Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did you not read the piece by Bloom? Did you only read the Twitter feed?

You probably should read the piece. You will be much better informed about this if you do.

Here's the link again: Recovery of deleted deep sequencing data sheds more light on the early Wuhan SARS-CoV-2 epidemic

It might be confusing because I posted the link in post 1255 and quoted from it in 1256.

I read it and was referencing it before you even figured out it existed.

It says he found mutations specific to the Wuhan fish market, but we already knew that linage A and lineage B had separated by this point and that different linages were circulating elsewhere. IOW we already knew that lineage B from the fish market had distinct mutations, so there is nothing particularly interesting about this conclusion.
 
I read it and was referencing it before you even figured out it existed.
:rolleyes:

It says he found mutations specific to the Wuhan fish market, but we already knew that linage A and lineage B had separated by this point and that different linages were circulating elsewhere. IOW we already knew that lineage B from the fish market had distinct mutations, so there is nothing particularly interesting about this conclusion.
That's all you got out of it?

For whatever reason a lot of these researchers reiterate the Wuhan market was not where the first cases occurred despite the fact that has been reported a year or more ago. What Bloom found is that the A lineage preceded the B (market) lineage and he documents which mutations he based that on.

That wasn't the biggest takeaway here. Rather it appeared from the additional genomic data that COVID was circulating in Wuhan before any of the recognized cases were detected.

As an aside he also found that cases in Guangdong were actually from Wuhan in people who have traveled to Guangdong. He reminded researchers to look further than just where the case was detected when putting the timeline of which cases came first together.


  • So we have evidence of COVID circulating in Wuhan before Nov.
  • There is concomitant evidence cases were circulating in Italy and the US very early on, probably Dec 2019. (I'll come back to this below.)
  • The virus still came ready to go out of the box, Bloom found no evidence of any precursor cases circulating that eventually gained a greater ability to pass from person to person.
  • The WHO report evaluated whether or not cases might have been circulating elsewhere in China before the cases in Wuhan and found no evidence they were.
  • We have the genome database being taken down in mid-Sept. Bloom has recovered some of the deleted data and notes the reasons for covering up the data on the earliest cases in Wuhan is very suspicious.
And here's the coup de gras not yet being discussed much: Did the Military World Games Spread COVID-19?
WASHINGTON – Less than a month before data shows the first Chinese citizen became ill with coronavirus, nearly 300 members of the U.S. military, Department of Defense, and support personnel attended the 2019 Military World Games in Wuhan, China. When the games ended, they returned to at least 219 home bases in 25 states, without ever being screened for possible COVID-19 infection.

According to the Pentagon, there was no reason to do so then, or subsequently. A spokesperson issued a terse email response to the question, saying there was no screening because the event—held from October 18 to 27, 2019—“was prior to the reported outbreak.”

The spokesperson cited December 31, 2019, as the critical outbreak day and that no testing was deemed necessary for any possible exposure prior to February 1, 2020.

Since that email, Pentagon officials have repeatedly declined to speak on or off the record regarding the subject.

Contrary to the Pentagon’s insistence, however, an investigation of COVID-19 cases in the military from official and public source materials shows that a strong correlation exists in COVID-19 cases reported at U.S. military facilities that are home bases of members of the U.S. team that went to Wuhan....

Recent research released from Harvard and Boston University suggests COVID-19 might have been present in China as early as last August, well before the illness was first publicly identified in Wuhan on December 31.

But it wasn't just in the US.
Athletes who participated from other nations—both U.S. allies like France and Italy and adversaries like Iran—have reported suffering from COVID-19 symptoms. Some Iranian athletes died from COVID-19, including some who were in Wuhan, according to news reports not verified by Tehran. ...

The 2019 Military World Games, branded the “Peace Games,” was the largest military sports event ever held in China. More than 9,000 athletes representing the militaries of more than 100 countries competed in 27 sports, ranging from golf to parachuting.


The epidemiology is consistent with other outbreaks that spread too far before they were detected to stop the pandemic. For influenza it has been suggested we could stop the next severe pandemic if the new strain is stopped within a couple of weeks of being detected. After that, it's too late, the genie would be out of the bottle.

It happened with SARS as well when it circulated in Guangdong for at least a month and probably longer before it was detected as a new dangerous pathogen.
 
  • We have the genome database being taken down in mid-Sept. Bloom has recovered some of the deleted data and notes the reasons for covering up the data on the earliest cases in Wuhan is very suspicious.
[/INDENT]

"The database" was and still is available to scientists, but these sequences are not from that database. These sequences are from early human patients, and filed with the NIH. They don't precede the first known human cases they are further samples from these same early human cases.
 
:rolleyes:

That's all you got out of it?

For whatever reason a lot of these researchers reiterate the Wuhan market was not where the first cases occurred despite the fact that has been reported a year or more ago. What Bloom found is that the A lineage preceded the B (market) lineage and he documents which mutations he based that on.

That wasn't the biggest takeaway here. Rather it appeared from the additional genomic data that COVID was circulating in Wuhan before any of the recognized cases were detected.

As an aside he also found that cases in Guangdong were actually from Wuhan in people who have traveled to Guangdong. He reminded researchers to look further than just where the case was detected when putting the timeline of which cases came first together.


  • So we have evidence of COVID circulating in Wuhan before Nov.
  • There is concomitant evidence cases were circulating in Italy and the US very early on, probably Dec 2019. (I'll come back to this below.)
  • The virus still came ready to go out of the box, Bloom found no evidence of any precursor cases circulating that eventually gained a greater ability to pass from person to person.
  • The WHO report evaluated whether or not cases might have been circulating elsewhere in China before the cases in Wuhan and found no evidence they were.
  • We have the genome database being taken down in mid-Sept. Bloom has recovered some of the deleted data and notes the reasons for covering up the data on the earliest cases in Wuhan is very suspicious.
And here's the coup de gras not yet being discussed much: Did the Military World Games Spread COVID-19?

But it wasn't just in the US.


The epidemiology is consistent with other outbreaks that spread too far before they were detected to stop the pandemic. For influenza it has been suggested we could stop the next severe pandemic if the new strain is stopped within a couple of weeks of being detected. After that, it's too late, the genie would be out of the bottle.

It happened with SARS as well when it circulated in Guangdong for at least a month and probably longer before it was detected as a new dangerous pathogen.

It’s interesting about the possible link to the Wuhan Military Games, but I have a question:

Given that the article about it is about a year old, why hasn’t any follow up research on the US soldiers or Iranian soldiers or French or German soldiers moved out understanding of the virus. It seems to me that if the Military Games were a vector or superspreader event and it took place in October 2019, then plenty of scientists outside of China would have been able to isolate other lineages of the virus. There would be no more talk of the earliest known case being in December 2019.

Why are there apparently no scientific papers on this? How did the world’s virologists and epidemiologists miss it and how is it that only the American Prospect know about it, report on it a year ago and ….then.. *crickets*.

It doesn’t make a lot of sense….
 
It’s interesting about the possible link to the Wuhan Military Games, but I have a question:

Given that the article about it is about a year old, why hasn’t any follow up research on the US soldiers or Iranian soldiers or French or German soldiers moved out understanding of the virus. It seems to me that if the Military Games were a vector or superspreader event and it took place in October 2019, then plenty of scientists outside of China would have been able to isolate other lineages of the virus. There would be no more talk of the earliest known case being in December 2019.

Why are there apparently no scientific papers on this? How did the world’s virologists and epidemiologists miss it and how is it that only the American Prospect know about it, report on it a year ago and ….then.. *crickets*.

It doesn’t make a lot of sense….

It's a year old because that is closer to the time the games were played. At that time it was a month before the cases emerged in Wuhan. No one suspected there was any risk.

Recently a number of cases have been found in the US that occurred before the first case in Everett (Seattle). Dr Bloom is the same researcher at Fred Hutch here in Seattle who connected the dots between the Everett case, a case in Seattle found during a flu study and the outbreak at the nursing home in Kirkland, a couple of miles from my house. It demonstrated there were cases in between circulating undetected in the Seattle area.

Re the newly found cases in the US before the first recognized case in Everett: Antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 in All of Us Research Program Participants, January 2-March 18, 2020
Our findings indicate SARS-CoV-2 infections weeks prior to the first recognized cases in 5 US states.
Now it's time to connect the dots between military personnel and those particular states. It sounds like they correlate.

And I believe the same thing has been found in Italy. There are two reports of early cases in Italy, one that has been questioned as it relied on unreliable antibody tests of blood stored for blood donations and another thought to represent actual early cases. I'll have to look at earlier posts in this thread or go into the rabbit hole to find it.


As to why no one looked, that needs a multifactorial answer but mostly because these cases weren't connected to the first known cases. Remember when this started here in the US Fauci told everyone they didn't need testing if they weren't exposed to a known case? If it wasn't for an ED doctor here who went against those guidelines and found patients in the nursing home were indeed dying of COVID those cases would have also been missed.


The plot thickens. :popcorn1
 
Last edited:
"The database" was and still is available to scientists, but these sequences are not from that database. These sequences are from early human patients, and filed with the NIH. They don't precede the first known human cases they are further samples from these same early human cases.
I think you need to reread Bloom's research paper. You seem to have missed a lot in translation.

See my post #1255 upthread where I quote from Bloom's paper.
 
It's a year old because that is closer to the time the games were played. At that time it was a month before the cases emerged in Wuhan. No one suspected there was any risk.

Recently a number of cases have been found in the US that occurred before the first case in Everett (Seattle). Dr Bloom is the same researcher at Fred Hutch here in Seattle who connected the dots between the Everett case, a case in Seattle found during a flu study and the outbreak at the nursing home in Kirkland, a couple of miles from my house. It demonstrated there were cases in between circulating undetected in the Seattle area.

Re the newly found cases in the US before the first recognized case in Everett: Antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 in All of Us Research Program Participants, January 2-March 18, 2020 Now it's time to connect the dots between military personnel and those particular states. It sounds like they correlate.

And I believe the same thing has been found in Italy. There are two reports of early cases in Italy, one that has been questioned as it relied on unreliable antibody tests of blood stored for blood donations and another thought to represent actual early cases. I'll have to look at earlier posts in this thread or go into the rabbit hole to find it.


As to why no one looked, that needs a multifactorial answer but mostly because these cases weren't connected to the first known cases. Remember when this started here in the US Fauci told everyone they didn't need testing if they weren't exposed to a known case? If it wasn't for an ED doctor here who went against those guidelines and found patients in the nursing home were indeed dying of COVID those cases would have also been missed.


The plot thickens. :popcorn1

Hmmm.... so I see it is now a theory being pushed by politicians that the Wuhan Military Games was a superspreader event.

I just wonder why this is not something that scientists themselves seem to be taking an interest in.

And of course, it would not just be of interest to the US, but of every other country that participated.

Could you give some more details about how the military bases and cases connect with the early cases in the US care homes?
 
Hmmm.... so I see it is now a theory being pushed by politicians that the Wuhan Military Games was a superspreader event.
Political motives or not, they may be right. I am only interested in the political issues here in how they have distorted the science or if understanding them adds to the science like Daszak's conflict of interest. The WA Po op ed is very interesting.

I just wonder why this is not something that scientists themselves seem to be taking an interest in.
I think you may be thinking you've not read any papers so that means no one is looking. Bloom is most certainly interested in the early circulation of COVID in Wuhan and in why the data from those early cases has been covered up.
Repeating the analysis of the previous section with these changes shows that several sequences from the deleted project and all sequences from patients infected in Wuhan but sequenced in Guangdong are more similar to the bat coronavirus outgroup than sequences from the Huanan Seafood Market (Figure 5). This fact suggests that the market sequences, which are the primary focus of the genomic epidemiology in the joint WHO-China report (WHO 2021), are not representative of the viruses that were circulating in Wuhan in late December of 2019 and early January of 2020.
We know this but Bloom is corroborating it.

Moving on from lineage B (seafood market) to lineage A being earlier than B:
... given current data, there are two plausible identities for the progenitor of all known SARS-CoV-2. One is proCoV2
described by Kumar et al. (2021), and the other is a sequence
that carries three mutations (C8782T, T28144C, and C29095T)
relative to Wuhan-Hu-1. Crucially, both putative progenitors are
three mutations closer to SARS-CoV-2’s bat coronavirus relatives
than sequences from the Huanan Seafood Market. Note also
that the progenitor of all known SARS-CoV-2 sequences could
still be downstream of the sequence that infected patient zero
depending on the transmission dynamics of the first infections.


And of course, it would not just be of interest to the US, but of every other country that participated.
I suspect that snowball has just started rolling down the hill. Cue your WA Po link.


Could you give some more details about how the military bases and cases connect with the early cases in the US care homes?
They don't connect to the US care home in Kirkland. That case was connected to a man who flew in from Wuhan and who was diagnosed with COVID after arrival. Then the care home cases popped up and another case was found among cultures from a flu study.

The scientists at Fred Hutch looked at all 3 genomes which at the time no one knew were connected. Turns out they were and that suggested COVID was circulating undetected in the Seattle area because the gaps between these 3 related cases were unknown cases. How did it go from Everett (probably didn't, probably went from the airport) to Seattle and to Kirkland?

I heard about the early cases in the US only a couple days ago. It just stayed there in the back of my mind.

Then I read Bloom's paper. He essentially discusses the evidence COVID was circulating in Wuhan before the recognized cases. We know that because of the A & B lineages had to have split somewhere, but Bloom fills in the missing details there hypothetically, not conclusively yet.

The fact there are two lineages in the initial cases was stated to somehow be evidence the outbreak did not start in or near the WIV. But that's simply not required and Bloom's work provides the evidence for the how/why that is not necessarily the case.
The lab accident OTOH, would fit the scenario if COVID was circulating in Wuhan undetected for a few weeks before the initial cases were detected**.

**Keep in mind that we only know when the cases were brought to the attention of the world at large. We don't know when China was aware of the first cases. Taking the databases offline suggests something was up at least as early as mid-Sept.

The military games were in Oct. If the virus first began circulating in Aug or Sept in Wuhan then there would have been enough amplification for a few of those 9,000 military personnel to develop cases and seed the countries they returned home to.
 
Last edited:
This is interesting from the Daily Mail linked from the WA Po op ed about the anecdotal evidence people at the games got sick and some spread it further when they got home:
However, Swedish pentathlete Melina Westerberg said several of her compatriots got sick during the games, but tested negative for the virus. ‘It was just a coincidence,’ she said. ‘We all felt safe.’
The question is, what test(s) were they given and when was it. Because what tests were even available in Sweden in Dec 2019?

OTOH, let's not forget this was also influenza season and many of those people might have had flu. It would be easy for cases to be dismissed as flu and vice versa.

This anecdote was also interesting from the Daily Mail:
Gorges claims Wuhan’s streets were ‘nearly empty’ when he went for a cycle ride in the city. ‘It was a ghost town,’ he said. ‘There were rumours that the government warned the inhabitants not to go out.’
And from WA Po:
During the two-week event, however, many of the international athletes noticed that something was amiss in the city of Wuhan. Some later described it as a “ghost town.”
Sounds like the same anecdote.

And then we get this crap: China furiously hits back at coronavirus cover-up claims with 11,000-word article quoting Lincoln after President Xi was accused of 'personally asking the WHO to hold back information and delaying the global response by four to six WEEKS' Which is probably full of half-truths and red herrings, so it serves to muddy the waters even more.
 
There have been a lot of people who have made claims about having Covid-19 or suspecting that that "really bad cold" in 2019 might have actually been Covid-19.

Who was that singer or actress who claimed she and many others had got Covid-19 when they were in Bangkok? I remember the story was that people all around were sick and dying of a mystery. The problem is that it didn't match up with the cases that had been happening in Thailand at the time which (from what I remember had not seen many infections or hospitalizations).

I think it is quite likely that a lot of people impose a narrative that makes sense to them after the fact.

The Swedish athlete's comments make a lot of sense in that regard. It was flu season and people definitely did get sick around that time, but it doesn't mean it was Covid-19.
 
There have been a lot of people who have made claims about having Covid-19 or suspecting that that "really bad cold" in 2019 might have actually been Covid-19.

Who was that singer or actress who claimed she and many others had got Covid-19 when they were in Bangkok? I remember the story was that people all around were sick and dying of a mystery. The problem is that it didn't match up with the cases that had been happening in Thailand at the time which (from what I remember had not seen many infections or hospitalizations).

I think it is quite likely that a lot of people impose a narrative that makes sense to them after the fact.

The Swedish athlete's comments make a lot of sense in that regard. It was flu season and people definitely did get sick around that time, but it doesn't mean it was Covid-19.
I will be surprised to find out so many of these military athletes actually had COVID. OTOH we are reading about a mere handful that have come to the attention of the news media. So if a couple dozen actually became ill, remember there were more than 9,000 international athletes there.

Given those odds then the cases reported in these articles really only amount to a not so unusual number.

Bottom line, this is anecdotal evidence not systematically collected. There needs to be and hopefully will be some more objective evidence to come.
 
Last edited:
The Swedish athlete's comments make a lot of sense in that regard. It was flu season and people definitely did get sick around that time, but it doesn't mean it was Covid-19.

And we know for certain that viruses spread like wildfire in sports meets - they are the perfect vector, with lots of different people mingling with each other, and quite a lot of bodily fluids exchanged.

Every Olympics this century has seen norovirus sweep through the village, and it'd be surprising if a meet in 'flu season didn't have the same effect.

I am, however, amused by the post-hoc rationalisation of many people who have convinced themselves they had Covid before it existed.
 
...
I am, however, amused by the post-hoc rationalisation of many people who have convinced themselves they had Covid before it existed.
How many of the >9,000 people who attended the games in Wuhan do you suppose this entails?

Many of them thought they had had COVID as far back as June 2020 and no one in the US military followed up. I'm not sure how their concerns were dealt with in other countries. (See previous cite.)

Given the games were in Oct 2019 and we know by late Nov the first recognized cases had already split into 2 lineages. There are multiple reasons to believe they actually were exposed to COVID in Oct.

And then we find early US cases in 5 states: Forbes: Covid Was Circulating In The US Weeks Before First Documented Infection, NIH Study Suggests
The infections in Illinois, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, Mississippi and Massachusetts all came days or weeks before any cases were officially reported in those states. ...

The researchers found antibodies to coronavirus in the blood of at least nine people of the 24,000 tested as part of their study.

Notably, the study did not find positive test results in California, New York or Washington, the states considered to be the initial entry points for the virus. ...

the first known infection identified as a Washington state man who returned from a trip to Wuhan, China, on Jan. 15. Multiple studies, including one from the CDC published in December, have also found evidence the virus was in America at the end of 2019.
There are military bases in all of those states and in most US states for that matter.

Serologic Testing of US Blood Donations to Identify Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2)–Reactive Antibodies: December 2019–January 2020
These findings suggest that SARS-CoV-2 may have been introduced into the United States prior to 19 January 2020.

Contrary to some of the antibody positive tests on blood in Italy, these tests were confirmed by more definitive tests. But I'm going to go back and look at that Italy data again.

Antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 in All of Us Research Program Participants, January 2-March 18, 2020
Methods
All of Us study participants in all 50 US states provided blood specimens during study visits from January 2 to March 18, 2020. A participant was considered seropositive if they tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 immunoglobulin G (IgG) antibodies on the Abbott Architect SARS-CoV-2 IgG ELISA and the EUROIMMUN SARS-CoV-2 ELISA in a sequential testing algorithm. Sensitivity and specificity of the Abbott and EUROIMMUNE ELISAs and the net sensitivity and specificity of the sequential testing algorithm were estimated with 95% confidence intervals.

Results
The estimated sensitivity of Abbott and EUROIMMUN was 100% (107/107 [96.6%, 100%]) and 90.7% (97/107 [83.5%, 95.4%]), respectively. The estimated specificity of Abbott and EUROIMMUN was 99.5% (995/1,000 [98.8%, 99.8%]) and 99.7% (997/1,000 [99.1%, 99.9%), respectively. The net sensitivity and specificity of our sequential testing algorithm was 90.7% (97/107 [83.5%, 95.4%]) and 100.0% (1,000/1,000 [99.6%, 100%]), respectively. Of the 24,079 study participants with blood specimens from January 2 to March 18, 2020, 9 were seropositive, 7 of whom were seropositive prior to the first confirmed case in the states of Illinois, Massachusetts, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Mississippi.

Conclusions
Our findings indicate SARS-CoV-2 infections weeks prior to the first recognized cases in 5 US states.


CNN:
This study, published last Thursday in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, found a statistically significant uptick in clinic and hospital visits by patients who reported respiratory illnesses as early as the week of December 22.

The researchers noticed this trend by looking through nearly 10 million medical records from the UCLA Health system, including three hospitals and 180 clinics. ...

They looked at the records for the month of December 2019 through February 2020 and compared their findings to records from the five prior years.

"With the outpatients, I found a 50% increase in the percentage of patients coming in complaining of a cough. It came out to over 1,000 extra patients above the average of what we would typically see," Elmore said.

The number of patient visits to the ER for respiratory complaints, as well as the number of people hospitalized with acute respiratory failure between December 2019 and February 2020, showed a similar increase compared to records from the past five years. The uptick in cases started in the final week of December.
"Some of these cases could have been due to the flu, some could be for other reasons, but to see these kinds of higher numbers even in the outpatient setting is notable," Elmore said.


We have Andersen again claiming it wasn't possible for anyone who wishes to stick with this POV:
Kristian Andersen, a professor in the Department of Immunology and Microbiology at Scripps Research, doesn't believe Covid-19 is to blame for the rise in the number of patients with respiratory ailments in California in late December.

"We know from the SARS-CoV-2 genetic data that the pandemic started in late November / early December in China so there's absolutely no way the virus could have been spreading widely in December 2019.

In contradiction to Andersen: Emergence of genomic diversity and recurrent mutations in SARS-CoV-2
Phylogenetic estimates support that the COVID-2 pandemic started sometimes around 6 October 2019 – 11 December 2019.


Then there is France: SARS CoV 2 was already spreading in France in late Dec 2019

The paper is copy protected but essentially they found one patient who was admitted to the ICU with the suggestive 'ground glass' on the CT of the chest. No pathogen was found in his sputum (there was no test at the time for COVID). They were not able to recover COVID from stored sputum samples.
 
Last edited:
Incredibly detailed and thorough summary of all the evidence to the date of the paper (Bloom's work is not in there), complete with a 70+ page bibliography: 3. WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY.
This is the third part of a series of reports based on our previously unpublished investigations into the origins of SARS-COV-2. We wish to thank all of the independent researchers who have contributed to this investigation, especially members of the DRASTIC Collective, many of whom wish to remain anonymous for reasons of security and privacy (PDF) 3. WUHAN LABORATORIES, BAT RESEARCH AND BIOSAFETY.

The paper goes over all the evidence of multiple possible scenarios. It includes much of which we've cited throughout this thread but in significantly greater detail. It's well organized. It includes work being done by other labs in Wuhan, issues before the BSL4 was built, images of students and workers collecting bat specimens without proper PPE, papers written by the scientists going back more than a decade including work by Daszak and Shi done in 2019.
This determined researcher also recently discovered another patent “Artificial
breeding method for wild bat” (Anon, 2021b) filed by the Wuhan Institute of Virology in
October 2020 which discusses how to feed captive bats and references the earlier bat cage
patent, revealing definitive evidence that WIV had kept bats for over one year, dating back to
October 2019 or earlier (Google Patents, 2020b). This is despite claims to the contrary by
Peter Daszak (Daszak, 2020). ...

In fact, Daszak, Olival and Li (2020) recently admitted that since 2010, EcoHealth (in
close cooperation with WIV researchers) “collected samples from over 10,000 bats and 2000
other mammals across South China and discovered 52 novel SARSr-CoVs, 122 other βCoVs, more than 350 novel α-CoVs”. More importantly for this investigation is their rather
candid admission that they “found SARS-related CoVs that can bind to human cells, and that
cause SARS-like disease in humanized mouse models that was not prevented with a vaccine
candidate against SARS-CoV, and were not treatable with almost all of the monoclonal therapies being developed for SARS” (Daszak, Olival & Li, 2020).

Every aspect is included from waste disposal to live animals and in vivo cultures of SARS CoV specimens.
 
I think you need to reread Bloom's research paper. You seem to have missed a lot in translation.

See my post #1255 upthread where I quote from Bloom's paper.

Have you even read the paper? It really doesn't sound like you have. It explicitly says that these are sequences from samples taken in Dec 2019 and Jan 2020. These sequence fragments do not come from the "missing database" nor do they pre-date the other early samples people were already looking at.

The analysis on how these samples are related probably won't stand either. There was a similar paper published last year that was widely criticized on the use of RaTG13 to root the phylogenetic tree. It turns out that RaTG13 much too distantly related and not a direct ancestor so you can't get meaningful results using it as the root. Bloom repeats this mistake in his analysis.

He also tries to make a big deal about mutations in lineage B. We already knew that lineage A and lineage B separated in the same timeframe as the jump from animals to humans. By definition this means they are extremely similar but contain unique mutations.

Bloom also fails to address the most interesting feature of the distribution of the early lineages. They are found in separate mutually exclusive clusters, this is more easily explained by having the divergency occur in the animal host just prior to the jump to humans.
 
Wow! An interesting article here which is an interview with an Australian woman who worked at the Wuhan Institute of Virology.

I haven't had time to read it all but she says that the WIV was a good laboratory, with professional scientists, not doing nefarious things. She says she never heard about her colleagues coming down with anything Covid-like and that she is upset by the accusations made against her colleagues, etc...

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/feat...a-lab-scientist-at-wuhan-institute-speaks-out
 
Yeah, I read that. I can't say "wow" was my reaction. The question I wished a reporter had asked her that would have been important was did the city seem shut down in Nov the way military athletes reported? And does she speak fluent Mandarin so that she knows what messages the Chinese population in Wuhan was getting on TV and in papers?

Those would have been important questions to suss out some key pieces of evidence.
 
Yeah, I read that. I can't say "wow" was my reaction. The question I wished a reporter had asked her that would have been important was did the city seem shut down in Nov the way military athletes reported? And does she speak fluent Mandarin so that she knows what messages the Chinese population in Wuhan was getting on TV and in papers? Those would have been important questions to suss out some key pieces of evidence.

You wouldn't need her to tell you that. Surely anyone who resided in Wuhan at the time, such as citizens of the city or foreigners who read and/or speak Putonghua, could tell that.
 
You wouldn't need her to tell you that. Surely anyone who resided in Wuhan at the time, such as citizens of the city or foreigners who read and/or speak Putonghua, could tell that.

All right, you got any of these witnesses who aren't afraid of speaking up against the Chinese government... you know, the government that is pressuring Chinese students in Australia not to criticize the Chinese government? We already know what happened to one doc who tried to speak out that the pandemic was being covered up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom