[Continuation]Corona Virus Conspiracy Theories Part III

Status
Not open for further replies.
German propagandist Joseph Goebbels said that if you repeat anything enough times, most people will start to believe it

1. No, he probably didn’t. https://www.bytwerk.com/gpa/falsenaziquotations.htm
2. It doesn’t seem to be working for you, because no matter how many times you post your debunked lies, they’re still not credible.

There is a world beyond the United States of America, Tom Palven. It’s not all about you.
 
So Childlike Empress was about six months behind the times when he or she wrote:


Johns Hopkins has this:

Cases in 28 days: 24.748
Deaths in 28 days: 675
Total cases: 26.115
Total deaths: 725


So if these numbers aren't pulled out of the rear end of that wonderful University, it has been a bit over a month that Tanzania is "reporting".

I know from the mentioned German dissidents (who I will not name) how the situation on the ground is. "CORONA" doesn't exist there.
 
Last edited:
We submit to you that Covid-19 viruses may gain their lethality from mass psychosis and the nocebo effect...

You're still pushing the idea that millions might just have died of psychogenic illness? Does that include all those previously healthy anti-vaccine folk who thought the virus was no big deal until it floored them? How did anxiety cause their blood O2 sat to plummet anyway?
 
Despite being convinced that it's all a profit motive, neither Tippit nor CE have explained where the profit would be in exaggerating the dangers of an illness and putting the economy in lockdown compared to keeping the economy running as normal.
It's not like Covid gave the hospitals more patients - people had to delay or do without procedures because there were no free beds.

I personally think it's much more than the profit motive. I think it's a depopulation program. Profits are certainly a motive for the pharmaceuticals involved, but that's just one layer of the onion. Putting the economy in lockdown also increases government control. "Vaccine" mandates coupled with "vaccine" checkpoints gets us ever-closer to a Chinese/North Korean police state, which benefits certain very powerful people.
 
Now that PCR test kits can easily be purchased by ordinary people for rapid in-home testing, all of us can follow Tippit's advice on the true nature of science by purchasing one of those test kits and using it to test whatever goats, papaya, sheep, or motor oil we happen to have on hand.

That is, if the test itself reflected actual science. I suppose you missed CE's post above about it. I don't advise anyone to buy bad tests.
 
I personally think ..... [stuff].....

Hey, I think you got distracted. No one cares what you personally think- get some evidence in here! You can start with:

  • The "millions of people" who have been fired in the United States for not being vaccinated for Covid-19
  • The "gene therapy checkpoints" in your local Publix supermarket
Get to it! Add some value to this thread, already.
 
Hey, I think you got distracted. No one cares what you personally think- get some evidence in here! You can start with:

  • The "millions of people" who have been fired in the United States for not being vaccinated for Covid-19
  • The "gene therapy checkpoints" in your local Publix supermarket
Get to it! Add some value to this thread, already.
My "millions" remark may have been premature. The firings are apparently just getting started. One person would be too many.

I was referring to German state allows ALL businesses to ban unvaxxed customers, even for groceries & other essentials. Given how crazy and well-armed Floridians are, I suspect it may take years (or months) of more pavlovian conditioning before that sort of thing wouldn't result in severe bloodshed here, but given the responses of people like you who support this sort of thing, the trend is worrisome.
 
Last edited:
Story at-a-glance

High COVID vaccination rates create pressure on the virus to mutate into variants with higher levels of contagion and pathogenicity



- hated internet messenger in need of way more cussing and shooting

That looks like a new flavor of ********. A viral arms race? Do those viruses react to the pressure by thinking about what to do, or do they vote on it? Maybe they apply to the Central Committee for a plan. Or more likely, I suppose, given the usual level of thinking here, perhaps they get out their teeny-tiny nano-phones and ask Doctor Fauci what to do.

I don't know what your source for that quote was, but whatever it was, I suggest you look for a more reliable source - a little less teleology and a little more biology.
 
Last edited:
My "millions" remark may have been premature. The firings are apparently just getting started. One person would be too many.

I was referring to German state allows ALL businesses to ban unvaxxed customers, even for groceries & other essentials. Given how crazy and well-armed Floridians are, I suspect it may take years (or months) of more pavlovian conditioning before that sort of thing wouldn't result in severe bloodshed here, but given the responses of people like you who support this sort of thing, the trend is worrisome.

When asked for evidence of your nonsense, you are 0-for-2. This batting average sounds about right.
 
My "millions" remark may have been premature. The firings are apparently just getting started. One person would be too many.

I was referring to German state allows ALL businesses to ban unvaxxed customers, even for groceries & other essentials. Given how crazy and well-armed Floridians are, I suspect it may take years (or months) of more pavlovian conditioning before that sort of thing wouldn't result in severe bloodshed here, but given the responses of people like you who support this sort of thing, the trend is worrisome.

You should get in touch with whats-is-name the Trump kid who is selling T-shirts and suggest one for the occasion. Perhaps "I don't take shots, I give them!"
 
Now that PCR test kits can easily be purchased by ordinary people for rapid in-home testing, all of us can follow Tippit's advice on the true nature of science by purchasing one of those test kits and using it to test whatever goats, papaya, sheep, or motor oil we happen to have on hand.

That is, if the test itself reflected actual science. I suppose you missed CE's post above about it. I don't advise anyone to buy bad tests.
I didn't miss Childlike Empress's post, and it looks as though I understood its allegations better than you did, but I did misspeak.

The rapid test kits that ordinary people can buy for use at home are are antigen tests, not PCR tests. The rapid antigen tests are less sensitive than RT-PCR tests, so false negative results from rapid antigen tests are considerably more common than false positives.

Magufuli ridiculed the PCR tests for producing false positives. False positives are a real thing. A survey of published results in November 2020 suggested RT-PCR false positives occur at rates ranging from 0.2% to 4.0% of all tests. Another study published in March 2021 found that about 23% of positive RT-PCR test results were false positives. (Those findings are consistent with each other because they express the rate of false positives using different denominators: all tests vs all positive tests.)

Because false positives are a real thing, positive results of a PCR test are routinely confirmed by a second test.

Magufuli had set out to ridicule the tests, so he did not follow up with retest. Even if we believe Magufuli, whose credibility is right up there with yours or Childlike Empress's, Magufuli offered no data that could be used to estimate the frequency of false positives. All available data refute your* idea that most positive results are false positives.

*The "your" is plural.​
 
You goddamn lefty nanobot-eaters can try as hard as you want, but CE and Bubba and Tippit, and now the new guy, TP, are 1000% reliable. You always know Xactly what they'll say and come up with! Rock solid! Like that Brother Magafuli over there in Zanzibar or wherever!

Go ahead, try & make an impression on my heroes' heads! Pachycephalosaurs* every one of 'em!



* Let's see one of you smart Australian or Irish or something guys look THAT up on Googlganda! You looooove big words!
 
That looks like a new flavor of ********. A viral arms race? Do those viruses react to the pressure by thinking about what to do, or do they vote on it? Maybe they apply to the Central Committee for a plan. Or more likely, I suppose, given the usual level of thinking here, perhaps they get out their teeny-tiny nano-phones and ask Doctor Fauci what to do.

I don't know what your source for that quote was, but whatever it was, I suggest you look for a more reliable source - a little less teleology and a little more biology.

Ehh... *that* bit is not actually total BS, just eye-rollingly dumb. It's a bit like how antibiotics put pressure on the infections that they're used to treat to become more antibiotic-resistant, because it's killing the parts of the infection without any resistance more quickly. That's one of the main reasons why it's strongly recommended to do the full course of antibiotic treatments and not just stopping when one feels better, because that way, the more antibiotic resistant bits are much more likely to be dead, too. Note too that just not taking antibiotics in the first place is generally a horrible idea, so this more sensibly would actually be an argument for firmly enforcing much more generalized vaccine mandates and booster requirements. The rest of what Bubba decided to be inane about and not post the link (fairly certainly because he knows that it's based on an utterly untrustworthy site's story and is probably more directly a quote from another utterly untrustworthy site) may as well be ignored based on a lack of trustworthy sourcing and information. Sites known for lying and horrendously dishonest spin just don't get much sympathy from me. If Bubba thinks that that's unfair to the data, he's welcome to present the actual source of the data for examination.

With that said, though, unsurprisingly, The Conservative Treehouse was... thoroughly misrepresenting the source.

To quote a response -

Charles Chiu, Professor of Laboratory Medicine and Medicine, University of California, San Francisco:

This article misinterprets the data presented in our report, which I emphasize is still in the process of peer review and was submitted early as a non peer-reviewed preprint to the medRxiv web site.

1. The claim that “vaccinated individuals are more susceptible to SARS-CoV-2 variant infections (or COVID-19) than unvaccinated (individuals)” is incorrect and is patently false. Our report showed that 81% of COVID cases (1248 out of 1373 cases) were in unvaccinated individuals while only 9% (125 out 1373 cases) were in fully vaccinated individuals. Therefore, in our study, there were approximately 10 times more cases of COVID in unvaccinated individuals than in vaccinated individuals. Our study also focused on vaccine breakthrough cases and showed that infections by “antibody-resistant” variants carrying one or more mutations associated with immune evasion, such as Beta, Gamma, and Delta variants, are overrepresented in vaccine breakthrough cases, while infections in unvaccinated individuals generally reflect the overall distribution of variants circulating in the community at the time, i.e., any variant in the community. However, infection by variants (Alpha, Beta, Gamma, Delta, etc.) comprised most infections overall, both in unvaccinated and unvaccinated individuals.

2. Our study was performed at a time when there was simultaneous circulation of multiple variants of the virus, including some that are relatively resistant to neutralizing antibodies. Vaccination prevents the vast majority of infections, but the small subset of vaccinated individuals (9%) who had breakthrough infections at that time were, not surprisingly, more likely to be infected by these “antibody-resistant” variants.

3. Our study does not support in any way the claims that “vaccine antibodies would suppress natural antibody responses. The vaccine antibodies take control of the immune system and defend only against a targeted virus” and “among vaccinated individuals, a COVID variant virus is not recognized by the specialized antibodies provided by the vaccine, and the natural antibodies have been programmed to stand down”. We did not address these issues in our study. Peer-reviewed published data by others show that although there can be reduced sensitivity of “antibody-resistant” variants such as Delta to antibody neutralization elicited, the full dose of the vaccine is still effective in neutralizing the virus and preventing infection[3,4].

4. Finally, our study also found that there “…were fewer hospital admissions and no deaths in vaccinated patients as compared to unvaccinated patients…” and that “…significantly lower viral RNA loads were observed in asymptomatic breakthrough cases as compared to unvaccinated cases…”, which support vaccination to prevent spread of the virus in the community and decrease the number of hospitalizations and deaths from COVID. The effectiveness of the vaccine in preventing hospitalizations from severe COVID is also reported in other published data[4].

5. Vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 were developed with the primary goal of preventing hospitalizations and deaths from COVID, and they have remained very effective in doing so.

To summarize, these three claims are false and misleading and are not supported by the results of our study.

Shocking how the manifest dishonesty of TCT is so easily predictable and yet those like Bubba grasp onto it like a lifeline.

Hey, Bubba! You don't actually need to stubbornly keep trying to win the argument, even when the evidence keeps showing that what you push is untrustworthy BS, over and over and over. Reminds me of numbers 1, 2, and 3 on your list from before, incidentally, with a bit of 4 thrown in on the side.
 
Last edited:
Ehh... *that* bit is not actually total BS, just eye-rollingly dumb. It's a bit like how antibiotics put pressure on the infections that they're used to treat to become more antibiotic-resistant, because it's killing the parts of the infection without any resistance more quickly. That's one of the main reasons why it's strongly recommended to do the full course of antibiotic treatments and not just stopping when one feels better, because that way, the more antibiotic resistant bits are much more likely to be dead, too. Note too that just not taking antibiotics in the first place is generally a horrible idea, so this more sensibly would actually be an argument for firmly enforcing much more generalized vaccine mandates and booster requirements. The rest of what Bubba decided to be inane about and not post the link (fairly certainly because he knows that it's based on an utterly untrustworthy site's story and is probably more directly a quote from another utterly untrustworthy site) may as well be ignored based on a lack of trustworthy sourcing and information. Sites known for lying and horrendously dishonest spin just don't get much sympathy from me. If Bubba thinks that that's unfair to the data, he's welcome to present the actual source of the data for examination.

With that said, though, unsurprisingly, The Conservative Treehouse was... thoroughly misrepresenting the source.

To quote a response -



Shocking how the manifest dishonesty of TCT is so easily predictable and yet those like Bubba grasp onto it like a lifeline.

Hey, Bubba! You don't actually need to stubbornly keep trying to win the argument, even when the evidence keeps showing that what you push is untrustworthy BS, over and over and over. Reminds me of numbers 1, 2, and 3 on your list from before, incidentally, with a bit of 4 thrown in on the side.

I may be wrong (often am) but it was my impression that the issue with resistant bacterial strains and antibiotics is that it selects for variants, not that it creates them, and that it happens only if you've already contracted the disease, not if you haven't. Bubba's source sounds as if it suggests that partial immunity actually makes the viruses mutate in ways they would not ordinarily, and that seems dubious.
 
Last edited:
Given how crazy and well-armed Floridians are, I suspect it may take years (or months) of more pavlovian conditioning before that sort of thing wouldn't result in severe bloodshed here, but given the responses of people like you who support this sort of thing, the trend is worrisome.

I would have no doubt there would be at least one crazy idiot who thinks a supermarket worker who denied him entry should be shot but even in a wacky place like Florida, this type of legislation wouldn't result in a bloodbath. Anti-vaxxers and woo-meisters talk a good game but when push comes to shove, they back down.

ETA: I fully support this type of legislation. My body, my choice. I choose to urge Governments to restrict anti-vaxxers in every way shape and form to limit the damage they can do to my body.
 
Last edited:
Ehh... *that* bit is not actually total BS, just eye-rollingly dumb. It's a bit like how antibiotics put pressure on the infections that they're used to treat to become more antibiotic-resistant, because it's killing the parts of the infection without any resistance more quickly. That's one of the main reasons why it's strongly recommended to do the full course of antibiotic treatments and not just stopping when one feels better, because that way, the more antibiotic resistant bits are much more likely to be dead, too. Note too that just not taking antibiotics in the first place is generally a horrible idea, so this more sensibly would actually be an argument for firmly enforcing much more generalized vaccine mandates and booster requirements. The rest of what Bubba decided to be inane about and not post the link (fairly certainly because he knows that it's based on an utterly untrustworthy site's story and is probably more directly a quote from another utterly untrustworthy site) may as well be ignored based on a lack of trustworthy sourcing and information. Sites known for lying and horrendously dishonest spin just don't get much sympathy from me. If Bubba thinks that that's unfair to the data, he's welcome to present the actual source of the data for examination.

Actually, I think bruto is perfectly on-target- the bit he quoted from Bubba's post is both total BS and eye-rollingly stupid, because it's the usual characterization as a normative process of one that is not. The mutations do not happen as a response to "pressure on the virus to mutate"- their survival as populations (as with your antibiotic-resistant infections) is a result of having mutated, but the mutations themselves are random. As bruto says, there's no group of viruses running around yelling "quick! Think of something! I know- mutate!" and then becoming super-viruses as an act of will, or by some direction. They don't become mutations in order to survive, they survive (and reproduce) because they are mutations.
 
Last edited:
I didn't miss Childlike Empress's post, and it looks as though I understood its allegations better than you did, but I did misspeak.

The rapid test kits that ordinary people can buy for use at home are are antigen tests, not PCR tests. The rapid antigen tests are less sensitive than RT-PCR tests, so false negative results from rapid antigen tests are considerably more common than false positives.

Magufuli ridiculed the PCR tests for producing false positives. False positives are a real thing. A survey of published results in November 2020 suggested RT-PCR false positives occur at rates ranging from 0.2% to 4.0% of all tests. Another study published in March 2021 found that about 23% of positive RT-PCR test results were false positives. (Those findings are consistent with each other because they express the rate of false positives using different denominators: all tests vs all positive tests.)

Because false positives are a real thing, positive results of a PCR test are routinely confirmed by a second test.

Magufuli had set out to ridicule the tests, so he did not follow up with retest. Even if we believe Magufuli, whose credibility is right up there with yours or Childlike Empress's, Magufuli offered no data that could be used to estimate the frequency of false positives. All available data refute your* idea that most positive results are false positives.

*The "your" is plural.​


We know the false positivity rate is far lower than that. The false positive rate depends on the prevalence in the population. If there is no Covid and you have a false positivity rate of 1 in 100k, and perform several hundred thousand tests, you'd expect to get a handful of positive results. The false positive rate would be 100% as they would all be false.

Australia has had periods where there have been hundreds of thousands of consecutive negative results, which means that the false positivity rate is no more than parts per million.


We don't have data that conclusive for the UK, but we do see reports with differences between symptomatic and asymptomatic test positivity rates.

https://www.gov.uk/government/stati...d-19-surveillance-reports-2021-to-2022-season


Screenshot 2021-10-26 183209.jpg

The wk15, 2021 asymptomatic positivity rate is the upper bound for the false positivity rate in the UK. It's actually lower, because there's no reason to believe those without symptoms are false positives - simply asymptomatic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom