Merged Covid vaccines - supply, distribution and rollout / Beginning of the end

Just to be clear:
-It is very easy to have high percentage vaccination when you can just force everybody eligible to have it (like any other dictatorship).
-That assertion about technology sharing is definitely disingenuous. When you use relatively simple method for vaccine design and production it is unsurprisingly easier to share it than using state-of-the-art Mrna/Adenovirus-based technology of vaccine production.
Also it ignores AstraZeneca's sharing of technology. (That's why it is produced among other places in India) Don't know current status of mRNA technology, but given how new it is and difficult to even procure equipment, I doubt it would be relevant for a long time.

Sorry, but this reads too much like bloody propaganda or PR crap.

Honestly, I am happy for Cuba to be doing this and although it is easy to be cynical, if they vaccinated the whole country and can share even a small amount of vaccines then it is an amazing achievement. The fact is that as good as the mRNA vaccines are, they are really not the best candidates for exporting to the developing world. For that, I think the AZ vaccines you mention, but perhaps even more so the one developed by the Texas Cbildren’s hospital under Peter Hotez could be the big game changer.
 
To be clear: You found reasons to minimize their claims or be unimpressed by them but are any of them actually untrue?

When you remove all those adjectives and PR, than most of them might be true. With one exception: Claim about technology transfer. That one is patently untrue. Cuba is not the only one that offered technology transfer, they weren't even first. (Either AZ, one of Chinese or Sputnik were first, not sure which one)

Honestly, I am happy for Cuba to be doing this and although it is easy to be cynical, if they vaccinated the whole country and can share even a small amount of vaccines then it is an amazing achievement. The fact is that as good as the mRNA vaccines are, they are really not the best candidates for exporting to the developing world. For that, I think the AZ vaccines you mention, but perhaps even more so the one developed by the Texas Cbildren’s hospital under Peter Hotez could be the big game changer.

I was mostly irritated by that almost reverent tone. Reminded me too much of communistic propaganda in not so distant past of my own country...
 
When you remove all those adjectives and PR, than most of them might be true. With one exception: Claim about technology transfer. That one is patently untrue. Cuba is not the only one that offered technology transfer, they weren't even first. (Either AZ, one of Chinese or Sputnik were first, not sure which one)
Don't see where they claim to be the only or the first. The quotes I see in this have them claiming to be one of the ones that shared, not first or only. I would think the wording I see was to draw a contrast between Cuba and the United States.
 
Honestly, I am happy for Cuba to be doing this and although it is easy to be cynical, if they vaccinated the whole country and can share even a small amount of vaccines then it is an amazing achievement. The fact is that as good as the mRNA vaccines are, they are really not the best candidates for exporting to the developing world. For that, I think the AZ vaccines you mention, but perhaps even more so the one developed by the Texas Cbildren’s hospital under Peter Hotez could be the big game changer.

Because of the US trade embargo, Cuba has had to develop an independent pharma industry, including a vaccine industry. Their vaccine industry is very good, they were the first in the world to develop a successful meningicoccal meningitis vaccine. They do have a good track record in vaccine innovation and production.
 
In addition to its four 'conventional' anti-Covid vaccines, Abdala and the three Soberanas (01, 02 and Plus), Cuba is now starting clinical trials of the nasal spray Mambisa:

En los estudios realizados hasta el momento, Mambisa indujo respuesta anti-RBD en más de cuatro veces con respecto al nivel inicial, y se incrementó en más del 20 % la capacidad inhibitoria frente al virus SARS-CoV-2, a nivel sistémico y en mucosa nasal.
Díaz-Canel sobre Mambisa: «Esto es resistencia creativa»(+Video) (Granma.cu, Jan 24, 2022)
Google translation:
In the studies carried out to date, Mambisa induced a more than quadrupled anti-RBD response compared to the initial level, and the inhibitory capacity against the SARS-CoV-2 virus was increased by more than 20%, at the systemic level and in nasal mucus.
 
Last edited:
Just to be clear:
-It is very easy to have high percentage vaccination when you can just force everybody eligible to have it (like any other dictatorship).


Just to be clear: Can you tell us more about Covid-19 vaccinations being forced upon Cubans? Could you maybe supply us with some kind of documentation for your allegations?
Your post reads like the kind of "bloody propaganda or PR crap" that we hear so much of.

But in Communist-led Cuba, having citizens get their shots simply doesn't seem to be a problem.
"People in Cuba are anxious and motivated to get vaccinated," Carlos Fernandez de Cossio, director-general for the United States at the Cuban Foreign Ministry, told Newsweek. "We don't have the cultural problem that seems to exist here in the U.S."
As Vaccine Mandates Face Resistance in U.S., Cuba Says It Doesn't Need Them (Newsweek, Oct 5, 2021)


Cuba's vaccine success sails past mark set by rich world's Covid efforts (The Guardian, Jan 5, 2022)

Our World in Data:
Daily new confirmed COVID-19 cases per million people
Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people
Share of people vaccinated against COVID-19
COVID-19 vaccine boosters administered per 100 people
 
I think we have to avoid poisoning the well too much with regard to Cuba. As I have heard it, they've thrown themselves into medical research for some time, and achieved a pretty enviable position in the field, especially with regard to tropical medicine. You can easily hate their government and their economic policies and their revolutionary rhetoric and a whole lot more, but that does not mean they're not doing a better job with Covid than many. And it's also true, of course, that the government could probably force people to take vaccines if it were necessary, but without evidence that it is true, it's also quite possible they don't have to. If you want to meet a maskless conservative Cuban you're more likely to do so in Miami these days, I think.
 
Meanwhile, here in Japan:

Infected young people don’t need to visit doctors, ministry says

The health ministry changed its COVID-19 policy and said Jan. 24 that young people with mild symptoms do not need to consult with doctors and can just recuperate at home.

The new policy is aimed at ensuring that outpatient care services are not overwhelmed by a surge in novel coronavirus infections.

The ministry said that people under 40 can test themselves for the virus and avoid clogging up hospitals because they are at a lower risk of developing severe symptoms.

In some municipalities, the number of outpatients has been soaring, leading to long lines for tests conducted by doctors.

Health experts advising the government on anti-virus measures on Jan. 21 recommended a change in policy to ease pressure on medical care systems.

“Young generations who are at a lower risk do not always need to go to see doctors and should be allowed to recuperate at home,” the proposal said.

Although 79% of people here are double-vaccinated now, very few people have had a booster shot yet.

Based on this data, here is my rough estimate of the case fatality rate in Japan for January:

Number of deaths: 130
Number of cases: 488,726
Number discharged (people who recovered): 125,702

I use the latter number (discharged) to calculate the CFR, since the outcome of most cases is not clear yet.

This yields a CFR of 0.1% (0.1034% if you want more digits of precision). I don't know if this is a sound method, and of course it only applies to Japan in the month of January, 2022, but if that is close to the true number, it is close to the CFR for influenza now. It's important to remember that this is with the vast majority of people over the age of 18 being double-vaxxed, but not boosted.
 
If you want to meet a maskless conservative Cuban you're more likely to do so in Miami these days, I think.

I don't think you will meet anybody in Cuba without a face mask. I am pretty sure that face masks are mandatory everywhere outside of homes. Even children wear them, and they don't seem to have any problems wearing them correctly.

Google translation from Spanish:
In Cuba, more than 1.6 million children have been vaccinated against COVID-19, with more than 3.3 million doses, and after the vaccination campaign ended, no pediatric deaths have been reported, said the doctor of Science María Eugenia Toledo, principal investigator of the Soberana 02 clinical trial at the Pedro Kourí Institute of Tropical Medicine (IPK).
Referring to the impact of Soberana's mass immunization in children between the ages of two and 18, he specified, during a recent appearance at the Round Table, that an adult who is not vaccinated has 2.2 times more risk of suffering from the asymptomatic disease than a vaccinated adult. In the case of a child, the risk is 18.2 times greater, compared to one who is vaccinated.
“If we had started the pandemic with everything we have done regarding vaccination, 94.8% of cases in children would have been avoided,” he stressed, adding that if there was one thing that put Cuba at the forefront, it was to start a childhood vaccination campaign, as well as the political will not to start the school year until the little ones who could be vaccinated had the complete immunization schedule.
Concluida la vacunación pediátrica, ningún niño cubano ha fallecido (Granma.cu, Jan 25, 2022)
 
Meanwhile, here in Japan:

Infected young people don’t need to visit doctors, ministry says



Although 79% of people here are double-vaccinated now, very few people have had a booster shot yet.

Based on this data, here is my rough estimate of the case fatality rate in Japan for January:

Number of deaths: 130
Number of cases: 488,726
Number discharged (people who recovered): 125,702

I use the latter number (discharged) to calculate the CFR, since the outcome of most cases is not clear yet.

This yields a CFR of 0.1% (0.1034% if you want more digits of precision). I don't know if this is a sound method, and of course it only applies to Japan in the month of January, 2022, but if that is close to the true number, it is close to the CFR for influenza now. It's important to remember that this is with the vast majority of people over the age of 18 being double-vaxxed, but not boosted.

Yeah, I am not sure, but of course, the vast majority of the new cases have only really come about in the last ten days or so. Deaths tend to lag of course just by the nature of the virus, but I am not sure if deaths are immediately reported or not, or the data is released later.

In other words there may be artifacts of both the virus itself and release of information that may make it difficult to make those calculations.

Still, I would expect that vaccination has played a large part in reducing mortality in the most at-risk groups, and with Japan having an impressive vaccination rate that should have reduced the death toll substantially.
 
Just to be clear: Can you tell us more about Covid-19 vaccinations being forced upon Cubans? Could you maybe supply us with some kind of documentation for your allegations?
Your post reads like the kind of "bloody propaganda or PR crap" that we hear so much of.
...

It's communistic dictatorship with still pretty tight control over population. You don't need much more. After all it is still more similar to former Czechoslovakia. We never had problems with high vaccination rates back then...
(Just little nudge here and there and some common understanding of consequences will get you very far in such regimes; there are more ways how to ensure/force compliance without being obvious - Chinese could learn a thing or two)

However, they do have lower rate than they could with such approach.

BTW: Just little reminder: there were more problems with your original post, than just rate of vaccination in Cuba..
 
So Covid-19 vaccinations weren't forced upon Cubans, after all. It was just bloody propaganda crap.
Could you tell us more about why the Czech Republic has problems with vaccination rates nowadays? It appears to have had a lot to do with the country's extremely high death toll, 3,459 per million, in spite of being almost unscathed by the first wave.
Why do Czechs have so little confidence in capitalist vaccines? (I assume that the Covid-19 vaccines used in the Czech Republic aren't Sinovac, Soberana, Abdala or Sputnik.)

Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people
Share of people vaccinated against COVID-19
Daily share of the population receiving a COVID-19 vaccine dose
COVID-19 vaccine boosters administered per 100 people
 
Google translation:
The ipk doctor reported that more than five million doses of Soberana have been administered in Cuba and coverage in children between two and 18 years of age is 96.6%.

An important element, she added, has been the safety with which everything was conducted: adverse events associated with this vaccination campaign were less than 0.01%. The most serious had to do with local events, there were no systemic events in the vaccinated children. In Cuba, she affirmed, there are no reports of myocarditis or pericarditis due to our vaccines.

Toledo Romaní spoke of the estimates made by the Soberana researchers on how the risk changes in a child who is vaccinated and in another who does not. A child who does not receive her dose, she explained, "has 18.2 times more risk of getting sick, but also has a much higher risk of suffering from severe forms of the disease."

The researcher reported on the 132,000 children convalescing from COVID-19 who have received their dose of Soberana Plus. According to her, the studies showed that the antibody titers of convalescent children immunized only with Soberana Plus and those who received all three doses are similar.
La campaña de vacunación de los niños nos permitió adelantarnos a la ola de Ómicron (+ Video) (Granma.cu, Feb 1, 2022)
 
After having vaccinated all children 2+, Cuba is now testing SARS-CoV-2 vaccines on children younger than 2:

Cuba quiere a todos sus niños protegidos: Ensayarán vacunación anti-COVID-19 en niños menores de dos años (Granma.cu, May 12, 2022)
Cuba wants its children protected: Clinical trials set to begin to determine the effectiveness and safety of Cuba´s anti-COVID-19 vaccines in children under two years of age

They are still masking up, even children. It doesn't seem to be a problem, and it seems to be working!
 
Last edited:
A million USAians have died from Covid-19, plus hundreds of thousands more "excess deaths".
 
3,000 deaths per million. Cuba 750. And the Cuban death toll is only this high because the country was late to the vaccination game:
Cumulative confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people: Cuba, USA.
Daily new confirmed COVID-19 deaths per million people: Cuba, USA.

Which wasn't really Cuba's fault:
Tania Urquiza Rodríguez is the Vice President of BioCubaFarma, the country's state-run biotech conglomerate. She breaks down how U.S. sanctions have impacted Cuba's ability to produce its own vaccines and medications during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Sanctions In a Pandemic, Pt. 2 (Belly of the Beast on YouTube, Oct 16, 2021 - 3:41 min. - text in English)
 
I don't know why it takes so much longer to develop nasal-spray vaccines. Cuba has been working on its own, Mambisa, for as long as on its other vaccines, Abdala and the three Soberanas:

Cuba’s bet on home-grown COVID vaccines is paying off (Nature, Nov 22, 2021)
Mambisa from Cuba could cut transmission of the coronavirus (Radio Habana Cuba, Jan 23, 2022)

In all groups, he added, the vaccine candidate induced an anti-RBD response by more than four times the initial level.
It also increased the inhibitory capacity against the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus, which causes Covid-19, more than 20 percent, at the systemic level and in the nasal mucosa.
(...)
Mambisa is a combination of two recombinant proteins: the RBD of the SARS-CoV-2 spike and the nucleocapsid of the hepatitis B virus.
(...)
Globally, four other nasally administered candidates have reached the stage of clinical studies, according to recent public data.
Avanzan ensayos clínicos de candidato vacunal Mambisa de Cuba (BMJ, Jan 27, 2022)


The development in Cuba of Mambisa, a nasal vaccine to strengthen immunity against Covid-19, is highlighted today by Salvadoran media.
“Cuba is about to launch an anticovid vaccine that is administered through the nose,” headlines newspaper El Mundo, which highlights the progress in clinical trials of the new vaccine candidate from the Center for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (CIGB).
The aforementioned newspaper reproduced the “tweet” of the CIGB on the positive results that support the use of Mambisa in the application of booster doses.
Cuban nasal vaccine against Covid-19 stands out in El Salvador (Prensa Latina, April 18, 2022)


Finland has also been working on a nasal spray against the virus. It sounds good ... until you get to the "up to 8 hours" bit.
The nasal spray consists of a molecule, developed by researchers at the University of Helsinki, Finland, that can inactivate the coronavirus spike protein
Finnish researchers have developed a novel nasal spray that is effective against all variants of Covid and can prevent infection up to 8 hours.
New nasal spray effective against all variants (National Herald, Jan 12, 2022)
But on the other hand, consider this:
In contrast to vaccine protection, the effect of TriSb92 begins immediately after its administration.


I wouldn't mind having a whiff of it immediately before boarding a plane, for instance. I have recently read a couple of stories about people on planes coming down with Covid-19 after sitting next to passengers who were coughing and sneezing, unmasked. :(
I am sure that cabin crews would like to be able to carry the spray around with them if it is safe to use repeatedly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom