I think you have read the book, seen the media reports on YouTube (!) and listened to the podcasts. I don't think you have read the Jama papers. You've certainly read the criticism.
Yes, unlike xjx388 I have read the criticism in addition to the reports that he keeps referring to but doesn't quote from or link to, for some reason. And unlike xjx388 (!), apparently, I watch the media reports on YouTube. That is where I have access to
60 Minutes, for instance.
What he thinks I haven't read is entirely irrelevant.
No. I'm pointing out that you are pretending to know, when you can't possibly know.
xj388's usual attempt to declare something impossible or unethical. Yes, I
can know, and I
do know, and in the case of the 'Havana Syndrome' (as in the case of Trump's narcissism), it isn't particularly difficult to find out what is going on if your mind isn't inhibited by a U.S. patriotic bias.
No. The CIA merely said that they have not found evidence to link it to a foreign power in the vast majority of people.
As always: no quotation, no link. xjx388 simply presents what he would like us to think. The reality is that the CIA hasn't found any link to a foreign power in
any of the cases, not just
in the vast majority of them. In the vast majority of cases, the CIA hasn't simply
not found links to a hostile foreign power. In the vast majority of cases
other causes have been found!!!
The remaining cases
also don't have any links to hostile foreign powers:
However, the CIA emphasized that it is still investigating around two dozen cases that
cannot be explained, and which were first reported by officials at the U.S. Embassy in Havana, Cuba, in 2016.
"Some of our toughest cases remain unresolved," said a CIA official who spoke on condition of anonymity. "We have so far
not found evidence of state actor involvement in any incident."
CIA report: No evidence linking Havana syndrome to a foreign country (NPI, Jan 20, 2022)
But that's xjx388 for you: making it up as he goes along.
When you have nothing, it's logical not to dismiss any plausible idea. All I'm doing is pointing out the hubris of the idea that anyone has this all figured out at this point.
When you have
nothing, you don't usually start fantasizing about who did it and what kind of (imaginary) weapon an imaginary perpetrator may have used. The idea isn't
plausible without one single ray detected. xjx388's false modesty,
"all I'm doing", is an attempt to forbid rational explanations of the 'Havana Syndrome'. We do know how it spread in Havana (in spite of CIA's attempts to keep it a secret) almost as well as we know how it was spread to the rest of the world. This is actual
knowledge. Pulsed directed microwave rays (whatever; it has been called a lot of things along the way, including ultrasound) aren't even on the level of
conjecture.
More medicine by TV on this forum. I'm no longer shocked by this kind of thing, but I should be.
Shocked, I tell you, shocked! Yes, he claimed that we had not seen the patients, and I pointed out that we have even seen the patients describe their symptoms and play recordings of their local lovelorn crickets! Now he is trying to pull the trick from the thread about Trump's narcissism: 'But we didn't see the patients as
our patients!' No, we didn't. But as in the case of Trump, we don't have to, it isn't necessary. Unlike Trump's pee tape, the cricket tapes actually exist, and the alleged attack victims are eager to play them as
evidence of the alleged attack.
And there it is: "patriots like you."
Yes, patriots like him coming to the rescue of a narcissistic president's honor or, in this case, the 'Havana Syndrome' delusion.
See that right there? That's the narrative you are trying to sell here: that we deluded Americans are conditioned by our governments to believe bad things about Cuba and only want to attack them.
"Oh, what a giveaway! Did'j'hear that, did'j'hear that, eh? That's what I'm all about! Did you see 'im repressing me? You saw it, didn't you?!"
No, the narrative here is that American deluders have spent five years scaring the **** out of each other with tales of hostile foreign agents with imaginary ray guns. That this tale was also used in an ongoing Cold War against Cuba deserves to be mentioned when relevant.
There is another thread about some of all the
other lies about Cuba that (some, far from all) Americans are conditioned by their governments to believe:
Protests erupt in Cuba
You keep saying that I'm the one who brought "America bad; Cuba good," into this discussion but that simply isn't true:
Strawman!
I said that he brought the "America bad, Cuba good" story into the discussion because that's what he did. His first couple of posts had nothing whatsoever to do with the theme of the thread. I never claimed that nobody else had ever done so, i.e.
"the one who".
But based on his imaginary
"the one who", xjx388 is now out to prove that others before him did the same thing, i.e. wrote posts about Cuba that had nothing to do with the 'Havana Syndrome', but that isn't even true:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11998721&postcount=44
ˆThat's you talking about all the great stuff Castro did after the revolution.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12063577&postcount=305
ˆThat's Sherkeu with a conspiracy theory tying it all to the unrest in Venezuela and a US plan to remove diplomats from Cuba to force them to make concessions on Venezuela. Or something.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12068738&postcount=337
ˆThat's The Don speculating that it's the Trump admin wanting to roll back Obama's Cuba policies.
The first link is to one of my posts where I write about what the USA may find annoying enough about Cuba to want to destroy the country, i.e. it is about the
motive for making up the 'syndrome' and using it as a false flag argument for withdrawing diplomatic staff from the embassy in Havana.
The two other links from Sherkeu and The Don are reflections on the
motivation for the USA's way of handling the alleged syndrome. I don't see anything wrong with that. The 'syndrome' was created by the USA. Speculations about the motive for both the 'Havana Syndrome delusion and the policies that it gave rise to are very relevant:
US may close Cuba embassy over 'health attacks' - unlike xjx388's post, which was simply an attempt to claim: USA good, Cuba bad. That is his general attitude, which can't be helped, but it is no excuse for attempts to derail the discussion about the 'syndrome'.
There's a lot more than that, of course. Those all came years before I ever participated in the thread. The main theory you believe is that there were no attacks and that this is a case of MPI fueled by a US government that wanted to destabilize relations with Cuba. You season that here and there with anecdotes about how the Cuban government is so great at health care, feeding their people, more honest and open than the US government, etc. You also do a lot of implication about how the NAS paper, as one example, is US sponsored propaganda.
I tend to post about
Cuba's pandemic response to the pandemic in comparison to USA in another thread where this comparison was
included in the OP, albeit
with a false claim (probably not the poster's intention). In that thread, I also post links about how the
U.S. blockade of Cuba managed to exacerbate the effects of the pandemic on the country.
A comparison of the efficacy of the two very different pandemic strategies is not very relevant to this thread unless you look at the whole context in which the 'Havana Syndrome' is still playing out, i.e: Which role does the 'Havana Syndrome' play in the general strategy of the USA towards Cuba? It is worthwhile considering, it's what I, Sherkeu and The Don were doing in the three linked posts - but not about the pandemic, obviously, since they were posted in 2017.
The only relevance xjx388's post could possibly have would be as an
example: How one U.S. American patriot thinks and feels about Cuba - to the extent where it makes him post about these feeling with complete disregard for what the theme of the thread is: the
'Havana Syndrome'.
It's also very interesting that right from the beginning you (and others including Skeptic Ginger) jumped right to the MPI explanation and you haven't backed down. Everything is interpreted in light of your very first conclusion and you refuse to budge even a little. Mostly because -you guessed it- "America bad; Cuba good." That's all you and others, not me. And it's all right there in the record of this thread dating back to the very beginning in 2017.
Nobody jumped to that conclusion! My first reaction was, 'WTF is going on?' My title for the thread reflected my confusion:
Alien Attack? Mass Hysteria? Conspiracy? My title was later replaced by Sherkeu's when two threads about the same theme were merged.
I no longer remember in which sub-forum I posted the OP, but I don't think it was in
Social Issues & Current Events.
It is not surprising that Skeptic Ginger would be one of the first to recognize the signs of mass psychogenic illness in the 'Havana Syndrome'. She has practical experience with it, so the similarities would be more apparent to her than to most of us.
"... and you haven't backed down," is an outright
lie based on xjx388's ignorance of the thread. For a long time, I thought that the Canadian idea, insecticide poisoning, had something going for it. I had witnessed fumigation against mosquitoes in Havana, and I even argued against dismissing the idea due to the apparent discrepancy: Only Americans and Canadians, but no Cubans were affected. Based on my experience with both private homes and hotel rooms in Havana, I proposed a possible reason for the discrepancy: In general, Cuban homes don't have air conditioning. Hotel rooms and houses for foreigners usually do. In other words, the dwellings of Americans and Canadians in Havana are pretty airtight. Those of Cubans aren't, and for this reason the fumes of insecticides evaporate fast.
However, the investigative cooperation between Cuban and Canadian health experts doesn't seem to have come up with any support for the fumigation poisoning idea. (And diplomats from other nations don't seem to have been affected by Cuban fumigation. Only Americans and the Canadians who were 'recruited' for the 'syndrome' by Patient Zero.)
It find it really annoying that xjx388 comes to this thread pretending to know it all and then makes accusations like this based on nothing but his bias and ignorance.