Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
I find that lab move to be an under-explored event.The following is from an interview given by Peter Embarek, who led the WHO team in Wuhan in 2021. He reveals some of the political issues that the team had to face when preparing the final report.
https://nyheder.tv2.dk/udland/2021-...re-smittet-af-flagermus-som-den-foerste-siger
The text is in Danish, and I have translated it below.
You also have to move the viral collection, the sample collection, and other collections from one place to the other. This entire procedure is a disturbing element in the daily working of a laboratory, so that is why it at one point also will be interesting to look at this period, and this lab, says Peter Embarek.
Interesting in that the hypothesis of a worker getting infected directly from a bat almost seems like a convenient compromise about the origin. There are a number of news articles reporting on the TV documentary. They say much the same things as you posted.
Aljazeera: WHO scientist puts COVID lab leak theory back under spotlight - Head of WHO mission probing pandemic origins says virus may have started with a Wuhan lab staffer becoming infected.
The only people likely to have approached these types of bats are employees of the city laboratories, he said. ...
Long derided as a right-wing conspiracy theory and vehemently rejected by Beijing, the lab leak hypothesis has been gaining momentum....
Jamie Metzl, who sits on a WHO advisory board on human genome editing and who has been leading efforts calling for an independent investigation on how COVID-19 started, described Embarek’s comments as “a game-changer”, describing his earlier declaration that a lab leak was unlikely “shameful”.
“It’s even more significant that the international expert team who stated with such confidence in the February Wuhan press event that a lab origin was unlikely themselves believed this was not the case and were simply trying to assuage their Chinese government-affiliated hosts,” said Metzl.
All of the scientists on the WHO-led team were approved by China and the team’s agenda and final report were also vetted by the Chinese government.
And as much as a couple people in this thread are downplaying what the WHO chief said about the lab accident:
In recent weeks, WHO chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus has acknowledged it was “ premature ” to rule out a possible lab leak as the source of COVID-19, saying last month that he was asking China to be more transparent about the early days of the pandemic.
“I was a lab technician myself. I’m an immunologist and I have worked in the lab and lab accidents happen,” Tedros said. “It’s common.”
From the AP: WHO expert ‘had concerns’ about lab close to 1st COVID cases
The Danish documentary also featured Ben Embarek expressing his worries in January about the Wuhan branch of the Chinese CDC, concerns that have never been publicly disclosed by WHO. While numerous experts have questioned whether there might have been a lab accident at the Wuhan Institute of Virology — where scientists were studying coronaviruses — there has been less interest in another nearby facility.
“What is more concerning to me is the other lab,” Ben Embarek said. “The one that is next to the market,” he explained, referring to the Wuhan branch of the Chinese CDC, located just 500 meters (547 yards) away from the Huanan market.
I thought I saw a note in one of these articles about a recent trip to the Yunnan mine/caves but I can't find it now. Without an account of a recent trip to obtain more specimens or without a specimen that is a closer match than the one Shi claimed was the only one the WIV had, I can't see giving any more weight to this hypothesis than other accidental releases from one of the Chinese labs.
But it is clear the lab origin continues to gain more traction the further away people get from the blatantly tainted Daszak/Chinese WHO report.