Yes, it's a pretty damning result!



I wonder if the tests were harder than Trump's cognitive test: Person, Woman, Man, Camera, TV.

Have you been following the story about the New Brunswick 'syndrome'? It appears to have been exacerbated considerably by the media - much like the Le Roy case, the Danish HPV-vaccine scare and, of course, the 'Havana Syndrome'.

Not to derail this thread but this does have very similar aspects and relevance. In this case 46 of 48 patients in the original "cluster" were identified by the same doctor.

A government report was released a couple of days ago but believers still believe.
New Brunswick has no mystery neurological illness, committee finds,

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/nb-mystery-illness-final-report-1.6362700

That comes after an oversight committee made up primarily of neurologists from New Brunswick reviewed records from 48 patients who are part of the cluster and found that while some have unusual symptoms, they don't have a common, unknown illness.

"The oversight committee has unanimously agreed that these 48 people should never have been identified as having a neurological syndrome of unknown cause and that based on the evidence reviewed, no such syndrome exists," Chief Medical Officer of Health Dr. Jennifer Russell said on Thursday.
 
I am not sure how you arrive at this conclusion. There was one study group of people complaining of symptoms. There were two control groups of healthy people, one of them specifically matched to the educational status and job duties of the study group and the other a broader group of healthy people. There was brain abnormality in the study groups that didn’t show up in either control group. That’s something I think you are missing.

Is it evidence of an attack? No. It is evidence of damage. Is it evidence that they were injured in Havana? No. It is evidence that there is damage. I don’t know how you are missing that simple fact, but you are.

Control group one had 21 people in it; control group two had 27. They were healthy volunteers, not random people from neurology clinics. I’m not sure how you make this kind of analogy when it doesn’t fit what happened here. I find you analysis flawed.
I already addressed this.

21 and 27 people in a control group is not a very big sample, and there's a lot more to matching the study population than educational status and job duties. When one is ruling out variables one has to match everything as closely as possible leaving out only the one variable you want to look at. That's why small sample sizes in this situation simply cannot reliably narrow a study down to a single variable.

In one study the only people with a brain abnormality were the people referred because they had something specifically wrong. BUT WE DON'T KNOW HOW BIG THE ORIGINAL GROUP WAS THESE PEOPLE WERE SELECTED FROM. They were not a random sample chosen out of the group of people with complaints of Havana Syndrome. This brain abnormality was not something found in all the people complaining of Havana Syndrome. It wasn't diagnostic for Havana Syndrome.

If you wanted a decent control group you would need 20 some people from the same neuro practice that referred these guys (IIRC it was only 3 people) and who had the same neuro problem but who had never been to Havana.

Tell us, how many people with Havana Syndrome had this abnormality and how many people with Havana Syndrome didn't have it?
All I’m going to say about any of this is that 1)Your significant and respectable education and clinical experience with a wholly unrelated group of people in a completely different setting and circumstance is not relevant and only seems to be biasing your analysis; 2) Not every person who suffers brain injuries exhibits the same consistent symptomology. There’s a whole host of reasons for that, which I’m sure you are aware of.

we will just have to agree to disagree here.
They are not a wholly unrelated group any more than reading about a patient with symptoms of congestive heart failure is not the same as all the other people one has seen and learned about with congestive heart failure. I've seen it before, multiple times with different groups of people under different circumstances.

This will make the third time I have noted the classic signs and symptoms:

They don't have consistent symptoms between themselves.
There is no means of injury found.
They are taking time off (probably with pay) for this disability. (In other cases they might be involved in a lawsuit, or they might be trying to prove to the person(s) who don't believe them that they really do have the thing wrong they say is wrong.)​

As for not everyone with brain injuries exhibiting the same symptoms: of course they don't! It's not relevant here and I shouldn't have to explain why.
 
Tell us more about the brain abnormality "that didn’t show up in either control group" - with linked quotations. And tell us about the "study group": Were they simply people who complained of symptoms? Or had some of the "people complaining of symptoms" been selected to be in the group unlike others whose symptoms had been dismissed as irrelevant?

I thought you said you had read the paper I have previously linked to? The 2019 Jama paper (which you -and Della Sala, for that matter- somehow seem to be conflating with the earlier 2018 Jama paper) is pretty clear about all those questions. I don't think you have actually read it. Maybe you should do that?


As always, xjx388 makes a general claim instead of actually citing the paper as I asked him to do, which is always a good idea. And yes, there were more JAMA papers + criticism! But let us see those quotations to back up his claims. His general references to something having been documented before is his frequently used escape hatch:
You know perfectly well about the documented brain damage. It’s been cited in this thread several times.
That he now seems to have discovered that there are more studies than he first thought does't impress me at all. Make specific references to specific papers with quotations! If referring to specific citations in this thread, link to them!

Brain abnormality is not evidence of damage. I don't know how xjx388 is missing that simple fact, but he is.

If group A is experiencing symptoms that groups B and C are not and group A shows structural abnormalities in the brain; it's a simple conclusion that group A had some kind of brain damage that groups B and C did not. Now, it's true that the damage may not be the result of an attack and that there are other things that need to be ruled out. But the abnormalities in this particular case are clearly damage of some kind.
1 An anomaly is not a symptom that anything is wrong with a person! Calling anomalies structural doesn't make it more scientific. (where is the linked quotation?)
2 And in "this particular case," it is not a symptom of group A having any kind of brain damage. The conclusion is not just simple. It is wrong.

ETA: Correction-Della Sala is not confounding anything. His opinions are focused on the 2018 Jama paper, not the 2019 paper. The confounding is all yours.


I never claimed that Della Sala confounded anything. In future, maybe you should quote from whatever JAMA paper you are talking about. That would make it easier for everybody to know. The general references to alleged "documented brain damage" don't help.
But primarily: Come up with those linked quotations!
 
Not to derail this thread but this does have very similar aspects and relevance. In this case 46 of 48 patients in the original "cluster" were identified by the same doctor.


We have discussed several other cases (and alleged cases) of mass psychogenic illness in this thread to establish what is and what isn't MPI, so I don't think the Brunswick example is a derail. I would never have heard about ergot poisoning if it weren't for the 'Havana Syndrome'! :)

A government report was released a couple of days ago but believers still believe.
New Brunswick has no mystery neurological illness, committee finds,

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/new-brunswick/nb-mystery-illness-final-report-1.6362700


That is why the kind of randomization used in New Brunswick could have been used to avoid bias in the investigation of the 'Havana Syndrome':
The report’s authors say the 48 cases in what was thought to be a cluster were randomly allocated to pairs of neurologists who reviewed them and presented their findings to an oversight committee of six New Brunswick neurologists and other officials. The committee said none of the cases met the full criteria of the case definition.
From post 1359


But instead, the U.S. approach was to conduct deliberately biassed investigations, to limit the information those investigators had access to, remove people who were open to the idea of MPI from the investigation and apparently have adamant advocates of the attack idea reappear on new panels.
I still find it shocking to see David Relman's ideas about acoustics when the IC Experts Panel allegedly included expertise in this field.
 
I think you have read the book, seen the media reports on YouTube (!) and listened to the podcasts. I don't think you have read the Jama papers. You've certainly read the criticism.


Yes, unlike xjx388 I have read the criticism in addition to the reports that he keeps referring to but doesn't quote from or link to, for some reason. And unlike xjx388 (!), apparently, I watch the media reports on YouTube. That is where I have access to 60 Minutes, for instance.
What he thinks I haven't read is entirely irrelevant.

No. I'm pointing out that you are pretending to know, when you can't possibly know.


xj388's usual attempt to declare something impossible or unethical. Yes, I can know, and I do know, and in the case of the 'Havana Syndrome' (as in the case of Trump's narcissism), it isn't particularly difficult to find out what is going on if your mind isn't inhibited by a U.S. patriotic bias.

No. The CIA merely said that they have not found evidence to link it to a foreign power in the vast majority of people.


As always: no quotation, no link. xjx388 simply presents what he would like us to think. The reality is that the CIA hasn't found any link to a foreign power in any of the cases, not just in the vast majority of them. In the vast majority of cases, the CIA hasn't simply not found links to a hostile foreign power. In the vast majority of cases other causes have been found!!!
The remaining cases also don't have any links to hostile foreign powers:
However, the CIA emphasized that it is still investigating around two dozen cases that cannot be explained, and which were first reported by officials at the U.S. Embassy in Havana, Cuba, in 2016.
"Some of our toughest cases remain unresolved," said a CIA official who spoke on condition of anonymity. "We have so far not found evidence of state actor involvement in any incident."
CIA report: No evidence linking Havana syndrome to a foreign country (NPI, Jan 20, 2022)
But that's xjx388 for you: making it up as he goes along.

When you have nothing, it's logical not to dismiss any plausible idea. All I'm doing is pointing out the hubris of the idea that anyone has this all figured out at this point.


When you have nothing, you don't usually start fantasizing about who did it and what kind of (imaginary) weapon an imaginary perpetrator may have used. The idea isn't plausible without one single ray detected. xjx388's false modesty, "all I'm doing", is an attempt to forbid rational explanations of the 'Havana Syndrome'. We do know how it spread in Havana (in spite of CIA's attempts to keep it a secret) almost as well as we know how it was spread to the rest of the world. This is actual knowledge. Pulsed directed microwave rays (whatever; it has been called a lot of things along the way, including ultrasound) aren't even on the level of conjecture.

More medicine by TV on this forum. I'm no longer shocked by this kind of thing, but I should be.


Shocked, I tell you, shocked! Yes, he claimed that we had not seen the patients, and I pointed out that we have even seen the patients describe their symptoms and play recordings of their local lovelorn crickets! Now he is trying to pull the trick from the thread about Trump's narcissism: 'But we didn't see the patients as our patients!' No, we didn't. But as in the case of Trump, we don't have to, it isn't necessary. Unlike Trump's pee tape, the cricket tapes actually exist, and the alleged attack victims are eager to play them as evidence of the alleged attack.

And there it is: "patriots like you."


Yes, patriots like him coming to the rescue of a narcissistic president's honor or, in this case, the 'Havana Syndrome' delusion.

See that right there? That's the narrative you are trying to sell here: that we deluded Americans are conditioned by our governments to believe bad things about Cuba and only want to attack them.


"Oh, what a giveaway! Did'j'hear that, did'j'hear that, eh? That's what I'm all about! Did you see 'im repressing me? You saw it, didn't you?!"
No, the narrative here is that American deluders have spent five years scaring the **** out of each other with tales of hostile foreign agents with imaginary ray guns. That this tale was also used in an ongoing Cold War against Cuba deserves to be mentioned when relevant.
There is another thread about some of all the other lies about Cuba that (some, far from all) Americans are conditioned by their governments to believe: Protests erupt in Cuba

You keep saying that I'm the one who brought "America bad; Cuba good," into this discussion but that simply isn't true:


Strawman!
I said that he brought the "America bad, Cuba good" story into the discussion because that's what he did. His first couple of posts had nothing whatsoever to do with the theme of the thread. I never claimed that nobody else had ever done so, i.e. "the one who".
But based on his imaginary "the one who", xjx388 is now out to prove that others before him did the same thing, i.e. wrote posts about Cuba that had nothing to do with the 'Havana Syndrome', but that isn't even true:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11998721&postcount=44
ˆThat's you talking about all the great stuff Castro did after the revolution.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12063577&postcount=305
ˆThat's Sherkeu with a conspiracy theory tying it all to the unrest in Venezuela and a US plan to remove diplomats from Cuba to force them to make concessions on Venezuela. Or something.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12068738&postcount=337
ˆThat's The Don speculating that it's the Trump admin wanting to roll back Obama's Cuba policies.


The first link is to one of my posts where I write about what the USA may find annoying enough about Cuba to want to destroy the country, i.e. it is about the motive for making up the 'syndrome' and using it as a false flag argument for withdrawing diplomatic staff from the embassy in Havana.

The two other links from Sherkeu and The Don are reflections on the motivation for the USA's way of handling the alleged syndrome. I don't see anything wrong with that. The 'syndrome' was created by the USA. Speculations about the motive for both the 'Havana Syndrome delusion and the policies that it gave rise to are very relevant: US may close Cuba embassy over 'health attacks' - unlike xjx388's post, which was simply an attempt to claim: USA good, Cuba bad. That is his general attitude, which can't be helped, but it is no excuse for attempts to derail the discussion about the 'syndrome'.

There's a lot more than that, of course. Those all came years before I ever participated in the thread. The main theory you believe is that there were no attacks and that this is a case of MPI fueled by a US government that wanted to destabilize relations with Cuba. You season that here and there with anecdotes about how the Cuban government is so great at health care, feeding their people, more honest and open than the US government, etc. You also do a lot of implication about how the NAS paper, as one example, is US sponsored propaganda.


I tend to post about Cuba's pandemic response to the pandemic in comparison to USA in another thread where this comparison was included in the OP, albeit with a false claim (probably not the poster's intention). In that thread, I also post links about how the U.S. blockade of Cuba managed to exacerbate the effects of the pandemic on the country.

A comparison of the efficacy of the two very different pandemic strategies is not very relevant to this thread unless you look at the whole context in which the 'Havana Syndrome' is still playing out, i.e: Which role does the 'Havana Syndrome' play in the general strategy of the USA towards Cuba? It is worthwhile considering, it's what I, Sherkeu and The Don were doing in the three linked posts - but not about the pandemic, obviously, since they were posted in 2017.
The only relevance xjx388's post could possibly have would be as an example: How one U.S. American patriot thinks and feels about Cuba - to the extent where it makes him post about these feeling with complete disregard for what the theme of the thread is: the 'Havana Syndrome'.

It's also very interesting that right from the beginning you (and others including Skeptic Ginger) jumped right to the MPI explanation and you haven't backed down. Everything is interpreted in light of your very first conclusion and you refuse to budge even a little. Mostly because -you guessed it- "America bad; Cuba good." That's all you and others, not me. And it's all right there in the record of this thread dating back to the very beginning in 2017.


Nobody jumped to that conclusion! My first reaction was, 'WTF is going on?' My title for the thread reflected my confusion: Alien Attack? Mass Hysteria? Conspiracy? My title was later replaced by Sherkeu's when two threads about the same theme were merged.
I no longer remember in which sub-forum I posted the OP, but I don't think it was in Social Issues & Current Events.

It is not surprising that Skeptic Ginger would be one of the first to recognize the signs of mass psychogenic illness in the 'Havana Syndrome'. She has practical experience with it, so the similarities would be more apparent to her than to most of us.

"... and you haven't backed down," is an outright lie based on xjx388's ignorance of the thread. For a long time, I thought that the Canadian idea, insecticide poisoning, had something going for it. I had witnessed fumigation against mosquitoes in Havana, and I even argued against dismissing the idea due to the apparent discrepancy: Only Americans and Canadians, but no Cubans were affected. Based on my experience with both private homes and hotel rooms in Havana, I proposed a possible reason for the discrepancy: In general, Cuban homes don't have air conditioning. Hotel rooms and houses for foreigners usually do. In other words, the dwellings of Americans and Canadians in Havana are pretty airtight. Those of Cubans aren't, and for this reason the fumes of insecticides evaporate fast.
However, the investigative cooperation between Cuban and Canadian health experts doesn't seem to have come up with any support for the fumigation poisoning idea. (And diplomats from other nations don't seem to have been affected by Cuban fumigation. Only Americans and the Canadians who were 'recruited' for the 'syndrome' by Patient Zero.)

It find it really annoying that xjx388 comes to this thread pretending to know it all and then makes accusations like this based on nothing but his bias and ignorance.
 
It's probably safe to say that Russia doesn't have this tech, otherwise half of Ukraine would have been shot with the headache gun by now.
 
It's probably safe to say that Russia doesn't have this tech, otherwise half of Ukraine would have been shot with the headache gun by now.
:sdl:

You have a good point in there: Why would Cuba develop and unleash a 'headache gun'?

What good would a headache gun do? Right there the logic of it doesn't pass the smell test.
 
<snippity, snip>
It find it really annoying that xjx388 comes to this thread pretending to know it all and then makes accusations like this based on nothing but his bias and ignorance.

Eh-heh...I am the one "pretending to know it all?" To directly quote you: "Yes, I can know, and I do know . . ." I have repeatedly said that I can't know and don't know what happened. Neither can you despite your hubristic certainty. You haven't "seen the patients" in the context of a medical workup. You've only seen them on TV in news reports and read limited medical information about them. Yet, as if you were a Medical intuitiveWP or something, you can and do know. Eh-heh.

Your original title revealed exactly what you thought from the beginning because it's almost exactly where you ended up. If you had been a little more prescient, you would have replaced "Aliens" with "Ray Guns," but that would probably have been too on-the-nose obvious. The fact that you had already reached your "Mass Hysteria, Conspiracy" conclusion is quite evident on page one of this thread. You dropped the "Does anybody have any idea what this is?" facade pretty quickly. Since then, every piece of evidence that something besides "Mass Hysteria, Conspiracy" might be occurring is explained away in favor of the "Mass Hysteria, America bad/Cuba good Conspiracy." You accuse me of a "U.S. patriotic bias," but your anti-US; pro-Cuba bias is quite evident.

Whatever; our biases are irrelevant here. What is relevant is simple: You are certain America concocted this whole thing to make Cuba look bad and it's really just a case of Mass Hysteria induced by crickets and the Trump Admin; I think America is certainly capable of doing that, Cuba already looks bad enough on its own and that there simply isn't enough good information to be certain about anything. Agree to disagree.
 
Last edited:


It's no surprise, really. Besides pretending to be a superior ethicist, snippity snip is the only thing xjx388 is good at. In this way he can ignore all the arguments against the obviously absurd attack theory and resort to his false modesty: 'I am just so terribly ethical that I can't know anything in this case.' This enables him to ignore criticism of, for instance Dr. David Relman's absurd lack of knowledge about simple acoustics, while at the same time presenting himself as the better person: 'Snippity snip, you know as little as I do, but I am the great admitter whereas everybody else is the great pretender.'

No, I haven't seen the patient in the context of a medical workup, but I also don't need to see the patients in that setting when the patients themselves play the chirpy-chirpy-cheep-cheep tape for me and claim it as proof that they were attacked. I also don't need to be a Medical intuitiveWP or have any medical expertise (like Skeptic Ginger) whatsoever, the same way I didn't need to be a psychiatrist with Trump next to me on the couch to know that he is a narcissist. I saw him on TV, which is enough for anybody who has the slightest knowledge of what narcissism is: Person - Woman - Man - Camera - TV. In that context, too, xjx388 pretended to be so bloody ethical and thus above the rest of humanity by claiming that nobody could possibly know and they were damned unethical if they claimed to do so.

Eh-heh...I am the one "pretending to know it all?" To directly quote you: "Yes, I can know, and I do know . . ." I have repeatedly said that I can't know and don't know what happened. Neither can you despite your hubristic certainty. You haven't "seen the patients" in the context of a medical workup. You've only seen them on TV in news reports and read limited medical information about them. Yet, as if you were a Medical intuitiveWP or something, you can and do know. Eh-heh.


Eh-heh, eh-heh!

And yet, he can know it all, without a degree in psychiatry, about my deepest inner thoughts and feelings when he starts analyzing my OP where I was not only prescient but also not prescient enough. And it's true: At the time, I couldn't possibly have imagined the directed-pulsed-microwave-frequency-ray gun that they would later concoct to save their idea of an invisible-energy attack:

Your original title revealed exactly what you thought from the beginning because it's almost exactly where you ended up. If you had been a little more prescient, you would have replaced "Aliens" with "Ray Guns," but that would probably have been too on-the-nose obvious. The fact that you had already reached your "Mass Hysteria, Conspiracy" conclusion is quite evident on page one of this thread. You dropped the "Does anybody have any idea what this is?" facade pretty quickly. Since then, every piece of evidence that something besides "Mass Hysteria, Conspiracy" might be occurring is explained away in favor of the "Mass Hysteria, America bad/Cuba good Conspiracy." You accuse me of a "U.S. patriotic bias," but your anti-US; pro-Cuba bias is quite evident.


xjx388 is just the latest in a long line of people on this forum with the uncanny super power to reveal that the guy quoting Karl Marx and Bertolt Brecht in his sig line is a communist. Not just any communist, but a particularly evil genius communist, who cannot possibly know anything and yet is prescient enough to know about the moronic ideas U.S. experts will come up with. And all this while hiding behind a "Does anybody have any idea what this is?" facade!
But as a true debunker, I guess I owe it to him to reveal how I discovered his "U.S. patriotic bias". I had already seen him defend the honor of an obviously narcissistic U.S. president, but then there were also his patriotic posts:
(If I were in Cuba, it would be necessary for me to say such a thing in order to avoid being jailed. Here in America, I have the freedom to say whatever I want about them).


Yes, here in America, xjx388 has the freedom to both defend the honor of president Trump, condemn anybody considered to be USA's enemies and to praise his freedom to do so! USA! USA!
But that is all irrelevant:

Whatever; our biases are irrelevant here. What is relevant is simple: You are certain America concocted this whole thing to make Cuba look bad and it's really just a case of Mass Hysteria induced by crickets and the Trump Admin; I think America is certainly capable of doing that, Cuba already looks bad enough on its own and that there simply isn't enough good information to be certain about anything. Agree to disagree.


No, the Trump Admin only contributed to the climate of uncertainty in the U.S. spy community in Havana, and the whole thing wasn't really concocted deliberately from the start - the same way xjx388 imagines that I did with this thread from the start:

1) A paranoid CIA spy is scared by unknown sounds and thinks sonic attack!
2) He either associates this idea with symptoms he already has or develops those symptoms because of his anxiety.
3) He encourages others in the embassy community to be on the lookout for symptoms and sounds and 'connect the dots' the same way he did, and he tells his Canadian neighbors to do so, too.
4) His CIA superiors take his paranoia seriously and help spread the idea.
5) Journalists get wind of the story and publish it, while spies and diplomats are still busy spreading it in their overlapping communities.
ISF local news:
6) dann comes up with a devious scheme, pretending not to understand what is going on, but actually already planning to dismiss the whole thing as mass psychogenic illness.
7) He manipulates sonic experts into delivering analyses that point at crickets as the source of the sounds and health-care professional into claiming that the whole thing is a case of mass psychogenic illness.
While in the rest of the world:
8) dann's evil communist co-conspirators in the international research community ruin the whole sonic attack idea, thus forcing the brave freedom fighters in the newly established research community to come up with the microwave attack idea along with a number of entirely new pseudo-medical labels (like 'immaculate concussion') for same old, same old symptoms under the umbrella of 'Havana Syndrome'.
9) This goes on for a couple of years, and more and more American spies and diplomats stationed abroad come down with the 'syndrome'.
10) And then the new Biden administration decides that it's time to give all of them a chance to participate.
11) Hundreds of people have already joined the club when their eager and earnest contributions are declared to be irrelevant.

When you have nothing, you don't usually start fantasizing about who did it and what kind of (imaginary) weapon an imaginary perpetrator may have used. The idea isn't plausible without one single ray detected. xjx388's false modesty, "all I'm doing", is an attempt to forbid rational explanations of the 'Havana Syndrome'. We do know how it spread in Havana (in spite of CIA's attempts to keep it a secret) almost as well as we know how it was spread to the rest of the world. This is actual knowledge. Pulsed directed microwave rays (whatever; it has been called a lot of things along the way, including ultrasound) aren't even on the level of conjecture.
 
:sdl:

You have a good point in there: Why would Cuba develop and unleash a 'headache gun'?

What good would a headache gun do? Right there the logic of it doesn't pass the smell test.


The question did occur to the true believers, and they have come up with answers. The ones I remember:

1 Havana was the testing ground. It is to be used in future wars.
2 It is an attempt to destabilize the intelligence community. (already in disarray.)
3 The real target is the US president and/or military leaders. (John Bolton's very recent idea, a variation of 1, see post 1286)

If anybody in the Ukraine reports a headache or feeling dizzy, it will be seen as confirmation of 1.


ETA: What good is a weapon that makes men lose their beards?!
The hilarious plots included an attempt to smuggle poisoned cigars into Castro’s household and also plant soluble thallium sulphate inside Castro’s shoes so that his beard will fall off and make him “the laughing stock of the socialist world.”
The Day CIA Failed to Un-beard Castro in His Own Den (IPS News, Jan 7, 2015)
I think that this was just misdirection.
 
Last edited:
Robert Bartholomew:
Brain changes reported in the Havana patients are consistent with findings one would expect to see in people exposed to prolonged stress. The study in question is a 2019 paper in the Journal of the American Medical Association which found brain anomalies. However, brain anomalies are not the same as brain damage. There is a big difference between the two. Brain anomalies are common in small cohorts such as those studied in Cuba – and the study itself admitted that the anomalies were so minor as to have been potentially caused by individual variation. What’s more, 12 of those affected had pre-existing histories of concussion, compared to none in the healthy controls. That alone could explain the differences in the groups.
What is Havana syndrome? (The University of Auckland, Feb 16, 2022)


Not to be confused with the article from Feb 11 (see post 1285).
 
As mentioned in post 1361, the U.S. embassy will resume some functions:

Although in a limited and gradual way, the United States Embassy in Cuba will restart the issuance of visas, after keeping the service suspended for more than four years, the Chargé d'Affaires of the diplomatic representation, Timothy Zúñiga-Brown, announced on Thursday.
Without specifying a date for the resumption of procedures, he explained that the consular session will offer essential services to US citizens and will process emergency visas for non-immigrants, detailed a Cuban television report.
(...)
The drastic reduction of the staff of the US Embassy was a decision of the Donald Trump administration in 2017, when, to damage bilateral relations, it used the alleged sonic attacks on diplomats of that nation as a pretext, an absurdity that, after five years, has not been confirmed by scientists or by authorities.
(...)
Since then, the persecution of our banking-financial relations has increased, remittances have been restricted, individual travel by US citizens has been annulled. In the US, cruise ships and direct flights to Cuban airports, except Havana, were prohibited; the leasing of aircraft with more than 10% US components and the acquisition of technologies and equipment in similar condition were prevented; and commercial promotion activities, cultural and educational exchanges ceased.
Embajada de EE UU. en Cuba reiniciará servicios de visado de manera limitada (+ Video) (Granma.cu, March 4, 2022)
 
Somebody didn't get the memo ...

... or just doesn't give a damn.

Senator Jeanne Shaheen doesn't seem to give a damn about recent reports mentioning that there is no evidence whatsoever of one single directed energy attack on U.S diplomats or spies. In a short article about her meeting with Maher Bitar, Interagency Coordinator for Anomalous Health Incidents, she talks about "attacks" eleven times, "directed energy attacks" nine times", and only three times are the alleged directed energy attacks referred to as "suspected directed energy attacks".

Senator Shaheen has long stood by government employees and their families who have suffered from these mysterious injuries from directed energy attacks, and leads efforts in Congress to provide them critical health benefits.
Shaheen, Collins Meet with AHI Interagency Coordinator Maher Bitar to Discuss Admin’s Response to Directed Energy Attacks (Shaheen.senate.gov, March 3, 2022)


Since she is adamant that she is dealing with directed energy attacks, it makes me wonder why she continues to call the alleged injuries mysterious!
 
Skeptic

Robert Bartholomew:
As well, the CBS program failed to mention that the authors of the very first study of Havana patients published in 20187 found no brain damage. While there were white matter tract changes in 3 of 21 patients, these are common in many conditions, including migraines and depression. The findings are what one would expect in a group of 21 randomly selected people. They also botched their assessment for impairment, defining it as any test score under the 40th percentile of normal responses. In other words, 4 out of 10 people tested would have qualified as being impaired. The study was so flawed that the editorial board of the respected journal Cortex called for it to be retracted.

A 2019 study in the same journal found brain anomalies, which is not unusual in small cohorts, and is not the equivalent of brain damage. The study authors even admitted that the changes could have been caused by individual variation between patients. Of even greater concern was the absence of a suitable control group, as 12 of the affected diplomats in Cuba had histories of concussion compared to zero in the healthy controls, and could thus account for the differences between the groups. The bottom line: both studies were poorly designed and neither demonstrated brain damage despite continued widespread claims in the media to the contrary.
60 Minutes Whips Up “Havana Syndrome” Hysteria, Airs Sensational Segment on White House “Attacks” (Skeptic, March 5, 2022)


This is also remarkable:
Conspicuously, (Dr. David) Relman’s two panels are the only investigations to reach the conclusions they have about the likely involvement of microwave radiation, brain injury and the presence of a foreign actor.
 
As mentioned in post 1361 and post 1392:

The United States has not revealed when the reopening will take place, but Cuban Foreign Minister Bruno Rodriguez said on Twitter that it was "a step in the right direction."
(...)
Rodriguez hit out at the US over its original reasons for suspending consular services.
He said it was taken after "unfounded accusations that Cuba had attacked American diplomats."
"The consequences for Cuban families and for relations between Cuba and the United States in multiple spheres were very damaging," he added.
Cuba hails US decision to partially reopen Havana consulate (anews, March 4, 2022)
 
So much for the 'Moscow Signal' (as well as for the 'Havana Syndrome')

The evidence for Havana syndrome is sufficient to warrant serious scientific investigation even though there has never been any evidence of a directed energy attack despite five years of searching by State, the IC and others. The closest evidence is a secondhand report* that an untrained person using an unreliable and inappropriate detector may have found high levels of microwaves at one of the residences overseas.

The National Academy of Sciences, given its limited and managed access to information, rightfully concluded that microwaves were the most likely explanation for the phenomenon, but not that microwaves were the cause of the medical problems. There may be a national security reason for attributing the medical problems to a directed energy attack by Russia, China, Cuba or whatever nation has made our current enemies list, but this should not be at the expense of those who may be suffering from a real medical problem.

The Moscow microwave affair was grossly mishandled by State, and we seem to be blundering down the same path with Havana syndrome. If there is a valid cause(s) for the syndrome, it is not a foregone conclusion that it is microwaves or a directed energy attack. State should fully disclose whatever information it has to a respected scientific investigation that has free rein to investigate any and all possible causes. What is done with the results of the investigation is another matter.
Regarding Moscow Signal (AFSA, March 1, 2022)


*The secondhand report would be the one from Mark Lenzi, who was stationed in Guangzhou, as mentioned in posts 1143, 1145 and 1150.
 
Last edited:
I used to enjoy the investigative journalism of 60 Minutes. I don't know what happened to it. Their recent show reflected the general attitude of the CBS to the 'syndrome': Giving vent to the attack paranoia of the alleged victims and their political backers without even attempting to consider the validity of their claims.

In Danish, we have the word mikrofonholderi ('holding the mic') for this kind of journalism:
My translation:
Meaning
interview where the interviewee is allowed to talk without critical questions from the interviewer
USE derogatory
SEE ALSO prostitution journalism [or maybe 'selling-out journalism' comes closer, dann]
One could have wished for more solid journalism and less servile mic holding
I wouldn't want to return to the mic holding of the past when politician could babble on for hours without being contradicted


Something else
This article is five months old but still interesting: ◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊◊ aren't buying 'Havana Syndrome' for a single second (MEL Magazine, Oct 4, 2021)
 
The Insanity of the Media - Washington Post Revisited

When the CIA interim report was made public by a CIA spokesperson, the reporting reflected what the media wanted to hear rather than what was actually said. And I am not talking about OAN, Newsmax or Fox. I am talking about respected news media of the kind that is supposed to care about objectivity in reporting and even to do fact checking. However, the comments in newspapers like Washington Post reflected how upset they were that the idea of the alleged syndrome being caused by an enemy attack (preferably Russian) had been dismissed in the majority of the "more than 1,000" cases:

Now a senior CIA official has announced, “We have assessed that it is unlikely that a foreign actor, including Russia, is conducting a sustained, worldwide campaign harming U.S. personnel with a weapon or mechanism.”
Opinion: The ‘Havana syndrome’ is still a mystery. It is too soon to stop investigating. (WP, Jan 23, 2022)


This is a pretty straightforward statement, but its interpreters have had a field day with it:
1) "We": The we in this case is the CIA, obviously, and we all know that the CIA is known for lying, deliberately, not just to enemies but also to the public: "We lied. We cheated. We stole." Making this point is legit! But in this case, the CIA has been pushing the attack idea for five years, i.e. lying, and people who loved the idea eagerly accepted the lie, but now that the CIA officials tell them that they were wrong and come clean, people suddenly become suspicious!

2) "a foreign actor": The CIA official didn't say 'foreign actors', plural, which gives us the opportunity to interpret it as if it is still likely that many such foreign actors, a minor local terrorist group, for instance, were the perps. He also said 'foreign', which can be interpreted to mean that a domestic terrorist group may still be likely.
This is obviously not what he meant, but we can use it to perpetuate the attack idea. We can also interpret 'actor', to mean a foreign superpower, which enables us to interpret it as meaning minor players. (At the very beginning of the 'outbreak' when people found it hard to believe that Cuba would have any interest in perpetrating or allowing the alleged attacks to take place, the idea was vented that a disgruntled faction of the Cuban armed forces or intelligence community might be behind it.)

3) "worldwide campaign": So it is still possible to interpret it to mean that some of those "more than 1,000" cases were caused by a local attack. So let us limit ourselves to the original cases, the ones that gave rise to the name of the 'syndrome'. We don't find it as satisfying as the Russia idea, but that can't be helped, now that the CIA has ruined it for us.

The Post doesn't make use of all the options for misinterpretation of the CIA official's statement, and it even comes up with an insane idea to make the misinterpretation seem probable:

This statement does not exclude the possibility that lesser actors — perhaps subcontracted — are responsible for the attacks, nor does it rule out that multiple sources are to blame. That might explain the diverse locations where the victims report being hit, although if such a large group of attackers was afoot, it might also increase the chances the culprits would be caught.
Opinion: The ‘Havana syndrome’ is still a mystery. It is too soon to stop investigating. (WP, Jan 23, 2022)


It is not as if the CIA official ruled out a "sustained, worldwide campaign", is it?! I am surprised that The Post does not suggest that Russia (or Russia, China and Cuba) may still have been behind an unsustained worldwide campaign.

For fairly obvious reasons, I have compared the 'Havana Syndrome' and the many interpretations of the alleged syndrome to UFOs and alien abductions. Consider how the community of UFO abductees and their fans would interpret a statement like this from a CIA (or other) official:

'We have assessed that it is unlikely that an alien actor, including Mars, is conducting a sustained, worldwide campaign abducting U.S. Americans and exposing them to anal probes.'

1) It just says unlikely. It doesn't say impossible.
2) It says alien actor. It doesn't say alien actors. We never claimed that it was only one actor!
3) We also never claimed that those actors are Martians! Venusians are much more likely culprits!
4) We didn't claim that the campaign was worldwide. Some areas have obviously been much more exposed to this campaign than others.
5) Many abductees were exposed to nasal or vaginal probes. The CIA interim report does not explicitly rule those out! That it doesn't only makes them seem so much more likely to be happening.
Up Uranus! :alien009:
 
Podcast - 54:01 min.
Join Justin and Dr. Sydnee McElroy on a marital tour of misguided medicine as they discuss the weird, gross, and sometimes downright dangerous ways we tried to solve our medical woes through the ages.

Havana Syndrome has been in the news lately, so we’ve brought an update. The CIA has continued to look into people experiencing the symptoms of this strange illness and have found . . . there is some sort of cause after all? So enjoy the full episode explaining the history of Havana Syndrome, and what we’ve learned in recent weeks.
Update: Havana Syndrome (Sawbones: A Marital Tour of Misguided Medicine - Episode 404, at MaximumFun, March 8, 2022)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom