Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Excuse my ignorance, but I was wondering whether one or more of the lab workers got it "naturally" as well. Hadn't considered that they might have got sick while collecting samples.

Serology on WiV staff apparently showed no sign of previous Covid infection.

Lab leak supporters claim this is evidence of a cover-up and want someone other than China to repeat these tests. Any test performed now wouldn't be valid since the infection could have occurred in the year and a half since the pandemic started. The cover-up claims are essentially impossible to prove or disprove at this point.
 
So this is probably going to cause some commotion...

one of the members of the WHO investigation, Paul Embarek, was giving some information about their trip to China and how China did not want any possibility of a lab leak to be in the report. This actually doesn't sound that weird, and the WHO themselves pointed out that they had to address the question even if only to say it was unlikely. Embarek spitballed that one possible way in which the lab could be implicated is if a worker at the WIV got infected in the field:

Link

I'd be interested to see the whole interview although I can imagine that much of what Embarek says is likely to be quote-mined or repackaged as:

"WHO INVESTIGATOR NOW SAYS COVID PROBABLY FROM A LAB!"
You know a lab worker getting infected directly from the Yunnan bats is not a new idea, right? It was always on the lab origin list. Or it could have been a student.

I tried to find any evidence of trips to the mine or other places in Yunnan in the fall/winter of 2019 and I couldn't find any. Doesn't mean it didn't happen but it does mean there still was no direct evidence. And there should still be a virus sample from the mine or nearby which is a closer match than the one trotted out as the 'closest ancestor'. Not to mention, why hide patient zero if there was one connected to the WIV?

I find that last sentence in your post to be hyperbole, but this is one of the biggest problems:
However, Embarek told TV 2 that while investigators were able to get access to laboratories in Wuhan, China, and have their questions answered, "we did not get to look at any documentation at all."

So we have the location of the first cases.
No immediate/proximal source animal.
And the Chinese unwilling to allow a proper look.

One could explain that last one by the fact Dump was POTUS at the time. But he's out of office now. And one would think China would want to clear its name. OTOH, I would think neither China nor the US trust the other in this matter.
 
Excuse my ignorance, but I was wondering whether one or more of the lab workers got it "naturally" as well. Hadn't considered that they might have got sick while collecting samples.

Although if they had got it in the wild, it would make the whole database thing and the “gain of function” thing a complete red herring, not to mention the fact that it would actually be a spillover and NOT a lab leak.
 
Although if they had got it in the wild, it would make the whole database thing and the “gain of function” thing a complete red herring, not to mention the fact that it would actually be a spillover and NOT a lab leak.

Re the database: collecting specimens resulting in a worker or student infection should mean that the proximal source was likely in the database.

And pictures of the workers/students collecting specimens and caring for the live bats at the WIV include images and accounts of direct exposures to bites, scratches, and skin due to lack of PPE. (Sources cited in this thread.)

It would hardly be a natural spillover event if a worker/student were infected collecting specimens for the WIV.

As for GoF, yeah, that might not have been part of such a scenario.
 
Although if they had got it in the wild, it would make the whole database thing and the “gain of function” thing a complete red herring, not to mention the fact that it would actually be a spillover and NOT a lab leak.

So the pandemic started due to the existence of the lab.

No lab.
No pandemic.

If not p then not q.
 
So the pandemic started due to the existence of the lab.


Stupid conclusion is stupid.

First of all, we are talking about speculation.

Second, this is like the stupid conclusion that Jon Stewart came up with "The pandemic was caused by science.

Even if (and this is a big if), it came from a lab worker being bitten in the field by a bat, we are still talking about bats in the in the wild. In which case, they could also be biting miners, or farm workers, or urinating in someone's juice etc...
 
Stupid conclusion is stupid.

First of all, we are talking about speculation.

Second, this is like the stupid conclusion that Jon Stewart came up with "The pandemic was caused by science.

Even if (and this is a big if), it came from a lab worker being bitten in the field by a bat, we are still talking about bats in the in the wild. In which case, they could also be biting miners, or farm workers, or urinating in someone's juice etc...

I don't recall Stewart said that. He did say prematurely that the coincidence made it conclusive. And not like him to do so, he used his political microphone to drift away from the science.

I fail to see how a worker or student collecting specimens for the WIV is the same as a casual exposure of people in the vicinity. That seems to me like an attempt to shoehorn 'spillover' into the equation where it's dicey to claim that at best.

However, that hypothesis that it could have been anyone in Yunnan still leaves you with the hurdle that it did not start in Yunnan, or Guangdong but rather in Wuhan and not just anywhere in Wuhan but close to the labs in the city/province (of 11 million people BTW) where coronaviruses were being studied.
 
And speaking of epidemiology, I came across these sources and I don't know if they've been posted in this thread before, they probably have been. A number of sources cited early in the thread can now be revisited to see how they fit in with additional information that has been posted since.

I've asked and it hasn't been answered if there were 2 lineages early on where did those lineages arise?

I've seen 2 (I think) different analysis that tried to place the A, B and C lineages in places distant from Wuhan. Bloom addressed the problem that to do that one had to ignore where the persons became infected and count them as if they were infected in the same place as they were diagnosed, thus distorting the temporal position these lineages fit in the scheme of things.

I also mentioned that one thing which did come out of the WHO final report was an examination of flu and pneumonia cases for all of 2019 in China and they found no unusual spikes in cases anywhere until the cases showed up in Wuhan.

Some additional epidemiological evidence was published by the CCDC in Feb in 2020 shortly after pandemic case numbers exploded. In looking for patient zero it helps to look at the epidemiology. How fast do cases increase once they enter a new location. It turns out, very quickly.

The Epidemiological Characteristics of an Outbreak of 2019 Novel Coronavirus Diseases (COVID-19) — China, 2020
Methods: All COVID-19 cases reported through February 11, 2020 were extracted from China’s Infectious Disease Information System. Analyses included the following: 1) summary of patient characteristics; 2) examination of age distributions and sex ratios; 3) calculation of case fatality and mortality rates; 4) geo-temporal analysis of viral spread; 5) epidemiological curve construction; and 6) subgroup analysis.

Results: A total of 72,314 patient records—44,672 (61.8%) confirmed cases, 16,186 (22.4%) suspected cases, 10,567 (14.6%) clinically diagnosed cases (Hubei Province only), and 889 asymptomatic cases (1.2%)—contributed data for the analysis. Among confirmed cases, most were aged 30–79 years (86.6%), diagnosed in Hubei (74.7%), and considered mild (80.9%). A total of 1,023 deaths occurred among confirmed cases for an overall case fatality rate of 2.3%. The COVID-19 spread outward from Hubei Province sometime after December 2019, and by February 11, 2020, 1,386 counties across all 31 provinces were affected. The epidemic curve of onset of symptoms peaked around January 23–26, then began to decline leading up to February 11. A total of 1,716 health workers have become infected and 5 have died (0.3%).

Conclusions: COVID-19 epidemic has spread very quickly taking only 30 days to expand from Hubei to the rest of Mainland China. With many people returning from a long holiday, China needs to prepare for the possible rebound of the epidemic.

See the map in the link as well as the graphs.

At the end of Dec 2019 all recognized cases were in Hubei Province in 14 counties. Just 10 days later cases had spread to 113 counties in 20 provinces. Then days after that there were cases in 627 counties in 30 provinces. Ten more days: 1310 counties in 31 provinces. By Feb 11 it was 1386 counties in 31 provinces. China has 31 provinces.

[note: What you see in addition to how quickly these cases spread is that when you get to the end of the timeframe being counted, it's not that numbers taper off. Rather it is that one isn't seeing existing cases that have not yet been diagnosed.]

We have what we need here and that is to demonstrate had cases started elsewhere in China and moved to Wuhan one would expect to see multiple foci of cases not just the one foci in Wuhan. IOW there would have been seeded clusters that converged rather than a single foci from which cases spread out.

That is true even if one missed additional foci at first.

And that point is especially important when you consider the next piece of data the CCDC provided. Dec 2020: Study from China's CDC suggests Wuhan may have had 10 times as many COVID-19 cases as reported - Wuhan, China, was the original epicenter of the pandemic.
China’s Center for Disease Control and Prevention conducted a serological survey in April among a sample of more than 34,000 people in the general population of Wuhan.
The CDC found 4.43 percent of those tested in Wuhan had antibodies for the virus, indicating they were infected some time in the past.
The ratio suggests the city of more than 11 million people may have had close to 500,000 infections, nearly 10 times the roughly 50,000 confirmed COVID-19 cases the city has reported.


There's no evidence to suggest Wuhan wasn't the center of the pandemic and there's evidence cases went from very few to as many as 500,000 within ~3 months.

It's easy to see how the first cases might indeed have started in Sept of 2019 as at least 2 sources cited upthread believe the data suggests. Efforts might have been made to control the outbreak and it's possible the Chinese believe they had. But they would have been wrong.


Next up, when and what was deleted from Chinese data bases and who was silenced?
 
I've seen 2 (I think) different analysis that tried to place the A, B and C lineages in places distant from Wuhan. Bloom addressed the problem that to do that one had to ignore where the persons became infected and count them as if they were infected in the same place as they were diagnosed, thus distorting the temporal position these lineages fit in the scheme of things.

I also mentioned that one thing which did come out of the WHO final report was an examination of flu and pneumonia cases for all of 2019 in China and they found no unusual spikes in cases anywhere until the cases showed up in Wuhan.


I don't know what you are referring to when you say that some different analyses "tried" to place the sources as being distant from Wuhan.

From what I can gather, basically everyone agrees it began in Wuhan (unless you can find some sources other than those that say, for example, it began in Italy or Fort Detrick, which nobody seriously believes).

The only thing that has been suggested is that it may have come to Wuhan through the wildlife trade. If that is the case, then maybe some people who raised the wildlife might have some kind of antibodies against SARS-CoV2 if they had been in prolonged contact with infected animals. But that is speculation.
 
...It's easy to see how the first cases might indeed have started in Sept of 2019 as at least 2 sources cited upthread believe the data suggests.
Thanks for the paper on the start and spread of the COVID-19 pandemic, Skeptic Ginger.

The news article is a reporter is hyping well known epidemiology. The number of people with antibodies to a virus is always larger than the number of people who report infections. People do not report no symptoms from an infection. People usually do not report mild symptoms from an infection. Reporting systems need resources and understanding, especially when they initially set up for an epidemic. As the article states, many countries underreported cases for that reason.
There may be additional reasons for underreporting in a country such as China such as distrust of the government, officials wanting to underplay their statistics, and pressure from the the government.

Searching this 50 page thread for Sept 2019 does not give any sources for speculations about cases in September 2019. Please link to them.
There some posts about a February 2021 preprint that is still not published. The public database of samples and viral sequences of the Wuhan Institute of Virology went offline on 12th September 2019. They cite why the database was placed offline. There was a hacking attack. Nothing was unavailable because the sequences are published and in the US-run GenBank database.

There is mention of Andersen's biological clock model showing a time to the most recent common ancestor in September 2019. A post picking a single strict clock model result from Table 8.
WHO-convened global study of origins of SARS-CoV-2: China Part page 80.
Different approaches have been used to analyse the SARS-CoV-2 genomes accumulated at different time points as the pandemic developed (Table 8), and the results suggest that the time to most recent common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred by more than 10 groups using different approaches is similar: between mid-November and mid-December 2019.(19, 31-42)

The tMRCA and mutation rate were estimated with the genomic sequences of 66 early cases (from Wuhan, before 31 January 2020). The inferred date of the tMRCA was 11 December 2019, with the 95% confidence interval ranging from 13 November 2019 to 23 December 2019, and the mutation rate was estimated to be 6.54 × 10-4 per site per year, with the confidence interval (3.32 × 10-4 – 9.54 × 10-4) (Table 9). The team also inferred the tMRCA with fixed mutation rate values (from previous studies), listed in Table 9. Overall, all these values are consistent with existing results, indicating a recent common ancestor of these viral genomic sequences.
Table 8. Time to the most common ancestor (tMRCA) inferred in different studies. ...
Strict clock model entries:
Bai et al. (31)|late September
Lu et al. (40)|2019.12.1
Duchene et al. (33)|2019.11.19
Volz et al. (42)|2019.12.8
Gómez-Carballa et al. (35)|2019.11.7
 
Last edited:
I don't know what you are referring to when you say that some different analyses "tried" to place the sources as being distant from Wuhan.
I'd have to go hunt for them. Essentially one source thought the genetic trail found the A lineage was dominant in SE Asia and I believe he suggested that is where it originated. I don't recall the specifics of the other but I believe it was similar. Nothing supports that so there is probably no reason to hunt the links down.

From what I can gather, basically everyone agrees it began in Wuhan (unless you can find some sources other than those that say, for example, it began in Italy or Fort Detrick, which nobody seriously believes).
That's because you never read my posts or sources.

I think it was worthwhile to look at both of those potential origins, I don't think they've been supported. But I've been trying to find out what we know about the early Italian, French and US cases. I believe the US CDC has some information about the earlier cases (7 cases/5 states) but they've not published it. I hope we will at least see some antibody testing on those participants in the military games with the 90day Biden investigation but one would think we'd have heard something by now.

The only thing that has been suggested is that it may have come to Wuhan through the wildlife trade. If that is the case, then maybe some people who raised the wildlife might have some kind of antibodies against SARS-CoV2 if they had been in prolonged contact with infected animals. But that is speculation.
Again, no spot fires, no proximal source species.

There were a small percentage of people in Yunnan with antibodies. But nothing has come of looking for a proximal source in Yunnan or elsewhere.
 
Stupid conclusion is stupid.

First of all, we are talking about speculation.

Second, this is like the stupid conclusion that Jon Stewart came up with "The pandemic was caused by science.

Even if (and this is a big if), it came from a lab worker being bitten in the field by a bat, we are still talking about bats in the in the wild. In which case, they could also be biting miners, or farm workers, or urinating in someone's juice etc...

No lab no pandemic is a substantial consideration, indeed pivotal since this pandemic has wrecked the world.
 
This seems to be the new part IMHO (from https://www.newsweek.com/wuhan-lab-...bable-covid-origin-theorywho-official-1618686)

Embarek said he had been told by management there that the lab had changed premises in early December 2019—around the time COVID was first detected. He said it would be "interesting to look at that period and this laboratory" at some point.

In some other article they claimed it happened on December 2nd. One Czech article also claimed that the original location was right next to the wet market. I wasn't able to find that claim in any article in English though ..

Edit:
It seems to be from this Danish interview .. and it's the new location which is closer to the market ..

https://translate.google.com/transl...re-smittet-af-flagermus-som-den-foerste-siger
 
Last edited:
Not true. I read some of them. I avoid the bull **** ones so I probably read about 10% of your sources.

I don’t click on Daily Caller, American Thinker, various other far-right documents etc…

The Fort Detrick CT came from the deep swamp -- Russian disinformation sites, Alex Jones and Q people. I can probably post where that CT evolved from better than we can trace this actual virus. But it's probably off topic in this forum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom