was taken offline at a suspicious time.


I give up. I have no mechanism to cauterize the hydra.
 
JFC Not every conspiracy is a conspiracy theory and we do have proven activity that a database was taken offline at a suspicious time.

The "database" was taken down in Sept the first real human case was likely in Oct, so the timelines don't work. There are other copies of the data around the world and they contain nothing suspicious.
 
Hmmm, I don't think that is peer-reviewed. Antibody-dependent enhancement has not been observed for COVID vaccines and is pretty much considered a non-issue.

"Gus" Dalgliesh is well known for discovering that CD4 is the receptor for HIV-1.
If you scroll down 13 papers cite their work.
 
Here is one of the papers that cites the June 2020 paper:

An open debate on SARS-CoV-2’s proximal origin is long overdue
There is a near consensus view that SARS-CoV-2 has a natural zoonotic origin; however, several characteristics of SARS-CoV-2 taken together are not easily explained by a natural zoonotic origin hypothesis. These include: a low rate of evolution in the early phase of transmission; the lack of evidence of recombination events; a high pre-existing binding to human ACE2; a novel furin cleavage site insert; a flat glycan binding domain of the spike protein which conflicts with host evasion survival patterns exhibited by other coronaviruses, and high human and mouse peptide mimicry. Initial assumptions against a laboratory origin, by contrast, have remained unsubstantiated. Furthermore, over a year after the initial outbreak in Wuhan, there is still no clear evidence of zoonotic transfer from a bat or intermediate species. Given the immense social and economic impact of this pandemic, identifying the true origin of SARS-CoV-2 is fundamental to preventing future outbreaks. The search for SARS-CoV-2’s origin should include an open and unbiased inquiry into a possible laboratory origin.



A reminder to those that keep repeating the Seafood Market origin:
However, three of the four patients with the earliest recorded onset of COVID-19 symptoms, none had an association with the seafood market (Huang et al., 2020), and the ancestral T8782 and C28144 genotype was not associated with the seafood market (Chen et al., 2020). Phyloepidemiologic analysis of early cases (Yu et al., 2020) also discounted this theory.
Garry claimed in his piece that the other cases were connected to other wet markets. I have yet to find any evidence supporting his assertion. As I noted a few times, one patient's son had been to a wet market but he did not have COVID 19.

The WHO paper mentioned 2 other markets and only found evidence of COVID in one. If the other early cases had a connection to this other market one would think there would have been stronger evidence for that hypothesis.

Unless there is a source for COVID infection connected to another market, for me this discredits Garry as someone just a tad too confirmation biased.



And for those who keep repeating the pangolin as an intermediary species:
Although two pangolin-CoV’s (Xiao et al. 2020, Liu, P. et al., 2020) exhibited strong binding to human ACE2, binding to pangolin ACE2 was approximately tenfold weaker, and binding to bat Rhinolophus ferremequinum ACE2 was very weak, which is comparable to that exhibited by SARS-CoV-2 (Wrobel et al. 2021).

And this was brought up in the thread:
All published pangolin-CoV genome sequences with a nearly identical spike RBD to SARS-CoV-2 were sourced from a single batch of smuggled pangolins (Chan and Zhan 2020), raising the question whether pangolins may have been infected from another host species or from humans during trafficking (Choo et al. 2020; Wenzel, 2020). ...

Finally, the discovery of synthetic DNA sequences in pangolin CoV metagenomic raw sequence reads by Zhang, D., (2020) and the interpretation that the pangolin-CoV genomes were generated from a synthetic construct,...



This is a scary bit:
A very recent emergence of SARS-CoV-2 into the human population has been proposed based on the sampling of eight nearly identical complete genomes in December 2019 (Lu et al., 2020). From earliest strains in Wuhan in 2019, SARS-CoV-2 resembled SARS-CoV in the late phase of its 2003 epidemic after SARS-CoV had developed several advantageous adaptations for human transmission (Zhan et al., 2020).
I thought there was a paper before the 2019 pandemic that noted researchers were using the SARS backbone in their research. I have those details wrong but I am sure they were using the SARS virus in the WIV lab. This paper addresses that and I've quoted that part below.***



This is the first I've seen mentioned that a direct jump from bats to humans has a problem:
However bat species are poorly infected by SARS-CoV-2 and they are therefore unlikely to be the direct source for human infection. SARS-CoV-2 does not replicate in R. sinicus kidney or lung cells (Chu et al., 2020), binds poorly to R. sinicus ACE2 (Tang, Y. et al., 2020; Li, Y. et al., 2020; Piplani et al., 2020) and exhibits no binding to R. ferrumequinum ACE2 (Tang, Y. et al., 2020). ...

... these results are perplexing as it indicates a significant and unexplained evolutionary distance between SARS-CoV-2 and bats....



Then there is this problem:
Interestingly, there is no evidence of recombination events in studies of SARS-CoV-2 by Richard et al. (2020) (6,546 genome sequences as of September 2020) or Bobay et al. (2020) (218 sequences as of August 2020). This is in contrast with MERS-CoV, where despite a much smaller sample size, recombination events were detected.



*** Re the backbone and SARS virus used in the lab:
The observation that SARS-CoV-2 was not derived from a previously used virus backbone was used as an argument by Andersen et al. and Liu et al. 2020 as evidence against a laboratory origin hypothesis. The Betacoronavirus RaTG13 was fully sequenced in 2018 (Zhou P. et al., 2020b) but only published after the beginning of the pandemic (Zhou P. et al., 2020a). [/More unpublished sequences existed in a WIV database that was deleted after the beginning of the pandemic (Segreto & Deigin, 2020). SARS-CoV-2 could have been engineered using one of the over 1,500 strains openly collected by institutions associated with the WIV (Sirotkin & Sirotkin, 2020), a completely undocumented backbone, or one of several fairly well correlated bat-CoV’s could have been used in combination with directed evolution, a widely used technique for introducing mutations and selection to achieve proteins with desired properties (Badran and Liu, 2015; Standage-Beier and Wang 2006; Simon et al., 2019). Specifically, this technique has been used for engineering novel virus variants (Excoffon et al., 2009; Lin et al., 2012; Meister et al., 2019). Furthermore, novel yet undocumented reverse-genetic systems could also have potentially been used. Indeed, multiple groups have developed SARS-CoV-2 reverse genetics systems for SARS-CoV-2 research in short periods of time (Hou et al., 2020; Torii et al., 2020; Thi Nhu Thao et al. 2020). Additionally, seamless “No See’em” technology pioneered nearly 20 years ago, allows reverse engineering to be used without leaving any traces (Yount et al., 2002).



The idea one cannot get COVID 19 with lab experiments to me is absurd on its face. But it has been proposed by at least one researcher along with the rationale. Here that hypothesis is disagreed with and it is addressed just how that could be done:
Culturing and adapting CoVs and influenza A virus to different cell lines, including human airway epithelial cells, has been conducted in various laboratories (Tse et al., 2014; Menachery et al., 2015; Zeng et al., 2016; Jiang et al., 2020); furthermore, experimental creation of chimeric viruses by directed engineering as discussed above does not require prior modelling.



No conflict of interest is cited. But because DRASTIC has been naively dismissed here I add this from the paper:
Acknowledgment
We are grateful to the D.R.A.S.T.I.C. (Decentralised Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating COVID‐19) Twitter group for their investigative work in uncovering a significant number of previously unpublished facts about SARS‐CoV‐2 and its relative strains.
 
Last edited:
Fairly certain it’s still not peer reviewed.

I think the fact they have not yet been able to produce a vaccine while other methods have been successful, discredits some of that paper. But not necessarily everything in it.
 
The "database" was taken down in Sept the first real human case was likely in Oct, so the timelines don't work. There are other copies of the data around the world and they contain nothing suspicious.
The timelines do work. It's been explained how/why that is in the thread. You are asserting something without addressing the rebuttal posted upthread.

If you want to debate how the timeline doesn't work, then address the reasons it does:

Incubation period before the first cases were found.

Milder cases before the serious ones came to the attention of the medical community.

The fact there were two lineages suggests there is missing time/cases, the virus might have been circulating in Wuhan for at least enough time the Sept action by the Chinese government fits the timeline.

We don't have all the genomes of those initial cases given the 3 researchers who were ill in Nov are not in the data released by China. Either the State Dept is wrong (quite possible) or the cases have been hidden by China (also possible).
​
 
I think the fact they have not yet been able to produce a vaccine while other methods have been successful, discredits some of that paper. But not necessarily everything in it.


Some of the statements are very speculative and would not have got through peer review and as a result would not be citable. It’s a bit sneaky in my opinion.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Vincent and Amy have just discussed the "it breaks the laws of physics" claim in Dalgliesh's paper (or the Daily Fail gloss on that) - and where have we heard that claim before?

Vincent and Amy say it is nonsense.

But here is a question - if it is "against the laws of physics" surely that would be true whether it is in nature or whether it is artificial, would it not?

How is "breaking the laws of physics" an indication of being man-made? It sounds like it would be evidence of being created by a supernatural being.
 
Apparently on Sunday, on TWiV, they will be looking at a paper that shows how the virus is natural and doesn't require any Gain of Function explanation.

(or at least that is how I understand what they said they will be looking at).
 
Amy and Vincent were asked what is the best evidence against a lab-leak (or presumably in favour of zoonotic spillover).

Amy cites this article as an example of an ongoing problem that has likely led to an increase in zoonotic spillover...

The extent to which humans facilitate zoonotic transmission of infectious diseases is unclear. Human encroachment into wildlife habitats as a consequence of expanding urbanization, cropland area and intensive animal farming is hypothesized to favour the emergence of zoonotic diseases. Here we analyse comprehensive, high-resolution datasets on forest cover, cropland distribution, livestock density, human population, human settlements, bat species’ distribution and land-use changes in regions populated by Asian horseshoe bats (>28.5 million km2)—the species that most commonly carry severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS)-related coronaviruses. We identify areas at risk of SARS-related coronavirus outbreaks, showing that areas in China populated by horseshoe bats exhibit higher forest fragmentation and concentrations of livestock and humans than other countries. Our findings indicate that human–livestock–wildlife interactions in China may form hotspots with the potential to increase SARS-related coronavirus transmission from animals to humans.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s43016-021-00285-x

The land-use in various parts of the world, and speficially in China has led to more and more of these serious viruses having contact with humans.
 
Vincent and Amy have just discussed the "it breaks the laws of physics" claim in Dalgliesh's paper (or the Daily Fail gloss on that) - and where have we heard that claim before?

Vincent and Amy say it is nonsense.

But here is a question - if it is "against the laws of physics" surely that would be true whether it is in nature or whether it is artificial, would it not?

How is "breaking the laws of physics" an indication of being man-made? It sounds like it would be evidence of being created by a supernatural being.
Vincent and Amy? First-name basis now? :p

No one here cites the Daily Mail as a source of scientific material. I cited them because they had some direct previews of the paper.

And this is likely a distortion of what the paper actually says: "breaking the laws of physics".
 
General thoughts on amino acids

I looked up the sequences of some DNA binding proteins that fall into the class of leucine zippers. Because DNA carries a negative charge, one expects the protein to have some positively charged amino acid side chains. A portion of the sequence for Jun reads RRMR. That is three positive charges out of four amino acid residues (M is uncharged). A few residues away is a second sequence KCRKRK. That is four positive charges in a row, and 5 out of 6 (C is uncharged). Some of the residues of Fos are in a special kind of alpha-helix called a coiled-coil. In the one-letter code, K is lysine, and R is arginine.

I would point out that being close in sequence is not quite the same thing as being close in three dimensions. A typical alpha-helix makes one full revolution every 3.6 amino acids. One can consult a diagram of a helical wheel to see how the side-chains are dispersed in the standard alpha helix (although a coiled coil is slightly different). In a beta-sheet, each side chain points in an approximately opposite direction to the last one. I am not saying that the claim that 4 positive charges in a row is rare is incorrect, but I am saying that I am not convinced.
 
Last edited:
Vincent and Amy? First-name basis now? :p

No one here cites the Daily Mail as a source of scientific material. I cited them because they had some direct previews of the paper.

And this is likely a distortion of what the paper actually says: "breaking the laws of physics".

Heh heh! I watch them a lot and feel like they are practically family now ;)

Yeah, I’m hedging on whether or not this is what the scientists themselves are saying or whether it is either an excitable press release or just the Daily Fail getting carried away.

I wouldn’t be surprised if we have a case of…dare I say it…. Chinese whispers*.


* I think that is the UK version of what Americans call Broken Telephone. Chinese whispers might not be considered a PC term these days. :o
 
Heh heh! I watch them a lot and feel like they are practically family now ;)

Yeah, I’m hedging on whether or not this is what the scientists themselves are saying or whether it is either an excitable press release or just the Daily Fail getting carried away.

I wouldn’t be surprised if we have a case of…dare I say it…. Chinese whispers*.


* I think that is the UK version of what Americans call Broken Telephone. Chinese whispers might not be considered a PC term these days. :o

Those darn Chinese, inflicting their viruses and whisperings upon us! :mad: :p
 
I looked up the sequences of some DNA binding proteins that fall into the class of leucine zippers. Because DNA carries a negative charge, one expects the protein to have some positively charged amino acid side chains. A portion of the sequence for Jun reads RRMR. That is three positive charges out of four amino acid residues (M is uncharged). A few residues away is a second sequence KCRKRK. That is four positive charges in a row, and 5 out of 6 (C is uncharged). Some of the residues of Fos are in a special kind of alpha-helix called a coiled-coil. In the one-letter code, K is lysine, and R is arginine.

I would point out that being close in sequence is not quite the same thing as being close in three dimensions. A typical alpha-helix makes one full revolution every 3.6 amino acids. One can consult a diagram of a helical wheel to see how the side-chains are dispersed in the standard alpha helix (although a coiled coil is slightly different). In a beta-sheet, each side chain points in an approximately opposite direction to the last one. I am not saying that the claim that 4 positive charges in a row is rare is incorrect, but I am saying that I am not convinced.

I appreciate your insight here. Once the paper is out I'll come back to this with some questions.
 
angrysoba said:
Yeah, I’m hedging on whether or not this is what the scientists themselves are saying or whether it is either an excitable press release or just the Daily Fail getting carried away.


Are you referring to the "laws of physics" quote? Look back one page in this thread, that was a quote the Daily Mail said came from an exclusive interview.



Daily Mail said:
The laws of physics mean that you cannot have four positively charged amino acids in a row. The only way you can get this is if you artificially manufacture it,' Dalgleish told DailyMail.com.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom