Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Which ones have been ignored? Provide the post links as well.
Are you on the fence? If so then my post doesn't apply to you.

But you claimed had I read/seen/whatever the evidence for said natural event then I would believe that scenario. Your words, half of which I highlighted:
Belz said:
You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it. You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms.
Those are both false dichotomies. Neither of those claims are true. And given you think I would be convinced if only I looked suggests you are convinced it was a natural spillover event.

Thus the exploding irony meter.

You've no doubt heard the mantra, "your failure to convince me is not due to my failure to see your supporting material/evidence".


As for what evidence supports the lab accident, I'm in the middle of compiling the supporting evidence for both sides. It's going to take a while to pull out all the citations in this thread which is 35 pages long. When I get it done I'll let you know which key pieces I think a lot of people here actually are ignoring. They were tl;dr for some people and my summaries of the papers were also tl;dr.
 
My understanding is that the “evidence” (i.e published papers, interviews, on the record statements - i.e no coverup or conspiracy) is that the “riskier” GoF work was done in Dr Baric’s lab, whereas the research being done in WIV by Dr Shi was of chimerical viruses, and that it was this research being done in BSL-2 labs. It might sound dangerous but apparently there is no way to produce SARS-CoV2 this way.
First off, no Dr Baric's published paper(s) was not the only one. Daszak described his GoF research in the Nov (Dec?) 2019 interview which is posted here.

As for no way to produce SARS CoV 2 this way, that's nonsense. Are you claiming the negative has been proved? Never mind, there are sources which contradict this.

Second, it has already been noted some of this research was done in the level 2 and/or level 3 labs. And it has been noted there are more labs in the area than those at the WIV. I believe there is a reference to Dr Shi needing to care for the live bats when someone (a student I think, I'll have to pull that citation up) was gone on vacation.


In addition, about the bat strains that seem to be so distant from SARS-CoV 2 the point about those viruses is just that they show how common similar viruses are in nature. It is not the natural spillover theory that puts special emphasis on RaTG13, it is the lab leakers who do that. For example, from what I can see, Deigin and Segreto (whose work you have approvingly cited here) seem to suggest that this is the virus that was transformed by GoF or by chimerical manipulation- or both - into SARS CoV-2. (These days on Twitter they seem to be clutching at all kinds of straws such as the Daily Mail and Zero Hedge and assuming that if it goes against the spillover hypothesis - whether the sources are consistent or not - then it is good enough for them.) The only problem is that RaTG13 apparently has something like 1000 mutations scattered throughout that differ from SARS CoV2. It would make no sense to make SARS-CoV2 in a lab from this one instead of simply adding a spike protein on top (iiuc). Instead ir makes sense to think of RaTG13 as simply an ancestor of SARS CoV2 divergent by around 60 or 70 years.
Blah blah blah... You are ignoring the work of Quay, Bloom and others.

Oh and the idea that Nature refused to publish a paper for a year because of Daszak is simply in a very particular type of conspiracy theory territory suggested by the Weinstein Brothers known as the Distributed Idea Suppression Complex (DISC). If you have evidence that Nature were influenced by him specifically then cite it otherwise you are pushing a CT.
The authors documented this, take it up with them.
 
First off, no Dr Baric's published paper(s) was not the only one. Daszak described his GoF research in the Nov (Dec?) 2019 interview which is posted here.

I've already said that. Look:

My understanding is that the “evidence” (i.e published papers, interviews, on the record statements - i.e no coverup or conspiracy) is that the “riskier” GoF work was done in Dr Baric’s lab, whereas the research being done in WIV by Dr Shi was of chimerical viruses, and that it was this research being done in BSL-2 labs

You are "contradicting" by repeating back what I said. It makes no sense.

As for no way to produce SARS CoV 2 this way, that's nonsense. Are you claiming the negative has been proved? Never mind, there are sources which contradict this.

Wut? Now I am confused. Are you arguing that RaTG13 was modified to make SAR CoV2?

Second, it has already been noted some of this research was done in the level 2 and/or level 3 labs. And it has been noted there are more labs in the area than those at the WIV. I believe there is a reference to Dr Shi needing to care for the live bats when someone (a student I think, I'll have to pull that citation up) was gone on vacation.

Duh! I noted it. And I explained that different research was done at different places in different BSLs. BSL 3 is normal for SARS CoV2.

As for you believing there is a reference to Dr Shi caring for bats, this is hardly specific. The details are important not just patching together lots of different anecdotes from different researchers in different labs and creating your own scary narrative from it.

Blah blah blah... You are ignoring the work of Quay,

Yes.

Bloom and others.

Explain.

The authors documented this, take it up with them.

That Peter Daszak had had their paper spiked? Evidence please!
 
Honestly, the most likelyTM lab leak hypotheses would probably either involve:

1.) a virus that has not been disclosed by the WIV

2.) a virus that infected someone during a bat cave expedition

The problem with both scenarios is that they are met with almost exactly the same issues that the spillover hypothesis has - the supposedly unsual structure or the supposedly extremely well-adapted nature of the virus to humans. In other words, those theories are really just spillover theories which add on a lab leak.
 
I've already said that. Look:

You are "contradicting" by repeating back what I said. It makes no sense.

Wut? Now I am confused. Are you arguing that RaTG13 was modified to make SAR CoV2?

Duh! I noted it. And I explained that different research was done at different places in different BSLs. BSL 3 is normal for SARS CoV2.

As for you believing there is a reference to Dr Shi caring for bats, this is hardly specific. The details are important not just patching together lots of different anecdotes from different researchers in different labs and creating your own scary narrative from it.

Yes.

Explain.

That Peter Daszak had had their paper spiked? Evidence please!
Chemical viruses? :confused: Are you trying to say not live cultures?


Are you arguing that RaTG13 was modified to make SAR CoV2?
Not at all, not even close. There were closer SARS CoV that were removed from the database.

That Peter Daszak had had their paper spiked? Evidence please!
Paper spiked? :confused:

If you haven't kept up on Daszak's campaign to turn the larger scientific community against the lab origin hypothesis, no wonder you keep citing him. Do you seriously not understand how Daszak manipulated the Lancet editorial and the WHO team's conclusions?

I'll put that in my review of citations. Again, it's a long thread to search through.

He was successful for a time, now researchers and news sources are reviewing their mistake and considering the lab origin more seriously.

The paper in question was turned down for publication more than a year ago without an explanation. Now it is recognized as a legit paper, not a fringe idea and it has been published. You can read what the authors themselves said about the events. [hang on I'll cite the commentary again]


Here's the paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-92388-5


Here's the WAPo op ed that you "yawned" at:The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting.


I'll have to hunt for the authors' discussion of the paper being rejected without comment in early 2020 and that it is now published after reconsidering the lab origin hypothesis.
 
Last edited:
Are you on the fence?

On the fence? Not anymore. You have failed to demonstrate your claim. Until evidence is presented, I have to provisionally conclude that the most common occurance, which is a natural source for this virus, is what happened.

You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it. You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms.

Those are both false dichotomies.

What the hell are you talking about? There are no dichotomies in those two sentences. It's a list of things you've done.

Do you even read posts before responding to them?
 
Chemical viruses? :confused: Are you trying to say not live cultures?

I said "chimerical viruses"...

A chimera virus is an artificial man-made product, and defined by the Center for Veterinary Biologics (part of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service) as a "new hybrid microorganism created by joining nucleic acid fragments from two or more different microorganisms in which each of at least two of the fragments contain essential genes necessary for replication."

Link

So, no, I am not trying to not say "live cultures".

Not at all, not even close. There were closer SARS CoV that were removed from the database.

Wait!? What????

If this is true then you really need to show your evidence here. I don't believe anyone has shown any such thing.

Look...

Bat coronavirus RaTG13 is a SARS-like betacoronavirus that infects the horseshoe bat Rhinolophus affinis.[2][3] It was discovered in 2013 in bat droppings from a mining cave near the town of Tongguan in Mojiang county in Yunnan, China. As of 2020, it is the closest known relative of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19.[4][5]

Link

You are claiming speculation is fact now.

Paper spiked? :confused:

If you haven't kept up on Daszak's campaign to turn the larger scientific community against the lab origin hypothesis, no wonder you keep citing him. Do you seriously not understand how Daszak manipulated the Lancet editorial and the WHO team's conclusions?

I'll put that in my review of citations. Again, it's a long thread to search through.

He was successful for a time, now researchers and news sources are reviewing their mistake and considering the lab origin more seriously.

The paper in question was turned down for publication more than a year ago without an explanation. Now it is recognized as a legit paper, not a fringe idea and it has been published. You can read what the authors themselves said about the events. [hang on I'll cite the commentary again]


Here's the paper: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-021-92388-5


Here's the WAPo op ed that you "yawned" at:The media called the ‘lab leak’ story a ‘conspiracy theory.’ Now it’s prompted corrections — and serious new reporting.
[/QUOTE]

The highlighted is the only relevant thing here.

Let me remind you of your claim:

Skeptic Ginger said:
The reason the research in question was not published was clearly spelled out: Journal editors were bamboozled by Daszak's efforts.

First you heavily imply that Nature refused the paper because of Peter Daszak.

Then you admit that there was no explanation for the delay in the publication in Nature.

Let me repeat that you are passing off speculation as fact.

If you do not know why Nature had not published the paper until now, you cannot simply fill in the story any way that you like by claiming that it was all the work of Peter Daszak. You simply do not know that!

By the way, Nature is a really, really difficult publication to get into. Peer review often takes a long time. In some cases, papers take years to get published. For all you know, there is nothing nefarious at all about it taking a year to get published.

As it happens, I myself have had papers published in peer reviewed journals, and sometimes the process is boring and infuriating. There is a whole meme for it called "Reviewer 2" (look it up). Now, most people who go through the peer review process just accept that sometimes things take a long time to get published, that the authors and their reviewers may not see eye to eye on things, that perhaps the reviewers may not even really understand the research (even if they are meant to), and sometimes journals are really competitive to get published in (Nature is most certainly one of those). Sometimes papers just get rejected, and sometimes authors simply get fed up with one journal and take it to another journal. This is COMPLETELY NORMAL.

However, there are some people who cannot accept this. They allege professional jealousy or conspiracy or some combination of the two. In some cases, maybe the peer reviewers genuinely are total ********, or maybe they are professionally jealous. But it doesn't mean that the papers cannot see the light of day. What you are alleging is no different from Bret Weinstein's claims that his Nobel-Prize was snatched from him because Nature refused to publish his brilliant work because they were intent on suppressing his Nobel Prize-worthy research.

The level at which you are claiming suppression of the lab leak is simply not credible. Besides, now you are showing us lots of journalists and op ed pieces demonstrating that whatever suppression may have been happening no longer is happening. Congress is even investigating led by two very right wing Trumpists, presumably because it is better to shift blame to China rather than the Trump administrations failings and because they want to goad Biden into spending more time going at it with China than investigating, say, January 6th, or Trump's mishandling of the pandemic. In other words, yes, there are clear and obvious attempts to control the narrative, but much of it is being done by the GOP and other assorted right-wing loons.
 
This is something you repeat a tad too often. Yes I read your post. Yes they are false dichotomies.

Ginger, they are not dichotomies at all. What exactly do you think is a dichotomy? It's a choice between two things. I have not even mentioned something of the sort. I said:

You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it.

That's not a dichotomy. It's a single thing: you've ignored the provided evidence.

You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms.

That's also not a dichotomy. It's two things that you've done, in concert.

Chemical viruses? :confused: Are you trying to say not live cultures?

I rest my case.
 
First off, no Dr Baric's published paper(s) was not the only one. Daszak described his GoF research in the Nov (Dec?) 2019 interview which is posted here.

Vincent Racaniello, who conducted the interview, has said that the conclusions you are jumping to about it are wrong. This has been explained and documented in this thread several times.

As for no way to produce SARS CoV 2 this way, that's nonsense. Are you claiming the negative has been proved? Never mind, there are sources which contradict this.

It's been documented in the peer reviewed literature that there is no way to get to SARS-CoV-2 from any known virus.

Second, it has already been noted some of this research was done in the level 2 and/or level 3 labs. And it has been noted there are more labs in the area than those at the WIV. I believe there is a reference to Dr Shi needing to care for the live bats when someone (a student I think, I'll have to pull that citation up) was gone on vacation.

A few days ago you linked to a paper that said Covid-19 could not jump directly from bats to humans and insisted it was evidence for a lab leak, when in fact it makes the scenario you are presenting here very unlikely.
 
Last edited:
The highlighted is the only relevant thing here.

Let me remind you of your claim:



First you heavily imply that Nature refused the paper because of Peter Daszak.

Then you admit that there was no explanation for the delay in the publication in Nature.

Let me repeat that you are passing off speculation as fact.

If you do not know why Nature had not published the paper until now, you cannot simply fill in the story any way that you like by claiming that it was all the work of Peter Daszak. You simply do not know that!

By the way, Nature is a really, really difficult publication to get into. Peer review often takes a long time. In some cases, papers take years to get published. For all you know, there is nothing nefarious at all about it taking a year to get published.

As it happens, I myself have had papers published in peer reviewed journals, and sometimes the process is boring and infuriating. There is a whole meme for it called "Reviewer 2" (look it up). Now, most people who go through the peer review process just accept that sometimes things take a long time to get published, that the authors and their reviewers may not see eye to eye on things, that perhaps the reviewers may not even really understand the research (even if they are meant to), and sometimes journals are really competitive to get published in (Nature is most certainly one of those). Sometimes papers just get rejected, and sometimes authors simply get fed up with one journal and take it to another journal. This is COMPLETELY NORMAL.

However, there are some people who cannot accept this. They allege professional jealousy or conspiracy or some combination of the two. In some cases, maybe the peer reviewers genuinely are total ********, or maybe they are professionally jealous. But it doesn't mean that the papers cannot see the light of day. What you are alleging is no different from Bret Weinstein's claims that his Nobel-Prize was snatched from him because Nature refused to publish his brilliant work because they were intent on suppressing his Nobel Prize-worthy research.

The fact that papers with fundamentally similar findings have already been published in Nature suggests there were problems with the paper itself had problems that needed to be fixed. Indeed it STILL has problems that should have been fixed.

This paper:
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-21006-9
published back in February has somewhat similar findings. The Wrobel et al paper from back in Feb and the supposedly suppressed paper from Piplani et al both show that SARS-CoV-2 binds strongly to both human and Pangolin ACE2 but only binds weakly to Bat ACE2.

Piplani et al spends a lot of time talking about how the binding strength to human ACE2 is higher than to Pangolin ACE2 in an apparent effort to suggest SARS-CoV-2 was somehow "tuned" for humans. The Wrobel et al paper, however, also shows that Pangolin specific Covid relatives also bind more strongly to human ACE2 than they do to their own target hosts. IOW this detail just doesn't support the suggestions being made in the Piplani et al paper.
 
Ginger, they are not dichotomies at all. What exactly do you think is a dichotomy? It's a choice between two things. I have not even mentioned something of the sort. I said

That's not a dichotomy. It's a single thing: you've ignored the provided evidence.
Don't know why I bother:
Belz said:
You've been provided with such evidence, you've ignored it.
Option one) I saw the evidence and ignored it.
Option two) I didn't read the post with the evidence essentially ignoring it.
Option three) I saw the evidence and was not convinced by it.

You're right, false dichotomy was less precise but my point was there was another option, the evidence was not convincing.


Belz said:
You've presented very weak evidence, and ignored the criticisms.
Option one) the evidence was weak and I ignored the criticisms.
Option two) the evidence was not weak and I ignored the criticisms.
Option three) the evidence was not weak and the criticisms were unconvincing.

More of a false dichotomy offering one possibility when there were other possibilities.


Misreading one word is hardly "ignoring" anything. Especially given it was a red herring anyway because why would it matter if Shi was or was not working on chimeras when the issue was working with live cultures or not.



I have a 2 hour appointment coming up. After that I'll continue pulling the citations from this thread.

You guys are going on and on with the same arguments and it is a waste of time to keep answering them. I think a look at the overall evidence will be more productive.
 
Last edited:
Don't know why I bother:
Option one) I saw the evidence and ignored it.
Option two) I didn't read the post with the evidence essentially ignoring it.
Option three) I saw the evidence and was not convinced by it.

There is no option, Ginger. I'm saying that what happened is ONE. I made no mention of other options and presented no alternative. You're wrong, but as usual you just can't admit it.

Option one) the evidence was weak and I ignored the criticisms.
Option two) the evidence was not weak and I ignored the criticisms.
Option three) the evidence was not weak and the criticisms were unconvincing.

More of a false dichotomy offering one possibility when there were other possibilities.

Again, as above, I made no mention of any "option" nor did I present alternatives. I made a statement based on what I observed. You simply do not know what false dichotomies are. You are embarrassing yourself.

What you mean to say is that this isn't what happened. Unfortunately for you, you have not erased your posts in the thread so we can see everything that transpired.
 
There is no option, Ginger. I'm saying that what happened is ONE. I made no mention of other options and presented no alternative. You're wrong, but as usual you just can't admit it.

Again, as above, I made no mention of any "option" nor did I present alternatives. I made a statement based on what I observed. You simply do not know what false dichotomies are. You are embarrassing yourself.

What you mean to say is that this isn't what happened. Unfortunately for you, you have not erased your posts in the thread so we can see everything that transpired.
That's your problem, 'you didn't mention them'?

Not how I see a false dichotomy but by all means take a victory lap. :rolleyes:

But stop with the insults, I'm not embarrassed and I know what a false dichotomy is. These petty insults only express your frustration and they don't move the discussion forward.
 
That's your problem, 'you didn't mention them'?

That is what a false dichotomy IS! You mention two options as if they are the only ones available while ignoring others. That's not what I did: I simply described your behaviour in this thread.

For pete's sake you could just look the damn thing up.

But stop with the insults, I'm not embarrassed and I know what a false dichotomy is. These petty insults only express your frustration and they don't move the discussion forward.

What insults? That you don't know what the phrase means? That we can read your posts and see what you have done in this thread? That you are embarrassing yourself? None of those are insults.

As for moving the discussion forward, we're way past that. You cannot support your pet theory, and so we're stuck in a loop.
 
An in depth critique.

https://zenodo.org/record/5075888

Most of the points raised here are discussed.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

hmmm....I'm just having a look at that.

I just want to flag up something that doesn't look right to me.

Page 4, the maps - b has labels for some of the landmarks in Wuhan, but it looks mislabelled to me.

Judging by where the Huanan Seafood Market is placed, it looks to me as though the WIV is in the wrong place. It should really be somewhere around where the "Qiyimen Market" is labelled (when I look it up on Google Maps, it appears to be labelled the Qiyimen Shengxian Market). Then the Baishazahou Market is labelled slightly to the West.

I don't know if it really amounts to much, but I don't want the lab leakers to think I am only critical of their evidence. ;)

I can see how the claim is that the infections began on the Huanan Market side of the river and then later on the WIV side of the river, but I don't think the maps really show that except by accepting the arbitrary colour-coding that reflects detected cases, but that is spread over a fairly short time period, so it is really difficult to see when people actually became infected as well as those who may have been infected but asymptomatic.

Am I missing something, Capsid, or is this type of evidence extremely ambiguous?

(Admittedly, I haven't read the pre-print paper)
 
An in depth critique.

https://zenodo.org/record/5075888

Most of the points raised here are discussed.
I'm going to point out a couple things about that report and get into more later.

It's unquestionably biased relying heavily on the WHO report which has already been discredited in a number of areas.

First, this is not the first paper to cite the WHO paper as evidence cases were connected to "other markets". But that is not what is in the WHO report, and even Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the WHO's director general, has challenged the investigation findings which dismissed a lab accident as too unlikely to consider.

Five takeaways from the WHO's report on the origins of the pandemic

There's a better article in the NYT but not everyone has access.

In the WHO final report the earliest cases, those that occurred before the Hunan Market cluster and had no other market connection are dismissed as [paraphrasing] "well they must have had a connection because we don't know who the milder cases were."

In addition the WHO report looked at cases starting in Dec 2019 to document market connections. So without looking at earlier cases they connected some cases to "other markets". I see no specifics to how these patients are connected to "other markets" or even a name of the market.

And while alluding to sustained transmission naturally occurring with unrecognized cases in the zoonotic hypothesis, the same is ignored when looking at the lab hypothesis. In fact, a lot is ignored about the lab hypothesis.

No mention is made of the data the Chinese removed access to. It's taken for granted we have clear evidence no other WIV associated people had evidence of past COVID infection yet this was one of the main complaints about the WHO report, the Chinese were not forthcoming with the actual data.

The fact there is a missing connection to the lab is cited as evidence while the missing connection to a spillover event is brushed off. Again, this is despite there being no mention of the data taken offline by the Chinese.

At least one lab accident that could have resulted in a major pandemic isn't noted in their list of all the lab accidents which did not result in sustained transmission, that of the Reston Virginia incident. And the 1977 influenza lab event is brushed off because they were working on a vaccine.

A discussion is in the paper about "engineered" viruses when no one is seriously considering it was purposefully engineered.

There's at least one citation in this thread noting that GoF research might result in a virus that is indistinguishable from a natural spillover event.

A lot is mentioned about SARS 1 claiming SARS 2 must be natural because SARS 1 was. And they cite the fact it took a decade to find the origin of SARS 1, while no mention is made of the fact we found al lot of bread crumbs on the trail to SARS 1 and we've found no breadcrumbs with SARS 2.


While relying on the WHO report, a number of research findings are left out. Quay and Bloom are not mentioned. If this is supposed to be a thorough unbiased assessment, it simply isn't.
 
I'm going to point out a couple things about that report and get into more later.

It's unquestionably biased relying heavily on the WHO report which has already been discredited in a number of areas.

First, this is not the first paper to cite the WHO paper as evidence cases were connected to "other markets". But that is not what is in the WHO report, and even Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, the WHO's director general, has challenged the investigation findings which dismissed a lab accident as too unlikely to consider.

Five takeaways from the WHO's report on the origins of the pandemic

There's a better article in the NYT but not everyone has access.

In the WHO final report the earliest cases, those that occurred before the Hunan Market cluster and had no other market connection are dismissed as [paraphrasing] "well they must have had a connection because we don't know who the milder cases were."

In addition the WHO report looked at cases starting in Dec 2019 to document market connections. So without looking at earlier cases they connected some cases to "other markets". I see no specifics to how these patients are connected to "other markets" or even a name of the market.

And while alluding to sustained transmission naturally occurring with unrecognized cases in the zoonotic hypothesis, the same is ignored when looking at the lab hypothesis. In fact, a lot is ignored about the lab hypothesis.

No mention is made of the data the Chinese removed access to. It's taken for granted we have clear evidence no other WIV associated people had evidence of past COVID infection yet this was one of the main complaints about the WHO report, the Chinese were not forthcoming with the actual data.

The fact there is a missing connection to the lab is cited as evidence while the missing connection to a spillover event is brushed off. Again, this is despite there being no mention of the data taken offline by the Chinese.

At least one lab accident that could have resulted in a major pandemic isn't noted in their list of all the lab accidents which did not result in sustained transmission, that of the Reston Virginia incident. And the 1977 influenza lab event is brushed off because they were working on a vaccine.

A discussion is in the paper about "engineered" viruses when no one is seriously considering it was purposefully engineered.

There's at least one citation in this thread noting that GoF research might result in a virus that is indistinguishable from a natural spillover event.

A lot is mentioned about SARS 1 claiming SARS 2 must be natural because SARS 1 was. And they cite the fact it took a decade to find the origin of SARS 1, while no mention is made of the fact we found al lot of bread crumbs on the trail to SARS 1 and we've found no breadcrumbs with SARS 2.


While relying on the WHO report, a number of research findings are left out. Quay and Bloom are not mentioned. If this is supposed to be a thorough unbiased assessment, it simply isn't.

To be fair, some of what you cite is probably not even considered evidence. Bloom’s paper is evidence of…what? Some data was deleted? But what does that prove?

As for Quay, I don’t even know if anyone takes his work seriously. Have any of his papers been published?
 
hmmm....I'm just having a look at that.

I just want to flag up something that doesn't look right to me.

Page 4, the maps - b has labels for some of the landmarks in Wuhan, but it looks mislabelled to me.

Judging by where the Huanan Seafood Market is placed, it looks to me as though the WIV is in the wrong place. It should really be somewhere around where the "Qiyimen Market" is labelled (when I look it up on Google Maps, it appears to be labelled the Qiyimen Shengxian Market). Then the Baishazahou Market is labelled slightly to the West.

I don't know if it really amounts to much, but I don't want the lab leakers to think I am only critical of their evidence. ;)

I think you are looking at the WIV headquarters building. The BSL-4 lab itself is reported as being in the Zhengdian Scientific Park in the Jiangxia District which about right.

https://lssf.cas.cn/en/facilities-view.jsp?id=ff8080814ff56599014ff59e677e003d
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom