Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I agree. But the claim was that it was evidence that none of the lab workers were registered as having been sick. We don’t know if relatives of lab workers were sick with with Covid-19 because this would have been at a stage when nobody would have connected a bout of cough or influenza with having an unknown disease, and I don’t think anybody would have started contact tracing at this stage.

No evidence is no evidence.

Are we going to now argue that we don't care if there is no evidence because something might have happened?

The serological tests apparently showed no signs of infection. Yes, the Chinese might be lying, but again, we have no evidence.
 
No evidence is no evidence.

Are we going to now argue that we don't care if there is no evidence because something might have happened?

The serological tests apparently showed no signs of infection. Yes, the Chinese might be lying, but again, we have no evidence.
You keep repeating this as if it were a fact when it is not an established fact.

It's not just that the Chinese might be lying, it is that they refuse to provide the evidence they have been asked repeatedly to provide. It's not that there is no evidence, it's that we know the Chinese have evidence they are refusing to share. There is a big difference.
 
That article is about infecting the mice after the pandemic was going. Angrysoba cited a source claiming work with the humanized mice could not have resulted in COVID 19.

Baric sent the mice to Shi at the WIV after they ended their joint study on the chimera coronavirus in the NC lab. The source said at that point they quit collaborating and became more competitive. And from there on the US had no eyes on the ground observing what research was going on at the WIV.

Feel free to weigh in if you think the GoF research could not have produced a gradually modified SARS CoV 2 adapted to humans. I'll be happy to go back over the sources linked in this thread which said a modified virus could have been created in the lab which looked no different from one which evolved in the wild.
Was Shi's lab doing GoF research? I don't see evidence that it was.
 
Was Shi's lab doing GoF research? I don't see evidence that it was.
At this point we don't have conclusive evidence one way or the other about GoF research at the WIV..

We have Daszak saying manipulating coronaviruses in the lab is easy to do.

We have Shi claiming they had no live bats at the WIV and no live coronavirus cultures, both of which there is good evidence was untrue.

We have Baric giving Shi the humanized mice.

We have Shi's paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records and that is absurd given they had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for a decade.

Shi was well aware funding for the GoF research from the US had been stopped. Her work with Baric had an exception because it was already in progress when the hold on the US funds began. Once the work was being done only at the WIV, there was no real access to what they were doing.

Daszak also 'laundered' $600K (I think that was the amount) of US funds from his company to the WIV.

And we have Daszak very much interested in finding PPPs (potentially pandemic pathogens) or demonstrating they were possible as his goal was in protecting wildlife from human encounters by showing how close the next pandemic was.


Do you have evidence of what Shi and the WIV were researching other than pinpointing the reservoir of SARS 1 which was completed a couple of years ago?

Even if they weren't using GoF to study PPPs, there are other possibilities they collected coronavirus pathogens ready to go in their samples. One scenario is they found a significant PPP collected from the Yunnan mine and that is when they themselves shut things down. That is one explanation for removing the genome data base back on Sept 9.

I think that possibility is remote however. It's not hard to see with a genetic timeline how the first cases do go a couple patients back to early Sept.


I also think there will be conclusive evidence found re the lab leak hypothesis despite the Chinese attempt to cover it up; like the evidence Bloom found in the cloud, for example, despite the researcher presenting a rationale for removing the research.

There are the hackers that a source upthread revealed who were working to hack the Chinese data. Unfortunately anything they find will likely be suspect.

There are a lot of doom and gloom "we'll never know" voices out there right now. From what has come out so far I believe we will know though not sure how long that will be.


I have significant doubt about the natural spillover proponents who hold up the WHO report as strong evidence. They don't even acknowledge Daszak's conflict of interest. But even beyond that, we have Embarek's description of the pressure the Chinese put on the WHO team to discount anything supporting the lab accident hypothesis.

The ones who have modeled the genome timeline and show it doesn't match the lab leak hypothesis have more credence but they don't have conclusive evidence just as there is no conclusive evidence of either hypothesis.


I've not heard your evidence/opinion of how the 2 lineages in the early cases proves the pathogen emerged outside of Wuhan. I think it has been sufficiently shown it is not evidence of a beginning of the pandemic outside of Wuhan.


From an epidemiological POV (my area of expertise), there would have been evidence had the pandemic began outside of Wuhan. There is none. And I have cited other expert sources that agree this was a one time event and it occurred in Wuhan.

In addition, some here in the thread and some cited sources have speculated about the sputtering, and spillovers dying out until one didn't. That requires evidence we don't see. With SARS 1 it was found, actually observed as it was happening. With several HPAIs (highly pathogenic avian flu) we have the cases that sputtered and are only one or two mutations away from being adapted to the human airway cells. They've been studied, observed, and we know why a few human cases emerged without significant spreading person to person.

If sputtering occurred in this case one would expect the same pattern of asymptomatic to fatal pneumonia proportions. It's not realistic to think only mild cases occurred in the first cases and then suddenly the pathogen became virulent. That would require different genetic changes, one for person to person spread and one for increased virulence.

Once you start going on with this speculation you start seeing how what might look reasonable at first turns out not to be.

I could go on; I've already posted this stuff.
 
A review of a Jan 2021 Taiwan news article I cited earlier: It notes Shi is not the only one at the WIV involved in GoF research. An assistant researcher, Hu Ben, was also involved.

First, no one needs to remind people that Taiwan news is probably not politically neutral. We can use our own heads to assess the value of this report without ignorant blanket dismissals of everything in the piece.

Clearly they didn't make this up out of whole cloth and they have also provided a means to corroborate the evidence they present.

Second, they speak the language and understand the culture in China. So there is that advantage.


Taiwan News: Wuhan lab infected 'humanized mice' with bat coronaviruses in 2019
On Friday (Jan. 8), a researcher who goes by the pseudonym Billy Bostickson and his colleagues at DRASTIC (Decentralized Radical Autonomous Search Team Investigating Covid-19) posted a Twitter thread demanding answers about a state-funded project at the WIV in 2019 that involved infecting transgenic mice with bat coronaviruses. The scientist who headed this project is assistant researcher Hu Ben (胡犇), according to the National Natural Science Foundation of China.


We know about the research Shi was involved in with Baric in NC. They include that information.

The conclusion of Shi's team was that a minimal insert region (amino acids 310 to 518) was enough to "convert the SL-CoV S from non-ACE2 binding to human ACE2 binding." In other words, as far back as 2007, the lab had discovered how to convert a virus that only infected bats into one that could infect humans.
Those would be the artificially created chimeras.
After the WIV experimented with Vero E6 cells, they used transgenic "humanized mice" from Baric's lab, meaning the rodents had been genetically modified to express the human ACE2 protein. In 2019, just before the known start of the pandemic, Hu began his work on a project titled "Pathogenicity of 2 new bat SARS-related covs to transgenic mice expressing human ACE2."


According to Bostickson, "This research involved 'novel' bat coronaviruses inoculated into immuno-suppressed mice with humanised features, such as hACE2, and possibly humanised lungs, bone marrow, etc..." He added that "Such experiments were a recipe for disaster, as we know."
In immunosuppressed humans, infection with COVID 19 results in more viral replication and the incidence of variant strains emerging. No doubt it is similar in immunosuppressed mice with related coronaviruses.


Then comes the secrecy:
No information about this research has been released to the public since the start of the pandemic, including data on the eight chimeric viruses the WIV had been infecting the mice with. In fact, all of the institute's databases have been offline since the start of the pandemic for alleged "cybersecurity issues," including 100 unpublished sequences of bat betacoronaviruses, which need to be sequenced by international scientists, according to Bostickson.

Hu has yet to respond to a request from Taiwan News for information about the experiments on mice, including the types of coronaviruses involved.


Note there are several Hu Bens including a researcher at Rice University. This is not that Hu Ben. From one of the papers he is an author of:
Affiliation CAS Key Laboratory of Special Pathogens and Biosafety, Center for Emerging Infectious Diseases of Wuhan Institute of Virology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Wuhan, China
 
Last edited:
No evidence is no evidence.

Are we going to now argue that we don't care if there is no evidence because something might have happened?

The serological tests apparently showed no signs of infection. Yes, the Chinese might be lying, but again, we have no evidence.
No evidence is of course exactly that: no evidence. And as far as I can see, this goes both ways. We know next to nothing of the early stages of the epidemic, but we know that when the public became aware of it, the epidemic had already sent many people to the hospital, and several had died. I wonder when it was recognized as a new disease, and when contact tracing started. And when it did, how can we disregard the known secrecy of the Chinese authorities, and the fact that people can be punished for exposing possible errors in the handling of the crisis?

There is clearly not enough evidence to decide either way, and I do not feel emotionally attached to either theory to rule any out, but it is clear that some do indeed rule the lab theory out, despite the lack of evidence.

I don’t think we’ll ever know, and even if some Chinese whistleblower would defect and tell all about the lab leak, I would probably be inclined to think that it was a fake statement designed to please his or her new masters, and ensure asylum, and a new living.
 
I don’t think we’ll ever know, and even if some Chinese whistleblower would defect and tell all about the lab leak, I would probably be inclined to think that it was a fake statement designed to please his or her new masters, and ensure asylum, and a new living.

Sure we could know. We may track down the virus that is closest to SARS-CoV2 in the wild.

However, unlike some of the lab leak proponents who think that this should have happened yesterday, it could take years or even decades to do this.

As I mentioned before, there is still a lot of ongoing research that is trying to get closer to finding the origins of HIV and when it spilled over to humans. I mentioned 1908 because that is the date that is mentioned in Spillover (published in 2012), but it seems that even more recent research now puts the date at 1920.
 
At this point we don't have conclusive evidence one way or the other about GoF research at the WIV..

We have Daszak saying manipulating coronaviruses in the lab is easy to do.

We have Shi claiming they had no live bats at the WIV and no live coronavirus cultures, both of which there is good evidence was untrue.

We have Baric giving Shi the humanized mice.

We have Shi's paucity of coronavirus genomes in the WIV records and that is absurd given they had been specifically studying them and collecting samples for a decade.

Shi was well aware funding for the GoF research from the US had been stopped. Her work with Baric had an exception because it was already in progress when the hold on the US funds began. Once the work was being done only at the WIV, there was no real access to what they were doing.

Daszak also 'laundered' $600K (I think that was the amount) of US funds from his company to the WIV.

And we have Daszak very much interested in finding PPPs (potentially pandemic pathogens) or demonstrating they were possible as his goal was in protecting wildlife from human encounters by showing how close the next pandemic was.


Do you have evidence of what Shi and the WIV were researching other than pinpointing the reservoir of SARS 1 which was completed a couple of years ago?

Even if they weren't using GoF to study PPPs, there are other possibilities they collected coronavirus pathogens ready to go in their samples. One scenario is they found a significant PPP collected from the Yunnan mine and that is when they themselves shut things down. That is one explanation for removing the genome data base back on Sept 9.

I think that possibility is remote however. It's not hard to see with a genetic timeline how the first cases do go a couple patients back to early Sept.


I also think there will be conclusive evidence found re the lab leak hypothesis despite the Chinese attempt to cover it up; like the evidence Bloom found in the cloud, for example, despite the researcher presenting a rationale for removing the research.

There are the hackers that a source upthread revealed who were working to hack the Chinese data. Unfortunately anything they find will likely be suspect.

There are a lot of doom and gloom "we'll never know" voices out there right now. From what has come out so far I believe we will know though not sure how long that will be.


I have significant doubt about the natural spillover proponents who hold up the WHO report as strong evidence. They don't even acknowledge Daszak's conflict of interest. But even beyond that, we have Embarek's description of the pressure the Chinese put on the WHO team to discount anything supporting the lab accident hypothesis.

The ones who have modeled the genome timeline and show it doesn't match the lab leak hypothesis have more credence but they don't have conclusive evidence just as there is no conclusive evidence of either hypothesis.


I've not heard your evidence/opinion of how the 2 lineages in the early cases proves the pathogen emerged outside of Wuhan. I think it has been sufficiently shown it is not evidence of a beginning of the pandemic outside of Wuhan.


From an epidemiological POV (my area of expertise), there would have been evidence had the pandemic began outside of Wuhan. There is none. And I have cited other expert sources that agree this was a one time event and it occurred in Wuhan.

In addition, some here in the thread and some cited sources have speculated about the sputtering, and spillovers dying out until one didn't. That requires evidence we don't see. With SARS 1 it was found, actually observed as it was happening. With several HPAIs (highly pathogenic avian flu) we have the cases that sputtered and are only one or two mutations away from being adapted to the human airway cells. They've been studied, observed, and we know why a few human cases emerged without significant spreading person to person.

If sputtering occurred in this case one would expect the same pattern of asymptomatic to fatal pneumonia proportions. It's not realistic to think only mild cases occurred in the first cases and then suddenly the pathogen became virulent. That would require different genetic changes, one for person to person spread and one for increased virulence.

Once you start going on with this speculation you start seeing how what might look reasonable at first turns out not to be.

I could go on; I've already posted this stuff.

SG, this is where I just think things sound silly.

You are presenting Peter Daszak and Zhengli Shi as some kind of Bond villains.

On the one hand you claim that they have been doing all these top secret things such as secret Gain of Function research, collecting viruses that nobody even knows about and covering up real spillover events despite that being their job to find, and all the while "laundering" hundreds of millions of dollars, to further an unknown end...just to be evil presumably... and then on the other hand, you point to the fact that Peter Daszak has been talking all about certain kinds of research (in Baric's lab) and you happily assume that what he says took place in Baric's lab was also taking place in China, and there is of course the whole point about the database. If all this stuff was so secret why would it be on public display on a database? Why would they be releasing so many papers all the time? Why would they be showing off like this unless of course they are Bond villains?

Honestly, I can get behind the idea that a leak from a lab could have happened, but this narrative that you are putting together of a Top Secret Enterprise stretching back decades really seems too weird, and it involves massive amounts of speculation to paper over some of the gaps, and even then, there are some glaring plot holes.
 
SG, this is where I just think things sound silly.

You are presenting Peter Daszak and Zhengli Shi as some kind of Bond villains.
That's bull ****. They are proven liars hiding potentially incriminating evidence. How does that make them Bond villains? :rolleyes:

On the one hand you claim that they have been doing all these top secret things such as secret Gain of Function research, collecting viruses that nobody even knows about and covering up real spillover events despite that being their job to find, and all the while "laundering" hundreds of millions of dollars, to further an unknown end...just to be evil presumably... and then on the other hand, you point to the fact that Peter Daszak has been talking all about certain kinds of research (in Baric's lab) and you happily assume that what he says took place in Baric's lab was also taking place in China, and there is of course the whole point about the database. If all this stuff was so secret why would it be on public display on a database? Why would they be releasing so many papers all the time? Why would they be showing off like this unless of course they are Bond villains?
This is more bull ****. It amounts to you creating a straw man instead of arguing the evidence I have actually posted.

There's nothing "top secret" here. There is hiding some of their research after some of their funding was threatened.

How did $600K become "hundreds of millions"? Exaggerating to make your POV sound better?

As for the continuation of the research done together in NC, I posted citations about all of that which you now conveniently ignore because it doesn't help your argument. I didn't make any of it up, I'm reporting what evidence I cited.

Honestly, I can get behind the idea that a leak from a lab could have happened, but this narrative that you are putting together of a Top Secret Enterprise stretching back decades really seems too weird, and it involves massive amounts of speculation to paper over some of the gaps, and even then, there are some glaring plot holes.
Of course you can't get behind it, you've ignored the evidence I posted, you're acting like it is my personal speculation and that's a bull **** straw man you've tried to change what I posted into because the straw is so much easer to argue about.
If you would stick to addressing the actual evidence I've posted instead of trying to attack me you might actually move this discussion forward.
 
Last edited:
That's bull ****. They are proven liars hiding potentially incriminating evidence. How does that make them Bond villains? :rolleyes:

This is more bull ****. It amounts to you creating a straw man instead of arguing the evidence I have actually posted.

There's nothing "top secret" here. There is hiding some of their research after some of their funding was threatened.

How did $600K become "hundreds of millions"? Exaggerating to make your POV sound better?

As for the continuation of the research done together in NC, I posted citations about all of that which you now conveniently ignore because it doesn't help your argument. I didn't make any of it up, I'm reporting what evidence I cited.

Of course you can't get behind it, you've ignored the evidence I posted, you're acting like it is my personal speculation and that's a bull **** straw man you've tried to change what I posted into because the straw is so much easer to argue about.

Could you please post evidence of money laundering?

And really? Now the theory is that the virologists are closing ranks to protect Peter Daszak’s funding?
 
And what have they lied about?

They haven’t been proven to be liars. You claim they have lied about fungus causing the deaths of miners. It’s not “proven”. We don’t even have a direct quote of what Shi said and we don’t have clear evidence that the claim is false.

You have said Daszak has lied about GoF and yet we have no evidence that WIV was doing GoF. On the contrary, we have the head of the NIH confirming it was NOT GoF.

You kept referring back to the TWiV interview as “proof” of Daszak’s lies despite the fact that in the interview he said it was in Baric’s lab. Then you claimed that that was not the issue with what he said. When I asked what the issue was you have not given an explanation.
 
Could you please post evidence of money laundering?
Daszak provided funds to Shi that the US would not give to Shi directly.

And really? Now the theory is that the virologists are closing ranks to protect Peter Daszak’s funding?
I'm not sure which virologists closing rank you imagine are involved here. It's only Daszak.

This is all in the thread, all those posts of mine you have been regularly ignoring:

NY Post: Who is Peter Daszak, the nonprofit exec who sent taxpayer money to Wuhan lab?
The nonprofit exec whose organization sent nearly $600,000 in US taxpayer money to a Chinese lab that may have been the source of COVID-19 masterminded an effort near the start of the pandemic to squelch the notion that the coronavirus was man-made, a new report reveals.

Peter Daszak, president of the New York City-based EcoHealth Alliance, secretly organized a statement issued by the influential British medical journal The Lancet in February 2020, according to Vanity Fair. ...

Nature: ‘Heinous!’: Coronavirus researcher shut down for Wuhan-lab link slams new funding restrictions
Peter Daszak, president of the research organization EcoHealth Alliance, describes how he has been caught in political cross-hairs over his partnership with a virology lab in China....

The US National Institutes of Health (NIH) has reinstated a research organization’s multimillion-dollar grant to study how coronaviruses move from bats to people — which it cancelled in a controversial move earlier this year. But as Peter Daszak, the head of the small non-profit organization — EcoHealth Alliance in New York City — found out in early July, the funding can’t be used unless the organization meets what he says are absurd conditions. The demands, detailed in a letter from the NIH, are politically motivated, he says.

To carry out its research, EcoHealth Alliance partners with the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) in China, which has been at the centre of unfounded rumours that the COVID-19 pandemic was caused by a coronavirus released from its laboratory. The NIH cancelled EcoHealth Alliance’s grant in April, days after US President Donald Trump told a reporter that the United States would stop funding work at the WIV.


Why the protesting and claims of outrage from both Daszak and Shi?
The NIH makes seven demands of EcoHealth; these were first reported by the Wall Street Journal this week, and have been viewed by Nature. The agency asks EcoHealth to obtain a vial of the SARS-CoV-2 sample that was used by the WIV to determine the virus’s genetic sequence. It also requests that EcoHealth arranges an inspection of the WIV by US federal officials.

Daszak calls the demands from the NIH “heinous”, and worries that the funding freeze is delaying vital work to identify and prevent the next pandemic. The NIH declined to comment, saying that the agency does not disclose internal deliberations on a specific grant.

In an e-mail to Nature, Shi calls the NIH’s demands “outrageous” and echoes Daszak’s assertions that the agency’s demands are unrelated to the WIV’s collaboration with EcoHealth.

The US did not owe them any research funds. Most researchers would simply comply with grant money obligations.

You want more?

Pentagon gave USD 39 million to Peter Daszak's NGO that funded coronavirus research at Wuhan lab

Peter Daszak’s EcoHealth Alliance Has Hidden Almost $40 Million In Pentagon Funding And Militarized Pandemic Science
“Pandemics are like terrorist attacks: We know roughly where they originate and what’s responsible for them, but we don’t know exactly when the next one will happen. They need to be handled the same way — by identifying all possible sources and dismantling those before the next pandemic strikes.”

This statement was written in the New York Times earlier this year by Peter Daszak. Daszak is the longtime president of the EcoHealth Alliance, a New York-based non-profit whose claimed focus is pandemic prevention. But the EcoHealth Alliance, it turns out, is at the very centre of the COVID-19 pandemic in many ways.

To depict the pandemic in such militarized terms is, for Daszak, a commonplace....

How long are you going to pretend Daszak is an innocent actor in all this? :rolleyes:
 

Yeah can’t read that Times article. Behind a Paywall. Do you have a non-paywalled link? I presume you must have read it somewhere. A Matt Ridley article perhaps? As for the other one…. Washington Examiner?

You might not be making things up but you seem to pass on a lot of stuff that is made up.
 
We have Shi claiming they had no live bats at the WIV and no live coronavirus cultures, both of which there is good evidence was untrue.
If there was good evidence you would cite it.
There is obviously no good reason to keep live Rhinolophus bats in a lab studying coronavirus when they have samples from those bats. It would be common knowledge that WIV scientists were collecting bats and housing them at WIV. There have been foreign scientists at the WIV who would have seen the cages. Their papers should mention that their samples came from captive bats.

Scientists close to the Wuhan virologist lab break silence, push away latest conspiracies has
The virologist also debunk the accusations of Australian journalist Sheri Markson, who pieced together a video and claimed WIV kept live bats which can harbor SARS or COVID-19 viruses. It is well known in the scientific field that the Rhinolophus bats which carry such viruses are unable to be kept live in any laboratory around the world and definitely not in WIV.
I suspect "unable to be kept live" is wrong. More likely is that keeping live, flying animals that feed on flying insects and carry coronavirus inside the labs is an unnecessary waste of time, money and lab space.
 
Last edited:
If there was good evidence you would cite it.
There is obviously no good reason to keep live Rhinolophus bats in a lab studying coronavirus when they have samples from those bats.

Scientists close to the Wuhan virologist lab break silence, push away latest conspiracies has

I suspect "unable to be kept live" is wrong. More likely is that keeping live, flying animals that feed on flying insects and carry coronavirus inside the labs is an unnecessary waste of time, money and lab space.

Yeah, Daszak himself has said that the specific bats for coronavirus research are caught, swabbed and released on the spot.
 
It would be pointless to lie about that stuff anyway. The only reason why the lab leakers claim that there are bats is because then they could say “See! Daszak told a lie! If he lied about that, what else is he lying about amirite?”

Is the idea that there are bats there so that there is a ready supply of off-the-books coronaviruses? That they can do gain of function research on them using “humanized mice” from Baric’s lab?

But why? Honestly, the idea is that they are mad scientists running a global money laundering operation. How is that not Bond Villain-esque?
 
Could I have the quote where it says he laundered money?

You can't comprehend the reference? Really? :rolleyes:

This is another of your avoidance tactics like fussing about one link when I've just posted 7 different links. And how is it behind a paywall for you, I didn't pay to read any of those sources.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom