Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
I expect that the WIV had DNA from bats from all over the place.

Before you say "from the Laos caves" you may want to make sure we are talking about the same caves.

Also, I don't usually put too much stock in reporting by The Sun. If you were from the UK you would understand why.
 
What are you talking about, the source I cited is The Telegraph, not The Sun.

As for which caves, do you really want so badly to hand wave this away? They specifically mention Banal-52.


Oh I see, you ignored my link then saw The Sun also reported on it. Hand wave away all you want. It won't change the facts.

The emails came from a FOIA request from the White Coat Waste Project. Multiple news sources have reported on the emails. Ooh ooh, you can hand wave that away too without having to actually address the evidence: they are a bit out there as a group being against taxpayers paying for animal cruelty.

But wait, that looks like a left-wing organization. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
For everyone else that isn't ignoring half the evidence, Dr Quay wrote up some comments on the Worobey research:

An Analysis of the Facts and Circumstances of the Worobey Science Perspective Paper Suggests it Makes No Contribution to the Investigation of the Origin of SARS-CoV-2

The summary:
Conclusion:

If it was believed that the pandemic began in December 2019 [then] the epidemiology of patients from December 2019 would be helpful in identifying the origin of the infection. If the December cases are appearing weeks or months after the Index Case, then the December epidemiology is less valuable.

Nonetheless, the earliest data on the relationship to the Huanan market, which has never been refuted, documents three of the first four cases had no relationship to the market.
Abundant evidence exists that the first patient with COVID-19 was in Wuhan, China and was infected sometime between the end of September 2019 and late November 2019. This includes Worobey’s own prior work.

We do not know who that first patient is, where they lived, their market association, etc.

By early December the ‘spacio-temporal’ signal from the unknown ‘Index Patient’ was lost through repeated human-to-human transmission. Therefore, classifying or reclassifying one of the three early patients with no exposure to the market to a later infection date does not change the probative value of those early cases, which is minimal.

The uncritical media response to this paper suggests a desire to close the debate on the origin of SARS-CoV-2 and to undermine the extensive evidence which is most consistent with a non-spillover event as the origin.

Make of it what you will.
 
What are you talking about, the source I cited is The Telegraph, not The Sun.

As for which caves, do you really want so badly to hand wave this away? They specifically mention Banal-52.


Oh I see, you ignored my link then saw The Sun also reported on it. Hand wave away all you want. It won't change the facts.

The emails came from a FOIA request from the White Coat Waste Project. Multiple news sources have reported on the emails. Ooh ooh, you can hand wave that away too without having to actually address the evidence: they are a bit out there as a group being against taxpayers paying for animal cruelty.

But wait, that looks like a left-wing organization. :rolleyes:

Oh sorry, you are right that the source was the Telegraph.

However, although it mentions BANAL-52 as one that was discovered a few months ago, it doesn't say which viral DNA samples went to the WIV, nor where they were discovered.

I think it is a huge stretch to conclude from this that therefore a progenitor virus was sent to the WIV, cultured and/or tinkered with which was then the virus that got out.

Remember, that literally nobody is saying BANAL-52 was the progenitor virus. The significance of the virus is to show how widespread similar viruses are to SARS-CoV2.

The only person who has been downplaying the significance of BANAL-52 in this thread is you, as you have been repeatedly asserting that it is not closer than RaTG13.

Suddenly, you leave RaTG13 and are deeply interested in the Laos virus after all. Hmmm....
 

Attachments

  • Lab Leak BANAl 52 SG.jpg
    Lab Leak BANAl 52 SG.jpg
    34.3 KB · Views: 2
The emails, uncovered in a Freedom of Information Request by the US-based White Coat Waste Project, suggest that viral DNA from “bats and other high-risk species” were sent to Wuhan between June 2017 to May 2019.
It's RNA.
 
It's RNA.

Oops! I notice that I also made the same mistake.

It was a mistake that I guess we copied from the Telegraph:

The emails, uncovered in a Freedom of Information Request by the US-based White Coat Waste Project, suggest that viral DNA from “bats and other high-risk species” were sent to Wuhan between June 2017 to May 2019.
 
I think it is a huge stretch to conclude from this that therefore a progenitor virus was sent to the WIV, cultured and/or tinkered with which was then the virus that got out.

The importance of this news is to remind us that the lab's efforts to collect viruses for study constitute a plausible pathway for viruses to travel from where they were collected to Wuhan. If someone becomes infected elsewhere and then travels to Wuhan, that travel can result in a spillover event in Wuhan even without a lab leak (or, indeed, any of the virus actually finding its way into the lab).
 
Skeptic Ginger spreads origin misinformation yet again.

...So let's put a couple pieces together....
Skeptic Ginger spreads origin misinformation yet again.
"And now we see they were also collecting and studying similar coronaviruses from caves in Laos." is wrong.
we have basically a tabloid rumor of an email from the EcoHealth Alliance saying they would like to send Laotian samples to Wuhan.
  • There is no evidence that these samples were from the same caves as the BANAL-52 samples.
  • There is no evidence that the samples were actually sent to Wuhan.
  • There is no evidence that these hypothetical samples did anything other than sit in an freezer at the WIV.

Coronaviruses with a SARS-CoV-2-like receptor-binding domain allowing ACE2-mediated entry into human cells isolated from bats of Indochinese peninsula
None of these bat viruses harbors a furin cleavage site in the spike. Our findings therefore indicate that bat-borne SARS-CoV-2-like viruses potentially infectious for humans circulate in Rhinolophus spp. in the Indochinese peninsula.
BANAL-52 was found in a single site in North Laos close to the Southwest China border. See the Supplementary Files where all of the closest to SARS-CoV-2 samples were found at Feuang (Site 1).

A "Daszak proposal to DARPA for research money" is not research undertaken at the WIV :eye-poppi.

A web site hacked and so taken down in September 2019 (over 2 months before the outbreak) is is not research undertaken at the WIV. The published genetic sequences in that database are still available.
 
Some of Dr Quay's comments are obviously wrong.
The title is blatantly wrong. Worobey finding some evidence that the first case was associated with the Huanan Seafood market is a contribution to the origins of COVID-19. It is not great evidence (a video) and needs verification.

Dissecting the early COVID-19 cases in Wuhan by Michael Worobey.
Worobey did not write "he knows the COVID-19 pandemic began at the Huanan Seafood market in Wuhan, China". The news article title has "says evidence points to Wuhan market". The paper is a review of the early COVID-19 cases in Wuhan.

Worobey was looking for the earliest case associated to the Huanan Seafood market. He found that there was some evidence that Mr. Chan got a fever on 16 December, not 8 December as in the WHO study.

Worobey did state the obvious fact that there were cases not associated with the market. There is a paragraph starting "How can this knowledge inform our understanding of the pandemic? If Huanan Market was the source, why were only one- to two-thirds of early cases linked to the market?"!
 
Oh sorry, you are right that the source was the Telegraph.

However, although it mentions BANAL-52 as one that was discovered a few months ago, it doesn't say which viral DNA samples went to the WIV, nor where they were discovered.

I think it is a huge stretch to conclude from this that therefore a progenitor virus was sent to the WIV, cultured and/or tinkered with which was then the virus that got out.

Remember, that literally nobody is saying BANAL-52 was the progenitor virus. The significance of the virus is to show how widespread similar viruses are to SARS-CoV2.
If you look at what I quoted it clearly says this is not a smoking gun and that BANAL-52 is not the progenitor virus. Like I said in previous posts it's not that much closer to COVID than RaTG13.

Remember, that literally nobody is saying BANAL-52 was the progenitor virus. The significance of the virus is to show how widespread similar viruses are to SARS-CoV2.
I didn't say it either, nor did the article which was about the newly discovered emails between Ecohealth Alliance and some "funder" in the US.

The emails say that viral samples from the Laos cave bats were collected and sent to Wuhan because it was unlikely researchers in Laos could get funding. It doesn't matter if those specimens included BANAL-52 or not, though it seems a stretch to think it wasn't among the specimens.

The only person who has been downplaying the significance of BANAL-52 in this thread is you, as you have been repeatedly asserting that it is not closer than RaTG13.
And I still say that when it comes to those 2 specific coronaviruses.

Suddenly, you leave RaTG13 and are deeply interested in the Laos virus after all. Hmmm....
Yeah...no, that's your misreading of my post. Try again.

Recently the viruses found in the Laos caves became the subject of interest (should I quote you?) and the implication was the animal source for the spillover might be in Laos. What the emails show is samples from both sites were collected and sent (or taken) to the WIV. All the pieces of COVID 19 were likely in the genetic sequences database that was taken offline in mid-Sept 2019.

There is one more piece to the puzzle: why was that database coincidentally taken offline at that time?
 
It's RNA.

The White Coat Waste Project is not a sophisticated source with virologists. It's pretty much an animal welfare group seeking to expose what taxpayer dollars in the US are going toward. They happened upon the emails looking into Rand Paul's attack on Fauci about GoF research. The news media reported on the emails.

We'll have to see what comes of the emails in the coming days/weeks. So far Ecohealth Alliance didn't respond to a request for a comment.
 
If you look at what I quoted it clearly says this is not a smoking gun and that BANAL-52 is not the progenitor virus. Like I said in previous posts it's not that much closer to COVID than RaTG13.

...

The emails say that viral samples from the Laos cave bats were collected and sent to Wuhan because it was unlikely researchers in Laos could get funding. It doesn't matter if those specimens included BANAL-52 or not, though it seems a stretch to think it wasn't among the specimens.

What? A stretch to think it wasn't in the samples? What are you talking about? Why on Earth do you say this?

It seems clear that you think the sampling was done in the same caves and you seem to think that if they were doing sampling they wouldn't be able to do it without falling over BANAL-52.

Maybe this is just your understanding of how bat sampling for viruses takes place as if there are only a few bat caves and only a few viruses around.

This is not the case at all. Assuming we are talking about different expeditions, the chances of EcoHealth/WiV scientists and a completely different group of scientists finding BANAL-52 independently is the stretch (to put it mildly.)


Recently the viruses found in the Laos caves became the subject of interest (should I quote you?) and the implication was the animal source for the spillover might be in Laos.

If you are going to quote me, why not quote what I said was the significance of the finding of BANAL-52. What I said was it demonstrated the range of these types of coronaviruses. We have seen that the Mojiang mine need not be where the virus is from.

I did not claim that the virus must have spilled over in Laos - that is your interpretation (perhaps your willful misinterpretation?). Is it possible it did? Sure, but I think it more likely that the Laos find, with its RBD, only shows that there are far more potential viruses that may have spilled over somewhere else. My position is that we simply don't know and may not know for years, or decades, if that.
 
keptic Ginger spreads origin misinformation yet again.

The emails say that viral samples from the Laos cave bats were collected and sent to Wuhan because it was unlikely researchers in Laos could get funding.
The emails cannot not say that for the simple reason that they have not been published yet so Skeptic Ginger has not read them :jaw-dropp!

What we currently have is that a single person (Viscount Ridley) said a single document says that bat viral samples from the Laos cave bats were collected by the EcoHealth Alliance and they would like to send them to Wuhan because it was complicated to get funding for researchers in Laos. The originally cited NZ Herald story quotes him.
The The Telegraph (via Yahoo!News) article Skeptic Ginger cited has the same quote.
Viscount Ridley, co-author of Viral: The Search for the Origin of Covid-19, said the emails added more weight to the theory that the virus leaked from a lab in Wuhan.

Speaking at the Institute of Economic Affairs in London, the peer said: “Banal-52 is not close enough to be the progenitor, it's still not the smoking gun, but it's pretty good. So maybe this virus started in Laos, not China. Interesting possibility.

“But we got a leak of a document showing that the EcoHealth Alliance was sampling bats in Laos.

“They say in the document that because it would be complicated to come back and ask the US Government for permission to give some of the grant to a Laotian lab, they’d like to send all these samples to a lab that can analyse it for them. It was in a place called Wuhan.

As expected The Sun spins the story in the most sensational way and do not notice Matt Ridley exaggerating what has been found (the 1 document he actually spoke about turns into documents and actual samples sent).

This is a few newspapers repeating the same story which is being ignored so far by the major, more responsible (they would want to read the emails and verify the information) news sources. No New York Times, The Times, Washington Post, etc. articles yet.
 
Last edited:
One thing it does do is undermine the claim that “the earliest cases had no connection to the market”. This can no longer be asserted with any confidence because the earliest known cases were associated with the market now.
You are citing a less than definitive source claiming it supports a definitive assertion. It doesn't. And given the analysis misses key earlier cases, I'm confident the seafood market has already been ruled out as the initial site of the first human infection.
[a few pages back] ...
Yes, lots of pieces of COVID 19 can be found in horseshoe bats from Laos to Yunnan. And the pangolin coronavirus genetic segment that lines up nicely with COVID genetics can be found IIRC in the Yunnan caves where a recombinant event [could have] resulted in it mixing with other bat coronaviruses.

But what hasn't been found and what should have been found after a 2 year intensive search is something with all those parts in one circulating virus....

Find some evidence for how a virus that did have all the segments not only found its way to Wuhan, but found its way to infect one patient zero without infecting anyone else along the way. ...
That was my position then and now.

WSJ from Oct 5, 2021: Science Closes In on Covid’s Origins Four studies—including two from WHO—provide powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory.
What that WSJ article says is evidence of circulating COVID virus should have been found and wasn't.
An extensive data set from late 2019—more than 9,000 hospital samples—is available of people exhibiting flulike (thus Covid-like) symptoms in China’s Hubei and Shaanxi provinces before the epidemic started. Based on SARS-1 and MERS, the natural zoonotic theory predicts 100 to 400 Covid infections would be found in those samples. The lab-leak hypothesis, of course, predicts zero. If the novel coronavirus were engineered by scientists pursuing gain-of-function research, there would be no instances of community infection until it escaped from the laboratory. The World Health Organization investigation analyzed those stored samples and found zero pre-pandemic infections. This is powerful evidence favoring the lab-leak theory.
The rest is paywalled but that's enough to make the point.


No, the finding of the bat viruses in Laos demonstrates that evidence for a natural origin is cumulatively emerging: ...
It might have been if there was a trail from Laos to Wuhan or even a trail from Laos to Yunnan. Without a trail there isn't a lot more here than we had with Yunnan.

You are arguing that, no, natural origin is not sufficient to explain the pandemic, we must also have a lab, and secret gain of function, and a progenitor virus that is still unknown, etc...
Just to be clear, your paraphrasing missed a key point, you need a trail from an animal source to Wuhan. And in the newly uncovered emails we have a trail ... right to the WIV.

[Splitting the rest off to get past the tl;dr problem]
 
I explained why BANAL-52 is signifiicant. I have not claimed that it went from Laos to the WIV. Okay, so now that is what you are doing. Fine, but it is a strange argument because we have no reason to claim it is the progenitor virus. The point is that some lab leakers were claiming RaTG13 was.

This is what I wrote a month ago...

I think the reason it is important is that as I have said some lab leakers assume that RaTG13 is the progenitor virus. With the discovery of BANAL-52 this theory is laid to rest in my opinion.

Similarly, it removes another objection that coronaviruses of its type don’t have this RBD. Even Yuri had to admit that he didn’t think one would show up.

To me it is looking more like the God of the gaps (or lab leak of the gaps) and the transitional fossils argument. The scientists are getting closer to discovering a virus which is similar to SARS-CoV2. Now, if one turns up in the wild with a furin-cleavage site what would be your response?

By the way, why is YOUR theory for how the closest known virus to SARS-CoV2 is in Laos?

BANAL-52 is incrementally closer to SARS-CoV2. The spread of such viruses suggest the progenitor virus could be anywhere in a large area. That makes it hard to track down.

So the argument should not be "Not found it, huh? It must have come from a lab, then!"
 
Stuart Neil points out that some researchers have found...

Link
Major new Bat sarbecovirus discovery in horseshoe bats in Laos. A virus with a spike protein containing an RBD only 2 amino acids different from Wuhan SARS CoV2 and uses hACE2 as efficiently

So now this is definitive. There is nothing unnatural or "uniquely adapted" about SARS2

Of course, I don't have or claim to have the competence to assess the paper:

Paper
I believe we are still missing the furin cleavage site in a SARS-like CoV but it was found in differnent coronaviruses or something IIRC. Either way, the argument there was evidence of unnatural viral 'construction' hasn't been a viable argument since before page 1 of this thread. The argument is 'unnatural' passage through 'natural' cell cultures (or at least semi-natural in the case of using human modified mice and other viral cultures in human respiratory cells or whatever I don't recall the exact detail of). Bottom line no inserted genetic segments were needed. They were allowed to develop via mutations.


What? A stretch to think it wasn't in the samples? What are you talking about? Why on Earth do you say this?

It seems clear that you think the sampling was done in the same caves and you seem to think that if they were doing sampling they wouldn't be able to do it without falling over BANAL-52.
This is bizarre reasoning but whatever floats your boat.

Maybe this is just your understanding of how bat sampling for viruses takes place as if there are only a few bat caves and only a few viruses around.
:rolleyes: Yes, I'm so naive.

This is not the case at all. Assuming we are talking about different expeditions, the chances of EcoHealth/WiV scientists and a completely different group of scientists finding BANAL-52 independently is the stretch (to put it mildly.)
Or the reason they found related virus segments in the Laos caves is because having found them before they knew where to look.

As for the sampling you seem to think was random, not targeted: it would have been targeted to the specific bat colonies of the species known to carry SARS-like CoVs. Daszak and Shi had been searching for SARS-like CoVs for a decade or more. They found and published their findings of what they believed was the source of SARS which then infected the civet cats which was in turn the source of the human spillover in Guangdong.

From there Daszak, and I assume Shi as well, were interested in finding (or creating) a coronavirus they could then use to make a generalized vaccine to be ready for the next SARS CoV spillover event. It's all in the Ecohealth Alliance and Daszak's paperwork. Topped off with Daszak's podcast interview at the Nipah Virus convention just before the pandemic emerged where he said outright that was his goal and that coronaviruses were easy to manipulate in the lab.

If you are going to quote me, why not quote what I said was the significance of the finding of BANAL-52. What I said was it demonstrated the range of these types of coronaviruses. We have seen that the Mojiang mine need not be where the virus is from.

I did not claim that the virus must have spilled over in Laos - that is your interpretation (perhaps your willful misinterpretation?). Is it possible it did? Sure, but I think it more likely that the Laos find, with its RBD, only shows that there are far more potential viruses that may have spilled over somewhere else. My position is that we simply don't know and may not know for years, or decades, if that.
Thank you for that clarification. I don't find we "may not know for years" to be a supportable argument.

Again, where is the source and why has it not been found in 2 years? Yes there is a lot of territory to search. But it would not have been the immaculate infection. There should be some semblance of an outbreak on the way to Wuhan. That is epidemiology 101.

Here's an off the cuff speculative hypothesis explaining the Chinese genome data purge in Sept 2019: Shi with or without Daszak were disturbed to discover they had created a dangerous SARS CoV while the work was being done in a level 2 biosecurity lab. They were not trying to do this and did not expect it to happen.

Whoops! Quick, destroy the virus (or maybe freeze and save it; you never know if you'll need it) and cover up the genetic segment data that was open access online to many other researchers. It could have been as benign a motive as to not want other researchers to copy the data.

It's a perfect movie scene: Camera pans to the little bit of contamination they hadn't noticed.
 
Last edited:
I explained why BANAL-52 is signifiicant. I have not claimed that it went from Laos to the WIV. Okay, so now that is what you are doing. Fine, but it is a strange argument because we have no reason to claim it is the progenitor virus. The point is that some lab leakers were claiming RaTG13 was. ...
I don't care what other "lab leakers" are claiming. I'm concerned with the cumulative evidence.


BANAL-52 is incrementally closer to SARS-CoV2. The spread of such viruses suggest the progenitor virus could be anywhere in a large area. That makes it hard to track down.
Not a whole lot "incrementally closer" but who's counting. ;) Hard but it's not a random search. It was a targeted search.

So the argument should not be "Not found it, huh? It must have come from a lab, then!"
Second time you repeated this but it is not and has never been my one argument. It is one piece of evidence.
 
Or the reason they found related virus segments in the Laos caves is because having found them before they knew where to look..

This is now outright conspiracism as you are accusing the researchers who found BANAL-52 of being in league with EHA and pretending to find viruses that EHA had already secretly discovered in order to...what...provide cover for EHA?

This makes no sense especially given that BANAL-52 is not considered the progenitor virus.

The mental gymnastics you are doing here is head-spinning.

You can only believe what you are saying if you are now claiming that independent researchers are fabricating a hunt for the virus.
 
This is now outright conspiracism as you are accusing the researchers who found BANAL-52 of being in league with EHA and pretending to find viruses that EHA had already secretly discovered in order to...what...provide cover for EHA?....
Get over it. It's not a CT, I'm not developing a conspiracy.

It has nothing to do with some secret discovery. Good grief!

Daszak and crew are searching out SARS like coronaviruses. It is their stated mission, published, in print! The emails are evidence that search included specific bat species in Laos caves which he then shipped to the WIV: also in print in the emails! Documented, you know that little thing that supports evidence based conclusions.

But now Echohealth Alliance is claiming the email only said they were going to collect those samples and that they never did so.

This story needs to ripen a bit. I'm waiting to see the actual emails.

:popcorn1
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom