I'm going to point out a couple things about that report and get into more later.
It's unquestionably biased relying heavily on the WHO report which has already been discredited in a number of areas.
First, this is not the first paper to cite the WHO paper as evidence cases were connected to "other markets". But that is not what is in the WHO report, and even Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the WHO's director general, has challenged the investigation findings which dismissed a lab accident as too unlikely to consider.
Five takeaways from the WHO's report on the origins of the pandemic
There's a better article in the NYT but not everyone has access.
In the WHO final report the earliest cases, those that occurred before the Hunan Market cluster and had no other market connection are dismissed as [paraphrasing] "well they must have had a connection because we don't know who the milder cases were."
In addition the WHO report looked at cases starting in Dec 2019 to document market connections. So without looking at earlier cases they connected some cases to "other markets".
I see no specifics to how these patients are connected to "other markets" or even a name of the market.
And while alluding to sustained transmission naturally occurring with unrecognized cases in the zoonotic hypothesis, the same is ignored when looking at the lab hypothesis. In fact, a lot is ignored about the lab hypothesis.
No mention is made of the data the Chinese removed access to. It's taken for granted we have clear evidence no other WIV associated people had evidence of past COVID infection
yet this was one of the main complaints about the WHO report, the Chinese were not forthcoming with the actual data.
The fact there is a missing connection to the lab is cited as evidence while the missing connection to a spillover event is brushed off. Again, this is despite there being no mention of the data taken offline by the Chinese.
At least one lab accident that could have resulted in a major pandemic isn't noted in their list of all the lab accidents which did not result in sustained transmission, that of the
Reston Virginia incident. And the 1977 influenza lab event is brushed off because they were working on a vaccine.
A discussion is in the paper about "engineered" viruses when no one is seriously considering it was purposefully engineered.
There's at least one citation in this thread noting that GoF research might result in a virus that is indistinguishable from a natural spillover event.
A lot is mentioned about SARS 1 claiming SARS 2 must be natural because SARS 1 was. And they cite the fact it took a decade to find the origin of SARS 1, while no mention is made of the fact we found al lot of bread crumbs on the trail to SARS 1 and we've found no breadcrumbs with SARS 2.
While relying on the WHO report, a number of research findings are left out. Quay and Bloom are not mentioned.
If this is supposed to be a thorough unbiased assessment, it simply isn't.